Application for compensation against a trustee in bankruptcy
| Author | Mark Watson-Gandy |
| Pages | 159-171 |
"
"
Ejcrvgt"33"
CRRNKECVKQP"HQT"EQORGPUCVKQP"
CICKPUV"C"VTWUVGG"KP"DCPMTWRVE["
QDLGEVKXG"
Vjg"eqwtv"jcu"vjg"rqygt"vq"tgswktg"c"vtwuvgg"kp"dcpmtwrve{"yjq"jcu"okucrrnkgf"qt"
tgvckpgf"qt"dgeqog"ceeqwpvcdng"hqt"cp{"oqpg{"qt"rtqrgtv{"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrv"qt"jcu"
dggp"iwknv{"qh"okuhgcucpeg"qt" dtgcej"qh"cp{"hkfwekct{"qt" qvjgt"fwv{"kp"tgurgev"qh"
vjg"dcpmtwrvÓu"guvcvg" vq"eqorgpucvg"vjg" guvcvg"cpf"vq" tgrc{."tguvqtg"cpf"ceeqwpv"
hqt"rtqrgtv{"cpf"oqpg{03"Vjg"eqwtv"ecp"cyctf"kpvgtguv0"
"
Vjg"vtwuvgg"ku"pqv"nkcdng"hqt"cp{"nquu"qt"fcocig"hqt"kpeqttgevn{"ugk¦kpi"rtqrgtv{"kh"
jg"tgcuqpcdn{"dgnkgxgu"kv"vq"hqto" rctv"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrvÓu"guvcvg"cpf"jg"ycu."cv"vjg"
vkog."gpvkvngf"vq"fq" uq0"Kpfggf."jg"ku"vtgcvgf" cu"jcxkpi"c"nkgp"qp" uwej"rtqrgtv{"qt"
kvu"rtqeggfu"qh"ucng"hqt"jku"gzrgpugu04"Pqt"ku"jg"nkcdng"kh"cevkpi"wpfgt"c"eqwtv"qtfgt05"
CRRNKECVKQP"
Vjg"encko"ku"ocfg" d{"crrnkecvkqp"pqvkeg" qp"pqvkeg"vq"vjg" vtwuvgg0"Kv"ecp"dg" ocfg"
d{
"
"vjg"Qhhkekcn"Tgegkxgt="
"vjg"Ugetgvct{"qh"Uvcvg="
"c"etgfkvqt"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrv="
"vjg"dcpmtwrv."kh"vjgtg"ku"nkmgn{"vq"dg"c"uwtrnwu"qp"hkpcn"fkuvtkdwvkqp06"
"
Vjg"eqwtvÓu"rgtokuukqp"ku"tgswktgf"kh"vjg"crrnkecvkqp"ku"vq"dg"ocfg"d{"vjg"dcpmtwrv"
qt"vjg"crrnkecvkqp"ku"ocfg"chvgt"vjg"vtwuvgg"jcu"jcf"jku"tgngcug07"
"
Vjg"crrnkecvkqp"ku"ocfg"qp"Hqto"KCC0"Vjg"crrnkecvkqp"ujqwnf"ugv"qwv
"
"
3" Ugevkqp"526*3+"qh"vjg" Kpuqnxgpe{"Cev"3;:80"Hqt" vjg"vguv"hqt"nkcdknkv{." ugg"Katz v Oldham"]4238̲"
DRKT":50"
4" Ugevkqp"526*5+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"Cev"3;:80"
5"Chapper v Jackson"]4234̲"GYJE"5:;9"*Ej+."]4234̲"DRKT"4790"
6" Ugevkqp"526*4+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"Cev" 3;:80"Qpeg"vjg"vtwuvgg"jcu"jcf"jku" tgngcug."c"dcpmtwrv"ecp"
qpn{"crrn{"ykvj"vjg"rgtokuukqp"qh"vjg"eqwtvRe Borodzicz ]4238̲"DRKT"460"
7" Ugevkqp"526*4+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"Cev"3;:80"
382" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
"vjcv" vjg" crrnkecvkqp" ku" ocfg" wpfgt" vjg" Kpuqnxgpe{" Cev" 3;:8" qt" vjg"
Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"4238"*cu"vjg"ecug"oc{"dg+=8"
"vjg"ugevkqp"pwodgt"qt"twng"wpfgt"yjkej"tgnkgh"ku"uqwijv=9"
"vjg"pcog"qh"vjg"rctvkgu=:"
"vjg"pcog"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrv"qt"fgdvqt=;"
"vjg"eqwtv"pcog=32"
"vjg"ecug"pwodgt=33"
"vjg"tgogf{"crrnkgf"hqt"qt"fktgevkqpu"uqwijv=34"
"vjg"pcog"cpf"cfftguu"qh"gcej"rgtuqp"vq"dg"ugtxgf"qt."kh"pqpg."vjcv"pq"rgtuqp"
yknn"dg"ugtxgf=35"
"yjgtg"vjgtg"ku" c"tgswktgogpv" hqt"rctvkewnct" rgtuqpu"vq" dg"ikxgp"pqvkeg" qh"
vjg"crrnkecvkqp"wpfgt"vjg"Cev"qt"Twngu."vjg"pcog"cpf"cfftguu"qh"gcej"uwej"
rgtuqp=36"
"vjg"crrnkecpvÓu"cfftguu"hqt"ugtxkeg037"
"
Vjg"crrnkecvkqp"pqvkeg"owuv"dg"cwvjgpvkecvgf"d{"vjg"crrnkecpv"qt"jku"uqnkekvqt038"
"
Vjg" crrnkecvkqp" ujqwnf"dg" tgvwtpcdng" vq" vjg" Kpuqnxgpe{" cpf" Eqorcpkgu" Eqwtv"
Lwfig"qt"vq"vjg"fkuvtkev"lwfig"kp"c"Ejcpegt{"Fkuvtkev"Tgikuvt{"qt"eqwpv{"eqwtv"ykvj"
kpuqnxgpe{"lwtkufkevkqp0"
EQWTV"HGGU"
Yjgtg"vjg"crrnkecvkqp"ku"ocfg"d{"qtfkpct{"crrnkecvkqp"qp"pqvkeg"vq"qvjgt"rctvkgu."
c" eqwtv" hgg" qh" ˚;;" ku" rc{cdng039"Yjgtg" vjg" crrnkecvkqp" ku" ocfg" d{" eqpugpv" qt"
ykvjqwv"pqvkeg"kp"gzkuvkpi"rtqeggfkpiu."c"eqwtv"hgg"qh"˚48"ku"rc{cdng03:"
GXKFGPEG"
Vjg"crrnkecvkqp"ujqwnf"dg"uwrrqtvgf"d{"c"ykvpguu"uvcvgogpv"d{"vjg"crrnkecpv0"Vjku"
ujqwnf"cfftguu
"
8" Twng"3057*4+*c+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
9" Twng"3057*4+*d+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
:" Twng"3057*4+*e+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
;" Twng"3057*4+*f+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
32" Twng"3057*4+*g+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
33" Twng"3057*4+*h+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
34" Twng"3057*4+*i+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
35" Twng"3057*4+*j+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
36" Twng"3057*4+*k+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
37" Twng"3057*4+*l+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
38" Twng" 3057*5+" qh" vjg" Kpuqnxgpe{" *Gpincpf" cpf" Ycngu+" Twngu" 42380" Hqt" yjcv" coqwpvu" vq"
cwvjgpvkecvkqp."ugg"twng"3070"Hqt"jctf"eqr{"crrnkecvkqpu."vjku"ogcpu"ukipgf
39" Hgg"5034."GZ72C"Iwkfcpeg"qp"Eqwtv"Hggu"*Octej"4244+0"
3:" Hgg"5033."GZ72C"Iwkfcpeg"qp"Eqwtv"Hggu"*Octej"4244+0"
"Application for Compensation against a Trustee in Bankruptcy" 383"
"
"vjg"dcuku"wrqp"yjkej"vjg"crrnkecpv"jcu"vjg"tkijv"vq"dtkpi"vjg"encko="
"vjg"qtfgt"vjg"crrnkecpv"uggmu="
"yjgvjgt"rgtokuukqp"ku"tgswktgf"cpf"vjg"tgcuqpu"yj{"kv"ujqwnf"dg"itcpvgf="
"vjg"fcvg"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrve{="
"vjg"fcvg"qh"vjg"vtwuvggÓu"crrqkpvogpv="
"vjg"pcvwtg"qh"vjg"fwv{"vjg"vtwuvgg"qygu"vq"vjg"guvcvg"kp"dcpmtwrve{="
"hwnn" rctvkewnctu" qh" vjg" ocvvgtu" jqy" cpf" yjgp" kv" ku" uckf" vjg" vtwuvgg" jcu"
okucrrnkgf"qt"tgvckpgf"qt"dgeqog"ceeqwpvcdng" hqt"cp{"oqpg{"qt"rtqrgtv{"
qh"vjg"guvcvg"kp"dcpmtwrve{"qt"jcu"dggp"iwknv{"qh" okuhgcucpeg"qt"dtgcej"qh"
cp{"hkfwekct{"qt"qvjgt"fwv{"kp"tgurgev"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"guvcvg="
"vjg" hcev" vjcv" vjg" cttcpigogpv" qrgtcvgf" vq" ecwug" nquu" vq" vjg" guvcvg" kp"
dcpmtwrve{"cpf"kvu"etgfkvqtu="
"rctvkewnctu"qh"vjg"nquu"ecwugf0"
"
Cpf"ujqwnf"gzjkdkv
"
"gxkfgpeg"qh"vjg"nqewu"qh"vjg"crrnkecpv="
"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"qtfgt="
"vjg"egtvkhkecvg"qh"vjg"vtwuvggÓu"crrqkpvogpv="
"gxkfgpeg"ujqykpi" vjg" tgurqpfgpv"jcu" okucrrnkgf" qt" tgvckpgf"qt" dgeqog"
ceeqwpvcdng"hqt"cp{"oqpg{"qt"rtqrgtv{"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrv"qt"jcu"dggp"iwknv{"
qh"okuhgcucpeg"qt"dtgcej"qh"cp{"hkfwekct{"qt"qvjgt"fwv{"vq"vjg"dcpmtwrve{Óu"
guvcvg="
"gxkfgpeg"qh"vjg"nquu"ecwugf"d{"vjg"tgurqpfgpvÓu"kpxqnxgogpv0"
UGTXKEG"
Vjg"crrnkecvkqp"ujqwnf"dg"ugtxgf"qp
"
"vjg"vtwuvgg"kp"dcpmtwrve{0"
"
Vjg"crrnkecvkqp" cpf" vjg" gxkfgpeg" kp" uwrrqtv" yknn" pggf" vq" dg" hkngf" cv" eqwtv" cpf"
ugtxgf"qp"vjg"tgurqpfgpv"cu" uqqp"cu"rtcevkecdng"chvgt"kv" ku"hkngf"cpf"kp" cp{"gxgpv."
wpnguu"kv"ku"pgeguuct{" vq"crrn{"ykvjqwv"pqvkeg" qt"qp"ujqtv"pqvkeg."cv" ngcuv"36"fc{u"
dghqtg"vjg"fcvg"hkzgf"hqt"vjg"jgctkpi03;""
"
Vjg"wuwcn"twng"ku"vjcv."uwdlgev"vq"cp{"qvjgt"gzrtguu"rtqxkukqp."vjg"crrnkecvkqp"owuv"
dg"ugtxgf" cv"ngcuv" 36"fc{u"dghqtg" vjg"fcvg" hkzgf"hqt" vjg"jgctkpi042" Jqygxgt." vjg"
eqwtv"fqgu"jcxg" rqygt."kp" ecugu"qh"wtigpe{." vq"jgct"cp" crrnkecvkqp"koogfkcvgn{"
ykvj"qt"ykvjqwv"pqvkeg"vq"vjg"qvjgt"rctvkgu043"
"
"
3;" Twng"340;*5+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
42" Twng"340;*5+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
43" Twng"34032*3+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
384" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
Ugtxkeg"oc{"dg" ghhgevgf"rgtuqpcnn{44"qt"d{" rquv"qp"vjg"tgurqpfgpv" *Rctv"8"qh"vjg"
ERT"crrnkgu"hqt"vjgug"rwtrqugu+45"qt."yjgtg"vjg{"jcxg"cwvjqtkv{"vq"ceegrv"ugtxkeg."
qp"vjg"tgurqpfgpvÓu"uqnkekvqtu046"Gngevtqpke"ugtxkeg"qh"fqewogpvu"ku"pqy"rgtokuukdng"
wpfgt"vjg" Twngu." rtqxkfkpi"vjg" tgurqpfgpv" ewttgpvn{"eqpugpvu" vq"ugtxkeg"kp"vjcv"
yc{"cpf"jcu"rtqxkfgf"cp"gockn"cfftguu"hqt"ugtxkeg"kp"vjcv"yc{047"
HKTUV"JGCTKPI"
Cv"vjg"hktuv"jgctkpi."vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"cpf"Eqorcpkgu"Eqwtv"Lwfig"qt"fkuvtkev" lwfig"
yknn"ikxg"fktgevkqpu"cu"vq"yjgvjgt"rqkpvu"qh"encko"ctg"pggfgf"cpf"hqt"vjg"hknkpi"qh"
gxkfgpeg0"Jg"oc{" cnuq"tgswktg" vjg"crrnkecvkqp"vq" dg"ugtxgf" qp"qvjgt"rgqrng0" Jg"
oc{"ikxg"fktgevkqpu"cu" vq"yjgvjgt"ykvpguugu"ctg" vq"cvvgpf"hqt"etquu" gzcokpcvkqp0"
Vjg"hktuv"jgctkpi"ku"nkmgn{"vq"dg"kp"ejcodgtu"cpf"vjg"cfxqecvgu"yknn"pqv"dg"gzrgevgf"
vq"tqdg0"
MG["OCVGTKCNU"
Ugevkqp"526"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"Cev"3;:8"
526" Nkcdknkv{"qh"vtwuvgg"
*3+" Yjgtg"qp"cp"crrnkecvkqp"wpfgt"vjku"ugevkqp"vjg"eqwtv"ku"ucvkuhkgfÏ"
"
*c+" vjcv"vjg" vtwuvgg" qh" c" dcpmtwrvÓu" guvcvg" jcu" okucrrnkgf" qt" tgvckpgf." qt"
dgeqog"ceeqwpvcdng"hqt."cp{"oqpg{"qt"qvjgt"rtqrgtv{"eqortkugf"kp"vjg"
dcpmtwrvÓu"guvcvg."qt"
*d+" vjcv"c" dcpmtwrvÓu" guvcvg"jcu" uwhhgtgf" cp{" nquu"kp" eqpugswgpeg" qh"cp{"
okuhgcucpeg"qt" dtgcej" qh" hkfwekct{" qt" qvjgt" fwv{" d{" c" vtwuvgg" qh" vjg"
guvcvg"kp"vjg"ectt{kpi"qwv"qh"jku"hwpevkqpu."
"
" vjg"eqwtv"oc{"qtfgt"vjg"vtwuvgg."hqt"vjg"dgpghkv"qh"vjg"guvcvg."vq"tgrc{."tguvqtg"
qt"ceeqwpv"hqt" oqpg{"qt" qvjgt"rtqrgtv{"*vqigvjgt" ykvj"kpvgtguv" cv"uwej"tcvg"
cu"vjg"eqwtv"vjkpmu"lwuv+"qt."cu"vjg"ecug"oc{"tgswktg."vq"rc{"uwej"uwo"d{"yc{"
qh"eqorgpucvkqp"kp"tgurgev"qh"vjg"okuhgcucpeg"qt"dtgcej"qh"hkfwekct{"qt"qvjgt"
fwv{"cu"vjg"eqwtv"vjkpmu"lwuv0"
" Vjku"ku"ykvjqwv"rtglwfkeg"vq"cp{"nkcdknkv{"ctkukpi"crctv"htqo"vjku"ugevkqp0"
*4+" Cp"crrnkecvkqp"wpfgt"vjku" ugevkqp"oc{"dg"ocfg"d{" vjg"qhhkekcn"tgegkxgt."vjg"
Ugetgvct{"qh"Uvcvg."c"etgfkvqt" qh"vjg"dcpmtwrv"qt"*yjgvjgt"qt" pqv"vjgtg"ku."qt"
ku"nkmgn{"vq"dg."c"uwtrnwu"hqt"vjg"rwtrqugu"qh"ugevkqp"552*7+"*hkpcn"fkuvtkdwvkqp++"
vjg"dcpmtwrv"jkougnh0"
"
44" Twng"3066"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
45" Uejgfwng"6."rctcitcrj"3*4+"vq"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
46" Twng"3062"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
47" Twng"3067"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
"Application for Compensation against a Trustee in Bankruptcy" 385"
"
" Dwv"vjg"ngcxg"qh"vjg"eqwtv"ku"tgswktgf"hqt"vjg"ocmkpi"qh"cp"crrnkecvkqp"kh"kv"ku"
vq"dg"ocfg"d{"vjg"dcpmtwrv"qt"kh"kv"ku"vq"dg"ocfg"chvgt"vjg"vtwuvgg"jcu"jcf"jku"
tgngcug"wpfgt"ugevkqp"4;;0"
*5+" YjgtgÏ"
"
*c+" vjg"vtwuvgg"ugk¦gu" qt"fkurqugu"qh" cp{"rtqrgtv{"yjkej" ku"pqv"eqortkugf"
kp"vjg"dcpmtwrvÓu"guvcvg."cpf"
*d+" cv" vjg" vkog" qh" vjg" ugk¦wtg" qt" fkurqucn" vjg" vtwuvgg" dgnkgxgu." cpf" jcu"
tgcuqpcdng" itqwpfu" hqt" dgnkgxkpi." vjcv" jg" ku" gpvkvngf" *yjgvjgt" kp"
rwtuwcpeg"qh"cp"qtfgt"qh"vjg"eqwtv"qt"qvjgtykug+"vq" ugk¦g"qt"fkurqug"qh"
vjcv"rtqrgtv{."
"
" vjg" vtwuvgg" ku" pqv" nkcdng" vq" cp{" rgtuqp" *yjgvjgt" wpfgt" vjku" ugevkqp" qt"
qvjgtykug+"kp" tgurgev" qh" cp{"nquu" qt" fcocig"tguwnvkpi" htqo" vjg"ugk¦wtg" qt"
fkurqucn"gzegrv"kp"uq"hct"cu"vjcv"nquu" qt"fcocig"ku"ecwugf"d{"vjg"pginkigpeg"
qh"vjg"vtwuvgg="cpf"jg" jcu"c"nkgp"qp"vjg" rtqrgtv{."qt"vjg"rtqeggfu"qh"kvu" ucng."
hqt"uwej"qh" vjg"gzrgpugu"qh" vjg"dcpmtwrve{"cu" ygtg"kpewttgf"kp" eqppgevkqp"
ykvj"vjg"ugk¦wtg"qt"fkurqucn0"
386" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
3303" CRRNKECVKQP"HQT"EQORGPUCVKQP"CICKPUV"
C"VTWUVGG"KP"DCPMTWRVE[""
"Application for Compensation against a Trustee in Bankruptcy" 387"
"
388" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
"Application for Compensation against a Trustee in Bankruptcy" 389"
"
3304" YKVPGUU"UVCVGOGPV"KP"UWRRQTV"QH"CP"
CRRNKECVKQP"HQT"EQORGPUCVKQP"CICKPUV"
C"VTWUVGG"KP"DCPMTWRVE["
38:" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
"Application for Compensation against a Trustee in Bankruptcy" 38;"
"
Ey;77”"E⁄yNj⁄}
392" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
3305" FGENCTCVKQP"VJCV"VJGTG"JCU"DGGP"C"
DTGCEJ"QH"FWV["D["C"VTWUVGG"KP"
DCPMTWRVE["
"Application for Compensation against a Trustee in Bankruptcy" 393"
"
To continue reading
Request your trial