Pierce v Bemis (Lusitania)
| Jurisdiction | England & Wales |
| Court | Queen's Bench Division |
| Date | 1985 |
| Year | 1985 |
Admiralty - Salvage - Sunken wreck - Crown's claim to droit of Admiralty - Vessel sunk in international waters - Whether “derelict” - Chattels from liner brought into United Kingdom - Whether droit of Admiralty available to Crown -
The Lusitania, a passenger liner outward bound for New York, was torpedoed by a German submarine on 7 May 1915. She was abandoned and sank outside United Kingdom territorial waters. Insurers compensated the owners for her loss and the ship and the contents belonging to the owners became the property of the insurers. In 1982, the vessel was located on the sea bed and the claimants salvaged a number of chattels and brought those items into the United Kingdom. The third defendant, acting for and on behalf of the Crown, asserted a droit of Admiralty and claimed to be entitled to retain for the Crown all items brought ashore within the United Kingdom and in respect of which no title had been proved.
On the claimants seeking a declaration that, in the absence of the true owners, they had a good title to the items that had been either part of the passengers' personal property or part of the cargo:—
Held, granting the declaration, (1) that a ship that had been abandoned by her master and crew without any intention of returning to her became a derelict whether the ship remained afloat or sank; that, accordingly, the locating of the Lusitania was the locating of a derelict and, being a derelict, was within the definition of “wreck” in section 510 of the Merchant Shipping Act 1894; and that, therefore, Part IX of that Act applied to the retrieval of the contents as being wreck (post, pp. 505A–B, H–506A, D–E, H–507A).
(2) That, by section 523 of the Merchant Shipping Act 1894, the Crown's right to claim a droit of Admiralty was limited to an unclaimed wreck found in United Kingdom territorial waters; that, although section 518 had been extended by section 72 of the Merchant Shipping Act 1906 so that, where a wreck lying outside territorial waters was found and brought within the United Kingdom, the finder had the duty to deliver the wreck to the receiver of wrecks, the Act of 1906 had not altered or extended the Crown's right over wrecks; and that, therefore, there was no droit of Admiralty over the wreck and in the absence of the true owners, the claimants had good title (post, pp. 515B–C, F–G, H–516E, G).
The following cases are referred to in the judgment:
Aquila, The (
Armory v. Delamirie (
Association, The and The Romney [
Bradley v. H. Newsom, Sons and Co. [
Cossman v. West (
Escoigne Properties Ltd. v. Inland Revenue Commissioners [
Gas Float Whitton (No. 2), The [
H.M.S. Thetis (
H.M.S. Thetis (
Parker v. British Airways Board [
Rex v. Property Derelict (
Tubantia, The [
The following additional cases were cited in argument:
Attorney-General v. De Keyser's Royal Hotel Ltd. [
Crystal, The [
Fulham, The [
Rex. v. Forty-Nine Casks of Brandy (
Rex. v. Two Casks of Tallow (
Sabally and N'Jie v. Attorney-General [
Simon v. Taylor [
ACTION
By a writ of summons dated 22 December 1983 and issued out of the Admiralty Registry the plaintiffs, John Elvet Pierce of Chirk, North Wrexham, Clwyd, Wales, and Barry Frederick George Lister of Carrog, Corwen Clwyd, Wales, sought a declaration, inter alia, that they were entitled to hold some or all the items recovered from the Lusitania on trust for sale for themselves.
By their defence, the third defendants, Department of Transport, did not admit that the plaintiffs had an entitlement to the items salved and asserted that they, for and on behalf of the Crown, were entitled to retain for the Crown all items recovered and brought ashore within the United Kingdom and in respect of which no title had been proved by other claimants.
The facts are stated in the judgment.
Charles Macdonald for the plaintiffs.
Richard Aikens for the Department of Transport.
29 November. SHEEN J. read the following judgment. Before this action came to trial the plaintiffs and the first, second, fourth and fifth defendants had composed their differences. They now present a united front. I shall refer to all of them collectively as “the claimants.” The only issue which the court now has to decide is an issue between the claimants and the third defendants who can conveniently be referred to as “the Crown.” The claimants and the Crown have agreed all the relevant facts, which I will set out.
On 7 May 1915 the British registered passenger liner Lusitania was torpedoed by submarine U-20 of the Imperial German Navy. Shortly afterwards she sank in a position distant 11.8 miles and bearing south-south-west of Head of Kinsale, Eire. The depth of water in that position is about 315 feet. That position was and is outside British and Irish territorial sea.
At the time of her loss the Lusitania was the property of the Cunard Steamship Co. Ltd. and was entered for war risks insurance with the London and Liverpool War Risks Association Ltd. That company paid the owners in respect of the total loss of the ship. The insurers thereby acquired legal title to the ship. It is agreed between all parties that the first and second defendants are now legally entitled to the vessel, including her hull, machinery, appurtenances, fixtures and fittings and the accoutrements, loose equipment, furniture or other goods owned at the time of the loss by the Cunard Steamship Co. Ltd. and used in her operation as a passenger liner.
At the time of her loss the Lusitania contained two further categories of chattel, namely, (a) the personal property and effects of her passengers, and (b) a quantity of general cargo. These two categories of chattel will be referred to as “the contents.”
In 1982 salvage operations were performed on the wreck, as follows. (a) Between 22 April and 1 May 1982 the wreck was surveyed. (b) Between 27 July and 30 August 1982 a ship's bell was recovered using a Scorpio remotely controlled submarine working from the vessel Myra Vag. (c) Between 10 September and 25 October 1982 a number of items were recovered by divers working from the vessel Archimedes. Apart from the ship's bell, some 94 items were salved. Some of these are agreed to be part of the vessel and others are agreed to be part of her contents. The issue for the court to decide is whether the claimants on the one hand or the Crown on the other hand have or has the better title to the contents.
The Merchant Shipping Act 1894 (to which I shall refer as “the Act” or, if the context so requires, “the principal Act”) is “an Act to consolidate Enactments relating to Merchant Shipping.” Part IX of the Act, which contains sections 510 to 571 (inclusive), must have been intended to be a comprehensive statement of the law relating to wreck and salvage. Sections 510 to 517 deal with vessels in distress. Sections 518 to 522 prescribe what should happen when a person finds or takes possession of any wreck within the limits of the United Kingdom. Sections 523 to 529 are entitled “unclaimed wreck” and deal with the right of the Crown and with the disposal of unclaimed wreck. Subsequent sections deal with the removal of wrecks, offences in respect of wreck, marine store dealers and salvage. This was a clear code. If the application of section 518 had not been extended the problem with which this court is now concerned would not have arisen because there would not have been any obligation on the claimants to deliver the contents to the receiver of wreck. Before turning to consider the relevant provisions of the Act it is necessary to understand the meaning of certain words.
For the purposes of definition it is convenient to quote first from Chitty's Treatise on the Law of the Prerogatives of the Crown (1820). The author said, at p. 148:
“Wreck (properly so called) is where goods shipwrecked are cast upon the land; and goods which are termed flotsam, jetsam and ligan, become and are deemed wrecks if they be cast upon the land. All these species of wreck prima facie belong to, and were originally in, the Crown by virtue of his prerogative. Being rights of a secondary nature they may belong to a subject by express grant or prescription, and are frequently vested in Lords of manors. If however a subject prescribe or have a grant, for wreck only, he shall not have jetsam, flotsam or ligan.”
My second quotation is from the judgment of Lord Esher M.R. in The Gas Float Whitton No. 2 [
“We begin with Sir Henry Constable's Case (
1601 )5 Rep. 106a , which defines what is ‘wreck of the sea,’ and that ‘flotsam’ is when a ship is sunk, or otherwise perished, and the goods float on the sea; ‘jetsam’ is when the ship is in danger of being sunk, and to lighten the ship the goods are cast into the sea, and afterwards notwithstanding the ship perish; ‘lagan’ is when the goods which are so cast into the sea, and afterwards the ship perishes, and such goods cast are so heavy that they sink to the bottom, and the mariners, to the intent to have them again, tie to them a buoy or cork, or such other thing that will not sink, so that they may find them again; … and none of these...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Argentum Exploration v The Silver
... ... [1919] AC 16, 24–25 ; Court Line v The King (1945) 78 Lloyd's Rep 390 , 396 Col 2 ; Pierce v Bemis (the Lusitania) [1986] 1 QB 384, 388D ... 64 A cargo also becomes ... ...
-
Re ""La Lavia""
...237. Pine Valley Development v. Minister for the Environment [1987] I.R. 23; [1987] I.L.R.M. 747. Pierce v. Bemis [1986] Q.B. 386; [1986] 2 W.L.R. 501; [1986] 1 All E.R. 1011. The Earl of Eglington (1855) 8 L.T. 178; 166 E.R. 989. The Industry (1835) Hagg. 203. The Santa Maria de la Rosa (U......
-
The Queen (on the application of David Knight) v Secretary of State for Transport Edward Huzzey and Another (Interested Parties)
... ... in Pierce v Bemis, The Lusitania [1986] 1 QB 384 at pp.391 and 398. The statutory scheme is therefore of ... ...
-
Chapter 24: Abandonment
...See The WD Fairway (No 2) [2009] EWHC 889 (Admlty); [2009] 2 Lloyd's Rep 191, [41]. See further post, §24.88. 142 See esp Pierce v Bemis (The Lusitania) [1986] QB 384; and generally Kennedy & Rose, §§4.059–4.066, 143 See The Douglas (1882) 7 PD 151, 160, per Brett LJ; SS Utopia (Owners ......
-
Chapter 8: Salvage and Wreck
...(Sweet and Maxwell, 2nd ed, 1993) at paragraph 3–06, n 13 it is doubted that the term “craft” would apply to jet skis. In The Lusitania [1986] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 132 Sheen J held that items salvaged from the Lusitania were “wreck” for the purposes of Part IX of the Merchant Shipping Act 1894 as ......
-
Salvage and Wreck
...236 will not have any effect in determining title to wreck not yet claimed or of which possession has not yet been taken; see The Lusitania [1986] Q.B. 384. For an examination of the operation of the section in its earlier form see in general, again, The Lusitania [1986] Q.B. 4 The failure ......
-
Table of cases
...Exchange Ass Co (1798) 7 TR 505 11.60, 15.32 Pickup v Thames & Mersey Mar Ins Co Ltd (1878) 3 QBD 594 26.25, 26.29 Pierce v Bemis (The Lusitania) [1986] QB 384 Piermay Shipping Co SA v Chester (The Michael) [1979] 1 Lloyd's Rep 55; affd [1979] 2 Lloyd's Rep 1 15.33–15.35passim, 26.20, 2......