Ultra Vires in UK Law
-
Berkeley v Secretary of State for the Environment Transport and the Regions and Another
“
Although section 288(5)(b), in providing that the court "may" quash an ultra vires planning decision, clearly confers a discretion upon the court, I doubt whether, consistently with its obligations under European law, the court may exercise that discretion to uphold a planning permission which has been granted contrary to the provisions of the Directive.
-
Rolled Steel Products (Holdings) Ltd v British Steel Corporation
“
For reasons which will appear, in my judgment, the use of the phrase "ultra vires" should be restricted to those cases where the transaction is beyond the capacity of the company and therefore wholly void.
-
Woolwich Equitable Building Society v Commissioners of Inland Revenue
“
I would therefore hold that money paid by a citizen to a public authority in the form of taxes or other levies paid pursuant to an ultra vires demand by the authority is prima facie recoverable by the citizen as of right.
-
Raymond v Honey
“
In my opinion, there is nothing in the Prison Act 1952 that confers power to make regulations which would deny, or interfere with, the right of the respondent, as a prisoner, to have unimpeded access to a court. Section 47, which has already been quoted, is a section concerned with the regulation and management of prisons and, in my opinion, is quite insufficient to authorise hindrance or interference with so basic a right.
-
F. Hoffmann-LA Roche & Company A.G. and Others v Secretary of State for Trade and Industry
“
It would, however, be inconsistent with the doctrine of ultra vires as it has been developed in English law as a means of controlling abuse of power by the Executive arm of Government if the judgment of a court in proceedings properly constituted that a statutory instrument was ultra vires were to have any lesser consequence in law than to render the instrument incapable of ever having had any legal effect upon the rights or duties of the parties to the proceedings ( c.f. Ridge v. Baldwin [1964] A.C. 40).
-
R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Simms
“
Fundamental rights cannot be overridden by general or ambiguous words. This is because there is too great a risk that the full implications of their unqualified meaning may have passed unnoticed in the democratic process. In the absence of express language or necessary implication to the contrary, the courts therefore presume that even the most general words were intended to be subject to the basic rights of the individual.
-
Smith v East Elloe Rural District Council
“
But this argument is in reality a play on the meaning of the word nullity. An Order, even if not made in good faith, is still an act capable of legal consequences. Unless the necessary proceedings are taken at law to establish the cause of invalidity and to get it quashed or otherwise upset it will remain as effective for its ostensible purpose as the most impeccable of Orders.
-
Northern Ireland Act 1998
... ... 1999/3209, art. 2, Sch ... 80: Legislative power to remedy ultra vires acts ... (1) The Secretary of State may by order make such ... ...
-
Scotland Act 1998
... ... 3(l) (with regs. 10, 22) ... 107: Legislative power to remedy ultra vires acts.: Subordinate legislation may make such provision as the person ... ...
-
The Terrorist Asset-Freezing etc. Act 2010 (Guernsey) Order 2011
... ... (a) the decision was ultra vires or there was some other error of law, ... (b) the decision was ... ...
-
Income Tax (Employments) (No. 2) Regulations, 1951
... ... -up, etc., which the Law Officers of the Crown have advised is ultra vires ... Regulations 4 and 5 amend the special Pay As You Earn system ... ...
-
Ultra Vires Review and the Demise of Constitutional Pluralism
The Czech Constitutional Court decision in the Czecho-Slovak pension saga, declaring a judgment of the Court of Justice ultra vires, represents one important step in the debate on the sustainabilit...
- Municipal Boroughs and Ultra‐ Vires
- Municipal Boroughs and Ultra Vires
- What is the Point of Ultra Vires?
- Jurisdiction Regulation: Knock-Out Blow To The Ultra Vires Torpedo
- Ultra Vires Still A Live Issue In OTC Derivatives Contracts But All May Not Be Lost
- Cost Cutting Cornwall Fails - Local Authority Pushes The Principle Of Pure Ultra Vires To The Limit In An Attempt To Jump Out Of Its Contractual Obligations
- If A Lender Lends Money Under A Contract Which Subsequently Is Found To Be Ultra Vires, Is The Lender Entitled To Recover That Money By Claiming Restitution?