R Syahvarrudi v Secretary of State for the Home Department

JurisdictionEngland & Wales
CourtQueen's Bench Division (Administrative Court)
JudgeMrs Justice Simler
Judgment Date03 December 2013
Neutral Citation[2013] EWHC 4628 (Admin)
Date03 December 2013
Docket NumberCO/5071/2012

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE

QUEEN'S BENCH DIVISION

THE ADMINISTRATIVE COURT

Royal Courts of Justice

Strand

London WC2A 2LL

Before:

Mrs Justice Simler

CO/5071/2012

Between:
The Queen on the Application of Syahvarrudi
Claimant
and
Secretary of State for the Home Department
Defendant

Mr D Chirico (instructed by Sutovic & Hartigan) appeared on behalf of the Claimant

Mr D Manknell (instructed by Treasury Solicitors) appeared on behalf of the Defendant

Mrs Justice Simler
1

This is a renewed application for permission, challenging the decision to remove the claimant to Italy pursuant to the Dublin II Regulation. I will deal with the facts in a moment but before I do, I deal with the current state of the law on this topic.

2

The Dublin II Regulation provides the regime for deciding which Member State within the EU will deal with an individual asylum seeker and contains provisions attributing responsibility for dealing with removal of asylum seekers and refugees to a particular Member State.

3

The law in this area is fast changing and there have been a number of recent developments that impact on it. First, the judgment of the Court of Appeal in EM (Eritrea [2012] EWCA Civ 1336, which in effect rejected as unarguable a case by individuals that their transfer to Italy under Dublin II would violate their Convention rights.

4

At paragraphs 62 to 64 of his judgment Sedley LJ dealt with the correct approach to the question whether a second State is required to refrain from returning an applicant to the State of first arrival under Dublin II. Two points should be emphasised. First, the Court of Appeal made clear that an applicant's evidence of his alleged individual past experiences in the Member State of first arrival cannot rebut the presumption that a safe third country would treat asylum seekers and refugees in accordance with its international obligations. To do that requires objective evidence of systemic flaws in the asylum procedure and reception conditions, amounting to substantial grounds for believing inhuman or degrading treatment would result from a return to the first state: see NS v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2011] EU ECJ C-411/10. The CJEU in NS also made clear that the protections conferred by EU law, in particular the rights concerning human dignity set out in the EU Charter, afforded no wider protection than that conferred by Article 3 of the Convention.

5

The second point emphasised is that the Cour of Appeal's analysis relates to all categories of returnees, that is to say asylum seekers, refugees and those whose asylum claims have been refused.

6

Although the Court of Appeal refused permission to appeal to the Supreme Court, it made clear its view that the Supreme Court might wish to consider granting permission itself and following the judgment in EM (Eritrea), the Supreme Court did in fact grant such permission to appeal and that hearing took place on 6th and 7th November. It is unlikely that the Supreme Court will deliver its judgment before early 2014. In Bushara v SSHD [2012] EWHC 3483 (Admin) the court held that the possibility of such an appeal did not mean other removals to Italy should necessarily be stayed.

7

Meanwhile, there have been two other significant decisions by the Strasbourg court (and others that have followed those). First, Hussein v Netherlands (App no 27725/10 2 April 2013), where up-to-date evidence concerning the arrangements for asylum seekers in Italy was reviewed and the court concluded that the applicant's claims under Article 3 against both the Netherlands and Italy were manifestly unfounded. The Strasbourg Court concluded that the applicant had not shown that her future prospects of returning to Italy, whether taken from a material, physical or psychological perspective disclosed a sufficiently real and imminent risk of hardship, severe enough to fall within the scope of Article 3.

8

At paragraph 78 the Strasbourg Court in Hussein said:

"… while the general situation and living conditions in Italy of asylum seekers … may disclose some shortcomings … it has not been shown to disclose a systemic failure to provide support or facilities catering for asylum seekers as members of a particularly vulnerable group of people, as was the case in M.S.S. v. Belgium and Greece (cited above). The reports drawn up by the UNCHR and the Commission for Human Rights refer to recent improvements intended to remedy some of the failings and all reports are unanimous in depicting a detailed structure of facilities and care to provide for the needs of asylum seekers…"

It also stated at [68]:

"It is in principle for the Claimant to adduce evidence capable of proving that there are substantial grounds for believing that if the measure complained of were to be implemented, he or she would be exposed to a real risk of being subjected to treatment contrary to Article 3."

9

The second case is Daytbegova & Magomedova v Austria (App no 6198/12) where the applicants were seeking to resist removal from Austria to Italy pursuant to Dublin II. The Strasbourg Court again rejected the claim that such removal would constitute a breach of Article 3 of the Convention as manifestly unfounded and inadmissible, finding that the information available did not point to the conclusion that a series of singular incidents relied on by the applicants (one of whom had suicidal tendencies) amounted to such a systemic failure as was identified as necessary in MSS. At paragraph 66 the Court said:

"While not disregarding the criticism raised in various reports concerning factual obstacles to the lodging of asylum applications in Italy,… the Court finds that the information available does not point to the conclusion that those singular incidents amount to such a systemic failure as was the case in M.S.S. v Belgium and Greece…Therefore, the Court establishes that there is no indication … deriving from the general information available that the applicants would not be able to access sufficiently thorough asylum proceedings upon their arrival in Italy…."

10

The court's rejection of both these cases as manifestly unfounded emphasises the strength of the Court's holding that the current evidence relating to Italy is insufficient by some considerable margin to rebut the presumption that Italy will comply with its international obligations.

11

Against that Mr Chirico relies on the fact that the case of Tarakhel v Switzerland (App No 29217/12) was recently referred to the Grand Chamber by the Second Section of the European Court of Human Right which relinquished jurisdiction in respect of claims resisting return to Italy by a family with young children, on the basis of potential breaches of their Article 3 and/or 8 rights.

12

There is nothing given by way of reasons by the Second Section for relinquishing such jurisdiction but it is clear from rule 72 of the Rules of Procedure of the ECHR that there are two situations where relinquishment of jurisdiction in favour of the Grand Chamber might occur. Firstly, where a case pending before a Chamber raises a serious question affecting the interpretation of the Convention or the Protocols thereto. Secondly, where the resolution of a question raised in a case before the Chamber might have a result inconsistent with the Court's case law. Mr Chirico submits that that fact of relinquishment shows that the ECHR may be drawing back from these earlier decisions, and undermines the view that there is consistent Strasbourg jurisprudence on these cases.

13

I cannot accept that argument. Whilst it is possible that the Grand Chamber may in future reach a decision that alters the approach to interpretation, or the principles to be applied in dealing with return to Italy cases, that is not the current position. Moreover, the Grand Chamber may confirm the current approach and principles. The fact of relinquishment alone is insufficient in my judgment to demonstrate any change.

14

So far as further case law...

Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI

Get Started for Free

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex