Competition and Markets Authority v Michael Christopher Martin
| Jurisdiction | England & Wales |
| Court | Chancery Division |
| Judge | Jones |
| Judgment Date | 03 July 2020 |
| Neutral Citation | [2020] EWHC 1751 (Ch) |
| Docket Number | CR-2019-001454 |
| Date | 03 July 2020 |
Insolvency and Companies Court Judge Jones
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE
BUSINESS AND PROPERTY COURTS OF ENGLAND AND WALES
INSOLVENCY AND COMPANIES LIST (ChD)
IN THE MATTER OF THE PROPERTY GROUP (2010) LIMITED
AND IN THE MATTER OF GARY BERRYMAN ESTATE AGENTS LIMITED
AND IN THE MATTER OF WARNE INVESTMENTS LIMITED
AND IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPANY DIRECTORS DISQUALIFICATION
ACT 1986
By Skype Remote Hearing,
Royal Courts of Justice
Ms Catherine Addy Q.C. and Mr Paul Greenwood (instructed by the CMA Legal Service) for the Claimant
Mr Robert Palmer Q.C. and Mr Christopher Buckley (instructed by Womble Bond Dickinson) for the Defendant
Hearing dates: 8–11 June 2020
Approved Judgment
I direct that pursuant to CPR PD 39A para 6.1 no official shorthand note shall be taken of this Judgment and that copies of this version as handed down may be treated as authentic.
CHJ – 03/07/20
I.C.C. JUDGE Jones
I.C.C. Judge
A) Introduction
The fact that the Competition and Markets Authority (“the CMA”) between September 2015 and 31 May 2017 investigated and reported upon suspected cartel activity by estate and letting agency businesses in the area of Burnham-on-Sea is a reminder not only of the scope of its work but also of its reach. Its statutory powers and duties exist because of the importance of competition law for the day to day business activities not only of large corporations but of all markets within this jurisdiction. The business of estate agency is concerned in part with the sale of what is for most people their most valuable and important asset. The importance of the requirement of fair competition and the prevention and termination of cartels fixing minimum levels of commission fees for property sales to the detriment of vendors is not to be understated.
From 20 June 2003 the framework for implementing and enforcing the UK's competition law was reinforced, in part as a result of the amendment of section 1 and the insertion of sections 9A-9E of the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986 (“the CDDA”) by the Enterprise Act 2002 (ss204(2), 279 and SI 2003/1397, art 2, the Schedule). Those provisions enable a claim to be made by the appropriate body, now including the CMA pursuant to section 25 of the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act 2013, for the disqualification of a director on the basis that specified conditions concerning anti-competitive conduct are satisfied. Whilst these provisions appear rusty through lack of use, that is not to undermine their importance and potential reasons for lack of use may be found in Mithani, “Directors' Disqualification”, [810–820], Section 2, Chapter 2A.
By a claim form issued on 26 February 2019 the CMA pursuant to section 9A(10) of the CDDA applied for Mr Martin's disqualification by reason of his conduct, which term includes omission ( section 9E(4)), as a director of (i) Gary Berryman Estate Agents Limited, (ii) its parent company The Property Group (2010) Limited and/or (iii) the ultimate parent, Warne Investments Limited. Mr Martin was registered as a member of Warne Investments Limited with 43.21% of the issued share capital during the relevant period.
It appears from Mr Martin's evidence that Gary Berryman Estate Agents Limited became a dormant company after it was purchased by The Property Group (2010) Limited on 19 April 2013 and to whom its trade assets and liabilities were transferred. Nothing turns on that transfer other than factual accuracy and it is convenient in this judgment to use the term “Berrymans” to refer to the transferred business and to the continuing role (if any) of Gary Berryman Estate Agents Limited in the business. References to Mr Martin's role as a director of Berrymans, therefore, will be to his appointment as a director of The Property Group (2010) Limited (unless otherwise stated) but in the context of him also being a director of Gary Berryman Estate Agents Limited.
The claim evolved out of formal investigations by the CMA under section 25 of the Competition Act 1998. They were started during September 2015 because the CMA had reasonable grounds to suspect cartel activity in the estate and letting agency sector of businesses in the Burnham-on-Sea area. Information was gathered under sections 26 and 28 of the Competition Act 1988, through cooperation and from “state of play” meetings. On 31 May 2017 the CMA published a decision (“the CMA Decision”) concluding that Abbott and Frost Estate Agents Limited, Annagram Estates Limited (trading as ‘CJ Hole’), Gary Berryman Estate Agents Limited (which was described as “an active company throughout” the relevant period of the investigation without distinguishing it from The Property Group (2010) Limited and hence the definition of “Berrymans” used in this judgment) and its ultimate parent company, Warne Investments Limited, Greenslade Taylor Hunt, Saxons PS Limited and West Coast Property Services (UK) Limited (together called “the Infringers”) infringed the prohibition imposed by section 2(1) of the Competition Act 1998.
It was found they did so by participating in an agreement and/or concerted practice to fix a minimum level of commission fees for property sales agency services which they provided within their operational areas from branches located in Burnham-on-Sea from at least 4 February 2014 until at least 18 February 2015 in the case of Saxons PS Limited and until at least 24 March 2015 in the case of the others. It was estimated that together, the Infringers had a market share perhaps as high as 95% of a value of some £1.5 million during the relevant period.
The CMA Decision against Berrymans is based upon evidence of its direct involvement in the prohibited conduct. The finding against Warne Investments Ltd is based upon a presumption that it “exercised a decisive influence” over its 100% owned subsidiary and, therefore, formed part of the same undertaking. The CMA Decision includes a finding that Mr Martin, as a director of Berrymans, The Property Group, and Warne Investments, was aware of the prohibited conduct and, at least, supported it rather than take steps either to prevent it or bring it to an end.
On 11 July 2017, the CMA opened investigations, within the meaning of section 9C CDDA, for the purpose of deciding whether to make this disqualification claim. It did so having reasonable grounds for suspecting that a breach of competition law had occurred. Pursuant to section 9C(3) and (4) of the CDDA the CMA informed Mr Martin of its intention to proceed with a claim on 7 February 2019.
The CMA's case, in a nutshell, is that Mr Martin whilst acting as a director had a responsibility for Berrymans' participation in the agreement and/or concerted practice to fix a minimum level of commission fees. Alternatively, that he failed to take any steps to prevent the prohibited conduct of Berrymans despite having reasonable grounds to suspect it was occurring. That in any event, he ought (at least) to have known that its conduct was such as to be prohibited conduct.
The CMA relies principally upon four pieces of direct evidence (together called “the Direct Evidence”): The minutes of a meeting of employees attended by Mr Martin on 22 January 2014; subsequent emails that day between an employee, Mr Hutchinson, and Mr Martin concerning the intention to instigate an agreement between local agents and Berrymans; a further email of 4 February 2014 from Mr Hutchinson to Mr Martin spelling out the terms of the local agents' agreement; and the minutes of a meeting on 15 May 2014 between Mr Martin and Berrymans' senior employee, Mr Gass, referring to the local agents' agreement. Mr Gass had originally formed the Berryman's business and sold Gary Berryman Estate Agents Limited to The Property Group (2010) Limited in April 2013.
B) The CDDA Requirements
Section 9A of the CDDA requires the CMA to satisfy the court:
a) First, that an undertaking which is a company of which the defendant was a director committed a breach of competition law by engaging in conduct which infringed any of the prohibitions within Chapters 1 and 2 of the Competition Act 1998 or within Articles 101 and 102 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (“the First Condition”).
b) Second, that the defendant's conduct as a director makes him unfit to be concerned in the management of a company (“the Second Condition”).
For the purposes of the Second Condition, subsections 5(a), (c), (6) and (7) of section 9A of the CDDA ( subsection 5(b), ability to have regard to any other competition law breach, not being relevant) provide that the Court must have regard to:
a) whether the director's conduct contributed to the breach of competition law (irrespective of whether he knew it did) or, if not,
b) whether he had reasonable grounds to suspect that the conduct of the company constituted the breach of competition law and he took no steps to prevent it; or
c) that he ought to have known that the conduct constituted the breach even if he did not know of it; but
d) the Court must not have regard to the matters mentioned in Schedule 1 to the CDDA, which will be relevant to claims under other sections. The claim is specifically concerned with competition law.
Section 9A(1) of the CDDA expressly provides that the court “must” make a disqualification order against a person if the First and Second Conditions are satisfied. There is a similar requirement in section 6 of the CDDA (duty to disqualify unfit directors in non-competition cases) where the word “shall” is used and section 1(1) of the CDDA treats the two provisions as mandatory by using the word “shall”.
It is agreed between the parties that as the law stands, in accordance with the authorities concerning section 6 of the CDDA, an order must...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Nicholas Terry Brown v Competition and Markets Authority
...brackets (which were applied by ICC Judge Jones in the only s.9A case to come before the courts, Competition Markets Authority v Martin [2020] EWHC 1751 (Ch) at [112]), at [19]: “The seriousness of the misconduct is another consideration… That is often expressed by reference to the bracket ......
-
Paul Cluskey v The Competition and Markets Authority
...applying for or proceeding with an application for a disqualification order on the terms set out in section 9B(1) of the Act. In CMA v Martin [2020] EWHC 1751, when considering the introduction of the Enterprise Act and the Enterprise Regulatory Reform Act of the provisions extending the di......
-
Nicholas Terry Brown v Competition and Markets Authority
...Ch 164 three brackets (which were applied by ICC Judge Jones in the only s.9A case to come before the courts, Competition Markets Authority v Martin [2020] EWHC 1751 (Ch) at [112]), at “The seriousness of the misconduct is another consideration… That is often expressed by reference to the b......
-
High Court Issues Lengthy Director Disqualification Order for Contributing to a Competition Law Infringement
...the company from implementing the anti-competitive conduct. [1] Competition and Markets Authority v Michael Christopher Martin [2020] EWHC 1751 (Ch) John ColahanPeter function JDS_LoadEvent(func) { var existingOnLoad = window.onload; if (typeof window.onload != 'function') { window.onload =......
-
Table of Cases
...122n.62, 123n.63, 123n.64, 124n.65, 124n.66, 130n.81, 133n.92, 134n.100, 135n.101, 135n.102, 248–49, 248–49nn.126–31 CMA v Martin [2020] EWHC 1751 (Ch) �����������38, 293n.95, 298n.142, 301n.165, 305n.181, 305n.183 CMA v Pfizer UK Limited and Others See CMA v Flynn Pharmaceuticals Co Ltd......
-
The Emerging Contribution of Director Disqualification in UK Competition Law
...the right to respect for one’s private and family life under art 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights): Competition and Markets Authority v Martin [2020] EWHC 1751 (Ch), 96 CDDA 1986, s 13(a). If the conviction is a summary one, then the convicted individual faces penalties of up to......