R (Mersey Care NHS Trust) v Mental Health Review Tribunal
| Jurisdiction | England & Wales |
| Court | Queen's Bench Division (Administrative Court) |
| Judgment Date | 22 July 2004 |
| Neutral Citation | [2004] EWHC 1749 (Admin) |
| Date | 22 July 2004 |
Court and Reference:Administrative Court ; CO/2009/2003
Sullivan J
Appearances: S Kovats (instructed by Capsticks) for the Trust; J Strachan (instructed by the Treasury Solicitor) for the Tribunal; H Southey (instructed by Peter Edwards Law) for the patient as Interested Party.
Whether the RMO may question witnesses and make closing submissions at a tribunal hearing; whether the tribunal's decision to discharge the patient was rational and adequately reasoned.
D was detained at Ashworth Hospital under s. 3 Mental Health Act 1983, though it was accepted that she no longer needed the level of security provided by that hospital; at the time, no rehabilitation facility had been identified. Her case was considered on 27 March 2003 by a Tribunal, which ordered her discharge as from 28 April 2003. The Tribunal accepted that she suffered from schizophrenia, noted that she had good insight into her condition, which had responded well to medication, and was able to cope with her residual symptoms in the community with an appropriate care package; they expressed the view that to detain her in high secure conditions which she did not need was a disproportionate breach of her rights under Art 8 European Convention.
The hospital challenged the decision of the Tribunal, arguing that (i) the Tribunal had been procedurally unfair because Dr S, D's Responsible Medical Officer, had been prevented from cross-examining a hospital social worker who gave evidence to the Tribunal and was refused permission to sum up the hospital's case; (ii) the decision was irrational in light of the fact that all the written evidence before the Tribunal supported D's continued detention, and there had been no evidence from the Tribunal medical member to justify discharge; (iii) the reasons were inadequate as they failed to deal with a number of relevant evidential matters. Permission was granted and the decision to release stayed pending an expedited final hearing.
1. The claimant is responsible for the management of Ashworth Hospital. Ashworth is a special hospital where patients are cared for in conditions of high security. The interested party, D, is a patient at the hospital.
2. In this application for judicial review, the claimant challenges a decision of the Mental Health Review Tribunal, Liverpool (the Tribunal), given on 27 March 2003. In that decision, the Tribunal discharged D from liability to be detained under s. 3 of the Mental Health Act 1983, with effect from 12 noon on 28 April 2003.
3. The claimant set out its concerns about the Tribunal's decision in letter before action dated 7 April. In the absence of a substantive response, these proceedings were filed on 23 April with a request for urgent consideration and an application for a stay of the Tribunal's decision.
4. The application was considered on the papers by Ouseley J the following day. He granted permission to apply for judicial review and ordered that the Tribunal's decision should be stayed until the hearing of the action. He gave liberty to the Tribunal and the interested party to apply to discharge the stay.
5. The matter came back before Keith J on 29 April on the application of the interested party to remove the stay. Keith J did not accede to that application but he gave directions for an urgent hearing, so that the matter has come before me today, Friday, 9 May. Keith J ordered that the defendant file evidence by Tuesday, 6 May, and the claimant and the interested party file any evidence in reply by Wednesday, 7 May. In response to that order, the defendant has filed witness statements from the 3 members of the Tribunal: Mrs Martin, a solicitor, and the legal member of the Tribunal; Dr Khan, a retired consultant psychiatrist, the medical member; and Mrs Mitchell, a psychologist, the lay member of the Tribunal. There is also a witness statement from Mr Kenny, the solicitor who represented D at the hearing.
6. Having considered the submissions made by Mr Kovats, on behalf of the claimant, Mr Strachan, on behalf of the Tribunal, and Mr Southey, on behalf of D, I indicated that I had come to the conclusion that the application should be refused. In the normal course of events, I would have wished to take a little time to prepare my reasons but since D is still detained, it is imperative that judgment is given today. In the circumstances, my reasons will be relatively brief and I do not propose to recite matters of background history.
7. The claimant contends that the Tribunal's decision was unlawful for 3 reasons: firstly, that it was irrational because it was against the weight of the evidence; secondly, that it was inadequately reasoned; and thirdly, that there was procedural unfairness.
8. The first observation I would make relates to the conflict of evidence between D's Responsible Medical Officer (RMO), Dr Swinton, on behalf of the claimant, and the account of the proceedings before the Tribunal that is given in the defendant's evidence and confirmed by the evidence of Mr Kenny. It is unnecessary to rehearse the detail. It is sufficient to note that there are substantial differences of recollection between the parties as to what actually occurred at the hearing. The burden is, of course, upon the claimant to establish that there has been an error on the part of the Tribunal. Where there is a conflict between Dr Swinton's account of what happened at the Tribunal and the account given by the 3 members of the Tribunal and Mr Kenny, I prefer the evidence given on behalf of the defendant. I mention that at the outset because there were a number of complaints relating to procedural irregularity which are no longer pursued.
9. Against the background of events as described by the members of the Tribunal, Mr Kovats submits that there were 2 procedural flaws. Firstly, it is said there was unfairness because Dr Swinton was not allowed to "cross-examine" Ms Linton. Ms Linton is a senior social worker at Ashworth Hospital. Secondly, it is said that the Tribunal was unfair because it refused to allow Dr Swinton to sum-up the hospital's case. According to Dr Swinton's account of the matter, at the conclusion of the cross-examination of Ms Linton by Mr Kenny on behalf of D, he told the Tribunal that he wanted to ask her some questions. His request was refused. According to the Tribunal, during the course of Mr Kenny's cross-examination of Ms Linton, Dr Swinton tried to interrupt and ask questions. The Tribunal told Dr Swinton that since he was simply appearing as a witness rather than a representative, he was not allowed to ask questions of another witness. In her witness statement, Ms Martin explains that she was, understandably, concerned "to prevent friendly-fire questioning by one witness of another appearing for the authority".
10. In the light of that response, Mr Kovats submitted that it was unfair for the Tribunal simply to refuse to allow Dr Swinton to ask questions. It should have elicited what questions he wanted to ask: if they were irrelevant they could have been ignored; if they were relevant, then perhaps the Tribunal could have asked the questions itself. However, it appears that Dr Swinton did not challenge Ms Martin's statement that he was appearing before the Tribunal simply as a witness rather than as a representative. The relevant procedure is prescribed by the Mental Health Review Tribunal Rules 1983 (the Rules). Rule 22(1) provides that:
"The tribunal may conduct the hearing in such manner as it considers most suitable bearing in mind the health and interests of the patient and it shall, so far as appears to it appropriate, seek to avoid formality in its proceedings."
So far as representation is concerned, r10(1) provides:
"Any party may be represented by any person whom he has authorised for that purpose not being a person liable to be detained or subject to guardianship or after-care under supervision under the Act or a person seeking treatment for mental disorder at the same hospital or mental nursing home as the patient. "
Rule 10(2):
"Any representative authorised in accordance with para (1) shall notify the tribunal of his authorisation and postal address."
11. Dr Swinton's witness statement does not make it clear whether he informed the Tribunal that he was appearing not merely as a witness, but as a representative of the hospital. In any event, he did not challenge the Tribunal's ruling in respect of Ms Linton, that is to say, that as a witness he could not ask questions of another witness.
12. The ground of challenge in the claim form, however, does not complain of the Tribunal's refusal to allow Dr Swinton to ask questions of Ms Linton. It contends that there was procedural unfairness because of "the refusal to allow Dr Swinton to question D or to make final submissions". However, the facts in support of the grounds make it clear that Dr Swinton did not ask for permission to cross-examine D, so there is no question of the Tribunal refusing to allow him to do so. He apparently took the view that having been refused permission to ask questions of Ms Linton, there was no point in his seeking permission to ask questions of D. In any event, the complaint that the Tribunal refused to allow him to question D is unjustified because there was no request from him to question D.
13. So far as a refusal to allow him to make a final submission is concerned, which is the second alleged procedural flaw, it seems to be accepted that he did not ask for permission to make such a final submission, again apparently because he was discouraged by the fact that he had not been allowed to cross-examine Ms Linton. The RMO is not entitled under the Rules to make any final statement. There is no indication as to what the Tribunal's attitude might have been if he had merely sought to "correct" any new points that...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
AH M 84 2010
...such rules appear to have arisen directly for consideration, since the Human Rights Act, seems to be R (Mersey Care NHS Trust) v Mental Health Review Tribunal [2004] EWHC 1749 (Admin); [2005] 2 All ER 820. The relevant rule, under the Mental Health Review Tribunal Rules 1983 (SI 1983/942), ......
-
AH HM 84 2010
...such rules appear to have arisen directly for consideration, since the Human Rights Act, seems to be R (Mersey Care NHS Trust) v Mental Health Review Tribunal [2004] EWHC 1749 (Admin); [2005] 2 All ER 820. The relevant rule, under the Mental Health Review Tribunal Rules 1983 (SI 1983/942), ......
-
The King on the application of Teresa Maher v First Tier Tribunal (Mental Health)
...have been if the newspaper had been threatening to publish part of the evidence before the tribunal. 110 In R (Mersey Care NHS Trust) v Mental Health Tribunal [2005] 1 WLR 2469, the claimant was the NHS trust responsible for Ian Brady, a convicted murderer. The MHRT had granted Mr Brady's r......
-
R (on the application of C) v Secretary of State for Justice
...Tribunals are very much concerned with risk as well as with diagnosis. 32 In R (Mersey Care NHS Trust) v Mental Health Review Tribunal [2004] EWHC 1749 (Admin); [2005] 1 WLR 2469, para 14, Beatson J quoted with approval the Tribunal's reasons for finding that their privacy rules were a pro......