Missing Evidence in UK Law
-
R v R.d.
“
In considering the question of prejudice to the defence, it seems to us that it is necessary to distinguish between mere speculation about what missing documents or witnesses might show, and missing evidence which represents a significant and demonstrable chance of amounting to decisive or strongly supportive evidence emerging on a specific issue in the case. The court will need to consider what evidence directly relevant to the appellant's case has been lost by reason of the passage of time.
Moreover, the complaints of J, G and S were not date specific but were couched in general terms of sexual abuse occurring on very many occasions during visits during school holidays within wide periods identified in the indictment. Accordingly, an alibi in its true sense was not the issue before the jury. The issue was in reality whether or not the jury could be sure that the abuse had taken place.
-
R v Feltham Magistrates Court, ex parte Ebrahim ; Mouat v DPP
“
If, in such a case, there is sufficient credible evidence, apart from the missing evidence, which, if believed, would justify a safe conviction, then a trial should proceed, leaving the defendant to seek to persuade the jury or magistrates not to convict because evidence which might otherwise have been available was not before the court through no fault of his. Often the absence of a video film or fingerprints or DNA material is likely to hamper the prosecution as much as the defence.
-
DPP v Fell
“
Fourthly, the grant of the stay in a case such as this is exceptional. It caters for and only for those cases which cannot be accommodated with all their imperfections within the trial process. It is of course a very different situation where evidence has gone missing through some serious culpability or bad faith on the part of the prosecutor or investigator, but that is not this case.
-
PR v The Crown
“
In some instances, this opportunity exists; in others it does not. It is to be regretted if relevant records become unavailable, but when this happens the effect may be to put the defendant closer to the position of many accused whose trial turns on a decision by the jury as to whether they are sure of the oral evidence of the prosecution witness or witnesses, absent other substantive information by which their testimony can be tested.
-
Secretary of State for the Home Department v Jovy Rodriguez
“
Taken overall, the Evidential Flexibility process instruction is demonstrably not designed to give an applicant the opportunity first to remedy any defect or inadequacy in the application or supporting documentation so as to save the application from refusal after substantive consideration.
-
Rodriguez (Flexibility Policy) [Upper Tribunal]
“
UK Border Agency caseowners employ a measure of flexibility when considering PBS applications. For example, caseowners operate a system which allows them to contact applicants to request further documentation or clarification where appropriate. In addition a validation stage is being trialled whereby applicants are contacted where mandatory evidence is missing and given the opportunity to provide it before their application is rejected.
-
Presumption of Death Act 2013
... ... 13An Act to make provision in relation to the presumed death of missing persons; and for connected purposes.[26th March 2013] ... Be it enacted ... of Presumed Deaths in relation to a person is to be received as evidence of the person's death, without further or other proof, if it purports to ... ...
-
The Fostering Services (England) Regulations 2011
... ... Behaviour management and children missing from foster parent's home ... (1) The fostering service provider must ... (5) Documentary evidence of any relevant qualification ... (6) A full employment history, ... ...
-
The European Union (Recognition of Professional Qualifications) Regulations 2015
... ... higher education used in the European Higher Education Area; ... “evidence of formal qualifications” has the meaning set out in regulation 9(2) ... F102regulation 42 commence at the point when an application or any missing documents have been submitted by an applicant to a point of single contact ... ...
-
The Armed Forces and Reserve Forces (Compensation Scheme) Order 2011
... ... to deciding a condition for payment of benefit under Part 2 is missing; and(b) there is other reliable evidence to determine the material fact ... ...
-
Further evidence on the extent and time course of repeat missing incidents involving children: A research note
This study examines the extent and time course of repeat missing incidents involving children. Using data from one UK police force (n = 2,251), we find (1) that the majority (65%) of missing incide...
-
Further evidence on the extent and time course of repeat missing incidents involving children: A research note
This study examines the extent and time course of repeat missing incidents involving children. Using data from one UK police force (n = 2,251), we find (1) that the majority (65%) of missing incide...
-
Lost from the conversation: Missing people, and the role of Police media in shaping community awareness
Media as a public health messaging tool can shape community perception. In missing persons’ investigations Police utilise media to assist in location and recovery of absent people. This study, of A...... ... This study, of Australian media in 2019, revealed that the statistical evidence ofwho goes missing, and returns, revealed that is not replicated in news articles. Contentanalysis of 2,400 media items highlighting a disconnect ... ...
-
Lost from the conversation: Missing people, and the role of Police media in shaping community awareness
Media as a public health messaging tool can shape community perception. In missing persons’ investigations Police utilise media to assist in location and recovery of absent people. This study, of A...... ... This study, of Australian media in 2019, revealed that the statistical evidence ofwho goes missing, and returns, revealed that is not replicated in news articles. Contentanalysis of 2,400 media items highlighting a disconnect ... ...
-
"Wagatha Christie": Adverse Inferences Can Be Drawn Where Evidence Has Been Lost
... ... In the recent case of Vardy v Rooney, the High Court ... provided useful guidance as to how it will deal with the issue of ... lost or missing evidence ... The court can draw adverse inferences against a party where ... data has been lost; particularly where the loss appears deliberate ... ...
-
Anticorruption compliance is more than adopting a policy
When the prosecutors come knocking on the door with a search warrant, one of the first things they will look for is evidence as to whether the company adhered to and fulfilled the six principles of...
-
Aston V City Of Liverpool YMCA ' A Leap Of Faith?
... ... in the face of inconsistent and unreliable evidence whether the ... YMCA were liable for the injuries sustained by a resident ... unsatisfactory or missing evidence on both sides to reach its ... conclusions - a somewhat ... ...
-
Home Office Evidential Flexibility Policy Explained
... ... approach to gaps in evidence. When evidential requirements are ... nearly met, decision-makers may ... Where information or a document is missing due to oversight or any ... other reason, the Home Office should liaise ... ...
-
Flats and premises collective enfranchisement (missing landlord)
Leasehold enfranchisement and extension applications forms including the form to apply for determination of reasonable costs.... ... Please do not send any other documents ... When further evidence is needed, you will be asked to send it in separately ... ... If you have any questions about how to fill in this form or the ... ...
-
Flats and premises leasehold enfranchisement (missing landlord, lease terms and/or premium)
Leasehold enfranchisement and extension applications forms including the form to apply for determination of reasonable costs.... ... Please do not send any other documents ... When further evidence is needed, you will be asked to send it in separately. ... If you have any questions about how to fill in this form or the procedures ... ...
-
Apply to determine the price for enfranchisement of houses with missing landlord
Leasehold enfranchisement and extension applications forms including the form to apply for determination of reasonable costs.... ... Please do not send any other documents ... When further evidence is needed, you will be asked to send it in separately ... If you have any questions about how to fill in this form or the procedures the ... ...
-
Supplement for an application for a Recovery Order
Standard directions forms under the Children Act.... ... the responsible person ... [is] [are] missing ... The reason(s) for the application ... Include your ground(s) for ... If you are relying on a report or other documentary evidence, state the date(s) and author(s) ... and enclose a copy ... ...