Variation of Contract in UK Law
Globe Motors, Inc. (a corporation incorporated in Delaware, USA) and Others v TRW Lucas Varity Electric Steering Ltd (First Defendant/Appellant) TRW Ltd (Second Defendant)
The second is that, as seen from the Carewatch Care Services case, an implication of a duty of good faith will only be possible where the language of the contract, viewed against its context, permits it. It is thus not a reflection of a special rule of interpretation for this category of contract.
At the conclusion of that trial, Steel J held that, notwithstanding the clause, the conditions in the contract in that case had been varied by the oral agreement: see  EWHC 244 (Comm).
Difficulties of proof may arise whenever it is claimed that a contract has been made orally or by the conduct of the parties, and the facts have to be determined by the trial judge from the evidence given by the parties and their witnesses.
As between the approaches in the two cases, the considerations of principle to which I have referred lead me to prefer the approach in the World Online Telecom case which recognised that in principle a contract containing a clause that any variation of it be in writing can be varied by an oral agreement or by conduct.
The governing principle, in my view, is that of party autonomy. The parties are therefore free to include terms regulating the manner in which the contract can be varied, but just as they can create obligations at will, so also can they discharge or vary them, at any rate where to do so would not affect the rights of third parties. If there is an analogy with the position of Parliament, it is in the principle that Parliament cannot bind its successors.
R BATCHELOR ENTERPRISES Ltd v NORTH DORSET DISTRICT COUNCIL
Since the court in judicial review proceedings may not substitute its own answer to that question for that of the local planning authority, the question in relation to an application for judicial review in respect of a local authority's decision under section 106A(1)(a) is whether a reasonable local planning authority could have concluded that the obligation still served a useful planning purpose.
Alstom Transport v Eurostar International Ltd and Another
It is clear to me that a notice of a qualification scheme is capable of being a notice required to be given for the purposes of the first ground, and no-one disputes that such a notice was given in this case. So the central question in this case is whether it is right (or sufficiently arguably right to prevent striking out) that the alteration of the contract makes that notice irrelevant, with the effect that a relevant notice was in fact not given.
Business transfers, employers’ strategies and the impact of recent case law
Under the European Union’s 1977 Acquired Rights Directive, workers transferred to another employer can expect the majority of their original terms and conditions of employment to be protected and c...
- The New Public Corporations and The Law
How does performance history impact supplier selection in public sector?
Purpose: – The purpose of this paper is to study if the performance history impacts supplier selection in the French public sector context. While French public procurement legislation forbids consi...
- STRIKES AND EMPLOYMENT CONTRACTS
Contract variation just got easier – mitigating the risk of inadvertent change
In finding that an oral agreement to defer payments was legally binding, the Court of Appeal in MWB Business Exchange Centres Ltd v Rock Advertising Ltd  EWCA Civ 553 has confirmed the limita...
- Contract Variation - Changing Terms And Conditions
Ten Key Learnings From The Administration Of Carluccio's - A Perfect Storm Of Employment Law, Furloughed Workers And Insolvency
...... priority to certain wages and salary liabilities arising under a contract of employment adopted by an administrator before they leave office - these ..., up to the relevant limits; the administrators had issued a variation letter to employees seeking consent to vary their contracts of employment ......
TUPE Update - Mitigating The Risk - November 2013
...... Restrictions on varying contract Terms. Arguably, this is the most interesting amendment. TUPE currently ... Under the new provisions, if the variation is because of the transfer, but there is an ETO reason, then the variation ......