Fairness and the Challenge of Making Markets Work Better
| Published date | 01 March 2021 |
| Author | Niamh Dunne |
| Date | 01 March 2021 |
| DOI | http://doi.org/10.1111/1468-2230.12579 |
bs_bs_banner
Modern Law Review
DOI:10.1111/1468-2230.12579
Fairness and the Challenge of Making Markets Work
Better
Niamh Dunne∗
This article explores the revival of fairness as the lodestar of EU competition enforcement. It
considers the theory and evolving discourse of fairness, then identies and evaluates examples
of fair ness-oriented enforcement activity. Concluding that fair ness represents a distinct devel-
opment from the ‘hipster antitrust’ movement, the article suggests reasons to explain the shift,
including a need to rehabilitate the social market economy in an age of market-scepticism,and
to facilitate the progressive expansion of competition law to address modern market failures.
INTRODUCTION
Well-functioning markets can be quite brutal. The dispassionate language of
market-clearing often disguises more dramatic stories of disappointed rivals,
ckle customer preferences, the exclusion of vulnerable consumers, and even
gales of creative destruction which drive innovation by destroying what has
come before. A question of increasing prominence, however, is whether the
notion of a well-functioning market requires some degree of fairness in its op-
eration or outcomes. An issue of broader relevance in an era when faith in
market-based mechanisms is under increasing strain, this article focuses on the
question as it arises in the competition law context – described as the ‘ght over
antitrust’s soul’.1Not only is this a eld where the clash between fairness and
the quotidian brutality of the market mechanism is particularly acute; more-
over ‘[c]ompetition rules have large footprints,’2with knock-on eects across
a spectrum of adjacent public policy areas. This article explores the purported
revival of fairness as the lodestar of enforcement within the European Union
(EU), alongside potential explanations for this shift in practice.
The issue has come to public attention through the ‘fairness mantra’3associ-
ated with Margrete Vestager’s tenure at DG Competition.Recent enforcement
∗Law Department, London School of Economics and Political Science. Earlier versions of this article
were presented at the SLS Annual Conference 2018 (QMUL),the Centre for Competition Policy
(UEA), and as part of the GOLEM (LSE) and DELI (Durham) seminar series. The nal version
benets from feedback from participants on these occasions.Special thanks to Pablo Ibáñez Colomo,
Derek Ridyard and two anonymous referees for their helpful comments. Mistakes remain my own.
All URLs were last accessed 12 August 2020.
1 A. Ezrachi and M.E. Stucke, ‘The Fight over Antitrust’s Soul’ (2018) 9 JECLAP 1.
2 C. Townley,A Framework for European Competition Law (Oxford: Hart, 2018) 43.
3 MLex, ‘Vestager’s ‘fairness’ mantra rattles through EU competition law’ 15 Novem-
ber 2016 at https://mlexmarketinsight.com/insights-center/editors-picks/antitrust/europe/
vestagers-fairness- mantra-rattles-through-eu- competition-law.
© 2020 The Authors. The Modern Law Reviewpublished by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of Modern Law Review Limited.
(2021) 84(2) MLR 230–264
Thisis an open access ar ticle under the terms of the CreativeCommons Attr ibution License,which permits use,distr ibution and reproduction
in any medium,provided the original work is properly cited.
Niamh Dunne
activity reinforces the perception that,after several decades during which com-
petition law pivoted towards a ‘more economic approach,’ this nominal con-
sensus may be less than settled. The proposition that the competition process
should deliver fairness raises challenging questions: from what is fairness,to fair-
ness for whom? A critical account may view this development as sloganeering –
a ‘wea sel word ’4– or an attempt to politicise or corrupt the application of these
ostensibly technical rules. This article explores such tensions, revisiting well-
worn questions about the goals of competition law, yet endeavouring to place
these within the distinctive circumstances of the contemporary internal market.
The following section sets the scene,descr ibing the shift from fairness-based
enforcement, to the more economic approach, and back again. The legal im-
plications of these changes are unclear, however, for two reasons. First, although
the concept appears throughout the EU competition framework, at no point
is fairness dened. Indeed, fairness is amenable to multiple competing, even
conicting denitions, creating a lack of clarity about what a f airness standard
requires. This is considered in the third section. Second, although the rhetor ic
of fairness is distinct from that of the more economic approach, the Commis-
sion insists that the former is not only compatible with, but is a manifestation
of, the latter. Yet, as explained in the fourth section, not only are these con-
cepts dicult to reconcile linguistically or theoretically but much of the tenor
and focus of recent enforcement moves away from a n economic approach as
strictly understood. Accordingly, the rhetorical shift towards a fair ness standard
occurs alongside a shift in enforcement practice, which may or may not mir-
ror these changes in discourse. The fth section asks: why now? If we accept
that the contemporary fairness mantra represents a substantive departure from
previously declared policy, what explains this, particularly coming so soon after,
and in apparent contradiction of, the initial corrective of the more economic
approach?
SETTING THE SCENE: FAIRNESS TO EFFICIENCY AND BACK
AGAI N?
EU law incorporates a wide spectrum of competition rules. Like most systems,
it has rules regulating collusion,5dominance,6and mergers.7It also includes
provisions that are EU-specic, including rules against State aids8and State
measures that require antitrust violations.9What unites these discrete provi-
sions are the overarching policy objectives served.The thor ny question of what
motivates EU competition law is one which perpetually sparks debate, and to
4 J. Laitenberger,‘EU competition law in innovationand digital markets: fairness and the consumer
welfare perspective’Speech, 10 October 2017 (JL Speech, 10 October 2017).
5 Art 101 TFEU.
6 Art 102 TFEU.
7 Regulation 139/2004 on the control of concentrations between undertakings (OJ L24/1, 29
January 2004).
8 Arts 107-109 TFEU.
9 Art 106(1) TFEU.
© 2020 The Authors. The Modern Law Reviewpublished by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of Modern Law Review Limited.
(2021) 84(2) MLR 230–264 231
Fairness and the Challenge of Making Markets Work Better
which arguably no denitive answer can be given.10 Our focus is the pursuit of
fairness as an enforcement goal within the evolving EU system: a question of
renewed importance in light of recent polarised debates about the necessity of
signicant changes in the antitrust area, in Europe and further aeld.
The concept of fairness is not an unknown quantity in EU competition
law. The language of fairness has been present within the textual framework
since the Treaty of Rome, and it continues to have a prominent role within the
Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU). The Preamble to
the TFEU includes an overarchingreference to ‘fair competition,’while Articles
101 and 102 refer to ‘a fair share’ for consumers and ‘unfair purchase or selling
prices or other unfair trading conditions,’ respectively. It has furthermore been
argued that the prohibition on selective advantages under the State aid rules
‘self-evidently’ reects notions of fairness ‘within the ordinary meaning of the
word’ .11 Accordingly, at least formally, fairness has always been a consideration
within the competition framework.
Fairness has instinctive appeal as a policy objective. Fairness discourse extends
beyond competition law to embrace a range of policy areas,including asylum,12
labour law,13 insolvency,14 data privacy15 and private law theory.16 Proponents
argue that the pursuit of fairness links directly to the ‘social rationale’ for com-
petition law.17 The idea is put forcefully by Marco Colino: ‘It makes little sense
to defend a competition policy that develops with its back purposefully turned
to the attainment of moral and social justice.’18 Accordingly,fair ness is posited as
a central concern because,otherwise, there is little point to market intervention
if not to generate fairer outcomes.
Much depends upon what is understood by fairness, a point considered in
the next section.Yet even if what might be broadly construed as a fairness-based
approach was evident during the early years of the EU system,it became more
dicult to make the case for a central role later on. Instead, the last couple of
decades have witnessed the explicit adoption of the so-called more economic
approach by the European Commission.19 From this per spective, the pursuit
of economic eciency is the primary if not the sole objective of competition
enforcement. The impetus for this shift was, at least partly,in response to con-
siderable criticism of the existing jurisprudence: criticism summed up in the
10 M. Motta, Competition Policy: Theory and Practice (New York, NY: Cambridge University Press,
2004) 17-30; and A. Ezrachi, ‘Sponge’ (2017) 5 J Antitrust E nforcement 49.
11 M. Vestager, ‘Competition and fairness in a digital society’ Speech, 22 November 2018 (MV
Speech, 22 November 2018)
12 E. Küçük, ‘The Principle of Solidarity and Fairness in Sharing Responsibility: More than Win-
dow Dressing?’(2016) 23 ELJ 448.
13 A. Sanders, ‘Fairness in the Contract of Employment’(2017) 46 Industrial Law Jour nal 506.
14 S. Paterson, ‘Debt Restr ucturing and Notions of Fairness’ (2017) 80 MLR 600.
15 D. Cliord and J. Ausloos ‘Data Protection and the Role of Fairness’(2018) 37 YEL 130.
16 G.S. Alexander, Property and Human Flourishing (Oxford: OUP, 2018) and N.J. McBride, The
Humanity of Private Law (Oxford: Hart, 2018).
17 D.Gerard, ‘Fairness in EU Competition Policy: Signicance and Implications’ (2018) 9 JECLAP
211, 211.
18 S. Marco Colino, ‘The Antitrust F Word: Fairness Considerations in Competition Law’ 2018
CUHK Faculty of Law Research Paper No 2018-09,18.
19 A useful study is A.C. Witt, The More Economic Approach to EU Competition Law (Oxford: Hart,
2016).
232 © 2020 The Authors. The Modern Law Reviewpublished by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of Modern Law Review Limited.
(2021) 84(2) MLR 230–264
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting