Foreign Judgment in UK Law

Leading Cases
  • New Cap Reinsurance Corporation Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Grant; Rubin v Eurofinance SA
    • Supreme Court
    • 24 October 2012
    “

    The court will not simply consider whether the steps taken abroad would have amounted to a submission in English proceedings. Conversely, it does not necessarily follow that because the foreign court would not regard the steps as a submission that they will not be so regarded by the English court as a submission for the purposes of the enforcement of a judgment of the foreign court. The question whether there has been a submission is to be inferred from all the facts.

  • National Navigation Company v Endesa Gereacion SA
    • Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
    • 17 December 2009
    “

    In my view the question whether the courts of this country should recognise a foreign judgment given in proceedings taken in breach of an arbitration agreement is also essentially one of jurisdiction.

  • AK Investment CJSC v Kyrgyz Mobil Tel Ltd
    • Privy Council
    • 10 March 2011
    “

    First, the claimant must satisfy the court that in relation to the foreign defendant there is a serious issue to be tried on the merits, i.e. a substantial question of fact or law, or both. Third, the claimant must satisfy the court that in all the circumstances the Isle of Man is clearly or distinctly the appropriate forum for the trial of the dispute, and that in all the circumstances the court ought to exercise its discretion to permit service of the proceedings out of the jurisdiction.

  • Carl-Zeiss-Stiftung v Rayner & Keeler Ltd and Others (Original Appeal) and Rayner & Keeler Ltd and Others v Courts and Others (Cross Appeal)
    • House of Lords
    • 18 May 1966
    “

    In the first place, we are not familiar with modes of procedure in many foreign countries, and it may not be easy to be sure that a particular issue has been decided or that its decision was a basis of the foreign judgment and not merely collateral or obiter.

    But with these reservations, where after careful examination there appears to have been a full contestation and a clear decision on an issue, it would in my opinion be unfortunate to exclude estoppel by issue decision from the sphere of recognition.

  • Owens Bank Ltd v Fulvio Bracco and Another ; Case C-129/92
    • House of Lords
    • 19 May 1994
    “

    The rule rests on the principle that there must be finality in litigation which would be defeated if it were open to the unsuccessful party in one action to bring a second action to re-litigate the issue determined against him simply on the ground that the opposing party had obtained judgment in the first action by perjured evidence. The rule rests on the principle that there must be finality in litigation which would be defeated if it were open to the unsuccessful party in one action to bring a second action to re-litigate the issue determined against him simply on the ground that the opposing party had obtained judgment in the first action by perjured evidence.

  • Buttes Gas and Oil Company v Hammer; Buttes Gas and Oil Company v Hammer (No. 3)
    • House of Lords
    • 29 October 1981
    “

    Leaving aside all possibility of embarrassment in our foreign relations (which it can be said not to have been drawn to the attention of the court by the executive) there are - to follow the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals - no judicial or manageable standards by which to judge these issues, or to adopt another phrase (from a passage not quoted), the court would be in a judicial no-man's land: the court would be asked to review transactions in which four sovereign states were involved, which they had brought to a precarious settlement, after diplomacy and the use of force, and to say that at least part of these were "unlawful" under international law.

See all results
Legislation
  • Nuclear Installations Act 1965
    • UK Non-devolved
    • Friday January 01, 1965
    ... ... F58 10: Duty of certain foreign operators ... (1) ... including proceedings for the enforcement of a judgment registered under the M5 ... ...
  • Foreign Judgments (Reciprocal Enforcement) Act 1933
    • UK Non-devolved
    • Sunday January 01, 1933
    ... ... (2) Subject to subsection (2A) of this section, a judgment of a recognised court is within this subsection if it satisfies the following conditions, namely— ... ...
  • County Courts Act 1984
    • UK Non-devolved
    • Sunday January 01, 1984
    ... ... to hear and determine an action by virtue of this section, the judgment of the court in the action shall be in full discharge of all demands in ... 68: Duty of judge to determine foreign law in jury trials ... Where, for the purpose of disposing ... ...
  • Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1991
    • UK Non-devolved
    • Tuesday January 01, 1991
    ... ... judgment ... ...
See all results
Books & Journal Articles
  • Effects of Foreign Judgments Relating to International Arbitral Awards: Is the ‘judgment Route’ the Wrong Road?
    • No. 4-3, 2013
    • Journal of International Dispute Settlement
    • 587-628
  • The Recognition, and Res Judicata Effect, of a United States Class Actions Judgment in England: A Rebuttal of V ivendi
    • No. 75-2, March 2012
    • The Modern Law Review
    • 0000
    United States' courts have proven willing to certify multi‐jurisdictional class actions which purport to adjudicate the claims of both American and foreign (i.e., non‐US‐domiciled) class members. T...
    ... ... States’ courts have proven willing to certify multi-jurisdictional class actions whichpurport to adjudicate the claims of both American and foreign (i.e., non-US-domiciled) classmembers.This article contends, however, that a class actions judgment/settlement issued by a UScourt would not be ... ...
  • Strategies for Preventive Diplomacy and Conflict Resolution
    • No. 34-1, March 1999
    • Cooperation and Conflict
    • 0000
    Every year, Uppsala University awards the Johan Skytte Prize in Political Science to a scholar who has made a valuable contribution to political science. In 1998 the prize was awarded to Stanford P...
  • Cross‐border asset protection: an offshore perspective
    • No. 10-3, July 2003
    • Journal of Financial Crime
    • 229-245
    Considers the ability of an applicant to reach assets in offshore jurisdictions, showing that there is a difference between the offshore world and the rest of the world; most of the “traditional” o...
    ... ... thecross-border preservation of assets and enforcementof eventual judgment takes time and can leave aclaimant at the behest of jurisdictions with ... the identi-®ed assets within Sunland (a freezing order inaid of foreign proceedings where the substantivecause of action will be ... ...
See all results
Law Firm Commentaries
See all results
Forms
See all results