Graham v Graham's Trustees
| Jurisdiction | Scotland |
| Judgment Date | 15 October 1901 |
| Date | 15 October 1901 |
| Docket Number | No. 1. |
| Court | Court of Session |
Lord President, Lord M'Laren, Lord Adam, Lord Kinnear.
Process—Mandatary—Soldier on Foreign Service.—
Circumstances in which the Court refused to ordain the pursuer of an action who was a soldier on foreign service to sist a mandatary.
Peter Macpherson Graham, gunner in the 15th Company of the Royal Artillery, and on service with the Northern Field Force in China, raised an action in the Sheriff Court at Glasgow against the trustees under the trust-disposition and settlement of his father, Alexander Graham, formerly a wine and spirit merchant in Glasgow, who had died domiciled in Scotland, and leaving estate situated exclusively in Scotland.
The action concluded for production of an account by the trustees of their intromissions with the moveable estate of the deceased, and for payment of the amount which should be ascertained as the pursuer's share of the estate.
The defenders admitted that the pursuer was entitled to one-sixth of the legitim fund, if any, under a provision of the settlement by which the trustees were directed to pay him his legitim.
In the inventory lodged by the trustees, and in a statement furnished by their agent to the pursuer, the free moveable estate was brought out at £845, 17s. 1d., and the legitim fund at one-half of this sum, £422, 18s. 6d., one-sixth share of which would amount to £70, 9s. 9d. But in their answers to the pursuer's condescendence the defenders stated that this estimate of the moveable estate was inaccurate, as it was based on the assumption that the goodwill of certain licensed premises of which the deceased was tenant, and which formed the chief asset, was moveable. They averred ‘that there was no free estate available apart from the goodwill of the businesses for the pursuer's legitim,’ and pleaded,—‘2. The pursuer having no interest in the goodwills, which follow the leases, and there being no estate otherwise available for legitim, the defenders should be assoilzied.’
On 6th July 1901, the Sheriff-substitute (Boyd) pronounced this interlocutor:—Finds that the goodwills of the premises cannot be regarded as forming part of the moveable estate of the deceased: Therefore, so far sustains the defences, and assoilzies the defenders from this claim, and decerns: Quoad ultra allows a proof, and sends the case to the Diet Roll of the 19th inst.’
The pursuer appealed.
In the Single Bills the defenders moved the Court to ordain the pursuer to...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
R. v. Heikel et al. (No. 3), (1990) 110 A.R. 161 (QB)
...[en.1986. c. 35. s. 14] 188(4)(e.1) [re-en. R.S.C. 1985, c. 27 (2nd Supp.), s. 10] 178.15(4)(c) [re-en. 1986 c. 35. s. 14] 188(4)(f.1) [en. R.S.C. 1985, c. 27 (2nd Supp.), s. 10] 178.15(4)(c.1) 188(4)(d) 178.15(4)(c.2) 178.15(4)(d) 188(4)(e) 178.15(4)(e) 188(4)(f) 178.15(4)(f) 188(4)(g) 178......
-
Fairford First Nation v. Canada (Attorney General), (1998) 156 F.T.R. 1 (TD)
...beyond merely land and that the Fairford First Nation had no capacity or authority to conclude such negotiations or agreements"? Para: 174 4.F.1. Plaintiffs' Position Para: 174 4.F.2. Facts Para: 175 4.F.3. The Crown's Duty Para: 183 4.F.4. Withholding of information by Canada Para: 187 4.G......
-
Kennedy v Judge Nolan & DPP
...or (b) quash the decision of the trial court, in which case the trial of the accused may proceed as if the charge had never been dismissed. 7 4F(1) At any time after the accused is sent forward for trial, the prosecutor or the accused may apply to the trial court for an order requiring a pe......
-
The Minster for Infrastructure and The Department for Infrastructure and Safe Electricity A&T Limited and Patrick Woods and The Executive Office
...of the Committee. (3) The Committee shall have the functions set out in paragraphs 19 and 20 of Strand One of the Belfast Agreement. (4) [F1 The Committee shall also have the function of discussing and agreeing upon— (a) [[F2 where the agreed programme referred to in paragraph 20 of Strand ......
-
When Does a Foreign Law Compel a U.S. Employer to Discriminate Against U.S. Expatriates?: A Modest Proposal for Reform
...2 and 3 at pp. 3-4 of ADEA Policy Guidance.[51] The EEOC’s ADEA Policy Guidance in turn provides: A critical element of a successful sec. 4(f)(1) "foreign laws" defense is proof by the United States employer, or a corporation controlled by such employer, that compliance with the ADEA would ......
-
Brief For Amici Curiea Economists In Support Of Appellees/Cross-Appellants And Affirmance
...Payers?,” California Foundation for Commerce and Education (2007), available at http://www.cornerstone.com/files/CaseStudy/9bc04cf2-dd57-4f1d-ab3c-e5e0d5e7c96e/Presentation/CaseStudyFile/4796ca54-3a8a-4676-a61c-4c4b9f5a5272/Kessler_CFCE_Cost_Shift_Study%206-6-07.pdf ..............................
-
False Claims Act Recent Developments
...the law" in Alison Engine I, including that intent and materiality standard. S. Rep. No. 10, 111th Cong., 1st Sess. 10 (2009). Under Section 4(f)(1) of FERA, the legislation "took effect as if enacted on June 7, 2008," two days before the Allison Engine I opinion was issued, and would apply......
-
A Confidential Consultation?
...version: '0' , handler: '//fbapps.jdsupra.com/statistics/pixel?partnerID=dc4a1c64-176f-4a9f-913d-afd8f74f746f&file_unique_id=408a7d4d-c43d-4f1d-951e-3db8fc529a31&profile_id=15516&type=5&' // Public , pageview: function (data) { if (data === undefined) { data = this._curpage(); } else if (ty......
-
The law
...plainti൵s. For disparate impact claims, the statutory defense for ADEA claims is the reasonable factor other than age (RFOA) defense in ADEA§4(f)(1), not the business necessity defense available in Title VII claims. The Supreme Court held in Gross v. FBL Fin. Servs. , 557 U.S. 167, 174 (200......
-
Revisiting Granite Falls: Why the Seattle Monorail Project Requires Re-examination of Washington's Prohibition
...193. Petition 1, § 4(g). 194. Wash. Rev. Code § 35.95A.120 (2002). 195. Petition l,§4(i)(2). 196. Petition 1, § 4(f)(1). 197. Id. at § 4(f)(2). This is particularly true of costs that are already locked in and/or construction that is completed by 2009, well within the 9 year 198. Id. at § 4......
-
Federal And State Takeover Laws
...by the target company. 87. Id. § 240.14d-5(e). 88. Id. § 240.14d-5(f). 89. Id. § 240.14d-7. 90. Id. § 240.14e-1. 91. Id. §§ 240.13e-4(f)(1)(ii), 240.14e-1(b). 92. 17 C.F.R. § 240.14d-8 (2008). 93. Pryor v. U.S. Steel Corp., 794 F.2d 52 (2d Cir. 1986); Pryor v. USX Corp., 1991 WL 346368 (S.D......
-
Parochial procedure.
...[listing four options]; or (3) by other means not prohibited by international agreement, as the court orders. (307) While the new Rule 4(f)(1) increased awareness of the Service Convention, the new Rule 4(f)(3) introduced a safety valve that the Ninth Circuit has interpreted as a broad stan......
-
Limitation on Use of Appropriated Funds to Influence Certain Federal Contracting and Financial Transactions
...319(a)(1), Oct. 23, 1989, 103 Stat. 750; amended Pub. L. 101-512, title III, Sec. 320, Nov. 5, 1990, 104 Stat. 1977; Pub. L. 103-272, Sec. 4(f)(1)(F), July 1994, 108 Stat. 1362; Pub. L. 104-65, Sec. 10, Dec. 19, 1995, 109 Stat. 700; Pub. L. 104-66, title III, Sec. 3001(b), Dec. 21, 1995, 10......
-
Disclosure Statement
...original tax return. Keep a copy for your records. You may be able to file Form 8275 with an amended return. See Regulations sections 1.6662-4(f)(1) and 1.6664-2(c)(3) for more To make adequate disclosure for items reported by a pass-though entity, you must complete and file a separate Form......
-
Arbitrage Rebate, Yield Reduction and Penalty in Lieu of Arbitrage Rebate
...administrative costs taken into account in computing the rebate amount under these special rules. Line 27. Under Regulations section 1.148-4(f)(1), fees properly allocable to Instructions for Form 8038-T (Rev. 10-2021) payments for a qualified guarantee for an issue are treated as additiona......
-
Regulation Disclosure Statement
...tax return. Keep a copy for your records. You may also be able to file Forms 8275-R with an amended return. See Regulations sections 1.6662-4(f)(1) and 1.6664-2(c)(3) for more To make adequate disclosure for items reported by a pass-through entity, you must complete and file a separate Form......
-
Georgia Monthly Bulletin, 2022-03, March 2022 v2a
...providing the packages do not contain any fissile material, or the material is exempt from classification as fissile material in .06(4)(f): 1. A package that contains no more than a Type A quantity of radioactive 2. A package transported within the United States that contains no more than 2......
-
New Jersey Register, Volume 46, Issue 09, May 5, 2014
...improvement plans. RESPONSE: The Department appreciates the support. 2. COMMENT: The commenter recommended that proposed N.J.A.C. 6A:9-8.4(f)1, require the chief school administrator to submit the district mentoring plan to the district board of education for "review and approval" of its fi......
-
Protection of Freedoms Act 2012
...are to be read accordingly) , and (b) the power of the Secretary of State under paragraph 4D(4) (b) , and of a senior officer under paragraph 4F(1) (c) , includes a power to remove areas or places from the (4I) (1) Sub-paragraph (2) applies if any decision of— (a) a senior officer to give, ......
-
Justice and Security (Northern Ireland) Act 2007
...are to be read accordingly) , and (b) the power of the Secretary of State under paragraph 4D(4) (b) , and of a senior officer under paragraph 4F(1) (c) , includes a power to remove areas or places from the (4I) (1) Sub-paragraph (2) applies if any decision of— (a) a senior officer to give, ......