Promissory Estoppel in UK Law
-
Amalgamated Investment & Property Company Ltd v Texas Commerce International Bank Ltd
“
When the parties to a transaction proceed on the basis of an underlying assumption—either of fact or of law—whether due to misrepresentation or mistake makes no difference—on which they have conducted the dealings between them—neither of them will be allowed to go back on that assumption when it would be unfair or unjust to allow him to do so. If he does seek to go back on it, the courts will give the other such remedy as the equity of the case demands.
-
Yeoman's Row Management Ltd and another v Cobbe
“
An "estoppel" bars the object of it from asserting some fact or facts, or, sometimes, something that is a mixture of fact and law, that stands in the way of some right claimed by the person entitled to the benefit of the estoppel. The estoppel becomes a "proprietary" estoppel - a sub-species of a "promissory" estoppel - if the right claimed is a proprietary right, usually a right to or over land but, in principle, equally available in relation to chattels or choses in action.
-
Sabrina Soon Duck Park Kim and Another v Chasewood Park Residents Ltd (Respondent/Claimant)
“
There is no doubt that in order to found a promissory estoppel (in the same way as any other estoppel based on a representation of fact) the representation or promise must be clear and unambiguous. But this principle raises a number of subsidiary questions.
-
Christopher Charles Dixon and Another v Blindley Heath Investments Ltd (Respondent/Cross-Appellant) Peter Bass and Others (Respondents to the Cross Appeal) Gerald Fred Clarke and Another (Respondents as to costs only)
“
Estoppel by convention is not founded on a unilateral representation, but rather on mutually manifest conduct by the parties based on a common, but mistaken, assumption of law or fact: its basis is consensual.
-
Collier v P & M J Wright (Holdings) Ltd
“
The facts of this case demonstrate that, if (1) a debtor offers to pay part only of the amount he owes; (2) the creditor voluntarily accepts that offer, and (3) in reliance on the creditor's acceptance the debtor pays that part of the amount he owes in full, the creditor will, by virtue of the doctrine of promissory estoppel, be bound to accept that sum in full and final satisfaction of the whole debt.
-
Motor Oil (Hellas) Corinth Refineries SA v Shipping Corporation of India
“
On the other hand, equitable estoppel requires an unequivocal representation by one party that he will not insist upon his legal rights against the other party, and such reliance by the representee as will render it inequitable for the representor to go back upon his representation.
-
Steria Ltd v Ronald Hutchison
“
Even this formulation is relatively broad brush, and it should be emphasised that there are many qualifications or refinements which can be made to it.
- THE PROBLEM PROMISSORY NOTE: A QUESTION OF ESTOPPEL
-
A Strange Sort of Survival for Pinnel's Case: Collier v P & M J Wright (Holdings) Limited
This note discusses the decision of the Court of Appeal in Collier v P & M J Wright (Holdings) Limited, and notes that while the Court purports to uphold both the decision in Pinnel's Case and the ...... ... and the e¡ect of Re Selectmove , in fact, by an extension of promissory estoppel,it bypasses them. In Collier v P & M J W right (Holdings) ... ...
-
VARIATION, WAIVER AND ESTOPPEL—A RE‐APPRAISAL
... ... deal with the problem of absence of consideration in such situations has been to develop the doctrine of equitable or promissory estoppel.‘ Neither the precise requirements nor the effect of the doctrine appear to be settled. The overall picture is thus ... ...
-
MWB Business Exchange Centres Ltd: The Practical Benefit Doctrine Marches On
In MWB Business Exchange Centres Ltd v Rock Advertising Ltd the Court of Appeal held that when an ongoing contract is varied so that one party's obligation to pay money is reduced, the variation is...... ... an agreed part-payment of a debt by a debtor will always raise an estoppel pre venting the creditor from demanding the remainder of the debt ... 5 ,1 6a n dM .H .Og i l v i e ,‘ P a r tP a y m e n t , Promissory Estoppel and Lord Denning’s “Brilliant” Balance’ (2010) 49 ... ...
-
THE 'ZENOVIA' - Commercial Court Overturns Maritime Arbitration Award Relating To Redelivery Notice: IMT SHIPPING AND CHARTERING GMBH V CHANSUNG SHIPPING COMPANY LTD [2009] EWHC 739 (Comm)
... ... Rather, the ... Tribunal held that there was a promissory estoppel in favour of the ... owners in that they had refixed their vessel ... ...
-
No Estoppel Where Terms Subsequently Found To Apply And 'Payment On Account' Sufficient Reservation To Enable Recovery Of Mistaken Payments
... ... that the parties had at all times dealt with each other on the basis of a mutual assumption that the RHA conditions did not apply and (ii) promissory estoppel, namely that Wincanton had represented by its silence or behaviour that it did not rely on the RHA conditions and that they had no ... ...
-
Pharmacy Benefit Managers Are Not Subject To The Any Willing Provider Laws In GA, MS, Or NC, Says Eighth Circuit
... ... District of Missouri, bringing claims sounding in contract, promissory estoppel, federal antitrust, and violations of Georgia, Mississippi, and ... ...
-
Harsh but fair? Implied terms won’t save you if written agreement clear
The Court of Appeal has confirmed, if confirmation were needed, that no term may be implied into an agreement where that implied term conflicts with the express wording of that agreement, even if t...... ... Joseph also failed to persuade the court that there was a promissory estoppel. In essence, all the email did was say when he would be informed ... ...