CCC (Suing by her mother and litigation friend MMM) v Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
| Jurisdiction | England & Wales |
| Court | King's Bench Division |
| Judge | Mr Justice Ritchie |
| Judgment Date | 12 July 2023 |
| Neutral Citation | [2023] EWHC 1770 (KB) |
| Year | 2023 |
| Docket Number | Claim number: QB-2020-000769 |
Mr Justice Ritchie
Claim number: QB-2020-000769
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE
KING'S BENCH DIVISION
Richard Baker KC and Sarah Edwards (instructed by Taylor Emmet solicitors) for the Claimant
Sarah Pritchard KC (instructed by DAC Beachcroft solicitors) for the Defendant
Hearing dates: 7–9, 12–16, 22 June 2023
APPROVED JUDGMENT
Judgment approved by the Court for handing down. This judgment will be handed down by the Judge remotely by circulation to the parties' representatives by email and released to The National Archives. The date and time for hand-down is deemed to be at 14:00 am on 12 th July 2023
The Parties
The Claimant is a young girl aged 8 years and 4 months who has sued the Defendant for damages for negligence resulting in her suffering cerebral palsy [CP]. Her mother is her litigation friend.
The Defendant runs the Royal Hallamshire Hospital, Sheffield and four years after her birth admitted that it was responsible for failing to prevent the Claimant suffering severe chronic partial hypoxic ischaemia before and during her birth, which caused the CP.
Bundles
For the hearing I was provided with 50 lever arch files of documents, skeleton arguments and two memory sticks of photos and videos. No core bundle was provided. Updated figures were provided in closing in a redrafted schedule.
Summary
Liability
The Claimant was born on the 6th of February 2015 at the Hospital. Her mother, who I will call “M”, entered the hospital on the 5th of February and a CTG was attached to her tummy at about 16.50 hours that afternoon. It showed a pathological trace for the Claimant's heartbeat with reduced variability and unprovoked decelerations. It was not read for 50 minutes. When it was finally read, a category one caesarean section was called for and the Claimant was born at 18.33 hours. The Claimant's APGAR scores were 4 at one minute; 4 at 5 minutes and 9 at 10 minutes and she displayed no respiratory effort during the early minutes of her life. Her cord blood readings indicated hypoxia had occurred.
The parties corresponded under the clinical negligence pre-action protocol and liability was admitted in full by the Defendant on the 28th of May 2019.
The Claimants issued a claim form on the 25th of February 2020. M was the 2nd Claimant, who sued for her daughter (the first Claimant) and for herself. She alleged that she suffered post-traumatic stress disorder and other psychiatric sequelae caused by the trauma of the Claimant's birth and the events subsequent thereto during which the Claimant struggled for life and nearly died. M's claim has been settled by the Defendant and is therefore not relevant to this judgment. This claim is about the 1 st Claimant's injuries, I shall simply call her “the Claimant”.
Quantum
The issues before this Court related to various substantial heads of loss within the quantification of the Claimant's claim. I heard evidence from lay and expert witnesses during the course of the trial which lasted 9 days. I am very grateful to leading counsel for their professionalism and focus during the trial.
Within this judgment I shall deal with the quantification of each of the disputed heads of loss in accordance with the law and the principles applicable to awards of damages in personal injury cases. However, before I embark on this process, I should state that the objective and unemotional quantification of damages should not undermine or take away from the underlying fabric of this case, which involved a tragic omission of care before and during the Claimant's birth and the struggle for life by this young girl alongside the hugely impressive determination and devotion of M throughout all of the daily battles fought by her, on the Claimant's behalf, to keep her alive, to keep her safe and to make her life as full and enjoyable as is possible within the challenging restrictions caused by her very severe disabilities.
The Issues
All personal injury claims for damages for living Claimants are split up into 3 sections: A, pain, suffering and loss of amenity; B, past loss and expense; C: future loss and expense.
The table below sets out the heads of loss which are agreed and the figures from the served trial schedules which are disputed. These figures were updated at the start and end of trial and I will deal with updates later. All figures are rounded up or down from pennies.
| No | Item | Claim £ Trial Schedule | Def £ C schedule | Agreed £ |
| 1. | A. Pain, suffering and loss of amenity | 380,000 | 350,000 | |
| 2. | Interest | 22,488 | 7,000 | |
| Total A | 402,488 | 357,000 | ||
| B. PAST | ||||
| 3. | Gratuitous care | 146,883 | 69,396 | |
| 4. | Commercial care | 1,309,808 | 546,075 | |
| 5. | Case Manager | 188,304 | 145,727 | |
| 6. | Accommodation (rentals) | 160,407 | 70,000 | |
| 7. | The New House (bought) | 646,169 | 473,476 | |
| 8. | Equipment | 70,667 | 34,129 | 69,841 |
| 9. | Therapies | 79,720 | 72,252 | 70,004 |
| 10. | 64,100.49 | 45,305 | 59,023 | |
| 11. | Travel and transport | 15,588 | 11,600 | 13,563 |
| 12. | Misc | 36,974 | 19,914 | |
| Subtotal B | 2,718,630 | 1,484,874 (the sums are not added correctly in the C shed) | ||
| 13. | Interest net, interest on IPs | 62,734 | 7,424 | |
| Total B | 2,781,364 | 1,495,298 | ||
| C. FUTURE | Life multiplier: 22.27 to age 30 | Life multiplier: 14.95 to age 23 | Agreed to age 29: 21.21 | |
| 14. | Loss of earnings | 223,966 | 35,903 | 160,000 |
| 15. | Lost years | 823,506 | 0 | 0 |
| 16. | C are | 372,080 pa | 158,827 pa (-19) 315,902 pa (19-) | PPO |
| 17. | Case Management | 22,860 pa | 10,542 (6m) 8,352 pa | PPO |
| 18. | Accommodation: alterations | 947,096 | 405,870 | |
| 19. | Accommodation: running expenses | 641,456 | 212,232 | |
| 20. | Therapies | |||
| OT | ||||
| Physio | 116,000 | |||
| SALT | 55,521 | |||
| Nutrition | 15,278 | |||
| Podiatry | 6,227.20 | |||
| Total | 491,427 | 151,666 | ||
| 21. | Equipment | 854,263 | 165,035 | |
| 22. | Transport | 832,114 | 149,287 | |
| 23. | Misc | 504,914 | 130,515 | |
| 24. | Education | 315,622 | 0 | |
| 25. | 396,646 | 231,508 | 310,000 | |
| Sub total C Lump sum | 6,031,010 | 1,449,640 | ||
| Total A+B+C | 9,214,862 | 3,301,938 | ||
| Less Interim Payments (IPs) | 2,750,000 | 2,750,000 | ||
| Lump sum remaining after IPs | 6,464,862 | 551,938 | ||
| PPOS Care and CM | 372,080 + 22,860 = 394,940 pa | 167,279 pa to 19 324,254 pa from 19 | ||
| Indexation | ASHE 6115 80th centile | Rate agreed | ||
| Start date for PPO | 15.12.2023 | 15.12.2023 | ||
| Catch up lump sum until start of PPO | Not calculated | Not calculated |
The parties' relative positions as shown by the above table were as follows. The Claimant sought a lump sum of £9,214,862 (gross of IPs) and a periodical payments order [PPO] of £394,940 pa. The Defendant accepted that the Claimant should be paid a lump sum of £3,301,938 (gross of IPs) and PPOs of £167,279 pa to age 19 and £324,254 pa from age 19.
The main Issues
The main issues in this case relate to the quantification of: Care, Case Management, Accommodation, Transport and Equipment.
The applications
At the start of the trial various applications were made by the parties. By a notice of application dated 23 May 2023 the Claimant applied for a further interim payment of £100,000 and for permission to rely on witness statements from 8 care support workers. By the time of the trial the interim payment application had been settled for a payment of £50,000. The application for permission was evidenced by the factual statement of James Drydale contained within the notice of application. This highlighted the issue between the parties over whether there should be two waking night carers or one sleeping night carer and one waking night carer and an error made by Miss Sargent, the Claimant's care expert, in the first joint expert statement provided to the parties in April 2023. The emergence of the issues had earlier led to the Claimant serving updated witness statements from M, the case manager and the Claimant's deputy, Richard King in October 2022. The Defendant did not object to those updated witness statements being relied on. However, the Defendant did object to the witness statements from the support workers which were also served in October 2022 which led to this application. By the time of trial the Claimant had pared down the number of care witnesses that she wished to rely on to only three.
The Defendant's objection to the application was not based on any prejudice suffered by the Defendant, nor was it supported by any witness statement. Instead, it was put on the basis of a purely procedural objection. Defence counsel submitting that the Civil Procedure Rules had to be followed and that the Claimant needed to apply for relief from sanctions, having failed to serve the witness statements from the support workers in accordance with the Court's directions. The Defendant relied on CPR rule 3.9 asserting that the Claimant had failed to comply with a Court order and that the application had to be supported by evidence. The Defendant submitted that the Claimant had to pass through the test set out in Denton v TH White [2014] EWCA Civ. 906, to which I shall return below. That test having two parts: firstly, a consideration by the Court of the seriousness of the breach. The Defendant asserted that the failure to serve the witness statements on the time, was a breach serious. The second part of the test in Denton for the Court involved considering whether the Claimant had a good reason for the failure, whether the application had been made promptly...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
CCC (by her mother and litigation friend MMM) (Appellant) v Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust (Respondent)
...award any additional sum to compensate him for the lost years.” 204 In my judgment the line drawn by Griffiths and Shaw LJJDecision of Ritchie J [2023] EWHC 1770 (KB) reversed in part. The following cases are referred to in the judgments: Amaca Pty Ltd v Latz [2018] HCA 22; (2018) 264 CLR 5......
-
R (Cgt) v West Sussex County Council
...be quashed (post, paras 75–83, 85–95). R (Tinsley) v Manchester City Council [2018] QB 767, CA applied. CCC v Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2023] EWHC 1770 (KB), WNA v NDP [2024] 1 WLR 1807 and R (Imam) v Croydon London Borough Council [2025] AC 335, SC(E) considered. T......
-
The King on the application of CGT (by his Litigation Friend SGT) v West Sussex County Council
...sought to address the issue of double recovery in various ways, including Peters and Tinsley. He also referred to CCC v Sheffield Teaching Hospitals [2023] EWHC 1770 (KB) which he described as an example of “a repayment mechanism.” In that case the claimant was in receipt of direct payments......
-
JBX (Suing by DBX, his Mother and Litigation Friend) v Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust
...to “best interests” obscures the clarity of Longmore LJ's statement of principle in Sowden. 131 In CCC v. Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2023] EWHC 1770 (KB) Ritchie J considered the role and relevance of proportionality in the assessment of future special damages. At pa......
-
Are Restrictions To "Lost Years" Claims Set To Be Challenged?
...of Croke v Wiseman [1982] WLR 71 CA may be set for challenge following Mr Justice Ritchie's judgment in CCC v Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2023] EWHC 1770 By way of background, in Croke the Court of Appeal held that child claimants are not permitted to bring a claim fo......