Aabar Holdings S.À.R.L. v Glencore Plc
| Jurisdiction | England & Wales |
| Court | Commercial Court |
| Judge | Mr Justice Picken |
| Judgment Date | 27 November 2024 |
| Neutral Citation | [2024] EWHC 3046 (Comm) |
| Docket Number | Case No: FL-2022-000024 |
Mr Justice Picken
Case No: FL-2022-000024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE
BUSINESS & PROPERTY COURTS OF ENGLAND & WALES
FINANCIAL LIST (KBD)
Royal Courts of Justice
Strand, London, WC2A 2LL
Bankim Thanki KC, Nicholas Damnjanovic and Kit Holliday (instructed by Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan UK LLP) for the Claimant.
Richard Hill KC, Tony Singla KC and Kyle Lawson (instructed by Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr LLP and Clifford Chance LLP) for the First Defendant.
Hearing dates: 15 & 16 October 2024.
Judgment provided in draft: 25 November 2024.
Introduction
This judgment follows a hearing at which a number of important privilege-related issues were addressed. As explained shortly, foremost amongst these are whether the so-called Shareholder Rule is valid and, if so, whether it applies not only to legal advice privilege and litigation privilege but also to without prejudice privilege.
The context in which these issues arise is a claim brought by the Claimant, Aabar Holdings S.à.r.l. (‘Aabar’) against Glencore Plc (‘Glencore’) and certain individuals.
Glencore is a global natural resources company and the ultimate parent company of the Glencore Group. Glencore was incorporated on 14 March 2011 under the laws of Jersey and is domiciled in Switzerland. Glencore's shares were the subject of an Initial Public Offering (the ‘IPO’) on 19 May 2011 and Glencore subsequently acquired Xstrata Plc on 2 May 2013 (the ‘Merger’). Glencore's shares are listed on the London Stock Exchange, with a market capitalisation of around £50 billion.
Aabar, otherwise known in this litigation context as the ‘QE Claimant’ reflecting the fact that it is represented by Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan UK LLP, is a private company incorporated in Luxembourg which is ultimately owned by the Government of the Emirate of Abu Dhabi (or its sovereign wealth fund).
Aabar is not, and never has been, a shareholder in Glencore. It was (or alleges that it was), rather, the sole shareholder in another Luxembourg company, Commodities S.à.r.l. (‘Commodities’) between 29 March 2012 and 20 December 2021. That company (so it is alleged) was the ultimate beneficial owner of shares in Glencore in that it held intermediated securities through CREST between 24 May 2011 and 28 December 2020 when it is alleged to have sold any interest which it may have had in any Glencore shares to another company called ATIC Second International Investment Company LLC (‘ATIC’). Commodities was dissolved on 20 December 2021 (after it had allegedly sold any interest it may have had in any Glencore shares) and Aabar claims that, immediately upon that event, all of the assets and liabilities of Commodities transferred to Aabar under Luxembourgish law.
Aabar is one of a number of a claimants who have brought claims against Glencore and (in some cases also) the Second to Fourth Defendants (the ‘Director Defendants’), each of whom are former directors of Glencore. In addition to Aabar, there are three other separately represented Claimant groups (viz. the ‘Pallas Claimants’, the ‘Stewarts Claimants’ and the ‘BCLP Claimants’) whose claims are being case managed and are to be tried together with the claims brought by Aabar (together, the ‘Co-Managed Claims’). In addition to the Co-Managed Claims, there is also a further group of Claimants (the ‘Fox Williams Claimants’) who have issued claims against Glencore which overlap very substantially with those of the Claimants in the Co-Managed Claims, but whose claims are not currently being case managed with the Co-Managed Claims.
The claims brought by the Claimants in each of the Co-Managed Claims relate to alleged (and, in some cases, admitted) misconduct by certain subsidiaries in the Glencore Group in certain countries in Africa (viz. the Democratic Republic of the Congo, South Sudan, Nigeria, Cameroon, the Ivory Coast and Equatorial Guinea) and South America (viz. Brazil and Venezuela), as well as admitted oil price manipulation in relation to the fuel oil market at certain US ports. To date, the misconduct alleged (or some of it) has led to the confiscation of funds, disgorgement and the imposition of fines against Glencore totalling approximately US$1.4 billion.
The various Claimants say that, as a result of the alleged and/or admitted misconduct on which they rely, certain documents issued by Glencore contained misstatements and/or omitted matters which they should have included and that each of the Claimants have incurred losses on their alleged investments in Glencore as a result.
Specifically, although only by way of summary, all of the Claimant groups in the Co-Managed Claims bring claims under s. 90 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (‘ FSMA’) in relation to the contents of the prospectus issued by Glencore on 4 May 2011 in relation to the IPO (the ‘IPO Prospectus’) and (save for Aabar) the prospectuses issued by Glencore on various dates between 31 May 2012 and 5 March 2013 in relation to the Merger (together, the ‘s. 90 Claims’). Aabar brings claims under s. 90A of FSMA in relation to the contents of certain Annual Reports, Half-Yearly Reports and Sustainability Reports issued by Glencore between 2010 and 2019. The BCLP Claimants also bring claims under s.90A (albeit that their claims are confined to alleged dishonest delay in the publication of certain information) (together, the ‘s. 90A Claims’). Aabar, the 31 st Stewarts Claimant and the 44 th Pallas Claimant (the ‘Cornerstone Investors’) bring contractual claims against Glencore under the terms of three separate ‘Cornerstone Investment Agreements’ (the ‘Cornerstone Claims’). Aabar brings common law claims in the torts of deceit and negligence (the ‘Common Law Claims’). Aabar and the Pallas Claimants also bring claims against the Director Defendants, namely Mr Glasenberg and Mr Kalmin and (in the case of Aabar only) Mr Hayward.
The first CMC in the Co-Managed Claims took place on 21–23 May 2024. In the runup to that hearing, a dispute arose in correspondence as to whether (and, if so, in what circumstances) Glencore would be entitled to assert privilege against the Claimants in these proceedings. The parties, therefore, agreed directions for the determination of the relevant issues, and those directions were approved by Bryan J at the CMC.
Those issues are these:
(1) Does the Shareholder Rule exist in English law? (‘Issue 1’).
(2) If so, does the Shareholder Rule apply to each of (i) legal advice privilege; (ii) litigation privilege; and (iii) without prejudice privilege? (‘Issue 2’).
(3) Does the Shareholder Rule extend to Aabar notwithstanding that it:
(a) was not a registered shareholder of any shares in Glencore at any material time, but, rather, claims to be the successor to the rights of an ultimate beneficial owner of shares in Glencore that held intermediated securities through CREST between 24 May 2011 and 28 December 2020; and
(b) does not currently hold any interest in any Glencore shares? (‘Issue 3’).
(4) Does the Shareholder Rule extend to privileged documents belonging to subsidiary companies within Glencore's corporate group? (‘Issue 4’).
(5) Is Glencore entitled to withhold inspection against Aabar of documents created during the period in which Aabar claims to have had an interest in Glencore shares (i.e. between 24 May 2011 and 28 December 2020) in categories 1 to 6 and 8 to 15 listed in the schedule to the letter from Clifford Chance dated 28 June 2024? (‘Issue 5’).
On 28 June 2024, in accordance with those directions, Glencore produced a list identifying (as best it can at this stage in proceedings and prior to having completed its Extended Disclosure document review exercise): (i) each of the categories of documents which it asserts that it will be entitled to withhold from production on the grounds of privilege; (ii) the likely nature of the privilege in each case; and (iii) the likely date ranges of the documents in each category.
On 12 July 2024, the Pallas, Stewarts and BCLP Claimants changed their positions. Each of these Claimant groups indicated that, upon further reflection, they did not “presently” intend to challenge any of Glencore's claims to privilege on the basis of the Shareholder Rule, whilst reserving their rights to do so “in the event that there is any future decision (in these proceedings or otherwise) which upheld or extended the scope or application of the [Shareholder Rule]”. Aabar indicated, however, that it did intend to challenge Glencore's claims to privilege, and that is why only Aabar was represented at the hearing before me on 15 and 16 October 2024.
I turn, then, to the various Issues, noting nonetheless that, in the event, it was common ground at the hearing that it is not currently feasible to address Issue 5.
Issue 1: Does the Shareholder Rule exist in English law?
Aabar's position
Aabar's position is that there is a principle, known as the Shareholder Rule, that a company cannot assert privilege against its own shareholder, save in relation to documents that came into existence for the purpose of hostile litigation against that shareholder. This principle, Mr Bankim Thanki KC notes on behalf of Aabar, has existed in English law for over 135 years and has been approved by both the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court.
Mr Thanki referred to the principle having first been applied in Gouraud v Edison Gower Bell Telephone Co of Europe Ltd (1888) 57 LJ Ch 498 by Chitty J (as he then was). Mr Thanki observed that the Shareholder Rule has subsequently been applied, including by the Court of Appeal in Woodhouse & Co Ltd v Woodhouse (1914) 30 TLR 559, where Phillimore LJ described the relevant principle as having...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Jardine Strategic Holdings Ltd v Oasis Investments II Master Fund Ltd and Others
...Rule, the success of the first full-frontal challenge to it in the English courts (subject to pending appeal) mounted in Aabar Holdings SARL v Glencore plc [2024] EWHC 3046 (Comm), [2025] 2 WLR 763 before Picken J probably came as a considerable surprise. The claimant Aabar Holdings was t......
-
Aabar Holdings Sàrl and Others v Glencore Plc and Others
...WLR 1991 distinguished. The following cases are referred to in the judgment: Aabar Holdings SÀRL v Glencore plc [2024] EWHC 3046 (Comm); [2025] KB 733; [2025] 2 WLR 763 Anderson v Bank of British Columbia (1876) 2 Ch D 644, CA Director of the Serious Fraud Office v Eurasian Natural Resource......
-
Aabar Holdings SARL v Glencore PLC & Ors
...be the successor to the rights of an ultimate beneficial owner of shares in Glencore that held intermediated securities through CREST[2024] EWHC 3046 (Comm) Case No: FL-2022-000024 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE BUSINESS & PROPERTY COURTS OF ENGLAND & WALES FINANCIAL LIST Royal Courts......
-
Aabar Holdings S.À.R.L. & Others v Glencore Plc
...In an earlier judgment in these proceedings, I concluded that the so-called Shareholder Rule should be regarded as no longer existing ( [2024] EWHC 3046 (Comm)), a conclusion with which the Privy Council subsequently agreed in Jardine Strategic Limited v Oasis Investments II Master Fund Ltd......