Queen Mary University of London v LSY & Ors
| Judge | Deputy Master Henderson |
| Neutral Citation | [2024] EWHC 2386 (Ch) |
| Year | 2024 |
| Court | Chancery Division |
| Counsel | Ms Myriam Stacey Kc,Ms Galina Ward Kc,Mr Jamie Burton Kc |
| Date | 20 September 2024 |
[2024] EWHC 2386 (Ch)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE Claim No: PT
2024 000483
BUSINESS AND PROPERTY COURT
CHANCERY DIVISION
Before Deputy Master Henderson
BETWEEN
QUEEN MARY UNIVERSITY OF LONDON
(1) LSY
(2) MBC
(3) PERSONS UNKNOWN
(IN OCCUPATION OF QUEEN MARY UNIVERSITY OF LONDON)
(4) FDE
(5) JST
Counsel and solicitors:
!"#$%&
%
'( )"!)!*
"(!)!)!*
"+,
1
- . )"!)!*/0(+12
,$3(440
(-
!- 44+1 !
4/ )"!)!*-
!(1+1
4+12(
$(+12,56Plan67$
3((0
(-(
+12(84(4
14$ !$+1
9(4
4*:-
;- #4 !2
14/<
"!)!*-%(1($/-
*- 414$ !$+1
9($8
8-.+1
+12=((+18
($/49
*:-01(
4$/(1
14$
$8 !$(4
-/43-
>($/3
-
4
*: ?"!)!*-
:- >(1((+12=(
/49+111
41
($4
14(,1
'@(5A,'@B7-/(1
2
3 -)) )"+1C8
4-
D- 4(((
48 E$!*F!D!?; "!)!*$4
3((1
$;))(-
44G2#(-4
48(
+1444
ABG2#(-$4(8$
4(G2
#(2-2814
(->(1$4
-/4((-
E- /14$1((1
0($8(4
0(+12((4-
>(/$/4
(14(--
?- 4G+1=5A+1B7-/
4(+84-/44
,+1$3(44
+1-
)- 4+18
(-/4(
H-
- (/-
>(($+11
(141
/$(9
I-+18
J4/1-
!- ;!)!*-
;-
3
;- - .:"!)!*+1((
+84@::-
;-!- .D"!)!*$1(1
1(44
'(1
148($
A0( )
"0(-1
$1@::-:5!757$4(
1414$
4;D"!)!*-B
;-;- 4(4-
;-*- /49149-
;-:- #(
$($(0
(-/04
!5=K#7-
;-D- 441=K#-
;- 944-
/440-
;-E- 4+144
(547-/4
+1((
((4-
;-?- 4$4(+1$
1,
+14
-
;- )- +1/4
444-
;- - .#2=K#$/
44(04(
(1$((
::::-E5!71@$4A(
(4-B
;- !- /494L
44
"-/0
4
+12
-
;- ;- /(19(11$8
0(
) )"4;$411
334-
;- *- 40(0-
(
441(
1-
;- :- .
4/ )"!)!*
04(-
;- D- # ?"!)!*=K#(1
1(!)"5!7(
(-
;- /4
0(
4((4
-/-
0(4/4
(4$
0$4$
((::::-E5!71@$
A((4
-B@3$4/
4/(
4/4
$4C((
44-
;- E- =K2#2
?"31
=(>>((3
+1(4
;- ?- /(
+12
!)"$!*"/3(
8(9
+!*"<"-/
8-/14(4
5
5@*)- !7(
4-
;-!)- #!)"!)!*+1(
11$4/(!*"!)!*-
;-! - #E"!)!*+1(
(,41
-/(1
114
11!*"-
;-!!- >$44
!4/
)"!)!*$/4(
-
*- 11+14
*- - #5A#B7$44
+1-
*-!- ,5A,B7$44..L-
*-;- (=((5A=((B7$44+12
,3.-
:- ( )"4(+12@
::-
D- +@::-E5!74(@
::4((4
-1C
0(@!*4
(45
M!)! N,>1 E;:$M!)!!N =@ )*D$=4="- ;
*7-
#
334-$1
H1$(/411
(1$
1$H
(11->$(4
6
0(@!*$/84
5$7
((4$$4(1(-
E- >(1149+1 !
-,3(111(4
+12440$
4(4494 $)))(3
E- - .; O:O!*5(7
E-!- .*ODO!*,$ -
E-;- .*ODO!*,$AB!
-
E-*- .*ODO!*#-
E-:- . ! ?ODO!*'P-
E-D- . !!)ODO!*-
E- . !!)ODO!*@%-
E-E- . !!:ODO!*=K5 7-
E-?- . !!:ODO!*#5!7-
E- )- .!O-
E- - .!O
E- !- . !*O -
E- ;- . !*O -
E- *- .EO
?- 410(
""M!)!*N,'
<
!)- /""29(
+12
444'@(>
??E5A'@>B7,'@$4(
-4J+1
$/(C$
0(/$4$4
14((((-
! - /144
C
! - - >4$8(
2,'@((48$
(41
7
+1$
(Q
! -!- /1+1
((((
144
,'@(4Q
! ! "#$%&
!!
! !'
!!- +1(,
-$($
,-(
-+1
,-$4/+12,$/
+12(40
1-+18-
!;- +12(,0
(45A(B71
-/414
3$/213
+1
+1-
!*- /A1B(40+12
%5AB7-
3-,C+12
+121-
4A1B4(-
1+12
->($(
3(
-/444
$4+1
4(-
!:- +14 ;4
8$-/0(
((
(,
8
R(1(
$-
!D- -+1(4
$
,-1
-$ 29
A ?-M---N%11(14
-4
-/$444#
*!)!*$444
441-
!)-11
((LO44
;!)!*-44-4
444(((-M---N
! -M---N1+1(
4444
441-/4+12
$(-M---NBB
!
14(
! 1 D,
(4(
3(S,-,2
1( D
L$(,
(44AB-'41$
14(1 !
4- D4
AB-A
B8,
1( :-8(
-
!
-,4
-'41$11
4(1 !
4-!!4A
B- D-
9
(A
+14J$1
D-B
!
AB-$(
($ D!!-
AC1$
1$/448
- >$
+12$(
(($44-
!- +12
-
;- +1C4-
/$+141
8(-B
,4441-'41$
;"!)!*%&%$$
#4($A
;"!)!*$
4-B/;"$%&%
A1G+1=
,5TG+=,275A
B79
G2#(---B$
+12;"
$$4
-
!
4J4C@::-D-
!E- >!*,AB
C(3,29$
14441/1
-AB$/48
-
!?- 4
1(-
.((R3
10
(1($$1
((1$
(4$4((
(-/4(
4L'(,.L4$C
8(+14
$4(40(
->4,
.L1844(044
(
1Q
;)- /4(48(4#
4-//4(
28(
((
$$! )M!)!;N+*
0(84-
; - '41$#2(($
/(
(((((
-
;!- >L(
+14
-L4
+1-/$
$+1(1((0$
(-
;;- /1$/
484(
(44(4
-.114
1(44(
((141
$4-""23-
;*- ((
(4(
11
4(+1
41(
44
144
2-/14
4/$/11
4((
4-'41$31$14
48(-
;:- >4
84,$4
(4(-1-
14,($
4(+1J
(-(
$((+15-E
""27-
;D- /""2418(
4$1""
84
-(""2(-
141
14G2#(->$
;AB+1$
41$(
($4A9(1
(4(,B-A,B4
+12,31-!D"
AG+=,B=(($1(
($A4((
41-B/
0(4(
(,4
-
;
#(
12
; .!)%!)!*G+=>*5(
47(
=C,-
; . *11(8
=C$C+1=-
;
144(+12#/./1
(+124
4D-
; .; G2
#((;HG2#(-
;
(
44
; . "(
4G2#(-1
4(,
=C4P(
-
;
4 "-
;E- >(/44$
34,$3
4401-
;?- /48(
,'@(48
;?- - +C+12
-
;?-!- 4(
41(13$-
;?-;- ,114$4
(4
44 )"-
;?-*- 4(4$
)"$$($4
,+14
,-
13
*)- >(,'@(48
$(8(
1+141,'@
>?$ ) ,'@$> *$>
%,'@-
* - >?11(-> )
11(3-> 1
1(
4-/(C9R5
($74(09
57457(
-
*!- > %11(
01
301
4(4-+12
4(4(
>-2,
4+12
0R41$
$44-
*;- /0(8($
0942(>?$ )
-
**- /4(43(>
?$ ) ((+124(
,'@(1(-'41$
""2(4/1
-/12
18(4
(?$ ) 1-
*:- =8(9C9?$ ) (A
4B+1(C-8(
(::1@-
8($4-
14
*D- =8(C9?$ ) (A
(B8(
(+12(4
> %,'@4$
3-($
$4A(B-
*
+12($
(-5 7
014L0
($5!7401$5;7
114(
101$5*7(12
J2((
01$341$
4(-
*E- L4(1((4
4-(A4(4
B $$! M!) )N+*:$M!) N!> )*
=(@M:*N-/((
(L04C9
1(48(1
""MDEN-
*?- @4
+1201-5
7((
3""MD?N-
:)- =111
101-/(1+13
-/(1+18
011-41
12,'@(-4
1(-,1
1$41
84(
->01->
(41
4$41$11((
15
+11-44
112(1
1((+1-
: - #/43?$
) (-(2
444$
(3-11
43(
4-4$41$44
13,'@(4(1
(+1$14441
J1-
:!- +14434
3,'@(-/41-
4$((4+1$
4-(4(1-
4-/1(
?$ ) 14(($
((4AMN
MNB*!+!!5!) D7D;,'@@;*M?
(1(4(9
3-
:;- >($+12(44(
517-4$8(
;"(48574
(3-
:*- %$12(
5(9(744((
01+1((
4-49
->(2(
>?$ ) ,'@18(
-
::- > *,'@10(
,'@4(
3$$$(($($$
($4$$-
16
1+1
-/1$3$
$1((1(->4
+1
1($4
H+12144
-1(((
2(+121
4/1$84
(1+14/2
I((1H
+1(1H
(-((%&%2;"
4#1(
(44(
14-%&%AB
+"44(4
1(-.(
$4#+1
4((
(4
4(4+1-
:D- %$$3444
(+12
($4
4(-44
JJ+1(
-
:(0(J
4$C8(
$J(J
44$/-'41$
J(
$(0((91
4((1-
:E- /41
($1+144$
8(409
4,'@(-
17
:?- $4$8(
2,'@((48$
(41+1$
4(-
D)- C1$444
1+1
((((14
42,'@(
4-C44
!R1#
$
4 !+1
((4+1-
40((
>1-//
41
+1-(
-.0(4
(((-'41$/
4(14
41+1$/4-#(
/3
$8(8((4
+124-
)"$ ,-
D - / *"!)!*,+14
(((44-
4+12%5AB7-
D!- +14
-*;,5!7> ?ED$'(
,@>!)
>!)!;-
D;- . )"!)!*$5 7F5;7-*;,5!7> ?ED
$1
5 7,11(1
48
18
4
4$
1(8-
5!75 7157
$$
1
(4U
57141
R
5701-
5;7(1(1$414
((5 71
$8
(U
574$
4
(U
57(4
44(
9R
57148
441
9R
57C4
(1R(4
(1(-B
D*- 11'(,5%7>
!)!;4 )"!)!*-
D:- 114(
D:- - - -+1((
(((C-/
4+1
4(3
A)!
./!
! !!
! 001B
D:-!- !- $41
19
A$
$44
J+1$41(8$
44J+1-B
D:-;- ;- $41$
A+1
4*;
,5!7> ?ED$'(,
@>!)
!)!;B-
D:-*- ;-
A,C>!) )+11(
$1$
1C(4
+12-/(
(1-B
D:-:- *- $141
A
7 (+1R
7 M---N
7 +1M---N
7 11$(1$(
1$$$($
+1G+$1$
((+1G+$
+1G+(($
411385
T127R
7 M---NB
D:-D- :-;41
A,343(41(
+12059+17$
+18$
(1(
3(144-B
D:-
A/$+111
((4
4$431444J
-B
D:-E- :-:41
20
A>$+1(4(144(
($1
1114
344-B
D:-?- D- 41
A18(
J1-B
D:- )- D-!41
A@
(5T
.L27-B
D:- - D-D41
A%15
/@/
T(.L21(
1$,$
($T(.L21-B
D:- !- 4
4(44((1-
14841
8(-
$4$
1$+1444-/($
+144144$
3$1C
7 J4
11R
7 $(4
(L
+1R
7 1
(14
(R
7 R
7 ((((C
R
7 811+1
$(
4((($(
(-
21
$1
114J$8$4$
(11
8-
(
((($
J4L
-1
$3$
+1-
$L
1((C19$
$$3$-+14
11
44-
14
-4414
31$(
1-
%$+11
>(0(+12
4(.L-
/(.L1
1+1G+(-
1$1((($0(
14-
14+1$
41(+1(
($C-
+11(
$(+1(
(32
114$
(H4:-;-B
DD- /*-
A1B-
22
D /*- 57
1-
DE- /
+1C14-
D?- /1$
(1$144
(41
,-
(4(4(4
(48(-/44
4((4((>#R4
4-
4/4%2!&!M E?;N # *!-/1
(4($
44523M ???N>!*)7$
(14(4+12
,-4$$
$(-
)
< - +12 ;!)!*-
,44
-$( ; * 2 $
A ;-G+=>*5474 !
%!)!*(-9
4(=C,
!)%!)!*-
*-1!)%!)!*$8=C
,(-
4J-44
G+=-3/
84!/49
23
%!
4$41-/
(11(9
41-B
# ;$(,(4
($8->
(4(8-
> ;*; ;$(+1113
(4G2#(-((
4G2#(-> *) >((( ;A
C-# D))C4-
<:- class="_ _3"> . *C4-#;)4!:
!C4G2#(-
,31G+1=BAG+1
=B41-((
9(4
AWe, the members of the encampment, are writing this letter to:
%C(4G+1=25G+=7
,315,728
(($
494R
4G+=2(2$
C(((IR
>3G+=211(/
R
G+=2((4
(41$1(
8(
-B
<$(
((4C41
$((42
4+1(
I-
< /9((A#8(B$
3+1
24
4(10-
(+1A4
(B-
A1B+14
(A(C$
14
/-B
<
A1$
1$G+=$1
1111(
/$((H
I-BAB
4((A$1(
(G+=2-B
<
A14$1
>((
G+=-B-(A1
0$1
24C-B
< /1C ;14$/
#$
+1$*!)!;((
AM1NB
+1A44B4/1-
4A8
B(A+12
(-B
19(444
(
-/14
1(3(
(A#8(B-44
A11($
(( ;!)!*$(9(
1(4(,B-
- 4
57(444
25
4+12(3$
4-
E)- . *8=C$C
+1=-.$4#48(=
C$8(
#((4
-4#4
4>1$((G2#(4
(4-4((
(#-
E - / *+11
44(334-
43$
31!4
A!)-.441(
3$48->8
(($
->((
$41(
84-/14
(44
(((39-
(4(3:;)
1-(84
3-
! -43
944(
D*:-,141
-(44
-4
(*:-4($($
(-
-
E!- /( : *",
A>41(1
-,341
(-A,
26
E;- 491(4AG+==/#,@E,V.,B-/
4-
913-49
A',+=,
: .P(8
; 148V&888(W
: K848
D;) P(B
E*- 4
A',+=,
> G+/,+K,'
;) .////%>>>=
!;) .@/>/%=.,@>/
D)) >#.=/'./%++@,,>'.+B
E:- ,218(1C
4(-
ED- 4$ :-,
41(
+12,-4AB
:!)!*+14
A(48J4
(B-,((
!)!*
A48(
4(
+1414(->
1$+14(11
8C81-B
E ,2 4
1( :114R(
(-,3,EA,3EB
*"!)!*(
4(4+12(-+$
494
414144
-(,3E44$
27
(H($((+12
(-/$(-,1
8/(441(4
48((-
EE- !AB :4($
4
A:;-/ :!)!*$ E;)$
,((G+=
=V-
:*-,@($
(-
::-/441(
$4414(
1(-/4414,2
4(!*$(D
:D-
((
448-
4-
:
(1084
41
((-4
(
4+1(-
:E-48G#($
(C4J
44(-
31$4J(4
$4(-
# E"!)!*$/494
J(4$44+1
1(-
:?->81
84((-
(488-
D)-/$
(108(((4
-#$G+=2
8(848-
28
D -44(8(
8(-44G+=-4
1G2#($(
414
G2#($(($$
(-
D!-/48(1
M3# :N-444(4-(
44
(-
D;-1$44($-G+=2
((44
4
4-
D*-.9$J
(-.4$?4
-G+=2
114
-
D:->440$
4
414-G+=2
144$4($
1($>(4
J$4(4444
((14-
$(0-B
E?- ,4A4B48(
1(+1
((-3
1444'
08( 3
1(8(
448J
-/411(
-
?)- . :#J-
134
29
A1$5 ;7
(4114
G2#(M---N
A((H,M---N
A(($4G
/,->+114
4-1
1J-/
4($M---N
+14L3
$414J$
L14944-
8C
-(
J(1+1$
4((1-4
8144(
4$
$+11
-B
? - /(; *"$,
A. D!)!*$/+114
1$1 :!)!*$4(
(4(8J$$
$+1(-C$#$
JM---NB
?!- ,444(+1
A14B->#2 D
43-@134
A/4(4((((
,-
/(5 :784
,4(
$8$
4J-
/(418
4J-
M---NB
30
?;- A(B4(4(
$01$8(84(G2
#(-.1$(8
5784
(R57(844
(($4
41(R57((8
8-
?*- . D,4-,
41(-,
4AB43
(S4((-
?:- D441,2..L
+1-@134
A$
M---N
>4$8
-134G
441-
(5 :7(G
$8$
4J-
8(44
J-B
?D- ,!!41-
!!441#2-/4
-/ D
C+1-/
A+14
J-B
?
414(BA
B-441$
AB-
?E- /AB#,$
31
AH48
-(4844
H1
-B
??- / 29$
4T42
(547-
))- 9AB#,
A>,B(-/A'>P,K.+,,
.+@.,@>/..%%/,@QB(,-+
(,24(3
A/%%.+=,>,/@,.',,>,.+/,G+,,#+/=/
--,/==NOT#,@,.P/.+@>.@>/.',
,>,+/=.+@,>>@,,
#,/1H(((
WB
) - /11,1((
-/11,A((B1
H(-'41$+1,4
+1(14
3+1214$:-;
$343(+1
41(+120$+18
$(-
)!- AB4494
J34(#-/4
>,
'>P,K.+,,.+@@//=,QMN
M(#N
.=/#>/=,K
/%%.+=,>,/@,.',,>,.+/,G+,,#+/=/
--,/==NOT#,@,.P/.+@>.@>/.',
,>,+/=.+@,>>@,,
32
(4
$(B
);- /11#-/
11#-'
111+12(
(14/
I
4/R$/4$
(4,(4-
)*- ,1(#
$+14C8
8-
1441@-
'41$$8$4148
R4(R
1481-
):- !,2#2
4(3((-(134
,#4-
)D- >! --
/414H(
-(C
-49(4
14((-48
-+12$
4-!
84+1
4-
) CAB44->/
1$
448-
)E- /*",A+1B1
4-44
(+1$3$-
9
3(0A2
33
B4A443(B5
47A-B%$,54
(47$A48
98-B
)?- !(44,3-
>( )F !
A )-/,4$(*?
((4(1(
3,/
-
-2(4-
44(((((
3-48
-/4
J4$4-'41$
$
3-(1$((
43(
($4(44-
!-40(4
-
4448
-
448-G+=2
4444444-
4118-B
)- ,44547
1(1(G2#($
A4(9IB547-
- ,4-
($
4(98
1-AM4$
N
48-B
4$+12J$9
8(91
$+1$O+1(-
34
!- >4(1##4
E-4-
;- ,8(93(141
4'4'L
((-
*- .!;>1
4+12#/./1(-
4,-
:- ,4547$A
44
(-B,4
1-,21
4
A/4444
- >1$449G4(
#/./1#(-+1/
44441-.
$/114+1
J-14( )F :
4(1-/
11(
4((((
4-.((A
1B-
- /4$441
5(G41C
47-+((
$41(
(-B
D- !21$4$
J$,21
(4((
((-!
AE)-/574
(((38
M3#!)N$4
(1-D(
M3#! N-
35
E -4((1/
4-.1$/4
4#/./1(
-.$
1(G+=,
48(-
G+=J44(
-
E!-/3
((+2
1((4G
=$41X
( !1I$-
E;->444($
41
44($(48-
11G+=
J4$4
44-
1
44(814$
(411-
E*->4(1$-4
)-
E:-M---N
ED-43-B
,14+1
$4
,-
E- .!*!:4$0
44(4441
-
?- .;" !25%&%7
+1$A%>.#B-;"!!(
-/9(
A1G+1=,
5TG+=,275AB79
G2
36
#(G2+1$=-
($G2+1=$5T+127-B
!)- 9((A/B
44-
A41
((+124$
($((4(
/I#8-
(3((4
-+1218
((14(O
(-/$(((
(457-
+12 :!)!*$
D!)!*$!!!)!*!*!)!*(
+12(-
+1
-B
! - %&%2;"!)!*18
(4
1(-
A18
(41
(-
184($
Y1(-
Y(O14
$J-
Y811
$J-
Y4J3
-111
(J
11-
Y18-
Y4J4
(-
Y1C(-
37
Y4J1$($
-
Y11-
Y814-
YJ$3
11-
Y11J44
0((4(-/
1-
Y11C1
-1
(131-
Y48418(3
41 ?-
4(84(1$(
-
Y>R
41L1
-
4491$4
4-
90+1
1
4(11H-B
!!- %&%2;"2
-9$1
(4((
!!- - AH4/IB-
!!-!- A/=4@(B-
!!-;- AK=(.(B-+(
!!-;- - >?,'@-
!!-;-!- > ),'@-
!!-;-;- > *,'@-
!!-;-*- -*;,5-!7> ?ED-
!!-;-:- '(,@>!)
!!-;-D- ,C>!) )-
!!-*- A#+12B-+(
!!-*- - -
!!-*-!- >A,B-
!!-*-;- +12/1-
38
!!-*-*- -
!!-:- A.@1B
!!-D- A(%43@CB-
!;- +(A(%43@CB
A4(+19((
4(
- 19
;!)!*-
!- @14+1211(
4(($
4$((
H(-
;- 111X!:$)))-
*- @14+1248((+1
(((44(
($4$((
H(-
:- 4(-
D- 4+1
-
C$(4-
E- 11
4(! -):-!)!*4
((-
?- /+1(((O4C
4449
(134
-
)- >4-
4481
-B
C1+14
-((
$41(-B
!*- 4; -,; 4
1(
=#(4'$(484A
@1BA>B-
39
!:- /,
A>+141M4
38; N1+1
-.(481:
4$384
4A8CB41
8(44-
+18
((4(-B
!D- ,
A ;-2(242
4ABA!!!
!B/((82
-
! ,3/(-4A>K ?
',+=,B-4 E)); 4
448-,4
311
+14141
-
!E- .; (1G2#(-.
(H44G2#($4(
1->(,$+12(
(314(
4-(4(((
(-,((4
3(-
!?- 1!J34-
!!D
48G2#((84
4-4HJ-
!204
1-/
A
444(4844
84-84T28
40
(4-
4444M3# ?N
<344
JH
G($48(8((-
4/3$(!*)4
44'/(-
814-4
(($8J1-
# E"!)!*$/93
44$8J1$4
-(
1-
-/834((
$444$4((
4441$4-
R42888
$14-B
;)- #38
4+1132
$+1J%1
44E"-44X ) $?)
(1X :*$)))-+1
J(4
(4(4(484
+1$(+12
-
; - %14-
A.11$
(((94'-1
1(11(
4$J-B
;!- =((4 "1(
4+12. * :"
-
;;- 4( !"=(($4
$@2+$!
41
1++1(+P
$+12>$1%54/8
A(B7-/(
3(
.-4((
(.-9$4
(14$4
(-4H1
4$($4(-
;*- 4G2#(
+18J(.
41-
;:- +1$1((4
>1$4
.1A28B-=(((1
8-/41E))'(1
4.-+11$
!?)14-
;D- +1!. * :"-"
+11 )$)))1-1(
(5( D <7$4(
(-81+1-
; 444-/
414$(C
+12(1$'2-
+1244-
;E- (. *"AG%+,./,B
4((-4
84+12(-4
C(-
;?- .4(.$
H-
*)- 3(
(1+1$$4
1JJJ-
42
* - . E"+124%&
%-
*!- / E"+12$(($
*!- - +1
4C
3%&%2-
*!-!- >(5 E"7+14A(
B$4((4%&
%2
1
-
*;- .!)",=((4;
4>1@2+->(4
1
-
**- >3)E-!
4-D-
*:- !D"11+1
+1-/
D-))9(43(
H(((-
*D- ! "=((
AB$(4+1
8!
1%&%2;"-
G2#(((14(4
-
* %4!E" "-
((-
*E- ( "$$($
(4G2#(-
43
4
((-
*?- > )"$3(1
+14-4
E$!*!D!?; "-3
4*$;E)( $;))(-
:)- 1+1-+1
1$449
(1-(
+1211$9
$=((AB$$$4
48(-
: - >(1$$
4G2#(
4(1((-44
81'2.(G2
#(-$1441
41141-
:!- =(($
$(40(
444
8(8-=((
441(9
+1$41
444(+1-
:;- J14-
( ;.44
+11 ;"- 4
(41-1$
(($1(A/,
8K=8GB-
1A1
13-B
A1
4$(41-B
$A/11
G213
44
8G+1=-B/0(
11(+141
-/$$+144
1114
41$14(4J
88J14-
:*- +1411
(8-31
((1(4
1-
::- 1(4(">(1
4+1-
4-
:D- (((
$ F D- $:))(
(8-
: $
!"1-
'41$'
204-4
-
$+12
4(8- (4
- 1(
1$$-
114((1
1484-
:E- 1
+1-
:?- /$+1J2
(">((1
-(4
X )$)))-4((
1C-
45
D)- 4$+18(4
8(2-4
+12$(89
41(444-
441
(2-
+124$
-$(3(8(4$
848(8(C4(1X:E$:))-
D - %1($
+1C1(41
(-
D!- +1(1
,@J4
+11- (-
4+1(-
(4
4- +1C
($3-
D;- >!"9+1
$
D;- - >"X!
D;-!- >.X !$)))-
D;-;- %1
X ) $E)
D;-*- (1X:E$:))-
D;-:- =8(19((1-
!
D*- >C !
(
>11+1
4$/44+12
-
D:- 91 D
8-
46
DD- +12(1
+12,((-/18
8-
D 42
( :-1
81
21(3-
DE- >(
((1
4-/
(1
4C+1-'41$
4((9-418
C+1-
D?- 1+1
;"
14R;"(
(4
$+1418(
-
4,181
:(+12$
4+1
1
-1$
;"$48(+1(
43J(
3$4145447
1
-
< - J144+124
!4
(+124-/21
41(4
((4-
'41$0((
47
+148(14(4
-
/$/21
21J4
(444-'41$
4
:
4-/0(4
(4+14
(14(J(0((4
1+124
J-
/$+14(
-/1
8
4(1-
'41$+1
8414
(-/0(
(4+14
(144
(((
(-
1$;"$+1
2(
(,C>,'@-'41$
14(1
((($
+1C2(
44-/4""2$-4-
M!) )N,';?<*5!));7;
,'@@;E-
<:- class="_ _7"> 4+1(1
8+1
-/0($1((57
2C4R
574+118
(57($+1
48
8(;"4(1(
8+1
-
4-8
(8((
-
< !((+141
8-41
((-2(+12
14/14
(9(($84
(1+14/2
I((1H
+1(1
H(- !#
1(( )4(-'41$1
4+1(
4-
;"((4(-%$1
4$$8$418
-9$+12!E"
(1
-41
+1-
- .!E"+121
-.
- - #-
-!- ,-
-;- "(51.L+17-
-*- =((-
-:- ==5'@7-
-D- (5J7-
E)- /#
D-!
4(-
49
,%4$D-D4
A(.LB1
4((-'41$57 !
(C
($(
(.L57
J#-
E - >(!E"4
5=(74,4/18
4-%(
(401-
E!- /(
+1
-41
344(
4 !
+1 )"-/8
1(1(+121-
!E"+12
(44((4( )
"-%1$+14
$04$,'@
44-%/(14$0(
!E"4$4
C1(!E"$4
+184
($44$3((
4 !$-
E;- 42(!E"$
(($
E;- - (3$(
$1($(14$J
4(IHR
3R+12(
RR((41
!)!
((+1
-
E;-!- 4
50
E;-!- - (+12( :
-
E;-!-!-
1$4$
($(
-,3(14
E;-!-!- - JA4B-
E;-!-!-!- GJ-
E;-!-!-;- ! 4$$4
1(+1-
E;-!-!-*- +11
#/1-
E;-!-!-:- >8(.$4
(-
E;-!-!-D- 24
+121(-
E;-!-!- 4
4A!!!B+1-
E;-!-;- 2$4
$5-(-$(1$
8(7-
E;-!-*- A1B4
1+18(
1((8$+1(
C41R$3$
111J
-
E;-!-:- +11
-
E;-!-D- (1
+12(4+1-
E;-!- (81
+14+1-
E;-!-E- 4+1
$4+12
4C-(
44R1(2
8R(
1(8-
E;-!-?- 8
+1-
51
E;-!- )- +13R
JR($((
15%1$.7R
J(2R
J-
E;-!- - 1
L((2-
E;-!- !- 1(49
-%4
1
$4((
R4
1R
C((=C$
44C
(((-
E*- C$42A410
1-B
E:- 14
!-9
E:- - (411(8J(
:4148
-
E:-!- 4G
J8$4-
E:-;- 4
! -
E:-*- 3$
#/1-
E:-:- 48(.$4
(-
E:-D- 432$
4$$
(1$8(-
E:- 444
4409-
E:-E- (+13R
J4-
52
ED- /1(+14
+148-'41$
4(1-/
0(214(4
(4
114$
(144$8(
4(1$8(4(
1-/4(-/4
111-/4$
42$((
+1-4$44
$14$
4$0(4$4
(-
E %&%2;">?$ )$ *,'@-/4
+14(
8(4> )-/
;"4C4
-/4
243((
> +18(C9
8(4> -+
> *4244A(
1B4(
(-
EE- +1$1
3(4
-/89($/1
+143(
4-
E?- /4444
,'@(D5 7'@(> ??E-
?)- (>?$ ) ,'@,'@
( 5 757 ??E>-
? - >?11(-> )
11(3-> 1
53
1(
4-/(C9-
4(09574
57(?5!7$ )5!7$
5!7-
?!- /0(2!E"
8547$48(
1$094
2(?$ ) -
?;- 32
3
18(-=8(9
C9?$ ) (A4B+1
(C-.(
24$
C*; ?ED>$
4$4$44-+12
8(1
1(
::1@44-
?*- =8(C9?$ ) (
A(B!
(18
4(+12(
4$3-($
$4A(B
-
?:- L1$4(1((
444(A4(4
B4((L
04C91(
48(1-
?D- @1$4
+1201-
? =11$1
1101$41
54
12(11
((+1-
?E- #1$43
?$ ) (-(2
444$
(3-1
143(
4-4$41$44
13,'@(4(1
(+1$1444
1J1-
??- 4/1132
+14434
3,'@(-/41-
4$((4+1$
4-(4(1-
4-/1(
?$ ) 14(($
((4AMN
MNB-4((1(4(9
3-
!))- >($(1$+12(4
4(-
!) - %$12
(5(9(744((
01+1((
4-49
-
!)!- /1> *1
C3-
!);- /41
(444
,'@(-(
-
!)*- %&%2;",C>!) )R-*;,
>5-!7 ?EDR'(,@>!)
55
>31
8$1
+14($41
4(>-
!):- %&%(+14(
48(44
(4(-%&%
(+14
1(3(
4>(-/
0($(41C
48(-
!)D- +121
J(44(3
$4,'@(
1$4
R(040-
+18(1J4
!E"$$
(-
4440
-
R8(
44-
!)$+1(48
(44(
4($1$4(3
( ! )"
+19$11(
O(1(
+1$574(
44((57(
4143
4(OC
4+12$$
-
!)E- %&%2;"(+14
A,B4+14
56
((1$((
4(-/4
$+1A
0141/24
IBA+1(4(4
48(4(4
4B5C7-@1
1J1444-/
4+144(-
,14$((1C
444+14
((8-
!)?- 41((%&%2;"
+1A-B
1-
! )- (+11-,1
4$34(
14+14((8
-
! - #A(1B/+1((
1$(
42+12
4+12-.
$+12(
1((4(
$(4
($1+12
-
! !- %$/1'
P$(I(4@
%449 !
! !- - P"4/=4+1-'
84(
41"4-.P$A"4
1(2(
3-B'A
1413I"4
57
J4-B/
-P$2(
3(C
41($$4((
-
! !-!- (J+1
-
(4, ;4
4-1(2-
4A($4(
-B(
+1-A1
8(1
4(B-+12/8
3$(AB8G+=$
A1((1J$
(3(-B(1
AC1B->/
(214J14+12
-
! !-;- I("4#/=
/@+1-
84(
41"4-I(;
!)!*44"4O/
J+1+12(3(
41(
+12941
+1-I(1"4O/
J+1(
-I(1(
4A(
34+(-BI(8($
$0A
(3B9(AB
11(1444
118(11($4
G+1R1
A(1(11
-B118(
1($(
81(4-%$""2
58
4-$J
4$(/
I$($($J4
4($8(8(
4->(($I
$84($+1(
(-4
AB-P(
-1((((
(9-'41$+1
4(+14-
4$ !
! ;- 11((
+144
(
(-/0(4(4
-4(-
,+K>,@',,@.
!)!)!*
59
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting