Unconscionable Bargain in UK Law
-
PORTMAN BUILDING SOCIETY v DUSANGH and Others (Defendants/Appellant)
“
To my mind none of the essential touchstones of an unconscionable bargain are to be found in this case. The appellant was not at a serious disadvantage to the building society: neither he nor his son had any existing indebtedness towards them. His situation was not exploited by the building society. The building society did not act in a morally reprehensible manner. The transaction, although improvident, was not "overreaching and oppressive".
-
Credit Lyonnais Bank Nederland NV v Burch
“
The cases show that it is not sufficient that she should have received independent advice unless she has acted on that advice; if this were not so, the same influence that produced her desire to enter into the transaction would cause her to disregard any advice not to do so.
-
Lobb (Alec) (Garages) Ltd v Total Oil (Great Britain) Ltd
“
Mere impecuniosity has never been held a ground for equitable relief. On the contrary the defendants were reluctant to enter into the transaction. The plaintiffs took independent advice from their solicitors and accountants. They went into the transaction with their eyes open, and it was of benefit to them because they were enabled to continue trade from the site for a number of years. In my view the Judge was right to refuse equitable relief.
-
Lucy Ann Andrews Habberfield v Jane Sarah Andrews Habberfield
“
Looking back from the moment when assurances are repudiated, the nearer the overall outcome comes to the expected reciprocal performance of requested acts in return for the assurance, the stronger will be the case for an award based on or approximating to the expectation interest created by the assurance. That does no more than to recognise party autonomy to decide for themselves what a proportionate reward would be for the contemplated detriment.
-
R v Attorney General of England and Wales
“
Nevertheless, an unreasonable refusal of consent by the MOD could have been challenged as a matter of public law and the appropriate tribunal for such a challenge would have been the court having jurisdiction to grant judicial review of decisions of the MOD, namely, the administrative court in England. It had the broader object of preventing public controversy which might be damaging to the efficiency of the Special Forces.
-
Paragon Finance Plc v Nash and Another; Same v Staunton and Another
“
"Nevertheless, it seems clear that the concepts of extortion and unconscionability are very similar. 'Extortionate', like 'harsh and unconscionable', signifies not merely that the terms of the bargain are stiff, or even unreasonable, but that they are so unfair as to be oppressive. This carries with it the notion of morally reprehensible conduct on the part of the creditor in taking grossly unfair advantage of the debtor's circumstances.
-
Takhar v Gracefield Developments Ltd and Others
“
Where fraud has been raised at the original trial and new evidence as to the existence of the fraud is prayed in aid to advance a case for setting aside the judgment, it seems to me that it can be argued that the court having to deal with that application should have a discretion as to whether to entertain the application.
-
Law of Property Act 1925
......livery and seisin, or by feoffment, or by bargain and sale;. and a conveyance of an interest in land may operate to. pass ...the court to set aside or modify unconscionable. bargains. X . Wills. Part X. . Wills. . S-175 . Contingent and ......
-
Law of Property (Amendment) Act 1924
......seisin, or by feoffment, or by bargain and sale; and a conveyance. of an interest in land may operate to pass ...the court to set aside or modify unconscionable bargains.’ SCH-3.34 . Corporations sole. 34 Corporations sole. . 34. ......
-
Without the Power to Drink or Contract
......A common ruse by someone seeking to gain an advantageous bargain is to supply the other party with alcohol as a way of weakening their ...47 These authors were describing unconscionable loans, but the same comment can be made more generally about unfair ......
-
Equity is Dead. Long Live Equity!
......References to conscience and the prevention of unconscionable conduct have become increasingly prevalent in judicial pronouncements at ..., is abused in a manner which extends beyond the remit of a hard bargain or mere folly, 12 and would be assessed in light of the abuser’s state ......
-
The Heir–Locator’s Lost Inheritance
......Those additional factors were unconscionable bargain in Rees v De Bernardy (an actual ground for the decision of ......
-
‘Real Rape’, Law Reform and The Role of
Research: The Evolution of the Victorian Crimes (Rape) Act 1991
This paper provides a brief history of the Victorian Crimes (Rape) Act 1991 and examines the role which social science research played in the development of .........Waye V (1992) 'Rape and the Unconscionable Bargain', Criminal Law Journal, Vol 16, pp 94-105. Wells C (1982) ......
- Undue Influence And The Unconscionable Bargain
-
LIA v Goldman Sachs: Unusual Investor Challenge Fails In The High Court
...... to rely on claims in equity, alleging undue influence and unconscionable bargain on the bank's part. These issues are usually raised in 'husband ......
-
The Libyan Investment Authority V Goldman Sachs International [2016] EWHC 2530 (Ch)
...... To find that a transaction amounts to an unconscionable bargain, there must be the following:. some impropriety in the conduct ......
-
Bad Leaver Provision Where Shares And Loan Notes Were Forfeited Was Found Not To Be Unconscionable Or A Penalty
...... The EAT held that there is a three stage test for setting aside an unconscionable bargain: (1) one party must have been at a serious disadvantage whether through poverty, ignorance, lack of advice or otherwise; (2) the other party must ......