Equality of Arms in UK Law
-
O'Neill v Phillips
“
Fourthly, the offer should, as in this case, provide for equality of arms between the parties. Both should have the same right of access to information about the company which bears upon the value of the shares and both should have the right to make submissions to the expert, though the form (written or oral) which these submissions may take should be left to the discretion of the expert himself.
-
Al-Rawi & others v The Security Service & others
“
Secondly, trials are conducted on the basis of the principle of natural justice. A party has a right to know the case against him and the evidence on which it is based. He is entitled to have the opportunity to respond to any such evidence and to any submissions made by the other side. The other side may not advance contentions or adduce evidence of which he is kept in ignorance. The Privy Council said in the civil case of Kanda v Government of Malaya [1962] AC 322, 337:
-
R Teresa G and Others v The British Red Cross Society (Intervener) The Director of Legal Aid Casework and Another
“
We accept the following summary of the relevant case-law given by Mr Drabble: (i) the Convention guarantees rights that are practical and effective, not theoretical and illusory in relation to the right of access to the courts ( Airey para 24, Steel and Morris para 59); (ii) the question is whether the applicant's appearance before the court or tribunal in question without the assistance of a lawyer was effective, in the sense of whether he or she was able to present the case properly and satisfactorily ( Airey para 24, McVicar para 48 and Steel and Morris para 59); (iii) it is relevant whether the proceedings taken as a whole were fair ( McVicar para 50, P,C and S para 91); (iv) the importance of the appearance of fairness is also relevant: simply because an applicant can struggle through "in the teeth of all the difficulties" does not necessarily mean that the procedure was fair ( P,C and S para 91); and (v) equality of arms must be guaranteed to the extent that each side is afforded a reasonable opportunity to present his or her case under conditions that do not place them at a substantial disadvantage vis-à-vis their opponent ( Steel and Morris para 62).
It is true that the test for article 8 as it is stated in the Strasbourg jurisprudence (whether those affected have been involved in the decision-making process, viewed as a whole, to a degree sufficient to provide them with the requisite protection of their interests) differs from the test for article 6(1) (whether there has been effective access to court).
-
Brown v Stott (Procurator Fiscal, Dunfermline)
“
The jurisprudence of the European Court very clearly establishes that while the overall fairness of a criminal trial cannot be compromised, the constituent rights comprised, whether expressly or implicitly, within article 6 are not themselves absolute.
-
ES v Chesterfield and North Derbyshire NHS Trust
“
Before the master, the application for two experts in the field of obstetrics seems largely to have been based on the argument of "equality of arms". The master rejected that argument since he drew a sharp distinction between witnesses of fact and expert witnesses.
-
Attorney General's Reference (No. 82a of 2000); R v Lea; R v Shatwell
“
The principle of equality of arms is as readily identified in the common law as it is in the Human Rights Act. It is a principle that entitles any defendant to a fair trial. However, a fair trial does not necessarily entail representation by a Queen's Counsel merely because the Crown are represented by a Queen's Counsel. The importance is to have an advocate, whether he be a barrister or a solicitor, who can ensure that a defendant's defence is properly and adequately placed before the court.
-
The Defence and Security Public Contracts Regulations 2011
... ... arms, munitions and war material adopted by the Council of the European ... means any person recognised as disabled within the meaning of the Equality Act 2010 ... ;“disability” has the same meaning as in that ... ...
-
Law Reform (Parent and Child) (Scotland) Act 1986
... ... law relating to adoption of children;(c) apply to any title, coat of arms, honour or dignity transmissible on the death of the holder thereof or ... be added the following subsection—“(5) Section 1(1) (legal equality of children) of the Law Reform (Parent and Child) (Scotland) Act 1986 ... ...
-
Wales Act 2017
... ... Equal opportunities ... 44: Equal opportunities: public sector equality duty ... (1) The Equality Act 2010 is amended as follows ... (2) In ... 1 of—(a) the hereditary revenues of the Crown,(b) the royal arms and standard, or(c) the compulsory acquisition of property—(i) belonging ... ...
-
Gun Barrel Proof Act 1855
... ... and Establishment in that Town of a public Proof House for Fire-arms : And whereas by an Act of the Fifty-third Year of the Reign of King ... voting, the Chairman having a Second or Casting Vote in Cases of Equality of Votes, and the Meeting may adjourn ; and it shall be the Duty of the ... ...
-
The EPPO and the equality of arms between the prosecutor and the defence1
This piece looks at the principle of equality of arms in EPPO proceedings, arguing that it should be looked at as a mandate for maximisation rather than only as a requirement of meeting certain min...
- Non-Disclosure of Prosecution Evidence and Equality of Arms: Edwards and Lewis v United Kingdom
-
A comparison between the standard of proof applicable in arbitration and formal adjudication
This article aims to describe the application of the standard of proof in arbitration and to question whether the standard to be applied should be the same as or lower than in ordinary civil justic...... ... of the applicable standard takes into consideration the equality of arms and other guarantees of due process, along with the fact of the ... ...
-
Bent into Security: Barrister Contribution to a Skewed Order in Two Terrorism Prosecutions in Australia
This article explores two terrorism prosecutions – R v. Benbrika and Ors and R v. Elomar and Ors – to probe how Australian lawyers approach the integration of national security interests into the h...... ... : accommodation to the pre- cautionary standard, the resetting of equality of arms expectations, and brokered agreements that depend on the ... ...
- 'Fairness And Equality Of Arms In Divorce
-
Consultation On Remote Hearings
... ... the location of the parties; ... equality of arms; ... minimising travel; ... the volume of documentation; ... ...
-
Consultation On Remote Hearings
... ... the location of the parties; ... equality of arms; ... minimising travel; ... the volume of documentation; ... ...
-
Inquests
... ... There will continue not to be 'equality of arms 'for all participants in the inquest process ... Evidence and ... ...