Admissibility of Evidence in UK Law
-
Mood Music Publishing Company Ltd v De Wolfe Ltd
“
In civil cases the Courts have followed a similar line but have not been so chary of admitting it. In civil cases the Courts will admit evidence of similar facts if it is logically probative, that is, if it is logically relevant in determining the matter which is in issue: provided that it is not oppressive or unfair to the other side: and also that the other side has fair notice of it and is able to deal with it.
-
R v Boardman
“
The test must be—is the evidence capable of tending to persuade a reasonable jury of the accused's guilt on some ground other than his bad character and disposition to commit the sort of crime with which he is charged? The similarity would have to be so unique or striking that common sense makes it inexplicable on the basis of coincidence.
-
O'Brien v Chief Constable of South Wales Police
“
And if those engaged in the recent event had in the past been involved in events of an apparently similar character, attention would be paid to those earlier events as perhaps throwing light on and helping to explain the event which is the subject of the current enquiry. To regard evidence of such earlier events as potentially probative is a process of thought which an entirely rational, objective and fair-minded person might, depending on the facts, follow.
-
Rush & Tompkins Ltd v Greater London Council
“
The "without prejudice rule" is a rule governing the admissibility of evidence and is founded upon the public policy of encouraging litigants to settle their differences rather than litigate them to a finish. It is nowhere more clearly expressed than in the judgment of Oliver L.J. in Cutts v. Head [1984] Ch. 290, 306:
The rule applies to exclude all negotiations genuinely aimed at settlement whether oral or in writing from being given in evidence.
These cases show that the rule is not absolute and resort may be had to the without prejudice material for a variety of reasons when the justice of the case requires it. I regard this as an exceptional case and it should not be allowed to whittle down the protection given to the parties to speak freely about all issues in the litigation both factual and legal when seeking compromise and, for the purpose of establishing a basis of compromise, admitting certain facts.
-
R v Kilbourne
“
Evidence is relevant if it is logically probative or disprobative of some matter which requires proof. It is sufficient to say, even at the risk of etymological tautology, that relevant (i.e., logically probative or disprobative) evidence is evidence which makes the matter which requires proof more or less probable. Evidence is admissible if it may be lawfully adduced at a trial.
-
Parliamentary Elections Act 1868
... ... Petition that any Question or Questions of Law as to the Admissibility of Evidence or otherwise require further Consideration by the Court of ... ...
-
Civil Evidence Act 1968
... ... 30), s. 1(1); amended by Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 (c. 63), s. 21 ... 2: Admissibility of out-of-court statements as evidence of facts stated ... (1) In any civil proceedings a statement made, whether orally or in a document or ... ...
-
Sheriff Courts (Scotland) Act 1907
... ... procedure as he thinks requisite, and (without a record of the evidence, unless on the motion of either party the sheriff shall order that the ... SCH-1.75 ... Appeal on questions of admissibility of evidence. 75 Appeal on questions of admissibility of evidence ... ...
-
Criminal Justice Act 2003
... ... 2(g) ... Part 1: Amendments of Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 ... 1: Extension of powers to stop and search ... (1) In this ... ) indicating any point of law (including any point as to the admissibility of evidence or an abuse of process) which he wishes to take, and any ... ...
-
Admissibility of Evidence in EPPO Proceedings
The issue of cross-border admissibility of evidence is a recurring theme of European Criminal Justice, and continues to be perceived as a decisive obstacle hindering the effective prosecution and a...
- The Admissibility of Evidence Showing ‘System’
- Parliamentary Privilege and Admissibility of Evidence
- The Admissibility of Evidence in Extradition Proceedings: R v Governor of Brixton Prison, ex parte Levin
- Admissibility of Evidence Obtained Through Secret Recording
- Admissibility Of Evidence Obtained In Breach Of Section 30 PACE
- Commercial Court Decides That New Practice Direction In Relation To Trial Witness Statements In Business & Property Courts Has Not Changed Law On Admissibility Of Evidence
-
Companies: Beware of Relying on Precontractual Negotiations
The recent decision in Merthyr (South Wales) Ltd v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council [2019] EWCA Civ 526, considered the extent to which precontractual material, such as precontractual negotiat...... ... , the Court of Appeal reiterated the rules relating to the admissibility of evidence used to adduce the objective or “genesis” and aim of a ... ...