Service Charge in UK Law
Dennis Phillips and Royna Goddard (suing on behalf of themselves and other owners of 97 Holiday Chalets at Point Curlew, St Merryn, Padstow, Cornwall) v Martin Francis and Another
Paragraph 6 of Schedule 3 entitles the Lessor to reimbursement by the service charge of both the pay and expenses of "staff employed" and "fees paid" to "architects agents surveyors and solicitors" employed in regard to the management of the Estate. The context in which the word "agent" is used is by reference to the provision of some professional service required in connection with the management of the Estate. That is to be distinguished from the general management of the Estate.
HM Revenue and Customs v Loyalty Management UK Ltd (Joined Cases C-53/09 and C-55/09)
It is thus not, in my view, the requirements of a direct link or of reciprocity or even the nature of "consideration" as an autonomous concept differing from the meaning of the word in our domestic contract law that finally contributes to the conclusion at which Mr Vajda's argument seeks to arrive.
Mr Venables then follows through that Redrow sequence. The payment in question is the Service Charge which LMUK pays to Suppliers. Did LMUK receive anything – anything at all – used or to be used for the purposes of its business in return for that payment?
There is no single touchstone, no reliable litmus paper, that assuredly reveals the characteristics for which I am looking but why I would prefer the Commissioners' argument is that it seems to me the more consistent with the requirements, illustrated in Auto Lease and the coupon cases, that one should stand back and look at the characteristics of the provision and payment in issue in a relatively robust and commonsensical way, not bound by a strict analysis of the mesh of the contracts or the language used in them.
In the light of the facts I have described, I would regard the Service Charges, so closely related to the occasions and often to the prices of provision by Suppliers to Collectors, as more having the characteristic of being a payment by LMUK for or towards the supply of goods or services by Suppliers to Collectors than being of any other nature.
Ruddy v Oakfern Properties Ltd
I also reject the suggestion that there is any significant relationship between the service charge provisions and the Rent Acts. As the judgments in Horford make clear (see in particular the extract from Scarman LJ's judgment, quoted in paragraph 34 above) , the decision in that case was materially influenced by the underlying policy of the Rent Acts.
Gilje v Charlegrove Securities Ltd
Finally, I agree with Ms Eilledge that, so far as discernible, the policy behind section 20B of the Act is that the tenant should not be faced with a bill for expenditure, of which he or she was not sufficiently warned to set aside provision. It is not directed at preventing the lessor from recovering any expenditure on matters, and to the extent, of which there was adequate prior notice. This does not leave the tenant without a remedy for the failure of the lessor to prepare a final account.
Rent review: dark art or rainy sky?
Purpose: – The purpose of this paper is to consider the impact on rent review clauses of a recent UK Supreme Court ruling on the interpretation and application of contractual provisions. Although t...
The hypothesis goes like this. If document supply centres could cut the cost of filling requests for journal articles, and continue to charge the same price for their service, publishers of the jou...
Determinants of prices in an online marketplace
Purpose: Despite the availability of side‐by‐side price comparisons, online retailers often charge very different prices for the same product. The purpose of this paper is to identify the drivers o...
Search Helper: Sancho Panza or Mephistopheles?
Search Helper was selected as a system for introducing the Carnegie‐Mellon University community to do‐it‐yourself database searching. Use of Search Helper was offered without charge to CMU students...
A Conclusive Conclusion for Service Charge Certificates?
In a case that will be welcomed by landlords, the Court of Appeal has ruled that a service charge statement was conclusive both as to the landlord’s costs and the scope of the services.
Service Charge – RICS code gets new teeth
As 2019 begins, the property sector is gearing up for the introduction of the new RICS professional statement, which will supersede the current code of practice from 1 April 2019.
- Wrong Payment Date Invalidated Service Charge Demand (H Stain V Richmond)
- Can I Withhold Service Charge? (Video)