Conclusive Evidence in UK Law
-
Hunter and Others v Chief Constable of West Midlands
“
On an appeal (which is a re-hearing) we have said that the fresh evidence must be such that, if given, it would probably have an important influence on the result of the case, though it need not be decisive, see Ladd v. Marshall (1954) 1 Weekly Law Reports at page 1491 and Skone v. Skone (1971) 1 Weekly Law Reports at page 815. But in order to avoid the effect of an estoppel (when there is no re-hearing) the fresh evidence must, I think, be decisive.
-
Suffolk County Council v Mason
“
The entry on the definitive map does not necessarily remain conclusive evidence for ever. Section 33 makes provision for quinquennial revisions—though these do not appear in practice to have been carried out punctually. On a revision, entries on the definitive map which require modification as a result of events that have occurred since the date of the last revision may be modified accordingly.
-
Springwell Navigation Corporation (A Body Corporate) v (1) Jp Morgan Chase Bank (A Body Corporate) (Formerly Known as the Chase Manhattan Bank) (2) Jp Morgan Europe Ltd (Formerly Known as Chase Manhattan International Ltd) and Others
“
Unless Lowe v Lombank is authority to the contrary, there is no legal principle that states that parties cannot agree to assume that a certain state of affairs is the case at the time the contract is concluded or has been so in the past, even if that is not the case, so that the contract is made upon the basis that the present or past facts are as stated and agreed by the parties.
-
Powell v Streatham Manor Nursing Home
“
But where the evidence is conflicting and the issue is one of fact depending on oral evidence, any Judge who has had experience of trying cases with witnesses cannot fail to realise the truth of what Lord Sumner says: as the evidence proceeds through examination, cross-examination and re-examination the Judge is gradually imbibing almost instinctively, but in fact as a result of close attention and of long experience, an impression of the personality of the witness and of his trustworthiness and of the accuracy of his observation and memory or the reverse.
-
HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd v New Hampshire Insurance Company
“
The difficulty of course is that, where the later contract is intended to supersede the prior contract, it may in the generality of cases simply be useless to try to construe the later contract by reference to the earlier one. Therefore a cautious and sceptical approach to finding any assistance in the earlier contract seems to me to be a sound principle.
-
R (M and another) v Lambeth London Borough Council and another
“
But the question whether a person is a "child" is a different kind of question. There is a right or a wrong answer. It may be difficult to determine what that answer is. The decision-makers may have to do their best on the basis of less than perfect or conclusive evidence. But that is true of many questions of fact which regularly come before the courts. That does not prevent them from being questions for the courts rather than for other kinds of decision makers.
-
Beaufort Developments (NI) Ltd v Gilbert Ash (NI) Ltd
“
But in all other respects, where a party comes to the court in the search of an ordinary remedy under the contract or for a remedy in respect of an alleged breach of it, the court is entitled to examine the facts and to form its own opinion upon them in the light of the evidence. The fact that the architect has formed an opinion on the matter will be part of the evidence. But, as it will not be conclusive evidence, the court can disregard his opinion if it does not agree with it.
-
Bills of Lading Act 1855
... ... Bill of Lading in Hands of Consignee, &c. conclusive Evidence of Shipment as against Master, &c.III Bill of Lading in Hands of ... ...
-
Bankruptcy Act 1869
... ... evidence, or for any other just cause, or may dismiss the ... petition, with or ... aforesaid shall be conclusive evidence in all legal proceedings ... of the debtor having been duly ... ...
-
Companies Act 1867
... ... of the Order and Minute, and his Certificate shall be conclusive Evidence that all the Requisitions of this Act with respect to the ... ...
-
Fisheries (Ireland) Act 1842
... ... for each such Certificate; and such Certificate shall be conclusive Evidence of such Registration, and the Number, Mark, or Letter which shall ... ...
-
Judicial ideology in economic cases: Evidence from the General Court of the European Union
We contribute new empirical evidence on the influence of ideology on the behaviour of European Union judges. As votes and other common proxies for judicial preferences are unavailable, we ask 46 co...... ... We find less conclusive evidence for the influence of attitudes towards integration, even in state aid cases where the integration dimension might be expected to be more ... ...
-
How much do we know about the long-term effectiveness of parenting programmes? Advances, shortcomings, and future directions
Purpose: – Parenting programmes are seen as feasible and cost-effective in preventing early behavioural problems in children and adolescents. A number of studies have concluded that such programmes...... ... The current evidence is favourable but is likely to be biased by methodological ... for more studies of greater methodological strength to obtain conclusive evidence that wouldguide empirical research, practice and ... ...
-
The Impact of Labor Force Attachment on Political Participation
Labor force attachment is currently seen as a major factor in increasing political participation of women. This article critically examines the data and methods of studies that have postulated a ca...... ... participation and argues that at present there is no conclusive evidence of such a rela- tionship. It then proposes three ... ...
-
Infrastructure: a new dimension of real estate? An asset allocation analysis
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to provide conclusive evidence that infrastructure constitutes a separate asset class and cannot be classified as real estate from an investment point‐of‐view....... ... – The purpose of this paper is to provide conclusive evidence that infrastructure constitutesa separate asset class and cannot ... ...
-
Conclusive Evidence Clauses And Failure To Mitigate
In ABM Amro Commercial Finance Plc v Ambrose McGinn & ors [2014] EWHC 1674 (Comm), 23 May 2014 the court ruled that an indemnifying party cannot argue that a failure to mitigate by an indemnified p...
-
London Court Upholds Arbitral Award In Contractor Dispute In Face Of Challenge That Arbitral Panel Failed To Consider Coverage Defenses
A court in London recently upheld an arbitral award in the face of claims that the arbitral panel failed to consider several coverage defenses one party asserted during the proceedings. The arbitra...... ... , Symbion alleged a defense that the court referred to as the “conclusive evidence” defense. Symbion argued Venco’s case was based on invoices ... ...
-
The High Court Considers The Final Certificate Conclusivity Provisions Of The JCT
... ... Clause 1.9.1 provides that the Final Certificate is conclusive evidence on a number of matters in any proceedings arising out of the ... ...
-
Does The Conclusivity Of A JCT Final Certificate Unlawfully Fetter A Partys Right To Adjudicate?
... ... In the absence of a challenge, the Certificate will become conclusive evidence of many aspects that might be the subject of a later dispute. The ... ...