AB v Brown
| Jurisdiction | Scotland |
| Court | Sheriff Appeal Court |
| Judge | Sheriff Principal DCW Pyle,Sheriff Principal GA Wade KC,Sheriff AM Cubie |
| Judgment Date | 01 September 2023 |
| Docket Number | No 4 |
[2023] SAC (Crim) 5
Sheriff Principal DCW Pyle, Sheriff Principal GA Wade KC and Sheriff AM Cubie
Justiciary — Evidence — Admissibility — Police asking appellant to provide electronic devices and statement without giving caution or advice appellant entitled to refuse request — Whether contents of electronic devices and statement admissible — Whether police obliged to advise appellant of entitlement to refuse requests
Justiciary — Crime — Breach of the peace — Constitution of offence — Appellant taking photographs of school pupils without their consent or that of their parents — Photographs taken in context of appellant having ‘fetish’ relating to children — Whether public element present — Whether realistic risk of discovery
Justiciary — Sentence — Sexual offences — Notification requirements — Whether significant sexual aspect to offence — Sexual Offences Act 2003 (cap 42), sec 80; sch 3, para 60
Police Scotland received a suspicious activity report (‘SAR’) after the appellant, a teacher, sent money to a South African website connected to child exploitation. No illegality had been established by the South African authorities. Thereafter, the police submitted a search warrant request to the procurator fiscal. This was refused on the basis that there was no reasonable cause to suspect criminality on the part of the appellant. Police officers attended the appellant's home nonetheless. They advised him of the SAR and told him that they wanted to ask about his interactions with the site. The appellant volunteered that he had bought videos and photographs. He stated that he did not believe the videos were indecent. The police asked to see them to check “that there was nothing untoward” on them. The appellant agreed. He showed them a video on his tablet computer that appeared to show boys of around 12 or 13 years of age wearing only shorts and engaged in “staged wrestling”. The police asked the appellant if he would provide his electronic devices for examination. He was not told that he could refuse the request. The appellant volunteered the devices. The officers then asked if they could take a statement from him. No caution was applied and he was not told he could refuse the request. During the noting of the statement, the appellant volunteered that he had similar videos which he had recorded of children in the school gym class he taught. He added that he had a fetish for a number of years relating to “kids performing fireman's lifts”, but that he had not, and would not, act upon it. He admitted that the fetish was the sole reason for having the pictures. The following day, the police made a further application for a warrant which, again, was refused. The police proceeded to examine the appellant's devices without the warrant and discovered photographs of children performing wrestling moves at the appellant's school. The appellant had also taken photographs of pupils playing football and altered them by imposing images of children held in a fireman's lift. The images were held without the knowledge or consent of any relevant party. A total of 3,275 images of children were found. The appellant was subsequently charged and tried with a breach of the peace and a contravention of sec 170(1) of the Data Protection Act 2018 (cap 12).
At trial, a submission of no case to answer was made on the basis that the evidence obtained from the appellant and his devices was unlawfully obtained, and the public element necessary to establish a breach of the peace was not present. The sheriff repelled the submission on both grounds. The appellant was subsequently convicted. The sheriff found that there had been a significant sexual element to his behaviour, and he was made subject to the notification requirements under para 60 of sch 3 to the Sexual Offences Act 2003 (cap 42). The appellant appealed against conviction.
Following the production of the draft stated case, the appellant's solicitor sought the deletion of findings in fact. The sheriff was satisfied that the questions posed in the draft stated case were sufficient.
On appeal, the appellant argued that by the time the police attended the appellant's home, he was a suspect. That was clear from their application for a search warrant. Where there was no reasonable cause to suspect criminality, the police require an accused's consent to search, which consent required to be informed. The police acted in the knowledge that a warrant had been refused. Had the appellant declined, no further action would have been taken against him. The appellant ought to have been cautioned or warned that he need not comply with the requests to provide the devices and a statement. The appellant invited the court to amend the finding in fact that the police officers did not suspect him of any specific crime as it was not substantiated by the evidence. The appellant argued that his behaviour was not genuinely alarming and disturbing and, as there was no foundation for the Crown's submission at trial that the images were capable of discovery, the behaviour was private and could not amount to a breach of the peace. The appellant contended that there had been no significant sexual element to the offending as the use of ‘fetish’ alone was insufficient when the images involved were objectively non-sexual.
The Crown argued that the police were entitled to make general enquiries as part of their duties, that the appellant had consented to their attendance and that his admissions had been spontaneous. Further, the Crown submitted that the conduct was public in that, if discovered, it would lead to a serious disturbance in the community and that the appellant's position that he had a fetish justified the application of the notification requirements.
Held that: (1) the police officers were entitled, and it was not unfair for them, to attend the appellant's home and ask questions about his interaction with the website and view the footage; however, when the police determined that they wished to seize items which they knew would not have been recoverable by a search warrant, the line was crossed into unfairness and they had gone well beyond permissible conduct and the summary sheriff erred in repelling the objection to the fairness of the recovery (paras 48, 49); (2) the stage having been reached where there was sufficient suspicion for an application for a search warrant to be made, the police should have provided a specific warning of a right to refuse to provide items or a statement and the failure to provide such a warning made the seizure and everything following thereafter unfair (para 50); (3) the circumstances had not been urgent or trivial and the police had known that a warrant was necessary and no other circumstances justified the excuse of any irregularity (para 54); (4) while a failure to tell an accused person that he did not need to comply with requests made by the police might not be fatal to the admissibility of evidence, the prejudice to the appellant in admitting the evidence which ultimately formed the basis of his conviction outweighed the public interest in allowing it to be admitted, given that the appellant clearly believed he had done nothing wrong, whereas the police clearly had suspicions as evidenced by their attempt to obtain a warrant (paras 55–57); and appeal allowed and convictions quashed.
Observed that: (1) a challenge to a finding in fact should be addressed in a stated case in the form of a question, and the request at adjustment stage to delete a finding in fact did not constitute such a challenge (paras 36, 37); (2) the court would not readily explore matters not focused in the questions posed and the summary sheriff had erred in deciding that the questions posed in the draft stated case were sufficient; they should have been more focused and they should have recognised the appellant's attack on certain findings (paras 38, 39); (3) while, on one view, there had been no question which entitled the court to look behind the findings in fact and look directly at the evidence, the complaints made were clear in the note of appeal and the failing was the form of the questions asked in the final stated case, thus the court was prepared to consider it on its merits (para 40); (4) the appellant's conduct, had it been admissible, would have caused alarm and distress to the public, but there had been no evidence that there was a risk of discovery, far less a realistic risk (paras 59, 64); (5) there had been no features from which the sheriff could infer that there had been a realistic risk of discovery, and in the absence of such a realistic risk, regardless of the nature of the conduct, the charge of breach of the peace could not have stood and the sheriff should have sustained the submission of no case to answer (para 65); and (6) while not every self-proclaimed fetish would necessarily meet the standard capable of supporting a significant sexual aspect, the number of images, their storing, their doctoring, the time-period over which they were taken, the appellant's self-proclaimed fetish, taken with his admission that he would not have acted on it, would have met that standard if the statement had been admissible, and there had been a public element (para 67).
McIntyre v Nisbet 2009 SCCR 506 and Hay v HM Advocate2014 JC 19considered, Chalmers v HM Advocate1954 JC 66 and Buchan v Aziz2023 JC 51applied and Jones v Carnegie2004 JC 136followed.
B v HM Advocate [2015] HCJAC 17; 2015 SLT 182; 2015 SCCR 101; 2015 SCL 389
Bell v Hogg 1967 JC 49; 1967 SLT 290
Brown v Glen 1998 JC 4; 1998 SLT 115; 1997 SCCR 636
Buchan v Aziz sub nom Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh v Aziz [2022] HCJAC 46; 2023 JC 51; 2023 SLT 431; 2023 SCCR 55
Burke v Wilson 1988 JC 111; 1988 SLT 749; 1988 SCCR 361
Chalmers v HM Advocate 1954 JC 66; 1954 SLT 177
Devlin v Normand 1992 SCCR 875
Fairley v Wardens of Fishmongers of the City...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting