Constitutional Reform in UK Law
-
Bovale Ltd v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
“
If a Head of Division exercised that inherent power to give directions as to a procedure to be adopted in a particular court as happened before the 2005 Act, and a fortiori if the direction is given with the approval or agreement of the Lord Chief Justice and Lord Chancellor, it cannot be open to another judge of the court to which the practice direction is intended to apply to ignore that practice direction or to suggest in a judgment that a practice direction should no longer be followed in that court.
-
Lee v Ashers Baking Company Ltd and Others
“
The Northern Ireland Court of Appeal is a superior court, but the underlying question of construction remains, whether the legislature has by article 61(7) of the 1980 Order, set out in para 62 above, excluded any right of appeal in circumstances such as the present. The finality provision in article 61(7) is therefore focused on the decision on the point of law, not on the regularity of the proceedings leading to it.
-
AXA General Insurance Company Ltd v Lord Advocate
“
The Scottish Parliament takes its place under our constitutional arrangements as a self-standing democratically elected legislature. Its democratic mandate to make laws for the people of Scotland is beyond question. Acts that the Scottish Parliament enacts which are within its legislative competence enjoy, in that respect, the highest legal authority. The United Kingdom Parliament has vested in the Scottish Parliament the authority to make laws that are within its devolved competence.
A requirement that the applicant demonstrate an interest in the matter complained of will not however operate satisfactorily if it is applied in the same way in all contexts. In some contexts, it is appropriate to require an applicant for judicial review to demonstrate that he has a particular interest in the matter complained of: the type of interest which is relevant, and therefore required in order to have standing, will depend upon the particular context.
-
FP (Iran) v Secretary of State for the Home Department
“
Section 106(1A) requires the Lord Chancellor to seek to make rules which balance the requirements for fairness, speed and efficiency. In this field, speed and efficiency are unquestionably important, but there must be a limit to the degree to which fairness can be sacrificed in order to achieve speed and efficiency. It must still be possible to say that a rule which has been designed to achieve speed and efficiency is fair in its operation.
-
R R Cart (First Claimant) U (Second Claimant) XC (Third Claimant) The Upper Tribunal (First Defendant) Special Immigration Appeals Commission (Second Defendant) The Secretary of State for Justice (First Interested Party) The Secretary of State for the Home Department (Second Interested Party) Child Maintenance & Enforcement Commission (Third Interested Party) Mrs Wendy Cart (Fourth Interested Party) The Public Law Project (Intervener)
“
section IV(2)(a) below I discuss the historic primacy of the High Court's predecessor, the Court of King's Bench. To offer the same guarantee of properly mediated law, any alternative source must amount to an alter ego of the High Court; and indeed there are instances where the authoritative source is another court, such as the Court-Martial Appeal Court and the Restrictive Practices Court (see the reference at paragraph 71 below to R v Cripps, ex parte Muldoon [1984] 1 QB 68).
-
R (Miller and Another) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union; Re McCord's application
“
Subject to any restrictions imposed by primary legislation, the general rule is that the power to make or unmake treaties is exercisable without legislative authority and that the exercise of that power is not reviewable by the courts — see Civil Service Unions case cited above, at pp 397–398. The second proposition is that, although they are binding on the United Kingdom in international law, treaties are not part of UK law and give rise to no legal rights or obligations in domestic law.
- Constitutional Reform Act 2005
- Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010
- The Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010 (Commencement No. 9) Order 2014
-
The Criminal Procedure Rules 2015
... ... 308 and 332 of Schedule 4 and Part 2 of Schedule 18 to, the Constitutional Reform Act 2005 (c. 4). # F3 1988 c. 53; section 12 was amended by article ... ...
-
The Case Against Constitutional Reform
Proposals for constitutional reform in the United Kingdom are examined critically. Ideas of ‘governance’ as posited by various accounts in the literature of politics are compared with the simpler i...
-
‘Tears Before Bedtime’ A Look Back At The Constitutional Reform Programme Since 1997
Within a year of the Blair Government taking office, Bagehot in The Economist (1998) was accusing them of presiding over ‘a frenzy of constitutional reform” which ne...
-
Slaying the ‘Westmonster’ in the Caribbean? Constitutional Reform in St Vincent and the Grenadines
The model of governance bequeathed by Britain to the Caribbean has long been praised for ensuring that vibrant democratic practice has generally prevailed since the era of decolonisation. Yet it ha...
-
Constitutional Reform, the Lord Chancellor, and Human Rights: The Battle of Form and Substance
This article examines the impact of the Human Rights Act on the government's constitutional proposals for reform of the role of the Lord Chancellor and the appointment of the judiciary. It also loo...
-
Public Bodies (Reform) Blog: Second Reading in the Lords
... ... The alternative opposition proposal in the name of Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, that the Bill be referred, as the Constitutional Reform Bill had been in 2004, to a Select Committee, was rejected by 188 votes to 151 ... Speakers, and over 50 peers sought to contribute, were ... ...
-
Article 50 - Royal Prerogative Or Parliament?
... ... Constitutional position ... Article 50 provides that it is for the United Kingdom to ... While the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010 requires that treaties are laid before the Houses ... ...
-
The Queen's Speech And Infrastructure
... ... programme will focus on economic growth, justice and constitutional reform. My Ministers' first priority will be to reduce the deficit and ... ...
-
Recent Select Committee Reports Show Tensions Between MPs Over Localism
... ... The Political and Constitutional Reform Committee published a report last month examining the prospects of ... ...