Medical Records in UK Law
-
Ashworth Hospital Authority v MGN Ltd
“
The extracts published consisted of observations of Brady by different members of the staff at Ashworth that were recorded as part of his medical records. Though they were personal to Brady, I consider that Ashworth had a clear independent interest in retaining their confidentiality. The Department of Health published, on 7 th March 1996, Guidance on the Protection and Use of Patient Information. This includes the following guidance under the heading, 'Who has a duty of confidence?'
The disclosure of confidential medical records to the press is misconduct which is not merely of concern to the individual establishment in which it occurs. It is an attack on an area of confidentiality which should be safeguarded in any democratic society. The protection of patient information is of vital concern to the National Health Service and, I suspect, to health services throughout Europe.
In my judgment, the true position is that it is always prima facie (I can do no better than the Latin) contrary to the public interest that press sources should be disclosed; and in any given case the debate which follows will be conducted upon the question whether there is an overriding public interest, amounting to a pressing social need, to which the need to keep press sources confidential should give way.
-
Ashworth Hospital Authority v MGN Ltd
“
In addition, Mr Brewster (information manager), in his statement, sets out the reasons why it is important that the authority should be able to identify the employee or employees who are responsible for the wrongful disclosure. Medical records will always be confidential but this is particularly important in the case of the class of patients that the authority is responsible for caring for at Ashworth.
The situation here is exceptional, as it was in Financial Times Ltd v Interbrew SA [2002] EWCA Civ 274 and as it has to be, if disclosure of sources is to be justified. The care of patients at Ashworth is fraught with difficulty and danger. The source's disclosure was wholly inconsistent with the security of the records and the disclosure was made worse because it was purchased by a cash payment.
-
Mersey Care NHS Trust v Ackroyd (No.2)
“
Authorities cited by Mr Nelson QC, such as X v Y, make clear the difficulty facing a person claiming to be justified in disclosing medical information to the public at large in the public interest. The force of those authorities is not diminished by the approach to public interest disclosure approved by the Court of Appeal in London Regional Transport.
-
Woolgar v Chief Constable of Sussex Police and Another
“
What it then did was to "examine whether, in the light of the case as a whole, the reasons adduced to justify the interference were relevant and sufficient and whether the measure was proportionate to the legitimate aim pursued." The court noted that the information was "communicated by one public institution to another in the context of an assessment of whether she satisfied the legal conditions for obtaining a benefit which she herself had requested."
-
The National Health Service (Personal Medical Services Agreements) Regulations 2015
... ... seek the advice of the medical practitioner or dentist who is a party to the plan;(b) the supplementary prescriber has access to the health records of the patient to whom the plan relates which are used by any medical practitioner or dentist who is a party to the plan;(c) if it is a prescription ... ...
-
The National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015
... ... seek the advice of the medical practitioner or dentist who is a party to the plan;(b) the supplementary prescriber has access to the health records of the patient to whom the plan relates which are used by a medical practitioner or dentist who is a party to the plan;(c) if it is a prescription ... ...
-
Crime and Courts Act 2013
... ... of retention of Supreme Court security officers,(b) the keeping of records about articles which have been so surrendered or seized,(c) the period for ... specified controlled drug had been prescribed or supplied to D for medical or dental purposes,(b) D took the drug in accordance with any directions ... ...
-
The Armed Forces and Reserve Forces (Compensation Scheme) Order 2011
... ... by the Armed Forces Pension Regulations 2014;“accredited medical specialist” means a medical practitioner whose name is included in the ... Order, the Secretary of State is to produce such medical or other records of a member or a former member (whether living or deceased) , as are held ... ...
-
Taking the long view of medical records preservation and archives
Purpose: – The purpose of this paper is to present an argument for taking the long view of the retention and preservation of inactive medical records. Design/methodology/approach: – Using the theo...
-
Medical records management framework to support public healthcare services in Limpopo province of South Africa
Purpose: This study aims to develop a framework for the management of medical records in support of health-care service delivery in the hospitals in the Limpopo province of South Africa. Design/me...
-
Setting the records straight: a study of hospital medical records undertaken by the Audit Commission
The Audit Commission is the statutory body which oversees the external audit of local authorities and agencies within the National Health Service in England and Wales. As part of its function the C...
-
Adoption of electronic medical records: the role of network effects
Purpose: This paper aims to examine the role of network effects (defined as increased utility for users of a technology that occurs when adoption increases among other users) in the adoption of ele...
- Medical Records In Compensation Claims
- Freedom Of Information - Disclosure Of Medical Records
-
Weekly Data Privacy Alert – 24 November
Please click here to read the latest data privacy alert from the Squire Patton Boggs Data Protection & Cyber Security team. This week, the alert covers news from the UK, Germany, the US and Austra...... ... and Australia, including: UK Pharmacist fined for spying on the medical records of family and friends Health Board ordered to improve privacy ... ...
-
Fraudulent insurance claims and private prosecutions
The insurer AXA in the UK successfully brought a private prosecution for a fraudulent claim. The insured alleged that he had damaged his back in the course of his employment and claimed £100 000 ag...... ... Medical records showed that the back injury pre-existed the date of the alleged ... ...
-
Medical report
Road Traffic Act (RTA) personal injury forms including the form to contest an RTA claim.... ... Section A — Claimant’s details ... Date of birth ... Claimant’s full name ... Occupation ... 1.1 Were medical records provided? ... If Yes, which records were seen? ... 1.2 Has photo ID been confirmed? ... If Yes, what type of photo ID was checked ... If No, what ... ...
-
Medical report - low value personal injury claims in employers' liability and public liability (£1,000 - £25,000)
Road Traffic Act (RTA) personal injury forms including the form to contest an RTA claim.... ... Section A — Claimant’s details ... Date of birth ... Claimant’s full name ... Occupation ... 1.1 Were medical records provided? ... If Yes, which records were seen? ... 1.2 Has photo ID been confirmed? ... If Yes, what type of photo ID was checked ... If No, what ... ...
-
Notice of application to consider the financial position of the respondent after divorce / dissolution
Forms to apply for a divorce, dissolve a civil partnership or legally separate, including the D8 application and financial order forms.... ... (ii) an appropriate health professional who has access to the medical ... records of the prospective party referred to below; or ... (iii) the ... ...
-
Form A
Forms to apply for a divorce, dissolve a civil partnership or legally separate, including the D8 application and financial order forms.... ... (ii) an appropriate health professional who has access to the medical ... records of the prospective party referred to below; or ... (iii) the ... ...