Unsound Mind in UK Law
-
Kirby v Leather
“
It seems to me that the words "of unsound mini" in a statute must be construed in relation to the subject matter with which the statute is dealing. So here it seems to me in this statute a person is "of unsound mind" when he is, by reason of mental illness, incapable of managing his affairs in relation to the accident as a reasonable man would do.
After a time he was to someextent able to appreciate (from being told by others) something of what had happened to him, and indeed to his scooter. Not long enough to be able to appreciate the nature and extent of any claim that he might have. In particular he had no insight at all into his own mental state. He was not capable of instructing a solicitor properly. He certainly was not capable of exercising any reasonable judgment upon a possible settlement.
-
Reeves v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis
“
People of full age and sound understanding must look after themselves and take responsibility for their actions. This philosophy expresses itself in the fact that duties to safeguard from harm deliberately caused by others are unusual and a duty to protect a person of full understanding from causing harm to himself is very rare indeed.
The difference between being of sound and unsound mind, while appealing to lawyers who like clear-cut rules, seems to me inadequate to deal with the complexities of human psychology in the context of the stresses caused by imprisonment. The duty, as I have said, is a very unusual one, arising from the complete control which the police or prison authorities have over the prisoner, combined with the special danger of people in prison taking their own lives.
But the duty of care may sometimes extend to preventing people injuring themselves deliberately. The person to whom the duty is owed may be unaware of the risks to which he will expose himself by his deliberate act. Or he may be of unsound mind, with the result that he is at risk of doing something to himself which no rational person would do as he would appreciate that to do this would inevitably lead to injury.
-
R (Ferreira) v HM Senior Coroner for Inner South London
“
In the case of a patient in intensive care, the true cause of their not being free to leave is their underlying illness, which was the reason why they were taken into intensive care. The person may have been rendered unresponsive by reason of treatment they have received, such as sedation, but, while that treatment is an immediate cause, it is not the real cause. The real cause is their illness, a matter for which (in the absent of special circumstances) the state is not responsible.
-
Airedale NHS Trust v Bland
“
First, it is established that the principle of self-determination requires that respect must be given to the wishes of the patient, so that if an adult patient of sound mind refuses, however unreasonably, to consent to treatment or care by which his life would or might be prolonged, the doctors responsible for his care must give effect to his wishes, even though they do not consider it to be in his best interests to do so (see Schloendorff v. Society of New York Hospital 105 N.E. 92, 93, per Cardozo J. (1914); S. v. McC. (Orse S.) and M (D.S. Intervener); W v. W [1972] A.C. 24, 43, per Lord Reid; and Sidaway v. Board of Governors of the Bethlem Royal Hospital and the Maudsley Hospital [1985] A.C. 871, 882, per Lord Scarman).
- William Neachell (a person of unsound mind) estate: enabling his Act 1844
-
Trustee Act 1850
... ... The Expression ‘Person of unsound Mind’ shall mean any Person, not an Infant, who, not having been found ... ...
-
Lunacy Regulation (Ireland) Act 1871
... ... of the persons and estates of persons found idiot, lunatic, or of unsound mind: ... And the expression ‘the master’ shall, as to all matters ... ...
-
Mental Treatment Act 1930
... ... the principal Act as a person of unsound mind or under ... section five of this Act as a person who is likely to ... ...
-
The notion of ‘a person of unsound mind’ under Article 5 § 1(e) of the European Convention on Human Rights
This article presents a critical analysis of the case-law of the ECtHR with regards to the interpretation of the notion of ‘a person of unsound mind’ under Article 5 § 1(e) of the Convention. Accor...
-
Royal Court (Jersey)
... ... (e) The lawful detention ... of persons of unsound mind ... HELD, although the M'Naghten Rules were applied in many ... ...
-
Problems in the Law Relating to Divorce on the Grounds of Incurable Unsoundness of Mind
... ... be presented to the court' either by the husband or the wife on the ground that the respondent- (d) is incurably of unsound mind and has been continuously under care and treatment for a period of at least five years he- diately preceding the ... ...
-
III. Jurisdiction in Lunacy;
... ... , after a solemn inquiry (" inquisition "), to be of unsound mind (" lunatics so found ") and the inquisition was ... ...
-
Can There Be Contributory Negligence In Suicide Cases?
... ... negligent after he committed suicide whilst thought to be of sound mind, and damages were reduced by 50% ... Mrs Justice Whipple also had ... (where it could be appropriate to reduce damages by up to 50%) or unsound mind (where it would be inappropriate to attribute any contributory ... ...
-
How To Resolve Disputes With Business Partners
... ... where a partner is of unsound mind (Scotland only); ... where a partner is permanently incapable of ... ...
-
Bournewood - Guidance on Implementation
... ... the lawful detention of persons of unsound mind, that detention must accord with a procedure prescribed by law. The ... ...
-
Employment Law In England And Wales
... ... The law is described as at 1 October 2011, so please bear in mind that it may have changed by the time you read it ... 1. The Contract of ... as gross misconduct, neglect of duties, bankruptcy, becoming of unsound mind and conviction of a criminal offence; and post-termination ... ...
-
Apply to authorise a deprivation of liberty
Court of Protection forms including the COP1 application to make decisions on someone's behalf.... ... in the functioning of the mind or brain and lacks capacity to consent to the ... measures proposed and ... I confirm that P has been medically diagnosed as being of ... ‘unsound mind’ and I attach written evidence from a medical practitioner ... If ... ...
-
Application to authorise a deprivation of liberty (Sections 4A(3) and 16(2)(a) of the Mental Capacity Act 2005)
Court of Protection forms including the COP1 application to make decisions on someone's behalf.... ... in the functioning of the mind or brain and lacks capacity to consent to the ... measures proposed and ... I confirm that P has been medically diagnosed as being of ... ‘unsound mind’ and I attach written evidence from a medical practitioner ... If ... ...