Highways and public rights of way
| Author | Christopher Jessel |
| Pages | 195-211 |
"
"
Ejcrvgt"33"
Jkijyc{u"cpf"Rwdnke"Tkijvu"qh"Yc{3"
3303" XGUVKPI"QH"JKIJYC[U
Jkijyc{u"ctg"vjg"swggpÓu"qt"mkpiÓu"jkij"yc{"*regia via+"cpf"hqtogtn{"ygtg"uggp"
cu"wpfgt"tq{cn"rtqvgevkqp0"Pqy"vjg{"ctg"oquvn{"xguvgf"kp"nqecn"cwvjqtkvkgu"gzegrv"
hqt"vjg"oqvqtyc{u"cpf"pcvkqpcn"tqwvgu"yjkej"ctg"xguvgf"kp"Jkijyc{u"Gpincpf0"
Kp"vjg"okf/35vj"egpvwt{"vjg"vtgcvkug"De Legibus et Consuetudinibus Angliae"
cvvtkdwvgf"vq"Ukt"Jgpt{"fg"Dtcevqp."kp"fkuewuukpi"dqwpfctkgu"dgvyggp"pgkijdqwtkpi"
ncpfqypgtu."uwiiguvgf"vjcv"vjg"mkpiÓu"jkijyc{<4"
ecp"pqv"dg"eqooqp"dgvyggp"pgkijdqwtu"pqt"vjg"rtqrgtv{"qh"cp{qpg"gzegrv"vjg"
nqtf"mkpi0"Kv"ku"c"swcuk/ucetgf"vjkpi"cpf"jg"yjq"qeewrkgu"cp{"rctv"vjgtgqh."d{"
gzeggfkpi"vjg"nkokvu"cpf"dqwpfctkgu"qh"jku"ncpf."ku"uckf"vq"jcxg"eqookvvgf"c"
rwtrtguvwtg"wrqp"vjg"mkpi0"
"
Vjcv"xkgy"ycu"dcugf"qp"Tqocp"ncy"cpf"fkf"pqv"dgeqog"ceegrvgf"kp"vjg"eqooqp"
ncy0"Kpuvgcf"vjg"rqukvkqp"ycu"fguetkdgf"d{"Nqtf"Ocpuhkgnf"kp"Goodtitle, ex dimiss.
Chester v Alker and Elmes5yjgtg"jg"uckf
vjg" Mkpi" jcu" pqvjkpi" dwv" vjg" rcuucig" hqt" jkougnh" cpf" jku" rgqrng
htggjqnf"cpf"cnn"rtqhkvu"dgnqpi"vq"vjg"qypgt"qh"vjg"uqkn0"Uq"fq"cnn"vjg"vtggu"wrqp"
kv."cpf"okpgu"wpfgt"kv"*yjkej"oc{"dg"gzvtgogn{"xcnwcdng+0"Vjg"qypgt"oc{"ectt{"
ycvgt"kp"rkrgu"wpfgt"kv0"Vjg"qypgt"oc{"igv"jku"uqkn"fkuejctigf"qh"vjku"ugtxkvwfg"
qt"gcugogpv"qh"c"yc{"qxgt"kv."d{"c"ytkv"qh"ad quod damnum"È"Vjgtg"ku"pq"
tgcuqp"yj{"jg"ujqwnf"pqv"jcxg"c"tkijv"vq"cnn"tgogfkgu"hqt"vjg"htggjqnf="uwdlgev"
uvknn"kpfggf"vq"vjg"ugtxkvwfg"qt"gcugogpv0"Cp"cuuk¦g"yqwnf"nkg."kh"jg"ujqwnf"dg"
fkuugkugf"qh"kv"fqpg"vq"kv0"
"
3"" Vjku"ejcrvgt"ku"dcugf"qp"vyq"ctvkengu"yjkej"crrgctgf"kp"vjg"Rights of Way Law Review"kp"Lwpg"
4235"cpf"vjg"ocvgtkcn"ku"tgrtqfwegf"ykvj"eqpugpv0"
4" Ukt"Jgpt{"Dtcevqp."De Legibus et Consuetudinibus Angliae"*e"3479+"*U"Vjqtpg"*gf+."Ecodtkfig
Jctxctf"Wpkxgtukv{"Rtguu."3;99+"xqn"5"r"83"hqn"3:2d0"
5" *3979+"3"Dwttqy"355"cv"365.";9"GT"453"cv"4580"
3;8" Crown and Government Land"
"
Vjg" ghhgev" ycu" vjcv" vjg" uqkn" qh" c" jkijyc{" ycu" rtguwogf." kp" vjg" cdugpeg" qh"
gxkfgpeg"vq"vjg"eqpvtct{."vq"dgnqpi"vq"vjg"qypgt"qh"vjg"cflcegpv"ncpf0"Kh"vjg"vyq"
ukfgu"qh"vjg"tqcf"qt"rcvj"ygtg"kp"ugrctcvg"qypgtujkr"vjgp"gcej"ycu"rtguwogf"vq"
qyp"wr"vq"vjg"egpvtg"nkpg."vjg"medium filum qt"okffng"vjtgcf06"
Gpcevogpvu" fwtkpi" vjg" 3;vj" egpvwt{" rcuugf" tgurqpukdknkv{" hqt" vjqug" jkijyc{u"
yjkej"ygtg"ecttkcigyc{u"vq"nqecn"cwvjqtkvkgu0"Vjg"Nqecn"Iqxgtpogpv"Cev"3:::.""
u"33*3+"cpf"*4+"rtqxkfgf"hqt"eqwpv{"eqwpeknu"qt"fkuvtkev"eqwpeknu"vq"ockpvckp"ockp"
tqcfu"cpf"u"33*8+"xguvgf"vjgo"kp"vjg"eqwpeknu0"Qvjgt"uvcvwvgu"xguvgf"tqcfu"kp"gkvjgt"
vjg"nqecn"jkijyc{"cwvjqtkv{"qt."hqt"oclqt"pcvkqpcn"tqwvgu."vjg"ugetgvct{"qh"uvcvg0"
Vjku"ycu"gzvgpfgf"vq"rwdnke"rcvju"*hqqvrcvju"cpf"dtkfngyc{u+"yjkej"gzkuvgf"kp"
3;6;"d{"vjg"Pcvkqpcn"Rctmu"cpf"Ceeguu"vq"vjg"Eqwpvt{ukfg"Cev"3;6;."uu"69"cpf"
6;0" Vjgug" rtqxkukqpu" ctg" pqy" eqpuqnkfcvgf" kp"vjg" Jkijyc{u" Cev" 3;:2." u" 485"
yjkej"rtqxkfgu
Uwdlgev"vq"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjku"ugevkqp."gxgt{"jkijyc{"ockpvckpcdng"cv"vjg"
rwdnke"gzrgpug." vqigvjgt" ykvj" vjg" ocvgtkcnu" cpf" uetcrkpiu" qh" kv." xguvu" kp" vjg"
cwvjqtkv{"yjq"ctg"hqt"vjg"vkog"dgkpi"vjg"jkijyc{"cwvjqtkv{"hqt"vjg"jkijyc{0"
"
Vjg{"jcxg" dggp" vjg" uwdlgev" qh" eqpukfgtcdng" lwfkekcn" eqoogpv07"Vjg"ghhgev"jcu"
dggp"jgnf"vq"xguv"kp"vjg"jkijyc{"cwvjqtkv{."cu"fkuewuugf"d{"Fgppkpi"NL"kp"Tithe
Redemption Commissioners v Runcorn Rural District Council.8vjg"vqr"vyq"urkvu."
kp"ghhgev"vjg"uwthceg."qh"vjg"tqcf"hqt"c"ngicn"guvcvg"kp"hgg"ukorng"fgvgtokpcdng9"kp"
vjg"gxgpv"qh"kvu"egcukpi"vq"dg"c"rwdnke"jkijyc{0"
Vjg"3;6;"Cev"cnuq"rtqxkfgf"hqt"c"fghkpkvkxg"ocr"qh"hqqvrcvju"cpf"dtkfngyc{u"vq"
dg"rtgrctgf0"Vjcv"rtqxkukqp"ycu"tg/gpcevgf"kp"vjg"Yknfnkhg"cpf"Eqwpvt{ukfg"Cev"
3;:3."u"78"yjkej"d{"u"89*3+"dkpfu"vjg"Etqyp0"Vjwu"kh"c"rcvj"qxgt"Etqyp"ncpf"ku"
ujqyp"qp"vjg"fghkpkvkxg"ocr"vjcv"ku"eqpenwukxg"qh"kvu"gzkuvgpeg0"
"
6" Pgwdgtigt"L"kp"Commission for the New Towns v JJ Gallagher Ltd"]4225̲"4"R"("ET"5"ekvkpi"vjg"
jgcfpqvg"kp"Berridge v Ward"*3:83+"32"ED"PU"622."364"GT"729="ugg"cnuq"Pardoe v Pennington"
*3;;8+"97"R"("ET"486"cv"48;."rgt"Yckvg"NL0"
7"Coverdale v Charlton"*3:9:+"6"SDF"326."EC0"Ugg"cnuq"Foley’s Charity Trustees v Dudley Corp"
]3;32̲" 3" MD" 539=" Tunbridge Wells Corporation v Baird" ]3:;8̲" CE" 656=" Wednesbury
Corporation v The Lodge Holes Colliery Company Ltd"]3;29̲"3"MD"9:0
8" ]3;76̲"Ej"5:50
9"Rolls v Vestry of St George the Martyr, Southwark"*3::2+"36"EjF"9:7."EC0"
"Highways and Public Rights of Way" 3;9"
"
3304" JKIJYC["CWVJQTKVKGU
Cnvjqwij"oquv"jkijyc{"cwvjqtkvkgu"ctg"eqwpv{"qt"wpkvct{"eqwpeknu."hqt"oclqt"tqcfu"
kv"ycu"hqtogtn{"vjg"Ugetgvct{"qh"Uvcvg"hqt"Vtcpurqtv0:"Wpfgt"vjg"Kphtcuvtwevwtg"Cev"
4237."u"3"c"uvtcvgike"jkijyc{u"eqorcp{"yjkej"ku"yjqnn{"qypgf"d{"vjg"ugetgvct{"
qh"uvcvg"ecp"dg"crrqkpvgf"kpuvgcf0"Wpfgt"vjg"Fgngicvkqp"qh"Hwpevkqpu"*Uvtcvgike"
Jkijyc{u"Eqorcpkgu+" *Gpincpf+" Tgiwncvkqpu" 4237;" vjg" Ugetgvct{" qh" Uvcvg" hqt"
Vtcpurqtv" nkegpugf" vjg" Jkijyc{u" Gpincpf" Eqorcp{" Nvf" mpqyp" cu" Jkijyc{u"
Gpincpf"qt"Pcvkqpcn"Jkijyc{u"yjkej"ku"pqv"c"Etqyp"dqf{"dwv"cp"PFRD0"Cp{"
jkijyc{u"xguvgf"kp"vjg"ugetgvct{"qh"uvcvg"cpf"pqv"rcuugf"qp"yknn"jcxg"tgockpgf"cu"
Etqyp"ncpf0"
Vjg" Jkijyc{u" Cev" 3;:2." u" 45;" rtqxkfgu" hqt" vjg" ceswkukvkqp" qh" ncpf" hqt"
eqpuvtwevkqp" qh" c" vtwpm" tqcf0" Wpfgt" u" 45:*3+" rqygtu" vq" ceswktg" ncpf" ctg"
gzgtekucdng"eqorwnuqtkn{"qt"d{"citggogpv0"Kh"*cu"ycu"fqpg"hqt"vjg"eqpuvtwevkqp""
qh"ocp{"oqfgtp"vtwpm"tqcfu."rctvkewnctn{"oqvqtyc{u+"vjg"htggjqnf"qh"vjg"ncpf""
ycu"ceswktgf"d{"vjg"ugetgvct{"qh"uvcvg"vjgp"vjg"yjqng"kpvgtguv"kp"vjg"ncpf."kpenwfkpi"
vjg" uwduqkn" cpf" ckturceg." yqwnf" dgnqpi" vq" vjg" fgrctvogpv" qt." pqy."Pcvkqpcn"
Jkijyc{u032"
D{"eqpvtcuv"vjg"ghhgev"qh"u"485"cpf"kvu"rtgfgeguuqtu"ku"vjcv"kp"vjg"ecug"qh"cp"cpekgpv"
jkijyc{"qt"qpg"etgcvgf"d{"fgfkecvkqp"d{"vjg"ncpfqypgt"qpn{"vjg"rj{ukecn"uvtwevwtg"
qh"vjg"tqcf"kvugnh"ku"uq"xguvgf0"Vjg"uwduqkn33"dgnqy"cpf"ckturceg"cdqxg"yjcv"ku"
tgswktgf"hqt"rcuucig"d{"vjg"rwdnke"tgockp"vjg"rtqrgtv{"qh"vjg"cflqkpkpi"ncpfqypgt0"
Cu"vjg"Nqecn"Iqxgtpogpv"Cev"3:::"cpf"qvjgt"ngikuncvkqp"fkf"pqv"dkpf"vjg"Etqyp."
vjgug"xguvkpi"rtqxkukqpu"cnuq"fq"pqv"crrn{"uq"vjcv"yjgtg"vjg"jkijyc{"ku"cp"cpekgpv"
qpg"etquukpi"Etqyp"ncpf"vjg"rqukvkqp"ecp"dg"fkhhgtgpv"htqo"rtkxcvg"ncpfqypgtu0"
Vjg"Etqyp"crrnkecvkqp"ugevkqp"ku"u"549*4+"yjkej"rtqxkfgu
Vjg"crrtqrtkcvg"cwvjqtkv{"kp"tgncvkqp"vq"cp{"ncpf"cpf"c"jkijyc{"cwvjqtkv{"oc{"
citgg"vjcv"cp{"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjku"Cev"urgekhkgf"kp"vjg"citggogpv"ujcnn"crrn{"vq"
vjcv"ncpf"cpf."yjkng"vjg"citggogpv"ku"kp"hqteg."vjqug"rtqxkukqpu"ujcnn"crrn{"vq"
vjcv"ncpf"ceeqtfkpin{."uwdlgev"jqygxgt"vq"vjg"vgtou"qh"vjg"citggogpv0"
"
"
:" Vjg"Ugetgvct{"qh"Uvcvg"hqt"Vtcpurqtv"Qtfgt"3;98"*UK"3;9813997+="vjg"Okpkuvgt"qh"Vtcpurqtv"Qtfgt"
3;9;"*UK"3;9;1793+0"
;" UK"4237159:0"
32"London Borough of Southwark v Transport for London"]423:̲"WMUE"850"
33"Norman v Department of Transport"*3;;8+"94"R"("ET"432"ekvkpi"Commissioners for Land Tax
for the City of London v Central London Railway Company"]3;35̲"CE"5860"
3;:" Crown and Government Land"
"
Kp"ocp{"ecugu"vjgtg"jcu"dggp"pq"gzrtguu"citggogpv"uq"u"485"yknn"pqv"crrn{0"Kh"vjg"
Etqyp"ceswktgf"ncpf"chvgt"3:::"*qt"qvjgt"tgngxcpv"fcvg+"yjgp"vjg"yc{"gzkuvgf"cpf"
kvu" uvtwevwtg" ycu" cntgcf{"xguvgf" kp" vjg" jkijyc{" cwvjqtkv{" vjcv" vkvng" yknn" pqv" dg"
fkuvwtdgf="yjgtg"vjg"Etqyp"jgnf"vjg"ncpf"dghqtg"vjcv"fcvg"vjg"vkvng"vq"vjg"uwthceg"
fkf"pqv"uq"xguv"dwv"tgockpgf"wpfgt"vjg"ocpcigogpv"qh"vjg"Etqyp"dqf{"yjkej"
jgnf"vjg"uwduqkn0"Kp"rtcevkeg"vjku"yknn"pqv"pqtocnn{"ocvvgt0"Vjgtg"yknn"jcxg"dggp"
cp"kornkgf"ceegrvcpeg"vjcv"vjg"jkijyc{"cwvjqtkv{"yqwnf"ockpvckp"vjg"tqcf0"Kuuwgu"
qh" vkvng" yknn" qpn{" tctgn{" dgeqog" tgngxcpv." cu" yjgp" kv" ku" pgeguuct{"vq" qdvckp" c"
rquuguukqp" qtfgt" cickpuv" rtqvguvgtu"qeewr{kpi" vjg" jkijyc{." kp" yjkej" ecug" vjg"
crrtqrtkcvg"Etqyp" cwvjqtkv{" ecp" cwvjqtkug" vjg" jkijyc{" cwvjqtkv{" vq" vcmg" uvgru"
wpfgt"u"3520"
3305" GZRTGUU"ETGCVKQP"CPF"FKXGTUKQP
Ncpf"oc{"dgeqog"c"jkijyc{"gkvjgt"d{"uvcvwvg"qt"cv"eqooqp"ncy"d{"vjg"ncpfqypgt"
fgfkecvkpi"kv"vq"vjg"rwdnke"wug"d{"ceegrvkpi"vjcv"ogodgtu"qh"vjg"rwdnke"jcxg"vjg"
tkijv" vq" rcuu" qxgt" vjg" ncpf0" Ukpeg" cpekgpv" vkogu." ocp{" tqcfu" cpf" rcvju" jcxg"
etquugf"ncpf"qh"vjg"Etqyp"yjkej"eqwnf"xqnwpvctkn{"fgfkecvg"kv"cu"c"jkijyc{0"
Vjg"lwfkekcn"xkgy"qp"kphgttgf"fgfkecvkqp"fkuewuugf"kp"3306"ku"vjcv"vjg"Etqyp"jcu"
rqygt"vq"fgfkecvg0"Vjgtg"crrgctu"vq"jcxg"dggp"cp"cnvgtpcvkxg"xkgy"vjcv"gzrtguu"
fgfkecvkqp"ycu"c"itcpv."ukoknct"vq"cp"gcugogpv34"cpf"vjg"rtqjkdkvkqp"qh"itcpvu"cpf"
cuuwtcpegu"kp"vjg"Etqyp"Ncpfu"Cev"3924"rtgxgpvgf"fgfkecvkqp0"Cv"qpg"vkog"rwdnke"
tkijvu"qh"yc{"ygtg"tgictfgf"cu"gcugogpvu35"dwv"vjg"oqfgtp"xkgy"ku"vjcv"vjg{"ecp"
pqv"dg"dgecwug."crctv"htqo"cp{vjkpi"gnug."vjg{"fq"pqv"dgpghkv"c"mpqyp"fqokpcpv"
vgpgogpv036"C"itcpv"qt"cuuwtcpeg"yqwnf"kpxqnxg"rctvkpi"ykvj"cp"guvcvg"qt"kpvgtguv"
kp"vjg"ncpf0"Hqnnqykpi"fgfkecvkqp"vkvng"vq"vjg"ncpf"tgockpgf"wpchhgevgf"cv"eqooqp"
ncy"cnvjqwij"vjg"Jkijyc{u"Cev"3;:2."uu"59"cpf"5:"yknn"pqy"qhvgp"dg"crrnkgf"vq"
pgy"yc{u"d{"citggogpv0"
Kv"oc{"dg"vjcv."dgecwug"vjgtg"ygtg"fqwdvu."vjg"Etqyp"Ncpfu"Cev"3;49."u"33"cu"
gzvgpfgf"d{"vjg"Etqyp"Ncpfu"Cev"3;58."u"9"icxg"vjg"Eqookuukqpgtu"qh"Etqyp"
ncpfu"gzrtguu"rqygt"vq"fgfkecvg"cp{"ncpf"cu"c"jkijyc{"qt"eqpugpv"vq"c"fkxgtukqp"
dwv"vjcv"ku"pqy"eqxgtgf"d{"igpgtcn"rqygtu"wpfgt"vjg"Etqyp"Guvcvg"Cev"3;830"Kh"
vjqug"fqwdvu"ygtg"lwuvkhkgf"qvjgt"Etqyp"dqfkgu"yqwnf"pggf"vq"jcxg"tgeqwtug"vq"
"
"
34" Eqorctg"vjg"Rtguetkrvkqp"Cev"3:54"yjkej"cwvjqtkugu"rtguetkrvkxg"gcugogpvu"qxgt"Etqyp"ncpf0"
35" G0i0"Harrison v Duke of Rutland"]3:;5̲"3"SD"364"cv"3760"
36"Rangeley v Midland Railway Company" *3:89Î8:+" NT" 5" Ej" Crr" 528" cv" 532=" DPP v Jones
(Margaret)"]3;;;̲"4"CE"462"cv"48:."rgt"Nqtf"Jqrg"qh"Etckijgcf="R (Godmanchester) v Secretary
of State for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs"]422:̲"3"CE"443"cv"]84̲."rgt"Nqtf"Ueqvv""
qh"Hqtvguewg0"
"Highways and Public Rights of Way" 3;;"
"
vjg"Jkijyc{u"Cev"3;:2."u"47"qt"u"52"cu"crrnkgf"d{"u"549"dwv"vjg"dgvvgt"xkgy"ku"vjcv"
vjg"Etqyp"jcu"vjg"rqygt0"Kp"ex parte Lewis37Yknnu"L"kp"vjg"Fkxkukqpcn"Eqwtv"jgnf"
vjcv" Vtchcnict" Uswctg."yjkej" y cu" yjqnn{"iqxgtpgf" d{" vjg" Cevu" qh" Rctnkcogpv"
yjkej"jcf"cwvjqtkugf"kvu"eqpuvtwevkqp"cpf"yjkej"fkf"pqv"rtqxkfg"hqt"kv"vq"dg"c"
rnceg"hqt"rwdnke"oggvkpiu."pgxgtvjgnguu"okijv"dg"fgfkecvgf"cu"c"jkijyc{038"
Vjg"Jkijyc{u"Cev"3;:2"eqpvckpu"eqorwnuqt{"rqygtu"vq"etgcvg"qt"fkxgtv"jkijyc{u"
vq"ocmg"c"rwdnke"rcvj"xctkcvkqp"qtfgt"cpf"wpfgt"u"549*4+"vjg"crrtqrtkcvg"cwvjqtkv{"
oc{"citgg" ykvj" vjg" dqf{" gzgtekukpi" vjg" rqygtu" vjcv" vjg" rtqxkukqpu" qh" vjg" Cev"
ujqwnf"crrn{"vq"vjg"ceswkukvkqp"qh"cp{"rtkxcvg"kpvgtguvu"uwej"cu"ngcugjqnfu"qt"vjg"
etgcvkqp"qh"pgy"tkijvu"qxgt"vgpcpvgf"ncpf"uwej"cu"c"hqqvrcvj"qt"dtkfngyc{"wpfgt""
u"480"Rqygtu"chhgevkpi"jkijyc{u"wpfgt"vjg"Vqyp"cpf"Eqwpvt{"Rncppkpi"Cev"3;;2"
ctg"iqxgtpgf"d{"Rv"ZKKK."cu"cogpfgf"d{"vjg"Rncppkpi"cpf"Eqorwnuqt{"Rwtejcug"
Cev"4226"kp"yjkej"ecug"vjg"3;;2"Cev."uu"448*4C+"cpf"44:*3C+"rtqxkfg"vjcv"vjg"
crrtqrtkcvg" cwvjqtkv{" ecp" eqpugpv" vq" vjg" Ugetgvct{" qh" Uvcvg" cwvjqtkukpi" vjg"
ceswkukvkqp"qh"c"rtkxcvg"kpvgtguv"kp"Etqyp"ncpf0"
Vjg"Etqyp"fqgu"pqv"jcxg"cp{"rtgtqicvkxg"qt"eqooqp"ncy"rqygt"vq"enqug."fkxgtv"
qt" uwurgpf" c" jkijyc{0" Uqog" fgrctvogpvu" jcxg" uvcvwvqt{" rqygtu" yjkej" ecp"
kpenwfg"rtqxkukqpu"cu"vq"gzkuvkpi"tkijvu"qh"yc{0"C"rctvkewnct"kpuvcpeg"tgncvgu"vq"
OqF"ncpf0"Vjg"Fghgpeg"Cev"3:64."u"38"rgtokvu"rcvju"vq"dg"fkxgtvgf"qt"uvqrrgf"
wr"cnvjqwij"u"39"tgswktgu"c"uwduvkvwvg"rcvj"vq"dg"rtqxkfgf039"Hwtvjgt"rtqxkukqpu"ctg"
kp"vjg"Fghgpeg"Cev"3:82."u"62."vjg"Oknkvct{"Ncpfu"Cev"3:;4."u"35"cpf"vjg"Ncpf"
Rqygtu"*Fghgpeg+"Cev"3;7:."uu":"cpf";0"Vjg"Ugetgvct{"qh"Uvcvg"hqt"Ngxgnnkpi"Wr."
Jqwukpi"cpf"Eqoowpkvkgu"jcu"rqygtu"kp"vjg"Vqyp"cpf"Eqwpvt{"Rncppkpi"Cev"
3;;2." uu" 469" cpf" 4790" Qvjgt" fgrctvogpvu" yjkej" j cxg" eqorwnuqt{" rqygtu" vq"
ceswktg"ncpf"wpfgt"igpgtcn"uvcvwvgu"oc{"dg"cdng"vq"wug"vjg"Ceswkukvkqp"qh"Ncpf"
Cev" 3;:3." u" 54" *yjkej" cwvjqtkugu" vjg" gzvkpiwkujogpv" qh" pqp/xgjkewnct" rwdnke"
tkijvu" qh" yc{+" vq" gzvkpiwkuj" c" yc{." cickp" wuwcnn{" uwdlgev" vq" rtqxkukqp" qh" cp"
cnvgtpcvkxg0"
Vjg" Tqcf" Vtchhke" Tgiwncvkqp" Cev" 3;:6." u" 352" crrnkgu" egtvckp" rtqxkukqpu" vq"
Òxgjkengu"cpf"rgtuqpu"kp"vjg"rwdnke"ugtxkeg"qh"vjg"EtqypÓ"cpf"wpfgt"u"353"Òcnn"qt"
cp{"qh"vjg"tqcf"vtchhke"gpcevogpvuÓ"oc{"dg"crrnkgf"vq"Etqyp"tqcfu."fghkpgf"kp""
u"353*9+*d+"cu"Òc"tqcf."qvjgt"vjcp"c"jkijyc{"È"vq"yjkej"vjg"rwdnke"jcu"ceeguu"d{"
rgtokuukqp"itcpvgf"d{"vjg"crrtqrtkcvg"Etqyp"cwvjqtkv{"qt"qvjgtykug"itcpvgf"d{"
qt"qp"dgjcnh"qh"vjg"EtqypÓ0"
"
37" *3:::+"43"SDF"3;30"
38" Cu"vq"tkijvu"qh"vjg"rwdnke"qp"jkijyc{u."ugg"DPP v Jones (Margaret)"]3;;;̲"4"CE"462="Director
of Public Prosecutions v Ziegler ]4243̲"WMUE"450"
39" Ugg"R (The Ramblers Association) v Secretary of State for Defence"]4229̲"GYJE"35;:"*Cfokp+."
]4229̲"Cnn"GT"*F+"5750"
422" Crown and Government Land"
"
3306" EQOOQP"NCY"KPHGTTGF"FGFKECVKQP"
Yjgp"vjg"rwdnke"jcxg"wugf"c"yc{"qxgt"ncpf."vjg"ncy"oc{"kphgt"vjcv"vjg"ncpfqypgt"
jcu"fgfkecvgf"vjg"yc{"cu"c"jkijyc{0"Wuwcnn{"vjcv"ku"kp"hcev"cickpuv"vjg"ncpfqypgtÓu"
ykujgu0"Ukpeg"vjg"Pcvwtcn"Gpxktqpogpv"cpf"Twtcn"Eqoowpkvkgu"Cev"4228."u"88"
rtqxkfgf"vjcv" vjku" fqgu" pqv" crrn{" vq" ogejcpkecnn{" rtqrgnngf" xgjkengu" kv" ku" pqy"
tgngxcpv"rtkpekrcnn{"vq"hqqvrcvju"cpf"dtkfngyc{u"cnvjqwij"wug"d{"ectvu."ecttkcigu"
cpf"yjggnejcktu"oc{"etgcvg"c"ecttkcigyc{0"
Vjgtg" ctg" vyq" ogvjqfu" qh" guvcdnkujkpi" c" jkijyc{" d{" kphgttgf" fgfkecvkqp
eqooqp"ncy"cpf"wpfgt"yjcv"ku"pqy"vjg"Jkijyc{u"Cev"3;:2."u"530"Eqooqp"ncy"
fgfkecvkqp"crrnkgu"vq"vjg"Etqyp"kp"vjg"ucog"yc{"cu"vq"rtkxcvg"ncpfqypgtu"dwv"u"
53"fqgu"pqv"kp"vjg"cdugpeg"qh"citggogpv"d{"vjg"Etqyp"wpfgt"u"5490"
Yjgtg"c"ncpfqypgt."ykvj"hwnn"mpqyngfig"cpf"ecrcekv{."vqngtcvgu"wug"qh"c"yc{"d{"
vjg" rwdnke" qrgpn{" hqt" c" uwhhkekgpv" rgtkqf" qh" vkog" vjgp" vjcv" ku" rtguwogf" vq" dg"
uwhhkekgpv"gxkfgpeg"qh"cp"kpvgpvkqp"vq"fgfkecvg"vjg"yc{0"Kv"ku"pqvqtkqwun{"fkhhkewnv"
vq"guvcdnkuj"vjku."dgecwug"ncpfqypgtu"ecp"tckug"fghgpegu"qh"kipqtcpeg"qt"ncem"qh"
ecrcekv{0"Kp"Harper v Charlesworth3:"c"hqtogt"rwdnke"hqqvrcvj"cetquu"uqog"Etqyp"
ncpf"jcf"dggp"gzvkpiwkujgf"d{"vjg"Pggfyqqf"Kpenquwtg"Cev"3:230"Pgxgtvjgnguu"
vjg"rwdnke"eqpvkpwgf"vq"wug"kv"hqt"qxgt"42"{gctu"cpf"vjg"swguvkqp"ctqug"yjgvjgt"kv"
jcf"dgeqog."cickp."c"rwdnke"jkijyc{0"Dc{ng{"L"jgnf"vjcv."cu"kv"ycu"pqv"ujqyp"vjcv"
vjg"Etqyp"jcf"dggp"cyctg"qh"vjg"rwdnke"wug."fgfkecvkqp"eqwnf"pqv"dg"rtguwogf0"
Jg"uckf
Dwv" vjg" tkijv" qh" uqkn" ku" kp" vjg" Etqyp." cpf" vjku"ecppqv" dg" c" rwdnke" yc{" d{"
fgfkecvkqp." wpnguu" vjgtg" dg" uqog" gxkfgpeg" vq" ujgy." vjcv" vjg" qypgt" jcu"
eqpugpvgf"vq"uwej"wugt0"
"
Vjgtg"ycu"pq"fkuewuukqp"cu"vq"yjgvjgt"kv"ycu"rquukdng"hqt"vjg"Etqyp"vq"fgfkecvg"
cpf"kpfggf"qp"vjg"hcevu"kv"jcf"pqv0"
R v East Mark Inhabitants3;"eqpegtpgf"c"tqcf"yjqug"qypgt"ycu"pqv"mpqyp0"Kv"jcf"
dggp"wugf"d{"vjg"rwdnke"hqt"ocp{"{gctu"kp"ektewouvcpegu"yjgtg."kh"kv"ycu"rtkxcvgn{"
qypgf."kv"yqwnf"jcxg"dgeqog"c"ockpvckpcdng"jkijyc{0"Kv"ycu"uwiiguvgf"vjcv"vjg"
uqkn"okijv"jcxg"rcuugf"vq"vjg"Etqyp"hqt"ncem"qh"cp{"qvjgt"qypgt"cpf"kv"ycu"ctiwgf"
vjcv"kh"uq"urgekcn"twngu"crrnkgf"uq"vjcv"vjg"rtguworvkqp"qh"fgfkecvkqp"ujqwnf"pqv"dg"
cxckncdng"cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp0"Nqtf"Fgpocp"EL"uckf."ÒVjg"Etqyp"egtvckpn{"oc{"
fgfkecvg"c"tqcf"vq"vjg"rwdnke."cpf"dg"dqwpf"d{"nqpi"ceswkguegpeg"kp"rwdnke"wugtÓ0"
Jg"fkf"pqv"ekvg"cp{"cwvjqtkv{"hqt"vjcv"uvcvgogpv"yjkej"ycu"obiter0"
"
3:" *3:47+"6"D"("E"796."329"GT"33960"
3;" *3:6:+"33"SD":99."338"GT"9230"
"Highways and Public Rights of Way" 423"
"
C"ecug"qh"rgtuwcukxg."cnvjqwij"pqv"fktgev."cwvjqtkv{"ku"vjg"Rtkx{"Eqwpekn"cfxkeg"kp"
Turner v Walsh042"Kv"kpxqnxgf"c"Pgy"Uqwvj"Ycngu"uvcvwvg."vjg"Etqyp"Ncpfu"
Cnkgpcvkqp"Cev"3:83."yjkej"tguvtkevgf"vjg"rqygt"qh"vjg"Etqyp"vq"fgfkecvg"ncpf0"
Vjgtg"jcf"dggp"rwdnke"wug"qh"c"yc{"hqt"qxgt"42"{gctu"dghqtg"3:83"cpf"vjgtghqtg"
kv"ycu"vq"dg"tgictfgf"cu"cntgcf{"dgkpi"c"jkijyc{"yjgp"vjg"Cev"ycu"rcuugf0"Vjg"
Dqctf"ekvgf"R v East Mark Inhabitants43"cpf"R v Petrie44"*yjgtg"kp"dqvj"ecugu"vjg"
vtwg"qypgt"ycu"wpmpqyp+"cpf"uckf
Htqo"nqpi/eqpvkpwgf"wugt"qh"c"yc{"d{"vjg"rwdnke."yjgvjgt"ncpf"dgnqpiu"vq"vjg"
Etqyp"qt"vq"c"rtkxcvg"qypgt."fgfkecvkqp"htqo"vjg"Etqyp"qt"rtkxcvg"qypgt."cu"
vjg"ecug"oc{"dg."kp"vjg"cdugpeg"qh"cp{vjkpi"vq"tgdwv"vjg"rtguworvkqp"oc{"cpf"
qwijv"vq"dg"rtguwogf0"
"
Vjg"tgngxcpeg"qh"vjg"ecug"ku"nkokvgf"d{"vjg"eqorngz"ngikuncvkxg"jkuvqt{"qh"Etqyp"
ncpf"kp"Cwuvtcnkc0"Kp"Folkestone Corp v Brockman45"kp"vjg"Jqwug"qh"Nqtfu"Nqtf"
Mkppgct"ecnngf"kv"Òjkij"cwvjqtkv{Ó."pqv"qp"vjg"urgekhke"kuuwg"qh"Etqyp"ncpf"*yjkej"
fkf"pqv"ctkug+."dwv"qp"vjg"igpgtcn"kuuwg"qh"rtguwogf"fgfkecvkqp"cv"eqooqp"ncy0"
Kp"Matthews v Wicks46"Ukt"Pkeqncu"Dtqypg/Yknmkpuqp"XE"uckf
Kv"oc{"ygnn"dg"vjg"ecug"*K"gzrtguu"pq"eqpenwfgf"xkgy"qp"vjg"ocvvgt+"vjcv."ikxgp"
vjku" dcemitqwpf." vjg" jkijyc{u" kp" vjg" Hqtguv" ]qh" Fgcp̲" owuv" jcxg" dggp"
fgfkecvgf"cu"jkijyc{u"d{"vjg"Etqyp"uwdlgev"vq"vjg"cpekgpv"tkijvu"*kh"cp{+"vq"
fgrcuvwtg"ujggr"kp"vjg"Hqtguv"cv"nctig="uwej"tkijvu"oc{"ygnn"kpenwfg"vjg"tkijv"vq"
cnnqy"uwej"ujggr"vq"itc¦g"vjg"xgtigu"cpf"ycpfgt"cv"nctig"qp"vjg"ncpf"dgkpi"
fgfkecvgf"cu"jkijyc{u0"
"
Kp"Tower Hamlets LBC v Sherwood47"cv"hktuv"kpuvcpeg"Uqpkc"Rtqwfocp"SE."ukvvkpi"
cu"c"Fgrwv{"Lwfig"qh"vjg"Jkij"Eqwtv."uckf
Cnvjqwij"vjg"uvcvwvqt{"rtguworvkqp"tckugf"d{"42"{gctu"wugt"fqgu"pqv"crrn{"vq"
vjg"Etqyp"*u053"Jkijyc{u"Cev"3;:2+"vjg"EtqypÓu"kpvgpvkqp"vq"fgfkecvg"oc{"
dg"kphgttgf"htqo"nqpi"wugt"cu"kp"vjg"ecug"qh"rtkxcvg"qypgtu"È"K"ugg"pq"tgcuqp"
vq"uwrrqug"vjcv"vjg"kpekfgpvu"qh"Etqyp"qypgtujkr"È"yqwnf"dg"kpeqpukuvgpv"
ykvj"c"fgfkecvkqp"qh"vjg"uwthceg"qh"vjg"tqcfu"cpf"hqqvyc{u"vq"vjg"rwdnke0"
"
"
42" *3::3+"8"Crr"Ecu"8580"
43" *3:6:+"33"SD":99."338"GT"9230"
44" *3:77+"6"G"("D"959."33;"GT"4940"
45"]3;36̲"CE" 55:" Ugg" cnuq" Wild v The Secretary of State for the Environment, Food and Rural
Affairs"]422;̲"GYEC"Ekx"36280"
46"The Times."47"Oc{"3;:90"
47" ]4224̲"GJNT"50"Vjg"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcn"fkf"pqv"eqpukfgt"vjku"curgev London Borough of Tower
Hamlets v Sherwood ]4224̲"GYEC"Ekx"44;."]4224̲"GJNT"350"
424" Crown and Government Land"
"
Qpeg"kphgttgf" fgfkecvkqp" ku" guvcdnkujgf" vjgp" vjg" pgy" yc{" ecp" dg" cffgf" vq" vjg"
fghkpkvkxg"ocr"yjgp"c"nqecn"jkijyc{"cwvjqtkv{"ocmgu"cp"qtfgt"wpfgt"vjg"Yknfnkhg"
cpf"Eqwpvt{ukfg"Cev"3;:3."u"75*5+*d+"yjkej"d{"u"89"crrnkgu"vq"Etqyp"ncpf0"Kh"
vjgtghqtg"c"rwdnke"tkijv"qh"yc{"ku"enckogf"vq"jcxg"eqog"kpvq"gzkuvgpeg"qxgt"Etqyp"
ncpf" c" jkijyc{"cwvjqtkv{" jcu" lwtkufkevkqp" vq" ocmg" c" rtqxkukqpcn"qtfgt"cpf"vjg"
ocvvgt."kh"fkurwvgf."oc{"dg"tghgttgf"vq"cp"kpswkt{"wpfgt"vjg"3;:3"Cev."Uej"370"
3307" UVCVWQT["KPHGTTGF"FGFKECVKQP
Ukpeg"kv"ku"fkhhkewnv"vq"guvcdnkuj"kphgttgf"fgfkecvkqp"d{"nqpi"wug"cv"eqooqp"ncy"vjg"
Tkijvu"qh"Yc{"Cev"3;54"ycu"rcuugf"vq"rtqxkfg"cp"cwvqocvke"rtguworvkqp"qh"
fgfkecvkqp" chvgt" 42" {gctuÓ" wug" d{" vjg" rwdnke" cu" qh" tkijv0" Vjcv" jcu" pqy" dggp"
eqpuqnkfcvgf"kp"vjg"Jkijyc{u"Cev"3;:2."u"530"Vjg"qtkikpu"cpf"rwtrqug"qh"u"53"
ygtg"ugv"qwv"d{"Nqtf"Jqhhocpp"kp"R (Godmanchester Town Council) v Secretary
of State for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs048"
Vjg"3;54"Cev"fkf"pqv"jcxg"c"Etqyp"crrnkecvkqp"ugevkqp0"Kv"ku"pqy"rquukdng"hqt"vjg"
Etqyp"xqnwpvctkn{"vq"citgg"wpfgt"vjg"3;:2"Cev."u"549"vjcv"u"53"ujcnn"crrn{"dwv"
qvjgtykug"kv" yknn" pqv0" Vjwu" kh" vjg" ncpf" chhgevgf" d{" vjg" enckogf" tkijv" qh" yc{" ku"
Etqyp"ncpf"u"53"yknn"pqv"pqtocnn{"dg"wugf0"Vjg"rqukvkqp"ku"oqtg"eqorngz"kh"vjg"
ncpf"jcu"pqv"cnyc{u"dggp"Etqyp"ncpf."qt"jcu"egcugf"vq"dg."qt"kh"vjgtg"ku"c"rtkxcvg"
kpvgtguv"kp"kv0"
Vjgtg"ctg"vjtgg"rquukdng"crrtqcejgu"vq"u"53."gcej"uwrrqtvgf"d{"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcn"
fgekukqpu"yjkej"uggo"vq"tgcej"vjtgg"kpeqpukuvgpv"eqpenwukqpu0"Kp"A-G and Newton
Abbot RDC v Dyer49"Nqtf"Gxgtujgf"OT"uckf
kv"ku"vq"dg"dqtpg"kp"okpf"vjcv"vjg"Cev"qh"3;54"ku"uwduvcpvkcnn{"c"rtqegfwtcn"Cev."
kp"vjg"ugpug"vjcv"kv"ku"fgukipgf."pqv"vq"etgcvg"pgy"tkijvu"qt"pgy"ecwugu"qh"cevkqp."
dwv"tcvjgt"vq"ukornkh{"cpf"tgpfgt"oqtg"gcu{"vjg"ogcpu"qh"ocmkpi"iqqf"enckou"
qh"c"ygnn"guvcdnkujgf"mkpf0"
"
Kp"vjcv"xkgy."ukpeg"vjg"Etqyp"ku"dqwpf"d{"vjg"eqooqp"ncy"twngu."kv"ujqwnf"dg"
dqwpf"d{"vjg"rtqegfwtcn"cogpfogpv0"
D{"eqpvtcuv"kp"Jones v Bates4:"kp"3;5:"Ueqvv"NL"uckf
"
48" ]422:̲"3"CE"4430"
49" ]3;69̲"Ej"89"cv"::0"
4:" ]3;5:̲"4"Cnn"GT"459"cv"4690"
"Highways and Public Rights of Way" 425"
"
vjg"Cev"crrnkgu"vq"cnn"hwvwtg"fkurwvgu"chvgt"3"Lcpwct{"3;56."yjgp"vjg"Cev"ecog"
kpvq"hqteg."cpf"vjgtg"ku"pq"nqpigt"c"eqooqp"ncy"rtqegfwtg"hqt"guvcdnkujkpi"vjg"
rwdnke"tkijv"qwvukfg"vjg"uvcvwvg0"
"
Kp"vjcv"xkgy"vjg"qpn{"tqwvg"yqwnf"dg"wpfgt"yjcv"ku"pqy"u"53"yjkej"fqgu"pqv"dkpf"
vjg"Etqyp0"
Kp"Fairey v Southampton County Council4;"vjg"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcn"vqqm"c"fkhhgtgpv"
xkgy"htqo"dqvj"hqtogt"ecugu0"Fgppkpi"NL"uckf
K"owuv"uc{"cv"qpeg"vjcv"vq"o{"okpf"vjku"Cev"qh"3;54"ku"pqv"c"rtqegfwtcn"Cev0"Kv"
chhgevu"vjg"uwduvcpvkxg"ncy"kp"vjg"hqnnqykpi"tgurgevugu"c"pgy"uvcvwvqt{"
tkijv"vq"c"jkijyc{"d{"rtguetkrvkqp"kp"cffkvkqp"vq"vjg"qnf"tkijv"d{"fgfkecvkqp0"
"
Dktmgvv"NL"uckf
vjg"pgy"rtqegfwtg"wpfgt"vjg"Cev"ku"cp"cffkvkqpcn"ogvjqf"qh"guvcdnkujkpi"vjg"
fgfkecvkqp"qh"jkijyc{u."cpf"fqgu"pqv"cdqnkuj"qt"cnvgt"vjg"gzkuvkpi"ogvjqfu052"
"
Fgurkvg"vjg"igpgtcn"twng"vjcv"vjg"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcn"ku"dqwpf"d{"kvu" rtgxkqwu"
fgekukqpu."vjg"vjktf"crrtqcej"ku"pqy"eqpukfgtgf"vq"dg"vjg"eqttgev"qpg0"
Kp"3;54"rtqeggfkpiu"cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp"ygtg"uwdlgev"vq"fkhhgtgpv"twngu"htqo"vjqug"
chhgevkpi"rtkxcvg"rgtuqpu"cpf"qpn{"dgecog"cuukokncvgf"kp"vjg"Etqyp"Rtqeggfkpiu"
Cev"3;690"Gxgp"kh"vjg"tghqtou"kp"vjg"3;54"Cev"jcf"dggp"uwduvcpvkcnn{"rtqegfwtcn."
kv"ku"wpnkmgn{"vjcv"cv"vjg"vkog"Rctnkcogpv"kpvgpfgf"vjgo"vq"crrn{"vq"Etqyp"ncpf0"
Ncvgt"lwfkekcn"tgoctmu"ceegrv"vjg"xkgy"vjcv"u"53"fqgu"pqv"crrn{"vq"Etqyp"ncpf0"Cu"
ogpvkqpgf"kp"3306."kp"Tower Hamlets LBC v Sherwood53"cv"hktuv"kpuvcpeg"Uqpkc"
Rtqwfocp"SE."ukvvkpi"cu"c"Fgrwv{"Lwfig"qh"vjg"Jkij"Eqwtv."uckf<"
È"vjg" uvcvwvqt{" rtguworvkqp" tckugf" d{" 42" {gctu" wugt" fqgu" pqv" crrn{" vq" vjg"
Etqyp"*u053"Jkijyc{u"Cev"3;:2+"È"
"
Kv"ku"jqygxgt"korqtvcpv"vq"fkuvkpiwkuj"dgvyggp"vjg"tkijvu"qh"vjg"Etqyp"cpf"tkijvu"
chhgevkpi"Etqyp"ncpf0"
Cnvjqwij"lwfkekcn"fgekukqpu"ctg"ncemkpi"vjgtg"jcxg"dggp"ugxgtcn"kpswktkgu"kp"yjkej"
Kpurgevqtu"jcxg"jcf"vq"fgekfg"yjgvjgt"c"Etqyp"dqf{"ujqwnf"dg"vtgcvgf"cu"jcxkpi"
fgfkecvgf"c" yc{" wpfgt" u" 53*9C+" cpf" *9D+0" Hqt" gzcorng"qpg" cv" Ejkvvngjcojqnv""
"
4;" ]3;78̲"4"SD"65;0"
52" Ugg"cnuq"Jaques v Secretary of State for the Environment"]3;;7̲"LRN"32530"
53" ]4224̲"GJNT"50
426" Crown and Government Land"
"
kp" Fgxqp" kp" 3;;854" eqpegtpgf" c" enckogf" dtkfngyc{" cetquu" uqog" Hqtguvt{"
Eqookuukqp"ncpf"xguvgf"kp"vjg"Okpkuvgt"qh"Citkewnvwtg."Hkujgtkgu"cpf"Hqqf0"Vjg"
Kpurgevqt"eqpenwfgf"vjcv."ukpeg"vjg"okpkuvgt"jcf"rqygt"wpfgt"vjg"Hqtguvt{"Cev"
3;89."u"5;*5+*d+"vq"fgfkecvg"c"yc{."jg"ujqwnf"dg"tgictfgf"cu"jcxkpi"fqpg"uq"wpfgt"
u"53"cpf"vjgtghqtg"vjg"qtfgt"ycu"eqphktogf0"Wphqtvwpcvgn{"vjku"okuugu"vjg"rqkpv0"
Cu"fkuewuugf"kp"3305"cpf"3306"vjg"Etqyp"ku"cdng"vq"fgfkecvg"c"yc{"gkvjgt"gzrtguun{"
d{"citggogpv"qt"d{"eqooqp"ncy"kphgtgpeg0"Vjg"swguvkqp"ku"yjgvjgt"u"53"ecp"dg"
crrnkgf"vq"ncpf"kp"yjkej"vjgtg"ku"qt"jcu"dggp"c"Etqyp"kpvgtguv0"Kp"vjg"cdugpeg"qh"
uwej"cp"citggogpv."vjg"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjg"Jkijyc{u"Cev"3;:2"fq"pqv"crrn{"vq"vjg"
Etqyp0"
3308" RTKXCVG"KPVGTGUVU"CPF"KPHGTTGF"
FGFKECVKQP
Kh"vjg"Etqyp"jcu"ngv"vjg"ncpf"qxgt"yjkej"c"tkijv"qh"yc{"ku"enckogf"vq"c"rtkxcvg"
vgpcpv"qt"kh"kv"qeewrkgu"wpfgt"c"ngcug"htqo"c"rtkxcvg"ncpfnqtf"vjgp"vjg"ncpf"ku"dqvj"
Etqyp"cpf"rtkxcvg0"Vjg"Jkijyc{u"Cev"3;:2"jcu"pq"fghkpkvkqp"qh"Etqyp"qt"rtkxcvg"
kpvgtguvu"uwej"cu"ku"hqwpf"kp"uqog"qvjgt"Cevu0"Kpuvgcf"u"549*3+"ku"cp"gzvgpukqp"
ugevkqp" yjkej" rgtokvu" vjg" CevÓu" rtqxkukqpu" vq" dg" crrnkgf." yjgtg" kv" yqwnf" pqv"
qvjgtykug"fq"uq."vq"ncpf
dgnqpikpi"vq"Jgt"Oclguv{"kp"tkijv"qh"vjg"Etqyp"qt"qh"vjg"Fwej{"qh"Ncpecuvgt."
qt" dgnqpikpi" vq" vjg" Fwej{" qh" Eqtpycnn." qt" dgnqpikpi" vq" c" iqxgtpogpv"
fgrctvogpv."qt"jgnf"kp"vtwuv"hqt"Jgt"Oclguv{"hqt"vjg"rwtrqugu"qh"c"iqxgtpogpv"
fgrctvogpv0"
"
Yjgvjgt" ncpf" ku" tgictfgf" cu" ÒdgnqpikpiÓ" owuv" dg" fgvgtokpgf" d{" vjg"igpgtcn""
ncy0"Vjg"koowpkv{"ku"in rem0"Dgecwug"c"rkgeg"qh"ncpf"gkvjgt"ku"qt"ku"pqv"uwdlgev"vq"
rwdnke"tkijvu" *cpf" fgfkecvkqp" yqwnf" dg" hqt" gxgt+." cpf" c" yc{" ecp" pqv" dg" rctvn{"
fgfkecvgf" cpf" rctvn{" pqv." vjgp." gxgp" kh" vjgtg"ku" c" rtkxcvg" kpvgtguv" kp" vjg" ncpf"
*yjgvjgt"vjg"Etqyp"ku"ncpfnqtf"qt"vgpcpv"qh"kv+"yjkej"okijv"dg"uwdlgev"vq"kphgttgf"
uvcvwvqt{" fgfkecvkqp." c" tkijv" qh" yc{" ecp" pqv" dg" etgcvgf" ykvjqwv"vjg"EtqypÓu"
kphgttgf" fgfkecvkqp0" Pq" fqwdv" vjg"Etqyp" eqwnf" citgg" gkvjgt" hqt" eqooqp" ncy"
rwtrqugu"qt"wpfgt"u"5490"Vjg"jqnfgt"qh"vjg"rtkxcvg"kpvgtguv"eqwnf"pqv"qdlgev"gkvjgt"
*kh"vgpcpv+"qp"vjg"itqwpfu"qh"fgtqicvkqp"htqo"itcpv55"qt"*kh"ncpfnqtf+"qp"vjg"dcuku"
qh"cnkgpcvkqp0"
"
54" HRU1M332219194."43"Oc{"3;;80"
55"Molton Builders Ltd v Westminster City Council and the Crown Estate Commissioners *3;97+"52"
R"("ET"3:40"
"Highways and Public Rights of Way" 427"
"
330803" Rtkxcvg"ngcugjqnfu"
Vjg"hktuv"ukvwcvkqp"ku"yjgtg"vjg"Etqyp"jcu"vjg"htggjqnf"cpf"jcu"itcpvgf"c"ngcug"qh"
vjg"ncpf0"Yjgtg"c"rtkxcvg"qypgt"jcu"ngv"ncpf"vq"c"rtkxcvg"vgpcpv."cnvjqwij"vjg"vgpcpv"
ku"kp"rquuguukqp."uwej"rquuguukqp"fqgu"pqv"cwvjqtkug"fgfkecvkqp"qh"c"yc{"ykvjqwv"
vjg" ncpfnqtfÓu" eqpugpv" qt" cv" ngcuv" ceswkguegpeg0" ÒKh" rtqrgtv{" ku" wpfgt" ngcug." qh"
eqwtug."vjgtg"ecp"dg"pq"fgfkecvkqp"d{"vjg"nguugg"vq"dkpf"vjg"htggjqnfÓ056"Vjku"twng"
ecp"dg"fkurncegf."hqt"kpuvcpeg"yjgtg"vjgtg"jcu"dggp"c"uweeguukqp"qh"vgpcpekgu"uq"
vjcv"vjg"ncpfnqtf"okijv"jcxg"dggp"cdng"vq"uvqr"rwdnke"ceeguu"dgvyggp"vjg"gpf"qh"
qpg"cpf"vjg"uvctv"qh"cpqvjgt57"cpf"kpvgpvkqp"vq"fgfkecvg"oc{"dg"korwvgf"wpfgt"u"
530" Kp" Rowley v Secretary of State for Transport, Local Government and the
Regions58" *yjkej"fkf" pqv" kpxqnxg" vjg" Etqyp+" vjg" gxkfgpeg" ujqygf" rwdnke" wug"
fwtkpi"c" vgpcpe{" cpf" vjcv" vjg" ncpfnqtf" ycu" hcoknkct" ykvj" vjg" ukvwcvkqp" cpf" vjg"
crrnkecvkqp"vq"cff"vjg"yc{"vq"vjg"fghkpkvkxg"ocr"ycu"wrjgnf0"Gnkcu"L"uckf"qh"vjg"
kpvgpvkqp"vq"fgfkecvg"wpfgt"u"53"vjcv<59"
C"ukoknct"ctiwogpv"ycu"cfxcpegf"kp"Smith v Thomas5:"cpf"tglgevgf."vjg"eqwtv"
crrctgpvn{"vcmkpi"vjg"xkgy"vjcv"kh"kv"ku"cnngigf"vjcv"vjg"htggjqnfgt"jcu"c"fkhhgtgpv"
kpvgpvkqp"vq"vjg"vgpcpv."vjgtg"ujqwnf"cv"ngcuv"dg"gxkfgpeg"guvcdnkujkpi"vjcv
Nqtf"Gxgtujgf"cv"r06650"
"
Cevwcn" mpqyngfig" qt" kpvgpvkqp" qh" vjg" Etqyp" *vjtqwij" kvu" ocpcigtu+" yqwnf"
pqtocnn{" pggf" vq" dg"rtqxgf05;" Jkijyc{u" ctg" rwdnke" tkijvu" cpf" jkuvqtkecnn{" vjg"
Etqyp"jcf"c"fwv{"vq"rtqvgev"vjgo"dwv"vjcv"fqgu"pqv"korn{"cp{"fwv{"vq"etgcvg"pgy"
qpgu0"Vjg"hqtogt"tgurqpukdknkv{"qh"vjg"Etqyp"hqt"jkijyc{u"pqy"tguvu"ykvj"vjg"
jkijyc{"cwvjqtkv{0"Cp"crrtqrtkcvg"Etqyp"cwvjqtkv{"yqwnf"pqv"qhvgp"dg"vcmgp"vq"
dg"cyctg"qh"cp{"vqngtcpeg"d{"c"vgpcpv"qh"rwdnke"wug"qh"c"yc{"uq"cu"vq"chhnkev"vjg"
Etqyp"ykvj"pqvkeg0"
330804" Etqyp"ngcugjqnfu"cpf"qvjgt"tkijvu"
Oqtg"eqpvgpvkqwu"kuuwgu"ctkug"yjgtg"kv"ku"vjg"Etqyp"kpvgtguv"yjkej"ku"ngcugjqnf0"
C"ngcug"etgcvgu"c"ngicn"guvcvg"kp"ncpf"yjkej"dgnqpiu"vq"kvu"qypgt0"Kp"uwej"c"ecug"
"
56"R v East Mark Inhabitants"*3:6:+"33"SD":99"cv"::5."338"GT"923"cv"926."rgt"Rcvvguqp"L0"
57"R v Barr"*3:36+"6"Ecor"38."393"GT"8="Davies v Stephens"*3:58+"9"E"("R"792."395"GT"470"
58" ]4224̲"GYJE"3262"*Cfokp+0"
59" ]4224̲"GYJE"3262"*Cfokp+"cv"]62̲0"
5:" *CwvjqtÓu"hqqvpqvg+"Recte"Lewis v Thomas"]3;72̲"3"MD"65:0"
5;" Rncppkpi"Kpurgevqtcvg."Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981"Î"Definitive Map Orders: Consistency
Guidelines"*tgxkugf"49"Lcpwct{"4244+"cv"rctcu"704074Î7040790"
428" Crown and Government Land"
"
vjg"kuuwgu"ctg"yjgvjgt"vjg"ncpf"ku"vq"dg"tgictfgf"cu"dgnqpikpi"vq"vjg"Etqyp"dqf{"
cpf"cnuq"yjgvjgt"Etqyp"koowpkv{"gzvgpfu"vq"dgpghkv"vjg"rtkxcvg"htggjqnfgt0"
Vjg"rqkpv"ycu"eqpukfgtgf."cnvjqwij"kpeqttgevn{."kp"cp"kpswkt{"kp"4232"cv"Ogvjng{"
kp"Nggfu062"Vjg"Pcvkqpcn"Eqcn"Dqctf"jgnf"c"ngcug"wpvkn"3;93"yjgp"okpkpi"egcugf"
cpf"vjg"ncpf"ycu"eqorwnuqtkn{"rwtejcugf"d{"vjg"Yguv"[qtmujktg"Eqwpv{"Eqwpekn0"
Vjg"Dqctf"ycu"pqv"c"Etqyp"dqf{63"dwv"vjg"ecug"rtqeggfgf"qp"vjg"okuvcmgp"dcuku"
vjcv"kv"jcf"dggp0"Vjg"Kpurgevqt"uckf<64"
Yjknuv"kv"ycu"ctiwgf"vjcv"vjg"Etqyp"gzgorvkqp"fkf"pqv"crrn{"vq"ngcugjqnf"ncpf."
cu"vjg"etgcvkqp"qh"c"tkijv"qh"yc{"yqwnf"cfxgtugn{"chhgev"vjg"EtqypÓu"ngcugjqnf"
kpvgtguv" K" eqpukfgt" vjcv" vjg" Etqyp" gzgorvkqp" yqwnf" gpeqorcuu" dqvj" ncpf"
dgnqpikpi"vq"cpf"ngcugf"d{"vjg"Etqyp0"Kv"hqnnqyu"vjcv"cu"vjg"ncpf"cv"Ogvjng{"
Lwpevkqp"ycu"ngcugf"vq"vjg"Pcvkqpcn"Eqcn"Dqctf"htqo"3;69"vq"3;93"wug"d{"vjg"
rwdnke"qh"rcvju"cpf"yc{u"qxgt"vjcv"ncpf"fwtkpi"vjcv"rgtkqf"ku"kpcfokuukdng"ykvj"
tgictf"vq"c"encko"hqt"rtguwogf"fgfkecvkqp"vjtqwij"nqpi"wug0"
"
Jg"cnuq"uckf"vjcv"kp"vjg"ecug"qh"Rowley v SSETR and Shropshire County Council<65"
vjg"eqwtv"jgnf"vjcv"vjg"cevkqpu"qh"vjg"vgpcpv"eqwnf"dkpf"vjg"htggjqnfgt"qp"vjg"
kuuwg"qh"fgfkecvkqp="kh"fggogf"fgfkecvkqp"ecppqv"dg"jgnf"cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp"cu"
c"tguwnv"qh"vjg"ngcug."kv"eqwnf"pqv"dg"jgnf"cickpuv"vjg"htggjqnfgt"fwtkpi"vjg"ucog"
rgtkqf0"
"
Cp" kpswkt{" cv" Whhewnog" kp" Fgxqp66" kpxqnxgf" cp" crrnkecvkqp" vq" cogpf" vjg"
fghkpkvkxg"tkijvu"qh"yc{"ocr"vq"ujqy"c"u"53"yc{"qxgt"ncpf"kp"c"ngcug"jgnf"d{"vjg"
Ugetgvct{"qh"Uvcvg"hqt"vjg"Gpxktqpogpv."Hctokpi"cpf"Twtcn"Chhcktu"qp"dgjcnh"qh"
vjg"Hqtguvt{"Eqookuukqp0"Vjg"crrnkecpv"ctiwgf"vjcv"u"53"ku"ckogf"cv"c"tkijv"qxgt"
ncpf"cu"c"rj{ukecn"vcpikdng"uwduvcpeg"cpf"vjcv"c"ngcug"ycu"ogtgn{"cp"kpeqtrqtgcn"
kpvgtguv0"Vjg"Kpurgevqt"fgekfgf"vjcv"kv"ycu"cp"kpvgtguv"kp"ncpf"cpf"vjgtghqtg"hqt"vjg"
rwtrqugu"qh"u"53"kv"ycu"ncpf"dgnqpikpi"vq"c"iqxgtpogpv"fgrctvogpv0"Vjg"crrnkecpv"
cnuq"uqwijv"vq"ctiwg"vjcv"gxgp"vjqwij"vjg"Etqyp"nguugg"ycu"koowpg"htqo"u"53."
pgxgtvjgnguu"vjg"rtkxcvg"htggjqnfgt"ujqwnf"dg"vtgcvgf"cu"jcxkpi"fgfkecvgf"vjg"ncpf0"
Vjg"Kpurgevqt" cnuq" tglgevgf" vjku" ctiwogpv" qp" vjg" dcuku" vjcv" vjg" ngcug" etgcvgf" c"
itgcvgt" kpvgtguv" vjcp" vjcv" qh" tgoqvg" tgxgtukqp" qh" vjg" ncpfnqtf0" Jqygxgt." vjg"
tgurgevkxg"xcnwgu"qh"vjg"kpvgtguvu"yqwnf"pqv"uggo"tgngxcpv0"Uwrrqug"fwtkpi"vjg""
"
62" Vjg"Nggfu"Ekv{"Eqwpekn"*Hqqvrcvju"cv"Ogvjng{"Lwpevkqp."Ogvjng{."Tqvjygnn"Nggfu+"Oqfkhkecvkqp"
Qtfgt."422;"HRU1P694219142"qh"9"Ugrvgodgt"42320"
63"Tamlin v Hannaford"]3;72̲" 3" MD" 3:." ]3;6;̲" 4" Cnn" GT" 549." EC0" Ugg" cnuq" vjg" Eqcn" Kpfwuvt{"
Pcvkqpcnkucvkqp"Cev"3;68."u"690"
64" Vjg"Nggfu"Ekv{"Eqwpekn"*Hqqvrcvju"cv"Ogvjng{"Lwpevkqp."Ogvjng{."Tqvjygnn"Nggfu+"Oqfkhkecvkqp"
Qtfgt."422;"HRU1P694219142"qh"9"Ugrvgodgt"4232"cv"rctcu"84Î860"
65" ]4224̲"GYJE"3262"*Cfokp+"]4225̲"4"R"("ET"490"
66" HRU1L3377191;2"qh"44"Lwn{"42330"
"Highways and Public Rights of Way" 429"
"
42/{gct"rgtkqf"vjg"Etqyp"vqqm"cp"cppwcn"vgpcpe{."vjcv"yqwnf"uvknn"uggo"vq"rtgxgpv"
u"53"crrn{kpi"ukpeg"gxgp"c"ujqtv"vgpcpe{"etgcvgu"c"ngicn"guvcvg"kp"vjg"ncpf0"
Vjg"nqike"crrnkgu"kh"vjgtg"ku"cp{"Etqyp"guvcvg"kp"vjg"ncpf."gkvjgt"ngicn"qt"gswkvcdng."
cpf"yjgvjgt"qt"pqv"kv"eqphgtu"rj{ukecn"rquuguukqp0"C"nguugt"Etqyp"kpvgtguv."uwej"
cu"c"ejctig"qt"cp"gcugogpv"qh"yc{"qt"c"nkegpeg"vq"wug"vjg"ncpf."yqwnf"pqv"uggo"vq"
dg"uwhhkekgpv"vq"cvvtcev"Etqyp"koowpkv{"dwv"kp"Rothschild v Buckinghamshire
County Council67yjgp" ncpf" ycu" uwdlgev" vq" yctvkog" tgswkukvkqpkpi." rwdnke"wug"
fwtkpi"vjcv"vkog"eqwnf"pqv"dg"kpxqmgf"kp"c"encko"vq"cp"kphgttgf"fgfkecvkqp"qh"c"
tkijv"qh"yc{0"
330805" Ceswktgf"ncpf"
Kh"vjg"Etqyp"ceswktgu"ncpf"qxgt"yjkej"cp"gzkuvkpi"rwdnke"tkijv"qh"yc{"twpu"vjgp"
vjg"tkijv"yknn"pqv"dg"chhgevgf068"Yjgtg"vjg"ceswkukvkqp"ku"wpfgt"eqorwnuqt{"rqygtu"
vjgp"kv"oc{"dg"rquukdng"vq"fkxgtv"qt"gzvkpiwkuj"c"rcvj69"dwv"kp"vjg"cdugpeg"qh"uwej"
rqygtu"cp{"jkijyc{"yknn"tgockp0"Ceeqtfkpin{"kh"dghqtg"vjg"Etqyp"rwtejcug."c"
rcvj"jcf"cntgcf{"dggp"wugf"d{"vjg"rwdnke"hqt"42"{gctu"kp"ektewouvcpegu"uwhhkekgpv"
vq"guvcdnkuj"eqooqp"ncy"fgfkecvkqp"vjgp."yjgp"vjg"tgngxcpv"hcevu"eqog"vq"nkijv."
cp"crrnkecvkqp"oc{"dg"ocfg"wpfgt"vjg"Yknfnkhg"cpf"Eqwpvt{ukfg"Cev"3;:3."u"75"
gxgp"vjqwij"vjg"ncpf"ku"Etqyp"ncpf"cv"vjg"vkog0"
Kp" cp" kpswkt{" kp" 4229" kpvq" enckogf" hqqvrcvju"vjtqwij" c" yqqf" cv" Uyct ncpf" kp"
Pqtvjwodgtncpf.6:"vjg"Hqtguvt{"Eqookuukqp"ctiwgf"vjcv."cu"vjg"Etqyp"jcf"
ceswktgf"vjg"htggjqnf"qh"Uyctncpf"Yqqf"kp"3;5:."htqo"vjgp"qp"kv"ycu"gzgorv"
htqo"u"530"Vjg"Kpurgevqt"citggf0"Jqygxgt"vjg"crrnkecpvu"hqt"vjg"tgikuvtcvkqp"qh"
vjg"yc{"cnuq"enckogf"vjcv"vjgtg"ycu"rwdnke"wug"dghqtg"vjg"Etqyp"rwtejcug0"Vjg"
Kpurgevqt" eqpukfgtgf" vjg"wugt" gxkfgpeg" hqt" vjg" rgtkqf" 3;3:" vq" 3;5:" ikxgp" d{"
rgqrng"yjq"jcf"dggp"ejknftgp"cv"vjg"vkog0"Jg"hqwpf"vjcv"kv"ycu"kpuwhhkekgpv"vq"tckug"
vjg"rtguworvkqp"qh"fgfkecvkqp"dwv"kh"kv"jcf"dggp"uwhhkekgpv"vjg"yc{"eqwnf"jcxg"
dggp"eqphktogf0"
330806" Chvgt"fkurqucn"qh"ncpf"
C"hwtvjgt"kuuwg"ku"yjgvjgt"u"53"uvknn"crrnkgu"yjgtg."cnvjqwij"vjg"ncpf"dgnqpigf"vq"
vjg"Etqyp"cv"uqog"vkog"fwtkpi"vjg"42/{gct"rgtkqf."Etqyp"qypgtujkr"jcu"egcugf"
"
67" *3;79+"343"LR"77:."392"Estates Gazette"950"
68"Shonleigh Nominees Ltd v Attorney General (At the Relation of Hampshire CC)"]3;96̲"3"YNT"
5270"
69" Vjg"Ceswkukvkqp"qh"Ncpf"Cev"3;:3."u"540"
6:" Vjg"Pqtvjwodgtncpf"Eqwpv{"Eqwpekn"*Rwdnke"Tkijvu"qh"Yc{+"Oqfkhkecvkqp"Qtfgt"*pq"45+"4227"
HRU1T4;221915:"qh"49"Lwpg"42290"
42:" Crown and Government Land"
"
d{"vjg"vkog"vjg"yc{"ku"dtqwijv"kpvq"swguvkqp0"Vjku"ecp"jcrrgp"kh"vjg"Etqyp"jcu"
uqnf"vjg"ncpf."qt"kh"kv"jcu"dgeqog"xguvgf"kp"c"rtkxcvg"qypgt"qp"c"uvcvwvqt{"
tgqticpkucvkqp."qt"kh"c"ngcug"jcu"dggp"uwttgpfgtgf"qt"jcu"gzrktgf0"
Cp"kpswkt{"kp"3;;9"kpxqnxgf"c"Hqtguvt{"Eqookuukqp"ngcug"hqt";;;" {gctu" htqo"
3;78"cv"Yqqdwtp"kp"Dwemkpijcoujktg"kp"vjg"pcog"qh"vjg"Okpkuvgt"qh"Citkewnvwtg."
Hkujgtkgu"cpf"Hqqf06;"Kp"3;:8"vjg"htggjqnfgt"nqfigf"c"uvcvgogpv"wpfgt"u"53*8+"cpf"
vjgtgd{" dtqwijv" vjg" yc{"kpvq" swguvkqp0"Kp"3;;4"vjg"ngcug"ycu"cuukipgf" vq" vjg"
Yqqdwtp"Rctkuj"Eqwpekn"uq"vjg"Etqyp"egcugf"vq"jqnf"cp"kpvgtguv0" Kp" 3;;7" c"
oqfkhkecvkqp"qtfgt" ycu" ocfg" vq" cff" vjtgg" hqqvrcvju" vq" vjg" fghkpkvkxg" ocr" cpf"
vjgtg"ycu"uvtqpi"wugt"gxkfgpeg"hqt"42"{gctu"rtkqt"vq"3;:80"Vjg"htggjqnfgt"qdlgevgf"
qp"vjg"itqwpfu"vjcv"htqo"3;78"vq"3;;4"vjg"ncpf"jcf"dggp"Etqyp"ncpf"vq"yjkej"u"
53"fkf"pqv"crrn{0"Vjg"Kpurgevqt"eqpukfgtgf"vjg"ecugu"cpf"eqpenwfgf"vjcv"u"53"ycu"
ockpn{"rtqegfwtcn0"Jg"uckf"vjcv."ÒCnvjqwij"vjg"rtqegfwtg"qh"u053"fqgu"pqv"cxckn"
cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp"vjcv"fqgu"pqv"kvugnh"rtgxgpv"vkog"twppkpi"hqt"vjg"rwtrqugu"qh"
u053"cu"vq"ncpfÓ0"Vjg"hcev"qh"ncpf"dgnqpikpi"vq"vjg"Etqyp"Òfqgu"pqv"coqwpv"vq"cp"
kpvgttwrvkqp"qh"vjg"42/{gct"rgtkqf"kp"u053*3+"dwv"ogtgn{"rtgxgpvu"c"rtguworvkqp"qh"
fgfkecvkqp" dgkpi" gphqtegf" cickpuv" vjg" EtqypÓ0" Jg" vjgtghqtg" eqphktogf" vjg"
rtqxkukqpcn"qtfgt0"
C" fkhhgtgpv" xkgy" ycu" vcmgp" kp" vjg" Ogvjng{" ecug072"Cnvjqwij"vjgtg"jcf"dggp""
42"{gctuÓ"wug."vjg"ncpf"ycu"vq"dg"tgictfgf"cu"Etqyp"ncpf"fwtkpi"rctv"qh"vjcv"vkog"
cpf"cu"vjgtg"jcf"pqv"dggp"42"{gctu"ukpeg"vjg"Etqyp"kpvgtguv"gpfgf."vjg"qtfgt"ycu"
pqv"eqphktogf0"
Cp"crrgcn"ycu"cnnqygf"cickpuv"c"fgekukqp"d{"Pqvvkpijcoujktg"Eqwpv{"Eqwpekn"
pqv"vq"ocmg"cp"qtfgt"kp"tgncvkqp"vq"ncpf"kp"vjg"rctkuj"qh"Ocpuhkgnf"Yqqfjqwug73"
yjgtg"vjg"ncpf"jcf"dggp"kp"ngcug"vq"vjg"Hqtguvt{"Eqookuukqp"hqt";;;"{gctu"htqo"
3;74"cpf"vjg"rcvj"ycu"cnqpi"c"vtcem"etgcvgf"d{"vjg"Eqookuukqp0"Vjg"EqwpeknÓu"
tghwucn"vq"ocmg"cp"qtfgt"jcf"dggp"dcugf"qp"vjg"ncem"qh"eqpugpv"wpfgt"u"549"dwv"
vjg"kpurgevqt"fkf"pqv"tgictf"vjcv"cu"hcvcn0"Jg"eqpukfgtgf"vjcv"cu"vjg"ncpfnqtf"jcf"
tgugtxgf" vjg" urqtvkpi" tkijvu." vjg" Eqookuukqp" ycu" pqv" kp" gzenwukxg" rquuguukqp""
cpf"vjgtghqtg"vjg"ncpfqypgt"eqwnf"dg"rtguwogf"vq"jcxg"fgfkecvgf"vjg"ncpf0"Vjku"
uggou"vq"fkutgictf"vjg";;;/{gct"ngcug"cu"c"ngicn"guvcvg0"Jqygxgt"jg"cnuq"tghgttgf"
kp"jku"fgekukqp"vq"eqooqp"ncy"fgfkecvkqp"cpf"vjg"fgekukqp"oc{"dg"lwuvkhkgf"qp"
vjcv"itqwpf0"
"
6;" Vjg"Dwemkpijcoujktg"Eqwpv{"Eqwpekn"*Rctkuj"qh"Yqqdwtp+"Fghkpkvkxg"Ocr"Oqfkhkecvkqp"Qtfgt"
3;;7"HRU1C26221916;"qh"9"Oc{"3;;90"
72"Nggfu" Ekv{" Eqwpekn" *Hqqvrcvju" cv" Ogvjng{" Lwpevkqp." Ogvjng{." Tqvjygnn" Nggfu+" Oqfkhkecvkqp"
Qtfgt."422;"HRU1P694219142"qh"9"Ugrvgodgt"42320"
73"Parkhouse v Nottinghamshire County Council."HRU1N5277136C136"fgekukqp"fcvgf";"Octej"42380"
"Highways and Public Rights of Way" 42;"
"
Kv"oc{"cnuq"dg"tgngxcpv"yjgvjgt"vjg"Etqyp"qypgtujkr"uwdukuvgf"cv"vjg"dgikppkpi"
qh"vjg"rwdnke"wug"qt"cv"vjg"fcvg"vjcv"ycu"ejcnngpigf0"Kp"Barlow v Wigan
Metropolitan Borough Council74"Dgcp"NL"uckf"kp"tgncvkqp"vq"cp"kphgttgf"fgfkecvkqp"
cv"eqooqp"ncy
Vjg"ghhgev"ku"vjcv"vjg"cev"qh"fgfkecvkqp"Î"qpg"vjkpmu"qh"c"j{rqvjgvkecn"tkddqp/
ewvvkpi" egtgoqp{."qt" cv" ngcuv" vjg" gzgewvkqp" qh" c" fggf" Î" ku" fggogf" vq" jcxg"
qeewttgf"cv"vjg"dgikppkpi"qh"vjg"rgtkqf"qh"eqpvkpwqwu"wugt."pqv"cv"vjg"gpf"qh"kv0"
"
D{" eqpvtcuv" u" 53*4+" rtqxkfgu" vjcv" kp" tgncvkqp" vq" kphgttgf" fgfkecvkqp" wpfgt"vjcv"
ugevkqp
Vjg"rgtkqf"qh"42"{gctu"tghgttgf"vq"kp"uwdugevkqp"*3+"cdqxg"ku"vq"dg"ecnewncvgf"
tgvtqurgevkxgn{"htqo"vjg"fcvg"yjgp"vjg"tkijv"qh"vjg"rwdnke"vq"wug"vjg"yc{"ku"
dtqwijv"kpvq"swguvkqp0"
"
Cv"eqooqp"ncy."qpeg"vjg"fgfkecvkqp"jcu"qeewttgf."vjg"yc{"fqgu"pqv"pggf"vq"dg"
qhhkekcnn{"tgeqipkugf"d{"cp{"hqtocn"cfqrvkqp"qt"gpvt{"qp"cp"qhhkekcn"tgeqtf0"Vjg"
qtfgt"rtqegfwtg"wpfgt"vjg"Yknfnkhg"cpf"Eqwpvt{ukfg"Cev"3;:3."u"75"fqgu"pqv"etgcvg"
c"pgy"yc{"dwv"ukorn{"tgeqipkugu"cp"gzkuvkpi"uvcvg"qh"chhcktu0"Hqt"u"53"crrnkecvkqpu"
vjg"u"75"gxgpv"ku"vjg"gzrktcvkqp"qh"vjg"tgngxcpv"rgtkqf"qt"vjg"fcvg"qh"crrnkecvkqp"
wpfgt"u"53*9D+"uq"vjcv"vjg"vguv"ku"yjgvjgt"vjg"ncpf"ku"Etqyp"ncpf"cv"vjg"fcvg"vjg"
yc{"ku"dtqwijv"kpvq"swguvkqp"wpfgt"u"53*4+0"Kh"kv"ku"vjgp."kp"vjg"cdugpeg"qh"Etqyp"
eqpugpv."u"53"ecp"pqv"crrn{"cpf"cp{"u"75"crrnkecvkqp"yknn"hckn0"Kh"kv"ku"pqv"vjgp."
rtqxkfgf"vjg"eqpfkvkqpu"kp"u"53"ctg"ucvkuhkgf."kv"fqgu"pqv"ocvvgt"yjgvjgt"vjg"ncpf"
jcf"gctnkgt"dggp"Etqyp"ncpf"hqt"rctv"qh"vjg"42/{gct"rgtkqf0"Vjg"cnvgtpcvkxg"xkgy"
yqwnf"ngcf"vq"vjg"wptgcuqpcdng"tguwnv"vjcv."ukpeg"qpeg"vjg"ncpf"egcugf"vq"dgnqpi"
vq"vjg"Etqyp"u"549"eqwnf"pq"nqpigt"dg"wugf"cpf"uq"u"53"eqwnf"pqv"crrn{"vq"vjcv"
ncpf"wpvkn"42"{gctu"chvgt"vjg"Etqyp"fkurqucn0"
3309" KPEQPUKUVGPE["YKVJ"RWDNKE"HWPEVKQP"
Kphgttgf"Etqyp"fgfkecvkqp"cv"eqooqp"ncy"oc{"dg"pgicvkxgf"kh"kv"ku"kpeqpukuvgpv"
ykvj"c"rwdnke"fwv{0"Kp"Hunwick v Essex Rivers Catchment Board75"vjg"rnckpvkhh"
ycu"ycnmkpi"cnqpi"c"hqqvrcvj"qp"vqr"qh"cp"cpekgpv"ugc"ycnn"cpf"ycu"kplwtgf"yjgp"
kv"eqnncrugf0"Vjg"Dqctf"ygtg"tgurqpukdng"hqt"ugc"fghgpegu"dwv"vjg"ycnn"oc{"jcxg"
"
"
74" ]4242̲"GYEC"Ekx"8;8."]4243̲"SD"44;"cv"]88̲0"
75" ]3;74̲"3"Cnn"GT"9870"
432" Crown and Government Land"
"
dggp"xguvgf"kp"vjg"Etqyp"cnvjqwij"kv"ycu"pqv"pgeguuct{"vq"fgekfg"vjcv0"Qpg"kuuwg"
ycu"yjgvjgt"vjg"rcvj"ycu"c"rwdnke"hqqvrcvj0"Etqqo/Lqjpuqp"L"uckf<76"
K"vjkpm"kv"ku"swkvg"rnckp"vjcv"vjg"hqqvrcvj"qp"vjg"vqr"qh"vjg"ugc"ycnn"jcu"dggp"wugf"
d{"vjg"rwdnke"hqt"igpgtcvkqpu."cpf."kh"uq."vjg"ektewouvcpeg"vjcv"vjcv"wugt"jcu"
eqpvkpwgf."crrctgpvn{"ykvjqwv"qdlgevkqp"qt"cp{"kpeqpxgpkgpeg"qt"kpvgthgtgpeg"
ykvj"vjg"fwv{"vq"ockpvckp"vjg"ugc"ycnn."ocmgu"og"vjkpm"vjcv"vjg"wug"d{"vjg"rwdnke"
qh"vjg"hqqvrcvj"ku"pqv"kpeqorcvkdng"ykvj"yjcv"ycu"rtguetkdgf"d{"vjg"ncy"qp"
yjqogxgt"vjg"fwv{"ycu"vq"ockpvckp"vjg"ugc"ycnn0"Vjgtghqtg."K"jcxg"eqog"vq"vjg"
eqpenwukqp" vjcv" kv" ycu" rquukdng" hqt" uqogqpg" vq" fgfkecvg" vjg" rcvjyc{" cu" c"
jkijyc{0"Yjgvjgt"vjg"Etqyp"eqwnf"fq"kv."K"fqwdv"xgt{"owej."cu"vjcv"okijv"
jcxg"kpxqnxgf"vjg"swguvkqp"jqy"hct"ogtg"wugt"ecp"chhgev"vjg"rtqrgtv{"qh"vjg"
Etqyp"cpf"kpvgthgtg"ykvj"vjg"rtgtqicvkxg0"Hqt"vjg"rwtrqug"qh"vjku"lwfiogpv."
jqygxgt."K"rtqrqug"vq"cuuwog"vjcv"vjg"rcvj"qp"vjg"vqr"qh"vjg"ugc"ycnn"ku"cp"
cpekgpv"jkijyc{"yjkej"ycu."cv"uqog"vkog"qt"cpqvjgt."fgfkecvgf"hqt"wug"qh"vjg"
rwdnke."cpf."ceeqtfkpin{."vjcv"vjg"rwdnke"jcf"c"tkijv"vq"rcuu"cnqpi"vjg"rcvj0"
"
Vjku"oc{"dg"cp"kpuvcpeg"qh"c"ykfgt"rtkpekrng0"British Transport Commission v
Westmorland County Council77"eqpegtpgf"c"enckogf"rwdnke"tkijv"qh"yc{"qp"c"
dtkfig"qxgt"c"tcknyc{"nkpg0"Vjg"Dtkvkuj"Vtcpurqtv"Eqookuukqp"*c"uvcvwvqt{"dqf{"
yjqnn{"qypgf"d{"vjg"Etqyp"dwv"pqv"vtgcvgf"cu"c"Etqyp"gpvkv{+"ctiwgf"vjcv"vjg"
gzkuvgpeg"qh"c"rwdnke"jkijyc{"ycu"kpeqorcvkdng"ykvj"kvu"uvcvwvqt{"rqygtu0"Vjg"
Jqwug"qh"Nqtfu"jgnf"vjcv"kp"vjg"ektewouvcpegu"kv"ycu"eqorcvkdng"dwv"ceegrvgf"vjcv"
kp"qvjgt"kpuvcpegu"fgfkecvkqp"okijv"pqv"dg0"Rtguwocdn{"vjgtghqtg"kv"yqwnf"hqnnqy"
vjcv"kh."hqt"kpuvcpeg."vjg"gzkuvgpeg"qh"c"rwdnke"hqqvrcvj"ycu"ujqyp"vq"eqphnkev"ykvj"
vjg"rtqrgt"wug"qh"ncpf"hqt"hqtguvt{"qt"vjg"pggfu"qh"fghgpeg"vtckpkpi"vjgp"c"encko"qh"
eqooqp"ncy"fgfkecvkqp"d{"vjg"Etqyp"okijv"dg"tgukuvgf078"
Ukoknctn{"u"53*3+"gzenwfgu"Òc"yc{"qh"uwej"c"ejctcevgt"vjcv"wug"qh"kv"d{"vjg"rwdnke"
eqwnf" pqv" ikxg" tkug" cv" eqooqp" ncy" vq" cp{" rtguworvkqp" qh" fgfkecvkqpÓ0" Vjg"
ejctcevgt"ku"gzrtguugf"vq"tgncvg"vq"vjg"yc{"pqv"vq"vjg"ncpf0"Yjkng"vjgtg"ecp"dg"pq"
yc{"kp"vjg"cduvtcev79"uq"vjcv"cp{"yc{"owuv"dg"qxgt"rctvkewnct"ncpf."kv"oc{"dg"ctiwgf"
vjcv"kh"kv"ku"qxgt"Etqyp"ncpf"vjcv"eqwnf"chhgev"kvu"ejctcevgt0"Jqygxgt."c"yc{"qxgt"
Etqyp" ncpf" ku" kp" rtkpekrng" uwdlgev" vq" kornkgf" fgfkecvkqp" cv" eqooqp" ncy" cpf"
vjgtghqtg"kv"ecp"pqv"dg"uckf"kv"ku"pgeguuctkn{"qh"uwej"c"ejctcevgt"cu"vq"gzenwfg"cp{"
rtguworvkqp"qh"fgfkecvkqp0"Yjkng"uqog"cnngigf"yc{u"qxgt"Etqyp"ncpf"eqwnf"pqv"
ikxg"tkug"vq"vjg"rtguworvkqp."dgecwug"kv"yqwnf"dg"eqpvtct{"vq"vjg"tq{cn"rtgtqicvkxg"
qt"vq"vjg"rwdnke"fwvkgu"qh"vjg"Etqyp."yjkej"okijv"qp"qeecukqp"dg"uwhhkekgpv"vq"
"
76"" ]3;74̲"3"Cnn"GT"987"cv"9890"
77" ]3;7:̲"CE"348."]3;79̲"4"Cnn"GT"5750"
78" Vjg"ucog"rtkpekrngu"crrn{"cu"hqt"vqyp"cpf"xknncig"itggpu0"R (Newhaven Port and Properties Ltd)
v East Sussex County Council"]4237̲" WMUE" 9." ]4237̲" 4" YNT" 823=" ]4235̲" GYEC" Ekx" 498."
]4235̲"5"YNT"35:;."]4235̲"5"Cnn"GT"8990
79"Attorney-General (ex rel Yorkshire Derwent Trust) v Brotherton"]3;;4̲"CE"6470"
"Highways and Public Rights of Way" 433"
"
pgicvkxg" uvcvwvqt{" fgfkecvkqp." vjcv" yknn" pqv" qhvgp" crrn{." gurgekcnn{" kh" vjg" dqf{"
ocpcikpi"vjg" ncpf" jcu" pqv" qdlgevgf" vq" rwdnke" wug0" Gxgp" kh" vjgtg" ycu" c" urgekcn"
tgcuqp"fwtkpi"Etqyp"qeewrcvkqp."vjcv"yqwnf"egcug"vq"crrn{"qpeg"vjg"ncpf"egcugf"
vq"dg" Etqyp" ncpf0" Kh" vjg" vguv" qh" ejctcevgt" ku" ocfg" cv" vjg" fcvg" qh" gzrkt{"qh" vjg""
42"{gctu"cpf."kh"vjg"uwdlgev"ncpf"ku"pqv"Etqyp"ncpf"cv"vjcv"vkog."vjgp"u"53"yknn"
crrn{"cpf"vjg"ncvgt"rtkxcvg"ncpfqypgt"ecp"pqv"kpxqmg"Etqyp"koowpkv{0"
"
"
"
"
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeUnlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations