Contract Formation Acceptance in UK Law
-
Trentham (G Percy) Ltd v Archital Luxfer Ltd
“
The fact that the transaction was performed on both sides will often make it unrealistic to argue that there was no intention to enter into legal relations. It will often make it difficult to submit that the contract is void for vagueness or uncertainty. Specifically, the fact that the transaction is executed makes it easier to imply a term resolving any uncertainty, or, alternatively, it may make it possible to treat a matter not finalised in negotiations as inessential.
In a case where the transaction was fully performed the argument that there was no evidence upon which the judge could find that a contract was proved is implausible. Thus in Brogden v. Metropolitan Railway, supra, decided in 1877, the House of Lords concluded in a case where the parties had acted in accordance with an unsigned draft agreement for the delivery of consignments of coal that there was a contract on the basis of the draft.
One must not lose sight of the commercial character of the transaction. It is not a case where there was a continuing stipulation that a contract would only come into existence if a written agreement was concluded. But I am, in any event, satisfied that in this fully executed transaction a contract came into existence during performance even if it cannot be precisely analysed in terms of offer and acceptance.
-
Apple Corps Ltd v Apple Computer Inc. [ChD]
“
Before considering whether authority compels a conclusion one way or another, it is worth considering the validity of the point as a matter of principle. I confess that I can detect no conceptual barriers to the notion of a contract being treated as having been made in two places, and some not inconsiderable attractions.
On the facts of this particular case, that would coincide with the clearly expressed intentions of the parties that neither wished to give the other an advantage in terms of governing law and jurisdiction, and although introducing the somewhat random element of offer and acceptance into the concept might be said in one sense to coincide with their respective wishes, and although their expressed wishes did not go so far as to encompass the place of contracting, it seems to me that there is a good arguable case for saying that a dual place of contracting coincides rather more closely with the intentions of the parties.
-
Maple Leaf Macro Volatility Master Fund v Jacques Rouvroy and Another
“
Although the formation of contract is conventionally analysed in terms of whether a contractual offer was accepted, the law does not require rigorous compliance with an analysis along these lines. Nor does it require that any particular communication or act must in itself manifest that the party intends to contract: the court will, if appropriate, assess a person's conduct over a period and decide whether its cumulative effect is that he has evinced an intention to make the contract.
-
James v Greenwich London Borough Council
“
The judgments of this court in Dacas and Muscat were cited and analysed. It was correctly pointed out (paragraph 35) that, in order to imply a contract to give business reality to what was happening, the question was whether it was necessary to imply a contract of service between the worker and the end user, the test being that laid down by Bingham LJ in The Aramis [1989] 1 Lloyd's Rep 213 at 224
-
Sale of Goods Act 1893
... ... Formation of the Contract. PART I ... Formation of the ... (3.) There is an acceptance of goods within the meaning of this ... section ... ...
-
The Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017
... ... for Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs;“contract of long-term insurance” means any contract ... or shadow directors, or the formation of companies in a third country;F358(vii) there ... (2) P may not notify acceptance of the offer where P has already appealed against ... ...
-
Sale of Goods Act 1979
... ... , this Act applies in relation to the contract concerned without such modification of the ... 3(g) (with art. 6(1)) ... Part II: Formation of the Contract ... Contract of sale ... 2: ... acceptance to the seller or does any other act adopting the ... ...
-
Agricultural Holdings Act 1923
... ... and, in a case where the contract of tenancy was ... made on or after the first day ... (2) A new tenancy created by the acceptance of a ... tenant in accordance with the provisions ... (2) Formation of silos ... (3) Laying down of permanent ... ...
-
Michael Furmston and G J Tolhurst, CONTRACT FORMATION: LAW AND PRACTICE Oxford: Oxford University Press (www.oup.com), 2010. liii + 421 pp. ISBN 9780199284245. £175.
... ... The chapters cover some old favourites – the battle of the forms, the postal acceptance rule, and auctions, for example – as well as newer topics, such as online formation. Two chapters are dedicated to letters of intent, including ... ...
-
W W McBryde, THE LAW OF CONTRACT IN SCOTLAND Edinburgh: W Green & Son Ltd (www.wgreen.co.uk), Scottish Universities Law Institute, 3rd edn, 2007. clviii + 818 pp. ISBN 9780414016101. £175.
... ... In some areas, such as error in contract formation (in which the law could be regarded as barely intelligible at all and on ... of a contract in the introduction to the chapter on offer and acceptance. Precisely because so much was taken on board in the second edition, ... ...
-
Preliminary Sections
... ... services combined by one trader before a contract is concluded 47 ... Regulation 2(5)(b)(i): ... Acceptance of liability clause 155 A taxonomy of contractual ... packages and common law principles 233 Formation of the contract 235 ... Offer and acceptance 235 ... ...
-
Discrimination, Freedom, and the Limits of Contract
This article offers a challenge to the widely held view that legislative prohibitions against discrimination in employment represent a restriction on freedom of contract. Rather than engage in the ...... ... the law setting out the basic requirements of contract formation, such as the legal requirements of offer, acceptance and consid- ... ...
-
Contract formation – prescribed mode of acceptance can be waived by conduct
In Reveille Independent LLC v Anotech International (UK) Ltd [2016] EWCA Civ 443 the Court of Appeal ruled that a binding contract can be made by the parties' conduct even when a written 'Deal Memo...
-
Is A Signature Necessary To Complete A Contract?
... ... The pre-requisites for the formation of a contract are an ... intention to create legal relations, offer, ... ...
-
Arbitration Clause Separability Re-visited In The Court Of Appeal
... ... may be separable from the principal contract of which it ... forms or formed part (Heyman v ... That is an issue of contract formation, ... concerned with issues such as offer and ... ...
-
Establishing a contract: subsequent negotiations and inconsistent intentions
When determining whether parties had validly entered into a contract, the Court of Appeal held that it was wrong to disregard subsequent communications which were inconsistent with the existence of...... ... forward to receiving Mr Al-Husseiny’s “confirmation of acceptance of [the] offer during the course of Sunday” so that they could “agree ... highlights the holistic way in which a court will consider the formation of a contract, taking into account negotiations before and after an ... ...