Litigation
| Author | Christopher Jessel |
| Pages | 221-236 |
"
"
Ejcrvgt"35"
Nkvkicvkqp"
3503" ETQYP"RTQEGGFKPIU"
Vjku"ejcrvgt"eqpukfgtu"vjg"twngu"cdqwv"enckou"qh"rtqrgtv{"tkijvu"d{"qt"cickpuv"vjg"
Etqyp" pqy" iqxgtpgf"d{"vjg" Etqyp" Rtqeggfkpiu"Cev" 3;690" Jkuvqtkecnn{" vjgtg"
ygtg"fkhhkewnvkgu"kp"uwdlgevu"uwkpi"vjg"Etqyp0"Vjg"eqwtvu"ygtg"vjg"mkpiÓu"eqwtvu"
cpf."wpvkn"vjg"Cev"qh"Ugvvngogpv"3922."u"5"rtqxkfgf"hqt"vjgkt"kpfgrgpfgpeg."vjg"
lwfigu"ygtg"tq{cn"ugtxcpvu"jqnfkpi"vjgkt"rqukvkqpu"cv"vjg"mkpiÓu"rngcuwtg0"C"nqtf"
eqwnf"pqv"dg"ocfg"ceeqwpvcdng"kp"jku"qyp"eqwtv"cpf."cnvjqwij"vjg"tq{cn"eqwtvu"
ygtg"urgekcn"kp"uqog"yc{u."vjg{"ygtg"uggp"cu"ukoknct"vq"vjqug"yjkej"cp{"nqtf"jgnf"
hqt"jku"vgpcpvu"kp"vjg"eqpvgzv"qh"ncpf"cpf"tkijvu"qxgt"ncpf0"Vjg"lwfigu"korwvgf"vjg"
uvcvwu"qh"koowpkv{"vq"vjg"mkpiÓu"rgtuqp"cpf"htqo"vjcv"vq"vjqug"cevkpi"qp"jku"dgjcnh0"
Kp"In the Goods of His late Majesty King George the Third, Deceased3Ukt"Lqjp"
Pkejqnn"uckf
Kv"ku"*cu"jcu"dggp"cntgcf{"uvcvgf+."kp"uwduvcpeg."pqv"ogtgn{"c"rtqeggfkpi"vq"vt{"
vjg"xcnkfkv{"qh"vjg"yknn"qh"jku"ncvg"Oclguv{."dwv"c"rtqeggfkpi"cickpuv"vjg"tgkipkpi"
Uqxgtgkip"Î"c"fgocpf"wrqp"jku"Oclguv{."yjkej"ku"vq"dg"gphqtegf."cfxgtugn{."
cickpuv"jko0"Vjcv"c"rtqeguu"qh"vjg"pcvwtg"rtc{gf"eqwnf"pqv"kuuwg"fktgevn{"cickpuv"
vjg"Uqxgtgkip"jkougnh"uggou"vq"dg"cfokvvgf."d{"rtc{kpi"kv."kp"hqto."cickpuv"vjg"
MkpiÓu"rtqevqt0"Kv"yqwnf"dg"swkvg"c"pqxgnv{"kp"eqpuvkvwvkqpcn"ncy"vq"korngcf"vjg"
Uqxgtgkip"rgtuqpcnn{0"Vjgug"Eqwtvu"ctg"pqv"rtguwogf"vq"dg"vjg"dguv"ceswckpvgf"
ykvj"vjg"tkijvu"cpf"rtgtqicvkxgu"qh"vjg"Etqyp tgictf"vq"uwej"ocvvgtu"yg"
owuv"nqqm"fkhhkfgpvn{"cpf"tgurgevhwnn{"vq"qvjgt"cwvjqtkvkgu="dwv"vjgtg"uggou"pq"
rtkpekrng"kp"vjg"eqpuvkvwvkqp"oqtg"fkuvkpevn{"nckf"fqyp"d{"eqooqp"ncy"ytkvgtu"
vjcp" vjcv" vjg" Uqxgtgkip" ecppqv" dg" rgtuqpcnn{" korngcfgf0" Ot0" Lwuvkeg"
Dncemuvqpg."kp"vjg"hktuv"xqnwog"qh"jku"Eqoogpvctkgu."urgcmu"qh"vjg"Òitgcv"cpf"
vtcpuegpfcpv"cvvtkdwvguÓ"yjkej"vjg"ncy"cuetkdgu"vq"vjg"Mkpi="cpf"hktuv"jg"pqvkegu"
vjg"cvvtkdwvg"qh"uqxgtgkipv{0"ÒJg"ku"uckf.Ó"uc{u"vjg"ngctpgf"eqoogpvcvqt"*3"Dn0"
"
3" *3:44+"3"Cff"477"cv"488."384"GT":;"cv";50"
444" Crown and Government Land"
"
Eqo0"464."(e04+"Òvq"jcxg"korgtkcn"fkipkv{="cpf"kp"ejctvgtu"dghqtg"vjg"Eqpswguv"
ku"htgswgpvn{"uv{ngf"dcukngwu"cpf"korgtcvqt0Ó"ÒJku"tgcno"ku"fgenctgf"vq"dg"cp"
gorktg."cpf"jku"Etqyp"korgtkcn."d{"ocp{"cevu"qh"rctnkcogpv."yjkej"cv"vjg"ucog"
vkog"fgenctg"vjg"Mkpi"vq"dg"vjg"uwrtgog"jgcf"qh"vjg"tgcno"kp"ocvvgtu"dqvj"ekxkn"
cpf"geengukcuvkecn0Ó"ÒJgpeg"kv"ku.Ó"jg"cffu."Òvjcv"pq"uwkv"qt"cevkqp"ecp"dg"dtqwijv"
cickpuv"vjg"Mkpi"gxgp"kp"ekxkn"ocvvgtu."dgecwug"pq"Eqwtv"ecp"jcxg"lwtkufkevkqp"
qxgt" jko0" Hqt"cnn" lwtkufkevkqp" kornkgu" uwrgtkqtkv{" qh" rqygt=" cwvjqtkv{" vq" vt{"
yqwnf"dg"xckp"cpf"kfng"ykvjqwv"cwvjqtkv{"vq"tgftguu="cpf"vjg"ugpvgpeg"qh"c"Eqwtv"
yqwnf"dg"eqpvgorvkdng."wpnguu"vjcv"Eqwtv"jcf"rqygt"vq"eqoocpf"vjg"gzgewvkqp"
qh"kv="dwv"yjq."uc{u"Hkpej"*Hkpej."N0":55+."ujcnn"eqoocpf"vjg"MkpiAÓ"
"
Ctg"vjgp."kv"oc{"dg"cumgf."vjg"uwdlgevu"qh"Gpincpf"vqvcnn{"fguvkvwvg"qh"tgogf{."
kp" ecug" vjg" Etqyp" ujqwnf" kpxcfg" vjgkt"tkijvu." gkvjgt" d{" rtkxcvg" kplwtkgu." qt"
rwdnke" qrrtguukqpuA" Vq" vjku" yg" oc{" cpuygt" vjcv" Òvjg" ncy" jcu" rtqxkfgf" c"
tgogf{"kp"dqvj"ecugu0Ó"
"
Cpf."hktuv."cu"vq"rtkxcvg"kplwtkgu="kh"cp{"rgtuqp"jcu"kp"rqkpv"qh"rtqrgtv{"c"lwuv"
fgocpf"wrqp"vjg"Mkpi."jg"owuv"rgvkvkqp"jko"kp"jku"Eqwtv"qh"Ejcpegt{."yjgtg"
jku" ejcpegnnqt" yknn" cfokpkuvgt" tkijv" cu" c" ocvvgt" qh" itceg." vjqwij"pqv" wrqp"
eqorwnukqp0"
"
Dgukfgu"vjg"cvvtkdwvg"qh"uqxgtgkipv{."vjg"ncy"cnuq"cuetkdgu"vq"vjg"Mkpi."kp"jku"
rqnkvkecn"ecrcekv{."cduqnwvg"rgthgevkqp0"Vjg"Mkpi"ecp"fq"pq"ytqpi0"
"
Gxgp"dghqtg"vjg"ncy"ycu"tghqtogf"d{"vjg"3;69"Cev."kv"ycu"rquukdng"vq"qdvckp"c"
fgenctcvkqp" kp" c" ecug" kpxqnxkpi" vjg" Etqyp0" Kp" The Eastern Trust Company v
McKenzie, Mann & Co Ltd6kp"c"ecug"kpxqnxkpi"c"ytqpihwn"rc{ogpv"d{"vjg"Etqyp"
kp"Dtkvkuj"Eqnwodkc."yjgtg"vjg"ncy"ycu"vjg"ucog"cu"kp"Gpincpf."vjg"Rtkx{"Eqwpekn"
gzrnckpgf
Vjgtg" ku" c" ygnn/guvcdnkujgf" rtcevkeg" kp" Gpincpf" kp"egtvckp" ecugu" yjgtg" pq"
rgvkvkqp"qh"tkijv"yknn"nkg."wpfgt"yjkej"vjg"Etqyp"ecp"dg"uwgf"d{"vjg"Cvvqtpg{/
Igpgtcn."cpf"c"fgenctcvqt{"qtfgt"qdvckpgf."cu"jcu"dggp"tgegpvn{"gzrnckpgf"d{"
vjg"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcn"kp"Gpincpf"kp"Dyson v. Attorney-General7"cpf"kp"Burghes
v. Attorney-General08"Kv"ku"vjg"fwv{"qh"vjg"Etqyp"cpf"qh"gxgt{"dtcpej"qh"vjg"
Gzgewvkxg"vq"cdkfg"d{"cpf"qdg{"vjg"ncy0"Kh"vjgtg"ku"cp{"fkhhkewnv{"kp"cuegtvckpkpi"
kv"vjg"Eqwtvu"ctg"qrgp"vq"vjg"Etqyp"vq"uwg."cpf"kv"ku"vjg"fwv{"qh"vjg"Gzgewvkxg"
kp"ecugu"qh"fqwdv"vq"cuegtvckp"vjg"ncy."kp"qtfgt"vq"qdg{"kv."pqv"vq"fkutgictf"kv0"
"
"
4"*CwvjqtÓu"hqqvpqvg+" Ukt" Yknnkco" Dncemuvqpg." Commentaries on the Laws of England" *Qzhqtf
Enctgpfqp"Rtguu."3987Î3992+"cv"309030"
5" *CwvjqtÓu"hqqvpqvg+"Ukt"Jgpt{"Hkpej."Law or a Discourse Thereof *3883+"cv":50"
6" ]3;37̲"CE"9720"
7" *Hqqvpqvg"4"kp"qtkikpcn+"]3;33̲"3"M0D0"6320"
8" *Hqqvpqvg"5"kp"qtkikpcn+"]3;34̲"3"Ej0"3950"
"Litigation" 445"
"
Vjg"Etqyp"Rtqeggfkpiu"Cev"3;69"rtqxkfgf"vjcv"kp"igpgtcn"enckou"eqwnf"dg"ocfg"
cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp"kp"vjg"ucog"yc{"cu"cickpuv"cp{"qvjgt"fghgpfcpv0"Kpgxkvcdn{"kv"
ycu"pqv"swkvg"cu"ukorng"cu"vjcv"cpf"vjg"Cev"jcf"vq"iq"kpvq"fgvckn0"Vjg"dtqcf"rqnke{"
ycu" cejkgxgf"dwv" c" pwodgt" qh" urgekcn" twngu" ygtg" tgvckpgf" qt" kpvtqfwegf0" Cp{"
tgockpkpi" icru" kp" vjg" rtqegfwtgu" hqt" rtkxcvg" rgtuqpu" vq" encko" cickpuv" vjg""
Etqyp"ctg"pqy"nkmgn{"vq"dg"hknngf"wpfgt"vjg"Jwocp"Tkijvu"Cev"3;;:."u"9"yjkej"
kpeqtrqtcvgu"vjg"Eqpxgpvkqp"hqt"vjg"Rtqvgevkqp"qh"Jwocp"Tkijvu"cpf"Hwpfcogpvcn"
Htggfqou."Ctv"8
Kp"vjg"fgvgtokpcvkqp"qh"jku"ekxkn"tkijvu"cpf"qdnkicvkqpu"qt"qh"cp{"etkokpcn"ejctig"
cickpuv" jko." gxgt{qpg" ku" gpvkvngf" vq" c" hckt" cpf" rwdnke" jgctkpi" ykvjkp" c"
tgcuqpcdng"vkog"d{"cp"kpfgrgpfgpv"cpf"korctvkcn"vtkdwpcn"guvcdnkujgf"d{"ncy0"
"
Wpfgt"vjg"3;69"Cev."u"3:"ekxkn"rtqeggfkpiu"cickpuv"c"fgrctvogpv"owuv"dg"ugtxgf"
qp" vjg" uqnkekvqt" hqt" vjcv" fgrctvogpv" qt." kh" vjgtg" ku"pq" uwej" uqnkekvqt" qt" kh" vjg"
rtqeggfkpiu"ctg"cickpuv"vjg"Cvvqtpg{"Igpgtcn."vjgp"qp"vjg"Vtgcuwt{"Uqnkekvqt0"Qp"
3"Crtkn"4237"vjg"Qhhkeg"qh"vjg"Vtgcuwt{"Uqnkekvqt"dgecog"vjg"Iqxgtpogpv"Ngicn"
Fgrctvogpv"dwv"vjg"Vtgcuwt{"Uqnkekvqt"tgockpu"cu"jgcf"qh"kv0"
Vjg"Etqyp"jcu"cnyc{u"dggp"cdng"vq"jcxg"tgeqwtug"vq"vjg"eqwtvu"vq"cuugtv"kvu"tkijvu"
cickpuv"uwdlgevu"d{"gkvjgt"eqooqp"ncy"tgogfkgu"qt"gswkvcdng"qpgu0"Hqtogtn{"kv"
jcf"uqog"urgekcn"rtkxkngigu"kp"nkvkicvkqp."hqt"kpuvcpeg"vjg"tkijv"vq"ejqqug"vjg"eqwtv."
dwv"vjgug"ygtg"nctign{"tgoqxgf"d{"vjg"cogpfogpvu"vq"vjg"Etqyp"Rtqeggfkpiu"Cev"
3;69" d{" vjg" Ekxkn" Rtqegfwtg" *Oqfkhkecvkqp" qh" Etqyp" Rtqeggfkpiu" Cev" 3;69+"
Qtfgt"42279"wpfgt"vjg"Ekxkn"Rtqegfwtg"Cev"3;;90"Vjgtg"ygtg"urgekcn"twngu"cdqwv"
fkuvtckpv:"dwv"vjg{"ygtg"cdqnkujgf"d{"vjg"Vtkdwpcnu."Eqwtvu"cpf"Gphqtegogpv"Cev"
4229."Rv"5"cpf"vjg"pgy"twngu"tgncvkpi"vq"gphqtegogpv"d{"vcmkpi"eqpvtqn"qh"iqqfu"
dkpf"vjg"Etqyp"d{"uu"::"cpf":;*3+0"JO"Tgxgpwg"("Ewuvqou"jcxg"egtvckp"urgekcn"
rtghgtgpvkcn" tkijvu" kp" cp" kpuqnxgpe{0" Ukoknct" tkijvu" ygtg" cdqnkujgf" d{" vjg"
Gpvgtrtkug"Cev"4224."u"473"dwv"tguvqtgf"kp"rctv"d{"vjg"Hkpcpeg"Cev"4242."u";:0
Cnvjqwij"cu"c"igpgtcn"twng"vjg"Etqyp"ku"pqv"tgswktgf"vq"ikxg"cp"wpfgtvcmkpi"kp"
fcocigu"yjgp"uggmkpi"cp"kplwpevkqp"kp"rwdnke"ncy"ecugu;"kv"oc{"dg"tgswktgf"vq"
ikxg"qpg"kp"ocvvgtu"kpxqnxkpi"rtqrgtv{."cnvjqwij"qp"urgekcn"vgtou032"
Vjg"Ctdkvtcvkqp"Cev"3;;8."u"328*3+"rtqxkfgu
"
9" UK"4227149340"
:" Ejkvv{."Prerogatives of the Crown cv"42:0"
;"F Hoffmann-La Roche & Co AG v Secretary of State for Trade and Industry"]3;97̲"CE"4;70"
32"Attorney General v Wright"]3;::̲"3"YNT"3860"
446" Crown and Government Land"
"
Rctv"K"qh"vjku"Cev"crrnkgu"vq"cp{"ctdkvtcvkqp"citggogpv"vq"yjkej"Jgt"Oclguv{."
gkvjgt"kp"tkijv"qh"vjg"Etqyp"qt"qh"vjg"Fwej{"qh"Ncpecuvgt"qt"qvjgtykug."qt"vjg"
Fwmg"qh"Eqtpycnn."ku"c"rctv{0"
"
Vjg"ugevkqp"fqgu"pqv"gzrtguun{"tghgt"vq"qvjgt"Etqyp"dqfkgu."uwej"cu"ugetgvctkgu"qh"
uvcvg"uwdokvvkpi"vq"ctdkvtcvkqp"dwv"Òqt"qvjgtykugÓ"ku"ykfg"gpqwij"vq"eqxgt"vjgo"
cpf" vjg" Etqyp" Rtqeggfkpiu"Cev" 3;69." u" 47*3+" eqpvgorncvgu" vjg" Etqyp" dgkpi"
kpxqnxgf"kp"ctdkvtcvkqp"cpf"kp"cp"crrtqrtkcvg"fkurwvg"uwej"c"ecug"oc{"dg"tghgttgf"
vq"ctdkvtcvkqp033"
3504" VQTV
Dghqtg"vjg"3;69"Cev"vjg"eqooqp"ncy"twng"ycu."cu"Ukt"Lqjp"Pkejqnn"uckf."vjcv"Òvjg"
mkpi"ecp"fq"pq"ytqpiÓ0"Kv"hqnnqygf"vjcv"vjg"Etqyp"eqwnf"pqv"dg"nkcdng"kp"vqtv."gxgp"
qp"c"dcuku"qh"xkectkqwu"nkcdknkv{034"Uqogvkogu"kv"ycu"rquukdng"hqt"c"enckocpv"vq"uwg"
vjg"qhhkekcn"tgurqpukdng"qt"vjg"okpkuvgt"rgtuqpcnn{"qp"vjg"dcuku"vjcv"kh"c"ytqpi"jcf"
dggp"eqookvvgf."cpf"kh"kv"eqwnf"pqv"jcxg"dggp"vjg"mkpiÓu"hcwnv."kv"owuv"jcxg"dggp"
vjcv" qh" c" Etqyp" ugtxcpv035" Kp" rtcevkeg" vjg" Etqyp" yqwnf" uvcpf" dgjkpf" vjg"
fghgpfcpv36"cpf"kp"ocp{"ecugu"yqwnf"rwv"wr"c"pqokpcvgf"rgtuqp"vq"dg"uwgf0"
Kp"Feather v The Queen.37"vjgtg"ycu"c"encko"kp"vqtv"hqt"kphtkpigogpv"qh"c"rcvgpv0"
Cnvjqwij"c"rgvkvkqp"qh"tkijv"eqwnf"dg"wugf"cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp"cu"uwej"vjgtg"ycu"pq"
tgogf{"cxckncdng"kp"vqtv0"Pgxgtvjgnguu"Eqemdwtp"EL"uckf<38"
Dwv"kp" qwt" qrkpkqp" pq" cwvjqtkv{" ku" pggfgf" vq" guvcdnkuj" vjcv" c" ugtxcpv" qh" vjg"
Etqyp"ku"tgurqpukdng"kp"ncy"hqt"c"vqtvkqwu"cev"fqpg"vq"c"hgnnqy"uwdlgev."vjqwij"
fqpg"d{"vjg"cwvjqtkv{"qh"vjg"Etqyp"Î"c"rqukvkqp"yjkej"crrgctu"vq"wu"vq"tguv"qp"
rtkpekrngu"yjkej"ctg"vqq"ygnn"ugvvngf"vq"cfokv"qh"swguvkqp."cpf"yjkej"ctg"cnkmg"
guugpvkcn"vq"wrjqnf"vjg"fkipkv{"qh"vjg"Etqyp"qp"vjg"qpg"jcpf."cpf"vjg"tkijvu"
cpf"nkdgtvkgu"qh"vjg"uwdlgev"qp"vjg"qvjgt0"Yg"gpvgtvckp"pq"fqwdv"vjcv."kh"vjg"ghhgev"
qh" vjg" ngvvgtu" rcvgpv" jcf" dggp" vq" gzenwfg" vjg" Etqyp" htqo" vjg" wug" qh" vjg"
kpxgpvkqp."cp"cevkqp"eqwnf"jcxg"dggp"ockpvckpgf"d{"vjg"rcvgpvgg"cickpuv"cp{"
qpg"d{"yjqo"vjg"kpxgpvkqp"jcf"dggp"wugf"kp"vjg"rwdnke"ugtxkeg0"
"
"
33"La Societe les Affreteurs Reunis v Shipping Controller"]3;43̲" 5" MD" 3= Secretary of State for
Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs v Percy Thomas Partnership"]3;;:̲"Cnn"GT"*F+"350"
34" C"rgvkvkqp"qh"tkijv"ycu"pqv"cxckncdng="Tobin v The Queen"*3:86+"38"ED*PU+"5320
35" Ugg"vjg"igpgtcn"fkuewuukqp"kp"In re M"]3;;6̲"3"CE"5990"
36"Mulcahy v Ministry of Defence"]3;;8̲"SD"954"cv"9620"Dwv"ugg"Adams v Naylor"]3;68̲"CE"765="
Royster v Cavey"]3;69̲"MD"4260"Enckou"kp"vqtv"d{"ugtxkpi"ugtxkeg"rgtuqppgn"ctg"pqv"cxckncdng="
Matthews v Ministry of Defence"]4225̲"WMJN"6."]4225̲"3"CE"33850"
37" *3:87+"8"D"("U"479."344"GT"33;30"
38" *3:87+"8"D"("U"479"cv"4;9."344"GT"33;3"cv"34270"
"Litigation" 447"
"
Vjg" twng" ycu"uq" cpekgpv"cpf"wpswguvkqpgf" vjcv" kv" fqgu" pqv" fgrgpf" qp" fgekfgf"
cwvjqtkv{0"Kp"Mackenzie-Kennedy v Air Council39"Dcpmgu"NL"swqvgf"Rcnngu"ED"kp"
cp"Ktkuj"fgekukqp."Wheeler v Public Works Commissioners3:yjkej"ygpv"hwtvjgt"
vjcp"ukorng"Etqyp"koowpkv{"vq"koowpkv{"qh"c"uwdqtfkpcvg"eqtrqtcvkqp
Pqy."kh"c"eqtrqtcvkqp"dg"eqpuvkvwvgf"hqt"vjg"uqng"rwtrqug"qh"fqkpi"cevu"hqt"vjg"
Etqyp." kv" ku" prima facie" qwvukfg" kvu" rqygtu" vq" fq" cp{vjkpi." gzegrv"hqt" vjg"
Etqyp."cpf"cu"kp"ncy"c"ytqpihwn"cev"ecppqv"dg"fqpg"hqt"vjg"Etqyp."uwej"c"
eqtrqtcvkqp"ku"pqv"ecrcdng"qh"fqkpi"uwej"ytqpihwn"cev"kp"kvu"eqtrqtcvg"ecrcekv{0"
Kp" uwej" c" ecug." vjgtghqtg." vjg" ytqpihwn" cev" ecppqv" dg" fggogf" vjcv" qh" vjg"
eqtrqtcvkqp."dwv"owuv"dg"fggogf"vjg"rgtuqpcn"cev"qh"vjqug"yjq"eqookvvgf"kv0"
"
Hqt"oquv"curgevu"qh"vjg"Etqyp"vjg"dcuke"twng"ycu"cdqnkujgf"d{"vjg"3;69"Cev"uq"
vjcv"kv"ku"pq"nqpigt"pgeguuct{"vq"rwtuwg"c"Etqyp"ugtxcpv"cpf"fktgev"enckou"kp"vqtv"
ctg"pqy"htgswgpv="u"4*3+"rtqxkfgu
Uwdlgev"vq"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjku"Cev."vjg"Etqyp"ujcnn"dg"uwdlgev"vq"cnn"vjqug"
nkcdknkvkgu"kp"vqtv"vq"yjkej."kh"kv"ygtg"c"rtkxcvg"rgtuqp"qh"hwnn"cig"cpf"ecrcekv{."
kv"yqwnf"dg"uwdlgev kp"tgurgev"qh"cp{"dtgcej"qh"vjg"fwvkgu"cvvcejkpi"cv"
eqooqp"ncy"vq"vjg"qypgtujkr."qeewrcvkqp."rquuguukqp"qt"eqpvtqn"qh"rtqrgtv{0"
"
Vjku"crrnkgu"pqv"qpn{"vq"dtgcej"qh"eqooqp"ncy"fwvkgu"dwv"cnuq"vq"uqog"uvcvwvqt{"
fwvkgu" kp" vqtv" cu" wpfgt" vjg" Qeewrkgtu" Nkcdknkv{" Cev" 3;79." u" 8." vjg" Qeewrkgtu"
Nkcdknkv{"Cev"3;:6."u"5"qt"vjg"Fghgevkxg"Rtgokugu"Cev"3;94."u"70"
C"rctvkewnct"kuuwg"ku"nkcdknkv{"hqt"vjg"pqkug"ecwugf"d{"nqy/hn{kpi"oknkvct{"cktetchv0"
Pwkucpeg"kpxqnxgu"dcncpekpi"vjg"pggfu"cpf"cogpkvkgu"qh"pgkijdqwtu0"Kp"Dennis v
Ministry of Defence3;"Dwemng{"L"uckf<42"
Kv"uggou"vq"og"vjcv"vjg"pgvvng"owuv"dg"itcurgf0"Gkvjgt"vjgug"Jcttkgtu"eqpuvkvwvg"
c"pwkucpeg"qt"rwdnke"kpvgtguv."cu"tgrtgugpvgf"d{"vjg"OqF"ockpvckpkpi"c"uvcvg"qh"
vjg"ctv"ckt"uvtkmg"hqteg"cpf"vtckpkpi"rknqvu."rtqxkfgu"koowpkv{"È"
"
Kh"vjgtg"ku"koowpkv{."kv"ku"qdxkqwun{"pqv"wpnkokvgf0"Vjg"OqF"owuv"fq"cnn"kv"
tgcuqpcdn{" ecp" vq"cxqkf" fcocikpi" vjg" kpvgtguvu" qh" qvjgtu0" Kp" o{" xkgy" vjcv"
yqwnf"kpenwfg"ejqqukpi"cp"crrtqrtkcvg"nqecvkqp"cpf"qrgtcvkpi"kv"tgcuqpcdn{"È"
Yjgtg"vjgtg"ku"c"tgcn"rwdnke"kpvgtguv"kp"c"rctvkewnct"wug"qh"ncpf."K"ecp"ugg"pq"
qdlgevkqp"kp"rtkpekrng"vq"vcmkpi"vjcv"rwdnke"kpvgtguv"kpvq"ceeqwpv."kp"qpg"yc{"qt"
cpqvjgt."kp"fgekfkpi"yjcv"ku"dguv"vq"dg"fqpg"È"Vjg"rwdnke"kpvgtguv"rtgxcknu."
rtqxkfgf"pq"oqtg"fcocig"ku"fqpg"vjcp"ku"tgcuqpcdn{"pgeguuct{0"Ugg"cnuq"Allen
"
39" ]3;49̲"4"MD"739"cv"7450"
3:" ]3;25̲"4"KT"424"cv"44;0"
3;" ]4225̲"GYJE"9;5"*SD+."]4225̲"Gpx"NT"560"
42" ]4225̲"GYJE"9;5"*SD+."]4225̲"Gpx"NT"56"cv"]62̲"vq"]6:̲0"
448" Crown and Government Land"
"
v Gulf Oil Refining Ltd"]3;:3̲"C0E0"32230"Vjg"fkhhgtgpeg"kp"vjg"kpuvcpv"ecug"ku"
vjcv"kv"ku"nghv"vq"vjg"eqooqp"ncy"vq"rtqxkfg"vjg"cpuygt."pq"uvcvwvqt{"htcogyqtm"
ku"rtgugpv"vq"cuukuv0"Jqygxgt."vjg"rwdnke"kpvgtguv"kp"swguvkqp"jgtg."cndgkv"xgt{"
fkhhgtgpv."oc{"dg"eqpukfgtgf"lwuv"cu"korqtvcpv."kh"pqv"oqtg"uq0"Kv"eqwnf"cnuq"dg"
vjqwijv"vjcv"vjg"OqFÓu"rqukvkqp."ejctigf"cu"kv"ku"ykvj"vjg"fghgpeg"qh"vjg"tgcno."
ujqwnf"dg"pq"nguu"rtqvgevgf"vjcp"eqoogtekcn"qt"qvjgt"wpfgtvcmkpiu"cwvjqtkugf"
fktgevn{"d{"uvcvwvg0"
"
K"vjgtghqtg"jqnf"vjcv"c"pwkucpeg"ku"guvcdnkujgf"dwv"vjcv"vjg"rwdnke"kpvgtguv"engctn{"
fgocpfu"vjcv"TCH"Ykvvgtkpi"ujqwnf"eqpvkpwg"vq"vtckp"rknqvu0"
"
Jg"cnuq"eqpukfgtgf"c"encko"wpfgt"vjg"Jwocp"Tkijvu"Cev"3;;:0"Vjg" ghhgev"
vjgtghqtg"ku"vjcv"vjg"Etqyp"oc{"dg"jgnf"vq"jcxg"dggp"eqookvvkpi"c"pwkucpeg"dwv"
vjcv"kv"ku"lwuvkhkgf"kp"vjg"ykfgt"pcvkqpcn"kpvgtguv"cpf"vjcv"rtqxkfgu"c"fghgpeg0"Kv"jcu"
nqpi"dggp"ceegrvgf"vjcv"ugtxcpvu"qh"vjg"Etqyp"ecp"dg"nkcdng"hqt"vtgurcuu043"
Vjgtg"ecp"cnuq"dg"nkcdknkv{"hqt"vjg"guecrg"qh"fcpigtqwu"uwduvcpegu0"Cp"qdxkqwu"
kpuvcpeg" ku" kp" tgncvkqp" vq" pwengct" kpuvcnncvkqpu0" Kp"Blue Circle Industries Ltd v
Ministry of Defence44"vjg"rnckpvkhhu"enckogf"dqvj"cv"eqooqp"ncy"wpfgt"vjg"twng"kp"
Rylands v Fletcher45"cpf"wpfgt"vjg"Pwengct"Kpuvcnncvkqpu"Cev"3;87."uu"9*3+"cpf"340"
Nkcdknkv{"ycu"pqv"fkurwvgf"kp"rtkpekrng"cpf"vjg"ecug"eqpegtpgf"vjg"swcpvwo"qh"
fcocigu0"
3505" EQPVTCEV"CPF"RTQRGTV["
Kv" ycu" ceegrvgf"cv" eqooqp" ncy" vjcv" vjg" Etqyp" eqwnf" wpfgtvcmg" c" eqpvtcevwcn"
eqookvogpv"cpf"eqwnf"dg"nkcdng"hqt"dtgcej046"Vjg"rtqegfwtcn"rtqdngo"qh"nkcdknkv{"
kp"vjg"EtqypÓu"qyp"eqwtvu"ycu"qxgteqog"d{"vjg"crrnkecpv"uwdokvvkpi"c"rgvkvkqp"
qh"tkijv47"vq"vjg"uqxgtgkip0"Vjg"ocvvgt"ycu"tghgttgf"vq"vjg"Cvvqtpg{"Igpgtcn"yjq"
yqwnf"kuuwg"c"hkcv."vjcv"ku"cp"qtfgt"vjcv"tkijv"dg"fqpg."cpf"vjg"eqwtvu"eqwnf"vjgp"
cflwfkecvg"kp"vjg"pqtocn"yc{0"
Vjg"Etqyp"Rtqeggfkpiu"Cev"3;69."u"3"rtqxkfgu
Yjgtg"cp{"rgtuqp"jcu"c"encko"cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp"chvgt"vjg"eqoogpegogpv"qh"
vjku" Cev." cpf."k h"vjku" Cev" jcf" pqv" dggp" rcuugf." vjg" encko" okijv" jcxg" dggp"
gphqtegf."uwdlgev" vq" vjg" itcpv" qh" Jku" Oclguv{Óu" hkcv." d{" rgvkvkqp" qh" tkijv." qt"
"
43"Wilkes v Wood *3985+"Nqhhv"3.";:"GT"6:;="ugg"A-G v Nissan ]3;92̲"CE"39;0"
44" ]3;;;̲"Ej"4:;0"
45" *3:8:+"NT"5"JN"5520"
46"Thomas v The Queen"72"*3:96+"NT"32"SD"530"Ugg"cnuq"Dunn v Macdonald"]3:;9̲"3"SD"7770"
47"The Warden v Commonalty of Sadlers’ Case"*37:9+"6"Eq"Tgr"76."98"GT"32340"
"Litigation" 449"
"
okijv"jcxg"dggp"gphqtegf"d{"c"rtqeggfkpi"rtqxkfgf"d{"cp{"uvcvwvqt{"rtqxkukqp"
tgrgcngf"d{"vjku"Cev."vjgp."uwdlgev"vq"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjku"Cev."vjg"encko"oc{"
dg"gphqtegf"cu"qh"tkijv."cpf"ykvjqwv"vjg"hkcv"qh"Jku"Oclguv{."d{"rtqeggfkpiu"
vcmgp"cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp"hqt"vjcv"rwtrqug"kp"ceeqtfcpeg"ykvj"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"qh"
vjku"Cev0"
"
Vjg" rtqegfwtg" uwtxkxgu" kp" tctg" ecugu." uwej" cu" kp" tgncvkqp" vq" egtvckp" qxgtugcu"
ugewtkvkgu48"cpf"hqt"vjg"tq{cn"guvcvgu"*3509+0"Cickp"vjg"Jwocp"Tkijvu"Cev"3;;:"
yqwnf"dg"tgngxcpv"ukpeg"wpfgt"vjg"Eqpxgpvkqp"hqt"vjg"Rtqvgevkqp"qh"Jwocp"Tkijvu"
cpf"Hwpfcogpvcn"Htggfqou."Rtqvqeqn"3."Ctv"3"gxgt{qpg"ku"gpvkvngf"vq"vjg"rgceghwn"
gplq{ogpv"qh"rquuguukqpu"kpenwfkpi"eqpvtcevwcn"tkijvu0"
350503" Nkokvcvkqp"cpf"cfxgtug"rquuguukqp"
Urgekcn" twngu" crrn{" vq" c" uwdlgevÓu" rquuguukqp" qh" Etqyp" ncpf0" Vjg" vtcfkvkqpcn"
rqukvkqp"ycu"vjcv"nullum tempus occurrit regi"*vkog"fqgu"pqv"twp"cickpuv"vjg"mkpi+0"
Vjku"ycu"rctvn{"ejcpigf"d{"vjg"Pwnnwo"Vgorwu"Cevu"*Etqyp"Uwkvu+"qh"384549"cpf"
398;4:"yjkej"kp"ghhgev"rtqxkfgf"c"nkokvcvkqp"rgtkqf"hqt"ncpf"qh"82"{gctu"wpnguu"c"
urgekhke"uvcvwvg"gzenwfgf"nkokvcvkqp04;"Vjcv"jcu"ukpeg"dggp"tgfwegf"cpf"vjg"rqukvkqp"
pqy"fkhhgtu"cu"dgvyggp"wptgikuvgtgf"cpf"tgikuvgtgf"ncpf"cpf"cu"dgvyggp"hqtgujqtg"
cpf"ft{"ncpf0"
Wpfgt"vjg"Nkokvcvkqp"Cev"3;:2."Uej"3."Rv"KK"vjg"pqtocn"rgtkqf"qh"34"{gctu"chvgt"
yjkej"c"rtkxcvg"rgtuqp"nqugu"vjg"tkijv"vq"tgeqxgt"rquuguukqp"qh"wptgikuvgtgf"ncpf"
ku"tgrncegf."hqt"enckou"vq"tgeqxgt"Etqyp"ncpf."d{"52"{gctu0"Hqt"tgikuvgtgf"ncpf"vjg"
Ncpf"Tgikuvtcvkqp"Cev"4224"dkpfu"vjg"Etqyp"uq"vjcv"Uej"8."yjkej"rtqxkfgu"vjcv"
vjg" pqtocn" rgtkqf" qh" 32" {gctu." hqnnqygf" d{" c" 4/{gct" rgtkqf"hqt" vjg" tgikuvgtgf"
rtqrtkgvqt"vq"uvctv"rtqeggfkpiu."crrnkgu0"
Kp" tgncvkqp" vq" dqvj" wptgikuvgtgf"cpf" tgikuvgtgf" ncpf" vjgtg" ctg" ugrctcvg" rgtkqfu""
hqt"hqtgujqtg."yjkej"ku"fghkpgf"vq"kpenwfg"vjg"ugc"dgf."ykvj"oqfkhkecvkqpu"yjgtg"
yjcv"ycu" qpeg" hq tgujqtg" jcu" dgeqog" ft{" ncpf0" Yjgtg" vkvng" ku" wptgikuvgtgf" vjg"
Nkokvcvkqp"Cev"3;:2."Uej"3."rctc"33"rtqxkfgu"vjcv"vjg"rgtkqf"ku"82"{gctu"*qt"52"{gctu"
htqo" vjg" fcvg" kv" egcugf" vq" dg" hqtgujqtg+0" Yjgtg" vkvng" ku" tgikuvgtgf"vjg"Ncpf"
Tgikuvtcvkqp" Cev" 4224."Uej" 8." rctc" 35" rtqxkfgu" hqt" vjg" rgtkqf" qh" 82" {gctu" *qt""
32"{gctu"chvgt"kv"egcugf"vq"dg"hqtgujqtg+"rnwu"vjg"4"{gctu0"
"
48"Franklin v AG"]3;96̲"SD"3:70
49" 43"L3"e"40"
4:" ;"I5"e"380"
4;"Goodtitle v Baldwin"*3:2;+"33"Gcuv"6::."325"GT"32;40"
44:" Crown and Government Land"
"
Vjg"urgekcn"twngu"qrgtcvg"in rem0"Kp"Hill v Transport for London52"uswcvvgtu"vqqm"
rquuguukqp"qh"uqog"tcknyc{"ctejgu"dgnqpikpi"vq"vjg"Itgcvgt"Nqpfqp"Eqwpekn"kp"
3;:70"Vjg"Eqwpekn"ycu"fkuuqnxgf"kp"3;:8"cpf"kvu"rtqrgtv{"rcuugf"vq"vjg"Etqyp53"
wpvkn"kp"4222"vjg"ctejgu"dgecog"xguvgf"kp"Vtcpurqtv"hqt"Nqpfqp054"D{"vjg"vkog"
rtqeggfkpiu"ygtg"uvctvgf"kp"4225"vjg"enckocpvu"jcf"vjgtghqtg"dggp"kp"rquuguukqp"
hqt"oqtg" vjcp" 34" {gctu" dwv" nguu" vjcp" 520" Vjg" eqwtv" jgnf" vjcv." gxgp" vjqwij" vjg"
Etqyp"kpvgtguv"jcf"gpfgf."vjg"gzkuvgpeg"qh"kvu"kpvgtguv"ogcpv"vjcv"vjg"rcrgt"vkvng"
ycu"pqv"gzvkpiwkujgf"cpf"Vtcpurqtv"hqt"Nqpfqp"ycu"gpvkvngf"vq"rquuguukqp0"
Vjg"Cfokpkuvtcvkqp"qh"Guvcvgu"Cev"3;47."u"52*3+"rtqxkfgu"vjcv"vjg"pqtocn"twngu"qh"
ncy"ujcnn"crrn{"yjgtg"vjg"cfokpkuvtcvkqp"qh"vjg"tgcn"cpf"rgtuqpcn"guvcvg"qh"cp{"
fgegcugf"rgtuqp"ku"itcpvgf"vq"c"pqokpgg"qh"vjg"Etqyp"urgekhkecnn{"kpenwfkpi"vjg"
ncy"qh"nkokvcvkqp"qh"cevkqpu0"
Vjg"Etqyp"ecp"vcmg"vjg"dgpghkv"qh"vjg"Nkokvcvkqp"Cev"3;:2"kp"c"encko"cickpuv"vjg"
uwdlgev0"Kp"Roberts v The Crown Estate Commissioners55Ot"Tqdgtvu"enckogf"vkvng"
vq"nctig" rctvu" qh" vj g" Ugxgtp" Guvwct{"wpfgt" ogfkgxcn" itcpvu0" Vjg" Etqyp" Guvcvg"
Eqookuukqpgtu"cpf"vyq"nqecn"ncpfqypgtu"fkurwvgf"vjcv"encko"dwv"cnuq"ctiwgf"vjcv."
d{"xktvwg"qh"vjgkt"ectt{kpi"qwv"cevu"qh"qypgtujkr."pqvcdn{"ftgfikpi."gxgp"kh"jg"jcf"
c" fqewogpvct{" vkvng." vjg{" jcf" gzvkpiwkujgf" vjcv" d{" vjgkt" rquuguukqp0" Cv" hktuv"
kpuvcpeg"Ot"Tqdgtvu"nquv"cpf"jg"ceegrvgf"vjcv"cu"hct"cu"vjg"rtkxcvg"ncpfqypgtu"
ygtg"eqpegtpgf"dwv"crrgcngf"kp"tgncvkqp"vq"vjg"Eqookuukqpgtu"qp"vjg"itqwpfu"vjcv"
kp"Ocipc"Ectvc"34;9"vjg"Etqyp"jcf"wpfgtvcmgp"pqv"vq"fkuugkug"uwdlgevu0"
Ugkukp"ku"c"ngicn"vgto"yjkej"crrnkgu"vq"htggjqnf"ncpf"cpf"hqtogtn{"ycu"rtqvgevgf"
d{"egtvckp"cpekgpv"rtqegfwtgu"mpqyp"cu"vjg"tgcn"cevkqpu"yjkej"ygtg"cdqnkujgf"d{"
vjg" Tgcn" Rtqrgtv{" Nkokvcvkqp" Cev" 3:550" Cnvjqwij" ugkukp" ycu" fgtkxgf" htqo" c"
eqpegrv"ukoknct"vq"rquuguukqp"kv"dgecog"gncdqtcvgf"cpf"ctvkhkekcn"cpf"nqpi"dghqtg"
3:55"vjg"tgcn"cevkqpu"jcf"kp"rtcevkeg"dggp"tgrncegf"d{"glgevogpv."fgtkxgf"htqo"
rtqegfwtgu"vq"rtqvgev"nguuggu"kp"vjgkt"rquuguukqp"qh"ncpf."uq"vjcv"cnn"tkijvu"vq"ncpf"
pqy"fgrgpf"qp"rquuguukqp"pqv"ugkukp056"Vjg"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcn"jgnf"vjcv"vjg"lqkpv"
ghhgev"qh"vjg"Etqyp"Rtqeggfkpiu"Cev"3;69"cpf"vjg"Nkokvcvkqp"Cev"3;:2"ycu"vjcv."
kh"vjg"Etqyp"eqwnf"fgoqpuvtcvg"rquuguukqp."kv"ycu"pqv"fkucdngf"htqo"enckokpi"vjcv"
cp{"rcrgt"vkvng"ycu"gzvkpiwkujgf0"
"
52" ]4227̲"GYJE":78"*Ej+."]4227̲"Ej"59;0"
53" D{"vjg"eqodkpgf"ghhgev"qh"vjg"Ogvtqrqnkvcp"Tqcfu"Vtwpmkpi"Qtfgt"3;:8"*UK"3;:81375+"cpf"vjg"
Jkijyc{u"Cev"3;:2."u"4870"
54" D{"vjg"INC"Tqcfu"cpf"Ukfg"Tqcfu"*Vtcpuhgt"qh"Rtqrgtv{"gve+"Qtfgt"4222"*UK"422213774+."ctv"40"
55" ]422:̲"GYEC"Ekx";:."]422:̲"Ej"65;0"
56"JA Pye (Oxford) Ltd v Graham ]4224̲"WMJN"52."]4225̲"CE"63;"cv"]57̲0"Kp"vjg"tctg"qeecukqpu"qh"
c"eqpxg{cpeg"qh"wptgikuvgtgf"ncpf"kv"ku"uvknn"wuwcn"vq"tgekvg"vjg"ugkukp"qh"vjg"xgpfqt0"
"Litigation" 44;"
"
350504" Rwtrtguvwtgu"
D{"vjg"ncy"qh"rwtrtguvwtgu"egtvckp"rwdnke"ncpfu"ygtg"rtqvgevgf"cv"vjg"kpuvcpeg"qh"
vjg"Etqyp0"Kp"c"owej/ekvgf"ctvkeng."ÒVjg"Dqwpfctkgu"qh"PwkucpegÓ.57"Rtqhguuqt"
Pgyctm"uckf
Kpvgthgtgpeg"ykvj"vjg"rwdnkeÓu"tkijv"qh"yc{"cnqpi"c"jkijyc{"ycu"uqogvjkpi"
fkhhgtgpv" htqo" c" pwkucpeg0" Kv" ycu" c" rwtrtguvwtg." cp"wpncyhwn" gpetqcejogpv"
cickpuv"vjg"mkpi."cpf"gpswktcdng"qh"d{"vjg"mkpiÓu"lwuvkegu"È"cpf"vjwu"ycu"dqtp"
vjg"rwdnke"pwkucpeg0"
"
Rwtrtguvwtgu"ctg"gpetqcejogpvu"qp"rwdnke"cuugvu"uwej"cu"vjg"ugc" ujqtg" qt"
pcxkicdng"tkxgtu"qt"jkijyc{u0"Vjgug"ygtg"cevkqpcdng"cu"dgkpi"kphtkpigogpvu"qp"
ocvvgtu"hqt"yjkej"vjg"mkpi"ycu"tgurqpukdng0"Vjg"ncy"ycu"cnuq"wugf"vq"rtqvgev"qvjgt"
tq{cn"rtqrgtvkgu"rctvkewnctn{"hqtguvu"cpf"kpenwfkpi"vjg"Fwej{"Guvcvgu058"Kp"igpgtcn"
vjg" mkpi" eqwnf" gkvjgt" tgoqxg" vjg" gpetqcejogpv" qt" *yjkej" qhvgp" jcrrgpgf" kp"
hqtguvu+"cnnqy"kv"vq"eqpvkpwg"cu"cp"cuuctv"dwv"ejctig"c"tgpv"hqt"kv0"
Vjg"ncy"qh"rwtrtguvwtgu"ku"pqv"pqy"kpxqmgf0"Kv"ycu"cp"gswkvcdng"lwtkufkevkqp59"cpf"
ycu"tgrncegf"d{"eqooqp"ncy"rtqeggfkpiu"kp"rwdnke"pwkucpeg05:"Kv"oc{"dg"qduqngvg"
kp"Gpincpf"cnvjqwij"kv"jcu"pgxgt"dggp"hqtocnn{"cdqnkujgf0"Kv"ku"uvknn"korqtvcpv"kp"
uqog"lwtkufkevkqpu"kp"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu."hqt"kpuvcpeg"vq"rtqvgev"rwdnke"ycvgtyc{u"
htqo"gpetqcejogpv05;"
3506" ETKOKPCN"NKCDKNKV[
Kh"c"etkog"ku"eqookvvgf"qp"Etqyp"rtqrgtv{"vjg"qhhgpfgt"ecp"dg"rtqugewvgf0"Vjgtg"
ku"pq"koowpkv{"in rem"wpfgt"vjg"etkokpcn"ncy062"C"oqtg"fkhhkewnv"kuuwg"ku"cnngigf"
etkogu" d{" vjg" Etqyp" qt" kvu" ugtxcpvu0" Vjgug" yknn" qpn{" tctgn{" chhgev" nkcdknkv{" kp"
tgurgev"qh"ncpf"qt"kvu"qeewrcvkqp"dwv"oqfgtp"uchgv{"tgiwncvkqpu"ecp"korqug"uvtkev"
"
57"*3;6;+"87" NST" 6:2=" ugg" g0i0" Hunter v Canary Wharf Ltd" ]3;;9̲" CE" 877=" Re Corby Group
Litigation"]422:̲"GYEC"Ekx"6850"
58"A-G to the Prince of Wales v St Aubyn"*3:33+"Ykijv"389."367"GT"34370"
59"A-G v Richards"*39;6+"4"Cpuv"825."367"GT";:20"
5:" Ugg"A-G v Parmeter"*3:33+"32"Rtkeg"59:."369"GT"567="London Corporation v A-G"*3:6:+"K"JN"
Ecu"662." ;" GT" :4;" yjkej" cnuq" fghkpgf" rwtrtguvwtg" cu" Òc" ytqpihwn" kpenquwtg" qh" c" rctv" qh" v jg"
htggjqnf"qh"vjg"EtqypÓ="Corby Group v Corby Borough Council"]422:̲"GYEC"Ekx"685."]422;̲"
SD"557"cv"]37̲0"
5;" Ugg"g0i0"Revell v People"*3:;:+."399"Knn"68:."74"PG"3274="Cobb v Commissioners of Lincoln Park"
*3;25+."424"Knn"649."89"PG"7="Hawaii v Kerr"38"Jcy"585"*3;27+="Sullivan v"Leaf River Forest
Products Inc"9;3"H"Uwrr"849"*UF"Okuu"3;;3+0"
62"R v Chaytor ]4232̲"WMUE"74."]4232̲"5"YNT"39290"
452" Crown and Government Land"
"
etkokpcn"nkcdknkv{0"Vjg"igpgtcn"twng"ku"uvknn"vjcv"ÒVjg"mkpi"ecp"fq"pq"ytqpiÓ"cpf"
yjkng" vjcv"jcu" d ggp"oqfkhkgf" kp" tgncvkqp" vq" vqtv" kv" tgockpu" vtwg" hqt" etkog0" Vjg"
Etqyp" ecp" pqv" dg" etkokpcnn{" nkcdng" dwv" qhhkekcnu." uqogvkogu" fguetkdgf" cu""
rgtuqpu"kp"vjg"ugtxkeg"qt"kp"vjg"rwdnke"ugtxkeg"qh"vjg"Etqyp."oc{"dg0"C"uvcvwvqt{"
tgurqpukdknkv{"ecp"ctkug"htqo"c"ugv"qh"hcevu"ykvjqwv"cp{"qdxkqwu"hcwnv0"Cp"kpuvcpeg"
ku"kp"Barnett v French063"Cu"vjg"tgrqtv"fguetkdgu
Vjg"fghgpfcpv64"ycu"vjg"rtkpekrcn"vtcpurqtv"qhhkegt"qh"vjg"Fgrctvogpv"qh"vjg"
Gpxktqpogpv"ykvj"cp"qhhkeg"kp"Nqpfqp."cpf"kp"qxgtcnn"eqpvtqn"qh"5.722"xgjkengu"
kp"xctkqwu"rctvu"qh"vjg"eqwpvt{0"Jg"ycu"pqokpcvgf"wpfgt"ugevkqp"3::"qh"vjg"
Tqcf"Vtchhke"Cev"3;94"cu"vjg"rgtuqp"tgurqpukdng"hqt"rtqeggfkpiu"kp"tgncvkqp"vq"
xgjkengu"kp"vjg"ugtxkeg"qh"vjg"fgrctvogpv0"Qpg"qh"vjg"fgrctvogpvÓu"xgjkengu"ycu"
hqwpf"rctmgf"ykvj"c"fghgevkxg"v{tg"cv"vjg"ukfg"qh"vjg"tqcf0"Vjg"ftkxgt"ycu"cp"
gornq{gg"qh"vjg"fgrctvogpv0"Vjg"fghgpfcpv."cu"vjg"fgrctvogpvÓu"pqokpgg."ycu"
eqpxkevgf"qh"wukpi"c"oqvqt"nqtt{"ykvj"c"yqtp"v{tg"qp"vjg"jkijyc{0"
"
Ugevkqp"3::"ku"vjg"fgvckngf"Etqyp"crrnkecvkqp"rtqxkukqp0"Kp"dtqcf"vgtou"oquv"qh"
vjg"Cev"crrnkgu"vq"xgjkengu"cpf"rgtuqpu"kp"vjg"rwdnke"ugtxkeg"qh"vjg"Etqyp"cpf"kp"
rctvkewnct"u"62*3+*j+"yjkej"kpeqtrqtcvgu"c"tgiwncvkqp/ocmkpi"rqygt"cdqwv"v{tgu0"
Vjg"SwggpÓu"Dgpej"Fkxkukqp"uwiiguvgf"vjcv"hqt"vjg"hwvwtg."cpf"vq"cxqkf"c"yjqnn{"
kppqegpv"qhhkekcn"jcxkpi"c"nqpi"etkokpcn"tgeqtf."rtqeggfkpiu"eqwnf"dg"kpuvkvwvgf"
cickpuv"c"hkevkqpcn"pqokpcvgf"nkvkicpv."Lqjp"Fqg."fgtkxgf"htqo"vjg"ejctcevgt"yjq"
htgswgpvn{"crrgctgf"dghqtg"3:55"kp"ekxkn"enckou"kp"glgevogpv"vq"fgvgtokpg"fkurwvgu"
cdqwv"ncpf"cnvjqwij"FqG"ycu"cnuq"vjg"wuwcn"cddtgxkcvkqp"qh"vjg"vjgp"Fgrctvogpv"
qh"vjg"Gpxktqpogpv0"
Uvcvwvgu"fq"pqv"korqug"etkokpcn"nkcdknkv{"qp"vjg"Etqyp"kvugnh"dwv"fq"uqogvkogu"qp"
ekxkn"ugtxcpvu"gxgp"kp"vjg"eqwtug"qh"vjgkt"fwvkgu0"Vjwu"vjg"Jgcnvj"cpf"Uchgv{"cv"
Yqtm"gve0"Cev"3;96."u"6:"crrnkgu"Rv"K"qh"vjg"Cev"vq"vjg"Etqyp0"Kv"vjgp"gzegrvu"vjg"
rtqxkukqpu"cu"vq"qhhgpegu"kp"uu"55"vq"64"dwv"u"6:*4+"uc{u"ÒCnvjqwij"vjg{"fq"pqv"
dkpf"vjg"Etqyp."ugevkqpu"55"vq"64"ujcnn"crrn{"vq"rgtuqpu"kp"vjg"rwdnke"ugtxkeg"qh"
vjg"Etqyp"cu"vjg{"crrn{"vq"qvjgt"rgtuqpuÓ0"
Cpqvjgt" crrtqcej" ku" hqt" gzcorng" kp" vjg"Gpxktqpogpvcn" Rtqvgevkqp" Cev" 3;;2.""
u"37;*4+
Pq" eqpvtcxgpvkqp" d{" vjg" Etqyp" qh" cp{" rtqxkukqp" qh" vjku" Cev" qt" qh" cp{"
tgiwncvkqpu"qt" qtfgt" ocfg" wpfgt" kv" ujcnn" ocmg" vjg" Etqyp" etkokpcnn{" nkcdng=""
dwv" vjg" Jkij" Eqwtv" qt." kp" Ueqvncpf." vjg" Eqwtv" qh" Uguukqp" oc{." qp" vjg"
"
"
"
63" ]3;:3̲"3"YNT":6:."*3;:3+"94"Et"Crr"T"4940"Ugg"cnuq"Secretary of State for the Environment v
Hooper"]3;:3̲"TVT"38;0"
64" *CwvjqtÓu"hqqvpqvg+"Ot"Dctpgvv0"
"Litigation" 453"
"
crrnkecvkqp" qh" cp{" rwdnke" qt" nqecn" cwvjqtkv{" ejctigf" ykvj" gphqtekpi" vjcv"
rtqxkukqp."fgenctg"wpncyhwn"cp{"cev"qt"qokuukqp"qh"vjg"Etqyp"yjkej"eqpuvkvwvgu"
uwej"c"eqpvtcxgpvkqp0"
3507" LWFKEKCN"TGXKGY"
Vjg"Etqyp"ku"uwdlgev"vq"lwfkekcn"tgxkgy"cpf"okpkuvgtu"ctg"coqpi"vjg"oquv"htgswgpv"
fghgpfcpvu0"Kh"c"fgekukqp"cdqwv"cp"ceswkukvkqp"qt"fkurqucn"qt"ocpcigogpv"qh"ncpf"
ygtg"xkvkcvgf"d{"c"okuwpfgtuvcpfkpi"qh"vjg"ncy"qt"d{"dkcu"qt"cp"kortqrgt"oqvkxg"
uwej" cu" c" ykuj" vq" qdvckp" c" rqnkvkecn" cfxcpvcig" qt" fkutgictf" qh" c" ngikvkocvg"
gzrgevcvkqp65"vjg" eqwtvu" ecp" kpvgtxgpg" cpf" rtgxgpv" qt" swcuj" c" ytqpi" fgekukqp0"
Vjgtg"ctg"hgy"tgrqtvgf"ecugu"fktgevn{"eqpegtpgf"ykvj"Etqyp"ncpfoquv"qp"vjku"
uwdlgev"kpxqnxg"nqecn"cwvjqtkvkgu066"Qpg"qhvgp"ekvgf"ku"R v Bolsover DC, ex parte
Pepper67"yjgtg"Mggpg"L"uckf
Kv"uggou"vq"og"swkvg"engct"vjcv"vjg"ogtg"hcev"vjcv"c"nqecn"cwvjqtkv{"ku"gzgtekukpi"
c"uvcvwvqt{"rqygt"yjgp"kv"fgekfgu"vq"ugnn"ncpf"ku"pqv"gpqwij"d{"kvugnh"vq"tgpfgt"
kvu"fgekukqp"c"rwdnke"ncy"ocvvgt0"
"
Jg"tghgttgf"vq"R v Lord Chancellor, ex parte Hibbit and Saunders68"kp"yjkej"vjg"
Fkxkukqpcn" Eqwtv" fgekfgf" vjcv" yjgtg" vjg" Nqtf" EjcpegnnqtÓu" Fgrctvogpv" ycu"
gzgtekukpi" eqooqp" ncy" rqygtu" *kp" tgncvkqp" vq" c" vgpfgt" hqt" c" eqpvtcev+" vjgp"
jqygxgt"wphcktn{"kv"jcf"cevgf."cu"vjg"rqygt"ycu"pqv"eqphgttgf"d{"uvcvwvg."lwfkekcn"
tgxkgy" ycu" pqv" cxckncdng0" Kp" eqoogpvkpi" qp" vjcv" fgekukqp" kp"R (Molinaro) v
Kensington and Chelsea Royal London Borough Council69"yjkej" eqpegtpgf" c"
nqecn" cwvjqtkv{Óu"f gekukqp" vq"tghwug" c" xctkcvkqp" vq" c" ngcug" yjgtg"vjg"eqwtv"cnuq"
tghwugf"vq"swcuj"vjg"fgekukqp"pqv"vq"fq"uq."Gnkcu"L"uckf
Kv"oc{"dg"vjcv"vjg"eqwtv"ycu"kphnwgpegf"d{"vjg"itgcvgt"ecwvkqp"vjcv"vjg"eqwtvu"
jcxg"vtcfkvkqpcnn{"ujqyp"vqyctfu"tgxkgykpi"vjg"eqooqp"ncy"rqygtu"qh"vjg"
Etqyp"eqorctgf"ykvj"uvcvwvqt{"rqygtu0"
"
"
65"HMB Holdings Ltd v Cabinet of Antigua and Barbuda"]4229̲"WMRE"590"
66"(Molinaro) v Kensington and Chelsea Royal London Borough Council" ]4224̲" NIT" 558=""
R (Galaxy Land Ltd) v Durham County Council"]4237̲"GYJE"38"*Cfokp+."]4237̲"Cnn"GT"*F+"
323"*Lcp+="R (Ise Lodge Amenity Committee) v Kettering Borough Council"]4224̲"GYJE"3354"
*Cfokp+."]4224̲"Cnn"GT"*F+"747"*Oc{+0"
67" ]4223̲"NIT"65"cv"]52̲0"
68" ]3;;5̲"EQF"5480"
69" ]4224̲"NIT"558"cv"]97̲0"
454" Crown and Government Land"
"
Jqygxgt."vjg"Jqwug"qh"Nqtfu"jgnf"kp"Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister
for the Civil Service6:" *yjkej" eqpegtpgf" vjg" rtgtqicvkxg" rqygt" vq" ocmg"
tgiwncvkqpu"hqt"vjg"cfokpkuvtcvkqp"qh"vjg"ugewtkv{"ugtxkegu+"kp"vjg"yqtfu"qh"Nqtf"
Htcugt"qh"Vwnn{dgnvqp<6;"
vjgtg" ku" pq" tgcuqp" hqt"v tgcvkpi"vjg" gzgtekug" qh" c" rqygt" wpfgt" ctvkeng" 6" cp{"
fkhhgtgpvn{"htqo"vjg"gzgtekug"qh"c"uvcvwvqt{"rqygt"ogtgn{"dgecwug"ctvkeng"6"kvugnh"
ku"hqwpf"kp"cp"qtfgt"kuuwgf"wpfgt"vjg"rtgtqicvkxg"
"
cpf"Nqtf"Fkrnqem<72"
K"ugg"pq"tgcuqp"yj{"ukorn{"dgecwug"c"fgekukqp/ocmkpi"rqygt"ku"fgtkxgf"htqo"
c"eqooqp" ncy" cpf" pqv" c" uvcvwvqt{" uqwteg." kv" ujqwnf" hqt" vjcv" tgcuqp" qpn{" dg"
koowpg"htqo"lwfkekcn"tgxkgy0"
"
Kp" R (Galaxy Land Ltd) v Durham County Council73vjg" eqwtv" swcujgf" vjg"
fgekukqp" qh" c" eqwpekn" vq" fkurqug" qh" ncpf" kp" c"r ctvkewnct"yc{0" Kp" R (Ise Lodge
Amenity Committee) v Kettering Borough Council74" yjkej" cnuq" eqpegtpgf" c"
eqwpekn"fgekukqp"kp"rtkpekrng"vq"ugnn"uqog"ncpf"Iqnftkpi"L"uckf
Vjg"ogtg" hcev" vjcv" c" nqecn" cwvjqtkv{" ku" cevkpi"kp" vjg" rtqeguu" qh" gzgtekukpi" c"
uvcvwvqt{"rqygt"*jgtg"wpfgt"ugevkqp"34575+"ku"pqv"gpqwij"d{"kvugnh"vq"tgpfgt"kvu"
fgekukqp"c"ocvvgt"qh"rwdnke"ncy0"Vjg"vguv"ku"yjgvjgt"kp"rcuukpi"vjg"tguqnwvkqp"kv"
fkf."vjg"nqecn"cwvjqtkv{"ycu"rgthqtokpi"c"rwdnke"hwpevkqp0"
"
Yjkng"pqpg"qh"vjgug"tgncvg"fktgevn{"vq"fkurqucnu"qh"Etqyp"ncpf"vjg"ucog"rtkpekrngu"
uggo"vq"crrn{0"Ukpeg"vjg"3924"Cev"rtqjkdkvu"fkurqucnu"d{"vjg"Etqyp."cp{"rqygt"
vq"fq"uq"owuv"pqy"dg"uvcvwvqt{"cpf"pqv"eqooqp"ncy"dwv"vjg"fgekukqp"vq"ugnn"cpf"
vjg"fkurqucn"vjgougnxgu"yknn"pqv"pgeguuctkn{"dg"rwdnke"hwpevkqpu0"
3508" TGOGFKGU"
350803" Kplwpevkqpu"
Jkuvqtkecnn{"kplwpevkqpu."yjkej"ctg"kuuwgf"wpfgt"vjg"gswkvcdng"lwtkufkevkqp"qh"vjg"
Ejcpegnnqt."eqwnf"pqv"dg"itcpvgf"cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp0"Dtgcej"qh"cp"kplwpevkqp"ku"
"
6:" ]3;:7̲"CE"5960"
6;"" ]3;:7̲"CE"596"cv"6220"
72"" ]3;:7̲"CE"596"cv"6320"
73" ]4237̲"GYJE"38"*Cfokp+."]4237̲"Cnn"GT"*F+"323"*Lcp+0"
74" ]4224̲"GYJE"3354"*Cfokp+."]4224̲"Cnn"GT"*F+"747"*Oc{+"cv"]76̲0"
75" *CwvjqtÓu"hqqvpqvg+"Qh"vjg"Nqecn"Iqxgtpogpv"Cev"3;940"
"Litigation" 455"
"
eqpvgorv"qh"eqwtv"cpf"ku"gphqtegf"gkvjgt"d{"hkpg."yjkej"yqwnf"iq"vq"vjg"Etqyp"kp"
cp{"ecug."qt"d{"kortkuqpogpv0"Vjg"3;69"Cev."u"43"rtqxkfgu
*3+" Kp"cp{"ekxkn"rtqeggfkpiu"d{"qt"cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp"vjg"eqwtv"ujcnn."uwdlgev"
vq"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjku"Cev."jcxg"rqygt"vq"ocmg"cnn"uwej"qtfgtu"cu"kv"jcu"
rqygt"vq"ocmg"kp"rtqeggfkpiu"dgvyggp"uwdlgevu."cpf"qvjgtykug"vq"ikxg"
uwej"crrtqrtkcvg"tgnkgh"cu"vjg"ecug"oc{"tgswktgÏ"
"
*c+" yjgtg"kp"cp{"rtqeggfkpiu"cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp"cp{"uwej"tgnkgh"
ku" uqwijv" cu" okijv" kp" rtqeggfkpiu" dgvyggp" uwdlgevu" dg"
itcpvgf"d{" yc{" qh" kplwpevkqp" qt" urgekhke" rgthqtocpeg." vjg"
eqwtv" ujcnn" pqv" itcpv" cp" kplwpevkqp" qt" ocmg" cp" qtfgt" hqt"
urgekhke"rgthqtocpeg."dwv"oc{"kp"nkgw"vjgtgqh"ocmg"cp"qtfgt"
fgenctcvqt{"qh"vjg"tkijvu"qh"vjg"rctvkgu=""
È"
"
*4+" Vjg"eqwtv"ujcnn"pqv"kp"cp{"ekxkn"rtqeggfkpiu"itcpv"cp{"kplwpevkqp"qt"ocmg"
cp{"qtfgt"cickpuv"cp"qhhkegt"qh"vjg"Etqyp"kh"vjg"ghhgev"qh"itcpvkpi"vjg"
kplwpevkqp"qt"ocmkpi"vjg"qtfgt"yqwnf"dg"vq"ikxg"cp{"tgnkgh"cickpuv"vjg"
Etqyp"yjkej"eqwnf"pqv"jcxg"dggp"qdvckpgf"kp"rtqeggfkpiu"cickpuv"vjg"
Etqyp0"
"
Ugevkqp"5:*4+"rtqxkfgu
ÒEkxkn"rtqeggfkpiuÓ"kpenwfgu"rtqeggfkpiu"kp"vjg"Jkij"Eqwtv"qt"vjg"eqwpv{"eqwtv"
hqt"vjg"tgeqxgt{"qh"hkpgu"qt"rgpcnvkgu."dwv"fqgu"pqv"kpenwfg"rtqeggfkpiu"qp"vjg"
Etqyp"ukfg"qh"vjg"MkpiÓu"Dgpej"Fkxkukqp0"
"
Ugevkqp"43*4+"rtgxgpvu"cp"kplwpevkqp"cickpuv"cp"qhhkegt"qh"vjg"Etqyp"kh"vjg"ghhgev"
yqwnf"dg"vq"ikxg"tgnkgh"yjkej"ecp"pqv"dg"itcpvgf"cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp"kvugnh0"Vjg"
kpvgpvkqp"ku"engctqrgtcvkqp"ku"pqv076"Kp"Re M77"vjg"Jqwug"qh"Nqtfu"jgnf"
vjcv."cnvjqwij"vjg"Etqyp"kvugnh"ecp"pqv"dg"uwdlgev"vq"cp"kplwpevkqp."kv"ku"rquukdng"
vq"kuuwg"qpg"cickpuv"c"Etqyp"ugtxcpv"qt"c"dqf{"tgrtgugpvkpi"vjg"Etqyp"cv"ngcuv"kp"
tgncvkqp"vq"lwfkekcn"tgxkgy"rtqeggfkpiu"*ugg"vjg"Ugpkqt"Eqwtvu"Cev"3;:3."u"53*4++"
dwv" vjg" fkuetgvkqp" vq" itcpv" qpg" ujqwnf" qpn{" dg" gzgtekugf" kp" vjg"oquv" nkokvgf"
ektewouvcpegu ku"rtguwogf"vjcv"vjg"Etqyp"yknn"tgurgev"cp"qtfgt"qh"vjg"eqwtv"
cpf"vjgtg"ujqwnf"dg"pq"tkum"qh"fkuqdgfkgpeg"ngcfkpi"vq"c"hkpg"qt"kortkuqpogpv0"
Cu"Nqtf"Yqqnh"uckf<78"
Kp"ecugu"pqv"kpxqnxkpi"c"iqxgtpogpv"fgrctvogpv"qt"c"okpkuvgt"vjg"cdknkv{"vq"
rwpkuj" hqt" eqpvgorv" oc{" dg" pgeguuct{0" Jqygxgt." cu" ku" tghngevgf" kp" vjg"
"
76"Davidson v Scottish Ministers"]4227̲"WMJN"96."4228"UE*JN+"630"
77" ]3;;6̲"3"CE"5990"
78" ]3;;6̲"3"CE"599"cv"6470"
456" Crown and Government Land"
"
tguvtkevkqpu"qp"gzgewvkqp"cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp."vjg"EtqypÓu"tgncvkqpujkr"ykvj"vjg"
eqwtvu"fqgu"pqv"fgrgpf"qp"eqgtekqp"cpf"kp"vjg"gzegrvkqpcn"ukvwcvkqp"yjgp"c"
iqxgtpogpv"fgrctvogpvÓu"eqpfwev"lwuvkhkgu"vjku."c"hkpfkpi"qh"eqpvgorv"ujqwnf"
uwhhkeg0"
"
Tguvtkevkxg" eqxgpcpvu" ctg" gphqtegcdng" d{" kplwpevkqp" cpf" enckou" vq" gphqteg" c"
tguvtkevkxg" eqxgpcpv" ctg" ekxkn" rtqeggfkpiu0" Vjg" Ugpkqt" Eqwtvu" Cev" 3;:3." u" 72"
rtqxkfgu
Yjgtg"vjg"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcn"qt"vjg"Jkij"Eqwtv"jcu"lwtkufkevkqp"vq"gpvgtvckp"cp"
crrnkecvkqp"hqt"cp"kplwpevkqp"qt"urgekhke"rgthqtocpeg."kv"oc{"cyctf"fcocigu"
kp"cffkvkqp"vq."qt"kp"uwduvkvwvkqp"hqt."cp"kplwpevkqp"qt"urgekhke"rgthqtocpeg0"
"
Cu" vjg" lwtkufkevkqp" vq"cyctf" fcocigu" ku" kp "nkgw " qh" cp" kplwpevkqp." kh" vjcv" ku" pqv"
cxckncdng"wpfgt"u"43"vjgp"pgkvjgt"ctg"fcocigu0"Kv"yqwnf"uggo"vjcv"c"tguvtkevkxg"
eqxgpcpv" ecp" pqv" dg" gphqtegf" cickpuv" vjg" Etqyp" dwv" vjg" eqwtv"oc{" ocmg" c"
fgenctcvkqp"wpfgt"u"43*3+*c+"cpf"fcocigu"oc{"dg"cxckncdng"d{"rtkxkv{"qh"eqpvtcev0"
Uqog"urgekhke"uvcvwvqt{"rtqxkukqpu"cwvjqtkug"kplwpevkqpu"kp"eqpvtcevwcn"ukvwcvkqpu079"
350804" Qvjgt"tgogfkgu"
Vjg"3;69"Cev."u"43*3+*d+"rtqxkfgu
kp"cp{"rtqeggfkpiu"cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp"hqt"vjg"tgeqxgt{"qh"ncpf"qt"qvjgt"rtqrgtv{"
vjg"eqwtv"ujcnn"pqv"ocmg"cp"qtfgt"hqt"vjg"tgeqxgt{"qh"vjg"ncpf"qt"vjg"fgnkxgt{"qh"
vjg"rtqrgtv{."dwv"oc{"kp"nkgw"vjgtgqh"ocmg"cp"qtfgt"fgenctkpi"vjcv"vjg"rnckpvkhh"
ku"gpvkvngf"cu"cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp"vq"vjg"ncpf"qt"rtqrgtv{"qt"vq"vjg"rquuguukqp"
vjgtgqh0"
"
Kp" rtkpekrng" qvjgt" gswkvcdng" tgogfkgu" ecp" dg" cyctfgf" cickpuv" vjg" Etqyp" cu"
fghgpfcpv" wpfgt" u" 430" Pgxgtvjgnguu" c" eqwtv" oc{" dg" tgnwevcpv" vq" qtfgt" vjg"
crrqkpvogpv" qh" c" tgegkxgt" qh" Etqyp" rtqrgtv{" qt" fktgev" cp" ceeqwpv"qh" rtqhkvu0"
Yjgtg"vjg"rtqeggfu"qh"rtqrgtv{"jcxg"eqog"kpvq"vjg"jcpfu"qh"vjg"Etqyp"vjg{"okijv"
dg"uwdlgev"vq"vtcekpi="cp"qtfgt"vq"fgnkxgt"vjgo"wr"yqwnf"dg"qwvukfg"u"43"dwv"c"
fgenctcvkqp"yqwnf"pq"fqwdv"dg"jqpqwtgf0"Tgevkhkecvkqp"cpf"tguekuukqp"yqwnf"dg"
cxckncdng" kp" cp" crrtqrtkcvg" ecug0" Wpfgt" u" 47" gphqtegogpv" ku" qpn{"cxckncdng" kp"
nkokvgf"ektewouvcpegu0"
"
79" Vjg"Rwdnke"Ugtxkegu"Eqpvtcevu"Tgiwncvkqpu"3;;5"*UK"3;;51544:+."tgi"54*9+="vjg"Rwdnke"Uwrrn{"
Eqpvtcevu"Tgiwncvkqpu"3;;7"*UK"3;;71423+."tgi"4;*9+="vjg"Fghgpeg"cpf"Ugewtkv{"Rwdnke"Eqpvtcevu"
Tgiwncvkqpu"4233"*UK"423313:6:+."tgi"87="vjg"Rwdnke"Eqpvtcevu"Tgiwncvkqpu"4237"*UK"42371324+."
tgi"3260"
"Litigation" 457"
"
3509" RTKXCVG"GUVCVGU"CPF"FWEJKGU
Vjg" Nkokvcvkqp" Cev" 3;:2." u" 59*5+" fghkpgu" rtqeggfkpiu" cickpuv" vjg" Etqyp" cu"
kpenwfkpi"vjqug"cickpuv"vjg"Fwejkgu."cpf"u"59*6+"crrnkgu"vjcv"urgekhkecnn{"vq"cevkqpu"
hqt" vjg" tgeqxgt{" qh" ncpf0" Vjcv" ku" uwdlgev" vq" cp" qxgttkfkpi" twng" kp"vjg" Etqyp"
Rtqeggfkpiu"Cev" 3;69." u" 62*3+" yjkej" uc{u" ÒPqvjkpi" kp" vjku" Cev" ujcnn" crrn{" vq"
rtqeggfkpiu"d{"qt"cickpuv."qt"cwvjqtkug"rtqeggfkpiu"kp"vqtv"vq"dg"dtqwijv"cickpuv."
Jku"Oclguv{"kp"Jku"rtkxcvg"ecrcekv{Ó"cpf"u"5:*5+"fghkpgu"Jku"Oclguv{"kp"Jku"rtkxcvg"
ecrcekv{" cu" kpenwfkpi" c" tghgtgpeg" vq" Jku" Oclguv{" kp" tkijv" qh" Jku" Fwej{" qh"
Ncpecuvgt"cpf"vq"vjg"Fwmg"qh"Eqtpycnn0"Pgxgtvjgnguu"yjgtg"c"rtkxcvg"rgtuqp"jcu"
uwhhgtgf"c"ytqpi"kv"pggfu"vq"dg"tgogfkgf0"Cnvjqwij"vjg"Jwocp"Tkijvu"Cev"3;;:"
fqgu"pqv"eqpvckp"c"Etqyp"crrnkecvkqp"ugevkqp"kv"engctn{"gzvgpfu"vq"vjg"iqxgtpogpv"
cpf"yqwnf"dkpf"vjg"tq{cn"guvcvgu"d{"pgeguuct{"kornkecvkqp="wpfgt"vjg"Eqpxgpvkqp"
hqt"vjg"Rtqvgevkqp"qh"Jwocp"Tkijvu"cpf"Hwpfcogpvcn"Htggfqou."Ctv"8"cp{"rgtuqp"
jcxkpi"c"encko"ku"gpvkvngf"vq"c"hckt"jgctkpi"uq"vjgtg"owuv"dg"c"ogcpu"hqt"enckou"vq"
dg"tguqnxgf0"
Vjg"ghhgev"qh"uu"5:*5+"cpf"62*3+"ku"vjcv"vjg"rgvkvkqp"qh"tkijv"rtqegfwtg"ycu"pqv"
cdqnkujgf"hqt"rtqrtkgvct{"cpf"eqpvtcevwcn"enckou"cickpuv"vjg"Rtkxcvg"Guvcvgu"cpf"
vjg"Fwejkgu07:"Kp"rtcevkeg."kh"c"encko"ygtg"vq"ctkug."cttcpigogpvu"eqwnf"dg"ocfg"
hqt" kv" vq" dg" fgvgtokpgf" ykvjqwv" kpxqmkpi" yjcv" yqwnf" pqy" dg" uggp" cu" ctejcke"
rtqegfwtgu0"Vjcv"eqwnf"dg"d{"cnvgtpcvkxg"fkurwvg"tguqnwvkqp"qt"d{"ctdkvtcvkqp"qt"d{"
rtqxkfkpi" c" pqokpcvgf" fghgpfcpv0"Uqog" uvcvwvgu" uwej" cu" vjg" Jqwukpi" Itcpvu."
Eqpuvtwevkqp" cpf" Tgigpgtcvkqp" Cev" 3;;8." u" 339" urgekhkecnn{" crrn{" fkurwvg"
rtqegfwtgu"vq"vjg"Fwejkgu0""
Vjg"rtqrgt"rctv{"kp"tgncvkqp"vq"vjg"Rtkxcvg"Guvcvgu"yqwnf"dg"JO"Cvvqtpg{"Igpgtcn"
cpf"hqt"Ncpecuvgt"vjg"Cvvqtpg{"Igpgtcn"vq"vjg"Fwej{0"Kp"vjg"ecug"qh"c"encko"cickpuv"
vjg"Fwej{"qh"Eqtpycnn"kv"yqwnf"dg"vjg"Cvvqtpg{"Igpgtcn"vq"vjg"Rtkpeg"qh"Ycngu7;"
qt." kh" vjgtg" ygtg" pq" Fwmg." vjg" Cvvqtpg{"Igpgtcn" vq" vjg" Fwej{0" Vjg" Fwmg" qh"
Eqtpycnn"ujqwnf"dg"fkuvkpiwkujgf"htqo"vjg"Rtkpeg"qh"Ycngu"cu"cp"kpfkxkfwcn"yjq"
cu" c" uwdlgev" jcu" pq" urgekcn" rtkxkngigu" *507+0" Wpnkmg" fgrctvogpvu." urgekhke"
rgthqtocpeg" ecp" dg" cyctfgf"wpfgt" vjg" Fwej{" qh" Eqtpycnn" Ocpcigogpv" Cev"
3:85."u"56"cickpuv"vjg"Mggrgt"qh"vjg"Tgeqtfu"qh"vjcv"Fwej{0"
Hqtogtn{"kv"ycu"pqv"ncyhwn"hqt"vjg"Ujgtkhh"vq"ngx{"gzgewvkqp"d{"ytkv"qh"fieri facias"
ykvjkp"c"tq{cn"rcnceg"yjkej"ycu"c"tq{cn"tgukfgpeg82"*405+0"Ejcvvgnu"dgnqpikpi"vq"
vjg" Etqyp" ygtg" cnuq" gzgorv" htqo" ugk¦wtg083" Ycttcpvu" qh" gzgewvkqp" ctg" pqy"
"
7:" Ugg"vjg"Nkokvcvkqp"Cev"3;:2."u"59*7+0"
7;"A-G to the Prince of Wales v St Aubyn"*3:33+"Ykijv"389."367"GT"34370"
82"A-G v Dakin *3:8;Î92+"NT"6"JN"55:0"
83"Secretary of State for War v Wynne"]3;27̲"4"MD":670"
458" Crown and Government Land"
"
iqxgtpgf"d{"vjg"Vtkdwpcnu."Eqwtvu"cpf"Gphqtegogpv"Cev"4229."Rv"5"yjkej"d{"u":;"
dkpfu"vjg"Etqyp0"Wpfgt"u":;*4+"vjg"pgy"rtqegfwtgu"qh"gphqtegogpv"d{"vcmkpi"
eqpvtqn"qh"iqqfu"ecp"pqv"dg"wugf"vq"tgeqxgt"fgdvu"fwg"htqo"vjg"Etqyp."vq"vcmg"
eqpvtqn" qh" qt" ugnn"iqqfu" qh" vjg" Etqyp" *kpenwfkpi" iqqfu" qypgf" d{"vjg"Etqyp"
lqkpvn{" qt" kp" eqooqp"ykvj" cpqvjgt" rgtuqp+." qt" vq" gpvgt" rtgokugu" qeewrkgf" d{""
vjg"Etqyp0"
"
"
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeUnlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations