Responding to a petition: application for a validation order
| Author | Mark Watson-Gandy |
| Pages | 63-81 |
"
"
Ejcrvgt"7"
TGURQPFKPI"VQ"C"RGVKVKQP
CRRNKECVKQP"HQT"C"XCNKFCVKQP"QTFGT"
QDLGEVKXG"
Kp"c"dcpmtwrve{."cp{"fkurqukvkqp"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrvÓu"rtqrgtv{"ocfg"chvgt"vjg"fcvg"qh"
vjg"rtgugpvcvkqp"qh" vjg"dcpmtwrve{"rgvkvkqp" wpvkn"vjg"rtqrgtv{" xguvu"kp"jku" vtwuvgg"
ku."wpnguu"vjg" eqwtv"qvjgtykug"qtfgtu."xqkf03" C"fghgpeg"gz kuvu."jqygxgt."hqt" vjktf"
rctvkgu"yjgtg"vjg" rc{ogpv"qt"rtqrgtv{" ku"tgegkxgf"dghqtg" vjg"eqoogpegogpv"qh"
vjg"dcpmtwrve{"kp"iqqf" hckvj."hqt"xcnwg"cpf" ykvjqwv"pqvkeg"qh"vjg"rtgugpvcvkqp" qh"
vjg"rgvkvkqp04"
"
Vjg"ghhgev" qh"vjku" kp"rtcevkeg" ku"vq" uvgtknkug" vjg"fgdvqtÓu" cdknkv{"vq" vtcfg"qt" ocmg"
rc{ogpvu"cpf" jku" dcpmgtu." cu" uqqp" cu" vjg{" dgeqog" cyctg" qh" vjg" rgvkvkqp." yknn"
htgg¦g"jku"dcpm"ceeqwpv0"Vjku"ku"dgecwug"rc{ogpvu"kpvq"qt"qwv"qh"vjg"fgdvqtÓu"dcpm"
ceeqwpv" ctg" fkurqukvkqpu"qh" rtqrgtv{." kttgurgevkxg" qh" yjgvjgt" vjg" ceeqwpv" ku" kp"
etgfkv"qt"qxgtftcyp05"
"
C"xcnkfcvkqp"qtfgt"ku"pgeguuct{"vq"cnnqy"vjg"fgdvqt"vq"wug"jku"hwpfu"hqt"ngicn"cfxkeg"
cpf"tgrtgugpvcvkqp6"qt"hqt"vjg"rc{ogpv"qh"qvjgt"rtqhguukqpcn"gzrgpugu07"
"
Vjg"fgdvqt"oc{"crrn{"vq" vjg"eqwtv"hqt"c"xcnkfcvkqp"qtfgt" yjkej"qrgtcvgu"vq"cnnqy"
vjg"fgdvqt"vq"eqpvkpwg"vq"vtcfg"d{
"
"xcnkfcvkpi" fkurqukvkqpu" qh" rtqrgtv{" kp" vjg" fgdvqtÓu" qtfkpct{" eqwtug" qh"
dwukpguu="
"xcnkfcvkpi"rc{ogpvu"vq"cpf"htqo"vjg"fgdvqtÓu"dcpm"ceeqwpv"kp"vjg"qtfkpct{"
eqwtug"qh"dwukpguu="
"xcnkfcvkpi"urgekhke"kuqncvgf"vtcpucevkqpu"dgpghkekcn"vq"vjg"fgdvqt0"
"
Vjg"eqwtv"ku"ecwvkqwu"cdqwv"ocmkpi"uwej"cp"qtfgt"cpf"etgfkdng"gxkfgpeg"pggfu"vq"
dg"ujqyp" vjcv" kv"yqwnf" dgpghkv" cnn"etgfkvqtu08" Vjg" eqwtv"yknn" uggm" vq"gpuwtg" vjg"
"
3" Ugevkqp"4:6*3+Î*5+."qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"Cev"3;:80"Kv"ku"xqkf"pqv"ogtgn{"xqkfcdngBateman v Hyde"
]422;̲"GYJE":3"*Ej+."]422;̲"DRKT"9590"
4" Ugevkqp"4:6*6+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"Cev"3;:80"
5"Re Tain Construction Ltd, Rose v AIB Group (UK) plc"]4225̲"GYJE"3959"*Ej+."]4225̲"3"YNT"
49;3="Re McGuinness Bros (UK) Ltd"*3;:9+"5"DEE"7930"
6"Pettit v Novakovic"]4229̲"DEE"684="Andrew v Kingsway Asset Leasing"]4242̲"DRKT"328;0"
7"Re the estate of Jimmy Savile"]4236̲"GYJE"875"*Ej+."]4236̲"DRKT"7730"
8"Re Fairways Graphics"]3;;3̲"DENE"68:0"
86" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
kpvgtguvu"qh"wpugewtgf"etgfkvqtu"ctg"pqv"rtglwfkegf09"Vtcpucevkqpu"yjkej"jcxg"vjg"
ghhgev"qh"tgfwekpi"vjg"cuugvu"cxckncdng"vq"etgfkvqtu"yknn"pqv"dg"xcnkfcvgf0"
"
Yjgtg" vjg" fgdvqt" ecp" dg" ujqyp" vq" dg" uqnxgpv." vjg" eqwtv"yknn" dg" owej" oqtg"
tgegrvkxg"vq" ocmkpi" c" xcnkfcvkqp"qtfgt0" Fkurwvgf"f gdvu"ctg" pqv" eqwpvgf"h qt"vjg"
rwtrqugu"qh"cuuguukpi"uqnxgpe{0:"
CRRNKECVKQP"
Gcej"crrnkecvkqp"ujqwnf"ugv"qwv
"
"vjcv" vjg" crrnkecvkqp" ku" ocfg" wpfgt" vjg" Kpuqnxgpe{" Cev" 3;:8" qt" vjg"
Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"4238"*cu"vjg"ecug"oc{"dg+=;"
"vjg"ugevkqp"pwodgt"qt"twng"wpfgt"yjkej"tgnkgh"ku"uqwijv=32"
"vjg"pcog"qh"vjg"rctvkgu=33"
"vjg"pcog"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrv"qt"fgdvqt=34"
"vjg"eqwtv"pcog=35"
"vjg"ecug"pwodgt=36"
"vjg"tgogf{"crrnkgf"hqt"qt"fktgevkqpu"uqwijv=37"
"vjg"pcog"cpf"cfftguu"qh"gcej"rgtuqp"vq"dg"ugtxgf"qt."kh"pqpg."vjcv"pq"rgtuqp"
yknn"dg"ugtxgf=38"
"yjgtg"vjgtg"ku" c"tgswktgogpv" hqt"rctvkewnct" rgtuqpu"vq" dg"ikxgp"pqvkeg" qh"
vjg"crrnkecvkqp"wpfgt"vjg"Cev"qt"Twngu."vjg"pcog"cpf"cfftguu"qh"gcej"uwej"
rgtuqp=39"
"vjg"crrnkecpvÓu"cfftguu"hqt"ugtxkeg03:"
"
Vjg"crrnkecvkqp"pqvkeg"owuv"dg"cwvjgpvkecvgf"d{"vjg"crrnkecpv"qt"jku"uqnkekvqt03;""
"
Cp{"rgtuqp" kpvgtguvgf" kp" vjg"vtcpucevkqp" *kp" rtcevkeg."vjg" crrnkecvkqp" ku"wuwcnn{"
ocfg"d{"vjg"fgdvqt+"oc{" crrn{"qp"pqvkeg"d{"crrnkecvkqp"pqvkeg" Hqto"KCC"ocfg"
vq"vjg" Kpuqnxgpe{"cpf" Eqorcpkgu"Eqwtv" Lwfig"qt" fkuvtkev"lwfig0" Cp" crrnkecvkqp"
ujqwnf"dg"ocfg"vq"vjg"Jkij"Eqwtv"lwfig"qpn{<"*c+"yjgtg"kv"ku"wtigpv" cpf" pq"
Kpuqnxgpe{"cpf"Eqorcpkgu"Eqwtv"Lwfig"qt"fkuvtkev"lwfig"ku"cxckncdng"vq"jgct"kv="qt"
"
9"Re Gray’s Inn Construction Co"]3;:2̲"3"YNT"9330"
:"Re Hood v HMRC"]423;̲"GYJE"4458"*Ej+0"
;" Twng"3057*4+*c+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
32" Twng"3057*4+*d+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
33" Twng"3057*4+*e+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
34" Twng"3057*4+*f+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
35" Twng"3057*4+*g+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
36" Twng"3057*4+*h+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
37" Twng"3057*4+*i+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
38" Twng"3057*4+*j+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
39" Twng"3057*4+*k+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
3:" Twng"3057*4+*l+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
3;" Twng" 3057*5+" qh" vjg" Kpuqnxgpe{" *Gpincpf" cpf" Ycngu+" Twngu" 42380" Hqt" yjcv" coqwpvu" vq"
cwvjgpvkecvkqp."ugg"twng"3070"Hqt"jctf"eqr{"crrnkecvkqpu."vjku"ogcpu"ukipgf
"Application for a Validation Order" 87"
"
*d+"yjgtg"kv"ku"eqorngz"qt"tckugu"pgy"qt"eqpvtqxgtukcn"rqkpvu"qh"ncy="qt"*e+"yjgtg"
kv"ku"guvkocvgf"vq"ncuv"nqpigt"vjcp"52"okpwvgu0"Vjg"crrnkecvkqp"ecp"dg"ocfg"ykvjqwv"
pqvkeg"kh"wtigpv0"Vjtgg" eqrkgu"qh"vjg"crrnkecvkqp"ctg" pggfgf0"C"ftchv"qh"vjg" qtfgt"
uqwijv"ujqwnf"dg"cvvcejgf"vq"vjg"crrnkecvkqp042"
EQWTV"HGGU"
Yjgtg"vjg"crrnkecvkqp"ku"ocfg"d{"qtfkpct{"crrnkecvkqp"qp"pqvkeg"vq"qvjgt"rctvkgu."
c" eqwtv" hgg" qh" ˚;;" ku" rc{cdng043"Yjgtg" vjg" crrnkecvkqp" ku" ocfg" d{" eqpugpv" qt"
ykvjqwv"pqvkeg"kp"gzkuvkpi"rtqeggfkpiu."c"eqwtv"hgg"qh"˚48"ku"rc{cdng044"
GXKFGPEG"
Vjg" crrnkecvkqp" ujqwnf" dg" uwrrqtvgf" d{" c" ykvpguu" uvcvgogpv" htqo"vjg"fgdvqt"
jkougnh0"Vjg" eqwtv"yknn" pggf"vq" dg"ucvkuhkgf" qp"etgfkdng" gxkfgpeg"vjcv" gkvjgt"vjg"
fgdvqt"ku" uqnxgpv"qt" vjcv"vjg" rtqrqugf" vtcpucekqpu"ctg" gkvjgt"dgpghkekcn" hqt"qt" cv"
ngcuv"yknn"pqv"rtglwfkeg"etgfkvqtu045"Vjg"ykvpguu"uvcvgogpv"ujqwnf"vjwu"cfftguu<46"
"
"vjg"fgdvqtÓu"pcog"cpf"cfftguu="
"qp"yjqo"vjg" crrnkecpv"jcu" ikxgp"pqvkeg" qh"vjku"c rrnkecvkqp"cpf" jqy"cpf"
yjgp"pqvkeg"ycu"rtqxkfgf="
"vjg"fcvg"qp"yjkej"vjg"rgvkvkqp"ycu"rtgugpvgf="
"vjg"fgvcknu"qh"vjg"ektewouvcpegu"ngcfkpi"vq"vjg"rtgugpvcvkqp"qh"vjg"rgvkvkqp="
"jqy" cpf" yjgp" vjg" crrnkecpv" dgecog" cyctg" qh" vjg" rtgugpvcvkqp" qh" vjg"
rgvkvkqp="
"yjgvjgt"vjg"dcpm"qt"vjg"rc{gg"ku"cyctg"vjg"rgvkvkqp"jcu"dggp"rtgugpvgf="
"yjgvjgt"vjg" rgvkvkqp" fgdv"ku" cfokvvgf" qt"fkurwvgf" cpf." kh"vjg" ncvvgt." dtkgh"
fgvcknu"qh"vjg"dcuku"qp"yjkej"vjg"fgdv"ku"fkurwvgf="
"hwnn"fgvcknu"qh"vjg"fgdvqtÓu"hkpcpekcn"rqukvkqp"kpenwfkpi"fgvcknu"qh"jku"cuugvu"
cpf"nkcdknkvkgu"cpf"ugewtkv{"wrqp"vjqug"cuugvu"*cpf"vjg"coqwpv"ugewtgf+="
"fgvcknu"qh"cp{"tgngxcpv"dcpm"ceeqwpv."kpenwfkpi"ceeqwpv"pwodgt."uqtv"eqfg. "
dcpm"pcog"cpf"dtcpej"cfftguu="
"vjg"etgfkv"*qt"fgdkv+"dcncpeg"qp"gcej"ceeqwpv="
"c"ecuj"hnqy"hqtgecuv"cpf"rtqhkv"cpf"nquu"rtqlgevkqp"hqt"vjg"rgtkqf"hqt"yjkej"
vjg"qtfgt"ku"uqwijv="
"fgvcknu" qh" vjg" fkurqukvkqpu" qt" rc{ogpvu" kp" tgurgev" qh" yjkej" cp"qtfgt" ku"
uqwijv="
"vjg" tgcuqpu" tgnkgf" qp" kp" uwrrqtv" qh" vjg" pggf" hqt" uwej" fkurqukvkqpu"qt"
rc{ogpvu"vq"dg"ocfg="
"vjg"ghhgev" qp" vjg" fgdvqtÓu"hkpcpekcn" rqukvkqp" kh" vjg"vtcpucevkqp" hqt" yjkej"
rgtokuukqp"ku"uqwijv"iqgu"cjgcf="
"
42" Rctcitcrj"340:0;"qh"vjg"ERT"Rtcevkeg"Fktgevkqpeggfkpiu0"
43" Hgg"5034."GZ72C"Iwkfcpeg"qp"Eqwtv"Hggu"*Octej"4244+0"
44" Hgg"5033."GZ72C"Iwkfcpeg"qp"Eqwtv"Hggu"*Octej"4244+0"
45" Rctcitcrj"340:09"qh"vjg"ERT"Rtcevkeg"Fktgevkqp"Î"Kpuqnxgpe{"Rtqeggfkpiu0"
46" Rctcitcrju"340:06Î340:08"qh"vjg"ERT"Rtcevkeg"Fktgevkqp"Î"Kpuqnxgpe{"Rtqeggfkpiu0"
88" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
"cp{"qvjgt"hcevqtu"vjcv"okijv"dg"vjqwijv"vq"dg"tgngxcpv"vq"vjg"gzgtekug"qh"vjg"
eqwtvÓu"fkuetgvkqp="
"fgvcknu" qh" cp{" eqpugpvu" qdvckpgf" htqo" vjg" rgtuqpu" chhgevgf" d{" vjg"
vtcpucevkqp"qt"ugtxgf"ykvj"pqvkeg"qh"vjg"crrnkecvkqp="
"fgvcknu"qh"cp{"rtqrgtv{"vq" dg"uqnf."oqtvicigf"qt" tg/oqtvicigf"*kpenwfkpi"
kvu"vkvng"pwodgt+="
"vjg" xcnwg" qh" vjg" rtqrgtv{"cpf" vjg" rtqrqugf" ucng" rtkeg." qt" fgvcknu" qh" vjg"
oqtvicig"qt"tg/oqtvicig="
"fgvcknu" qh" cp{" gzkuvkpi" oqtvicigu" qt" ejctigu" qp" vjg" rtqrgtv{" cpf"
tgfgorvkqp"hkiwtgu="
"vjg"equvu"qh"ucng"*g0i0"uqnkekvqtuÓ"qt"cigpvuÓ"equvu+="
"jqy" cpf" d{" yjqo" cp{" pgv"rtqeggfu" qh" ucng" *qt" uwou" eqokpi" kpvq" vjg"
fgdvqtÓu"jcpfu"cu"c"tguwnv"qh"cp{" oqtvicig"qt"tg/oqtvicig+"ctg"vq"dg"jgnf"
rgpfkpi"vjg"hkpcn"jgctkpi"qh"vjg"rgvkvkqp="
"yjgvjgt"vjg"rtqrqugf" vtcpucevkqpu"ygtg"kp"iqqf" hckvj"cpf"kp"vjg"qtfkpct{"
eqwtug"qh"dwukpguu="
"vjcv"vjgtg"ycu"pq" dcuku"hqt"eqpukfgtkpi" vjcv"vjg"vtcpucevkqp"okijv" qrgtcvg"
vq"rtghgt"c"etgfkvqt"qt"iwctcpvqt="
"cp{" hcevu" fgoqpuvtcvkpi" vjg" dgpghkv" qh" vjg" vtcpucevkqp" vq" etgfkvqtu" cu" c"
yjqng="
"cp{" hcevu" fgoqpuvtcvkpi" vjcv" vjgtg" ku" pq" rtglwfkeg" vq" vjg" etgfkvqtu" cu" c"
yjqng"d{"vjg"vtcpucevkqp"vcmkpi"rnceg="
"vjg"fgvckn"qh"vjg"fgdvqtÓu"hkpcpekcn"rqukvkqp"ujqykpi"vjg"fgdvqtÓu"vtcfkpi"ku"
rtqhkvcdng0"
"
Cpf"ujqwnf"gzjkdkv
"
"gxkfgpeg"qh"vjg" fgdvqtÓu"cuugvu" *kpenwfkpi"fgvcknu" qh"cp{"ugewtkv{"cpf"vjg"
coqwpvu"ugewtgf+"cpf"nkcdknkvkgu"*g0i0"vjg"oquv"tgegpv"vcz"cpf"ocpcigogpv"
ceeqwpvu"cpf"guvkocvgf"uvcvgogpv"qh"chhcktu."gxgp"kh"kp"ftchv+="
"c"ecuj"hnqy"hqtgecuv"cpf"rtqhkv"cpf"nquu"rtqlgevkqp"hqt"vjg"rgtkqf"hqt"yjkej"
vjg"qtfgt"ku"uqwijv="
"gxkfgpeg"qh"cp{"eqpugpvu"qdvckpgf"htqo
"
Î"vjg"rgvkvkqpkpi"etgfkvqt="
Î"cp{"etgfkvqt"uwduvkvwvgf"cu"rgvkvkqpgt="
Î"cp{"etgfkvqt"yjq"jcu"dggp"ikxgp"ecttkcig"qh"vjg"rgvkvkqp="
Î"cp{"etgfkvqt"yjq" jcu"ikxgp"pqvkeg" vq"vjg" rgvkvkqpgt"qh"jku" kpvgpvkqp"vq"
crrgct" qp" vjg" jgctkpi" qh" vjg" rgvkvkqp" rwtuwcpv" vq" twng" 3203;" qh"vjg"
Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"4238="
"
"cp{"ftchv"citggogpv"hqt"cp{"rtqrqugf"vtcpucevkqpu="
"cp"kpfgrgpfgpv"xcnwcvkqp"qh"vjg"rtqrgtv{"vq"dg"fkurqugf"qh0"
"
Kh"crrtqrtkcvg."vjku"ujqwnf"dg"uwrrqtvgf"d{"c"ykvpguu"uvcvgogpv"htqo"vjg"fgdvqtÓu"
ceeqwpvcpv047"Vjku"ujqwnf"eqphkto
"
"
47" Rctcitcrj"340:05"qh"vjg"ERT"Rtcevkeg"Fktgevkqp"Î"Kpuqnxgpe{"Rtqeggfkpiu0"
"Application for a Validation Order" 89"
"
"vjg"hkpcpekcn"kphqtocvkqp"ikxgp"d{"vjg"fgdvqt="
"vjcv"vjg"fgdvqt"ku"uqnxgpv"cpf"cdng"vq"rc{"jku"fgdvu"cu"vjg{"hcnn"fwg="
"vjcv"vjg"rtqrqugf"vtcpucevkqp"qt" ugtkgu"qh"vtcpucevkqpu"kp"tgurgev"qh" yjkej"
vjg"qtfgt"ku"uqwijv"yknn" dg"dgpghkekcn"vq"qt" yknn"pqv"rtglwfkeg"vjg"kpvgtguvu"
qh"cnn"vjg"wpugewtgf"etgfkvqtu"cu"c"encuu=48"
"vjg"ghhgev"qh"vjg"vtcpucevkqp"qp"vjg"fgdvqtÓu"hkpcpekcn"rqukvkqp0"
"
Cpf"ujqwnf"gzjkdkv
"
"gxkfgpeg"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrvÓu"cuugvu"*kpenwfkpi"fgvcknu"qh"cp{"ugewtkv{ "cpf"vjg "
coqwpvu"ugewtgf+" cpf" nkcdknkvkgu." g0i0"vjg" ncvguv" hkngf" ceeqwpvu."cp{" ftchv"
ceeqwpvu"cpf"guvkocvgf"uvcvgogpv"qh"chhcktu+="
"c"ecuj"hnqy"hqtgecuv"cpf"rtqhkv"cpf"nquu"rtqlgevkqp"hqt"vjg"rgtkqf"hqt"yjkej"
vjg"qtfgt"ku"uqwijv0"
UGTXKEG"
Vjg"crrnkecvkqp"ujqwnf"dg"ugtxgf"qp<49"
"
"vjg"rgvkvkqpkpi"etgfkvqt="
"cp{"etgfkvqt"uwduvkvwvgf"cu"rgvkvkqpgt="
"cp{"etgfkvqt"yjq"jcu"dggp"ikxgp"ecttkcig"qh"vjg"rgvkvkqp="
"cp{" etgfkvqt" yjq" jcu" ikxgp" pqvkeg" vq" vjg" rgvkvkqpgt" qh" jku" kpvgpvkqp" vq"
crrgct" qp" vjg" jgctkpi" qh" vjg" rgvkvkqp" rwtuwcpv" vq" twng" 3203;" qh"vjg"
Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
"
Vjg"crrnkecvkqp" cpf" vjg" gxkfgpeg" kp" uwrrqtv" yknn" pggf" vq" dg" hkngf" cv" eqwtv" cpf"
ugtxgf"qp"vjg"tgurqpfgpv"cu" uqqp"cu"rtcevkecdng"chvgt"kv" ku"hkngf"cpf"kp" cp{"gxgpv."
wpnguu"kv"ku"pgeguuct{" vq"crrn{"ykvjqwv"pqvkeg" qt"qp"ujqtv"pqvkeg."cv" ngcuv"36"fc{u"
dghqtg"vjg"fcvg"hkzgf"hqt"vjg"jgctkpi04:""
"
Vjg"wuwcn"twng"ku"vjcv."uwdlgev"vq"cp{"qvjgt"gzrtguu"rtqxkukqp."vjg"crrnkecvkqp"owuv"
dg"ugtxgf" cv"ngcuv" 36"fc{u"dghqtg" vjg"fcvg" hkzgf"hqt" vjg"jgctkpi04;" Jqygxgt." vjg"
eqwtv"fqgu"jcxg" rqygt."kp" ecugu"qh"wtigpe{." vq"jgct"cp" crrnkecvkqp"koogfkcvgn{"
ykvj"qt"ykvjqwv"pqvkeg"vq"vjg"qvjgt"rctvkgu052"
"
Ugtxkeg"oc{"dg" ghhgevgf"rgtuqpcnn{53"qt"d{" rquv"qp"vjg"tgurqpfgpv" *Rctv"8"qh"vjg"
Ekxkn"Rtqegfwtg" Twngu" *ERT+"crrnkgu" hqt"vjgug" rwtrqugu+54"qt." yjgtg" vjg{"jcxg"
"
48"Denney v John Hudson & Co Ltd"]3;;4̲" DENE" ;23." EC=" Re Fairway Graphics Ltd" ]3;;3̲""
DENE"68:0"
49" Rctcitcrj"340:04"qh"vjg"ERT"Rtcevkeg"Fktgevkqp"Î"Kpuqnxgpe{"Rtqeggfkpiu0"
4:" Twng"340;*5+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
4;" Twng"340;*5+"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
52" Twng"34032"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
53" Twng"3066"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
54" Uejgfwng"6."rctcitcrj"3*4+"vq"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
8:" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
cwvjqtkv{" vq" ceegrv" ugtxkeg." qp"vjg" tgurqpfgpvÓu" uqnkekvqtu0 55" Gngevtqpke" ugtxkeg""
qh" fqewogpvu" ku" pqy" rgtokuukdng" wpfgt" vjg" Twngu." rtqxkfkpi" vjg" tgurqpfgpv"
ewttgpvn{"eqpugpvu"vq"ugtxkeg"kp"vjcv"yc{"cpf"jcu"rtqxkfgf"cp"gockn"cfftguu"hqt"
ugtxkeg"kp"vjcv"yc{0"
MG["OCVGTKCNU"
Ugevkqp"4:6"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"Cev"3;:8"
4:6"Tguvtkevkqpu"qp"fkurqukvkqpu"qh"rtqrgtv{"
*3+" Yjgtg"c"rgtuqp"ku"ocfg"dcpmtwrv."cp{"fkurqukvkqp"qh"rtqrgtv{"ocfg"d{"vjcv"
rgtuqp"kp"vjg"rgtkqf"vq"yjkej"vjku"ugevkqp"crrnkgu"ku"xqkf"gzegrv"vq"vjg"gzvgpv"
vjcv"kv"ku"qt"ycu"ocfg"ykvj"vjg"eqpugpv"qh"vjg"eqwtv."qt"ku"qt"ycu"uwdugswgpvn{"
tcvkhkgf"d{"vjg"eqwtv0"
*4+" Uwdugevkqp" *3+" crrnkgu" vq" c" rc{ogpv" *yjgvjgt" kp" ecuj" qt" qvjgtykug+" cu" kv "
crrnkgu"vq"c"fkurqukvkqp"qh"rtqrgtv{"cpf."ceeqtfkpin{."yjgtg"cp{"rc{ogpv"ku"
xqkf"d{"xktvwg"qh"vjcv"uwdugevkqp."vjg"rgtuqp"rckf"ujcnn"jqnf"vjg"uwo"rckf"hqt"
vjg"dcpmtwrv"cu"rctv"qh"jku"guvcvg0"
*5+" Vjku"ugevkqp"crrnkgu" vq"vjg"rgtkqf"dgikppkpi" ykvj"vjg"fc{" qh"vjg"ocmkpi" qh"
vjg"dcpmtwrve{" crrnkecvkqp"qt" *cu"vjg" ecug"oc{" dg+"vjg" rtgugpvcvkqp"qh" vjg"
dcpmtwrve{"rgvkvkqp" cpf"gpfkpi"ykvj" vjg"xguvkpi." wpfgt"Ejcrvgt" KX"qh" vjku"
Rctv."qh"vjg"dcpmtwrvÓu"guvcvg"kp"c"vtwuvgg0"
*6+" Vjg"rtgegfkpi"rtqxkukqpu" qh"vjku" ugevkqp"fq" pqv"ikxg"c" tgogf{"cickpuv"cp{"
rgtuqpÏ"
"
*c+" kp"tgurgev" qh" cp{" rtqrgtv{"qt" rc{ogpv" yjkej"jg" tgegkxgf" dghqtg" vjg"
eqoogpegogpv"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"kp"iqqf"hckvj."hqt"xcnwg"cpf"ykvjqwv"
pqvkeg"vjcv" vjg"dcpmtwrve{" crrnkecvkqp"jcf" dggp"ocfg" qt"*cu"v jg"ecug"
oc{"dg+"vjcv"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"rgvkvkqp"jcf"dggp"rtgugpvgf."qt"
*d+" kp"tgurgev"qh"cp{"kpvgtguv"kp"rtqrgtv{"yjkej"fgtkxgu"htqo"cp"kpvgtguv" kp"
tgurgev"qh"yjkej"vjgtg"ku."d{"xktvwg"qh"vjku"uwdugevkqp."pq"tgogf{0"
"
*7+" Yjgtg"chvgt"vjg"eqoogpegogpv"qh"jku"dcpmtwrve{"vjg"dcpmtwrv"jcu"kpewttgf"
c"fgdv" vq"c" dcpmgt" qt"qvjgt" rgtuqp"d{" tgcuqp"qh" vjg" ocmkpi"qh" c"rc{ogpv"
yjkej"ku"xqkf"wpfgt"vjku"ugevkqp."vjcv"fgdv"ku"fggogf"hqt"vjg"rwtrqugu"qh"cp{"
qh"vjku"Itqwr" qh"Rctvu" vq"jcxg"dggp" kpewttgf"dghqtg" vjg"eqoogpegogpv"qh"
vjg"dcpmtwrve{"wpnguuÏ"
"
*c+" vjcv"dcpmgt"qt"rgtuqp"jcf"pqvkeg"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"dghqtg"vjg"fgdv"ycu"
kpewttgf."qt"
*d+" kv"ku"pqv"tgcuqpcdn{"rtcevkecdng"hqt"vjg"coqwpv"qh"vjg"rc{ogpv"vq" dg"
tgeqxgtgf"htqo"vjg"rgtuqp"vq"yjqo"kv"ycu"ocfg0"
"
"
55" Twng"3062"qh"vjg"Kpuqnxgpe{"*Gpincpf"cpf"Ycngu+"Twngu"42380"
"Application for a Validation Order" 8;"
"
*8+" C"fkurqukvkqp"qh"rtqrgtv{"ku"xqkf"wpfgt"vjku"ugevkqp"pqvykvjuvcpfkpi"vjcv"vjg"
rtqrgtv{" ku" pqv" qt." cu" vjg" ecug" oc{" dg." yqwnf" pqv" dg" eqortkugf"kp" vjg"
dcpmtwrvÓu"guvcvg="dwv"pqvjkpi"kp"vjku"ugevkqp"chhgevu"cp{"fkurqukvkqp"ocfg"d{"
c"rgtuqp"qh"rtqrgtv{"jgnf"d{"jko"qp"vtwuv"hqt"cp{"qvjgt"rgtuqp0"
Rctcitcrj"340:"qh"vjg"ERT"Rtcevkeg"Fktgevkqp"Î"Kpuqnxgpe{"
Rtqeggfkpiu."6"Lwn{"423:"
340:" Xcnkfcvkqp"qtfgtu"
340:03" C"rgtuqp" cickpuv"yjqo" c"d cpmtwrve{"rgvkvkqp" jcu"dggp" rtgugpvgf"
oc{"crrn{"vq" vjg"Eqwtv"chvgt" rtgugpvcvkqp"qh" vjg"rgvkvkqp"hqt" tgnkgh"
htqo"vjg"ghhgevu"qh"u04:6*3+"Î"*5+"qh"vjg"Cev"d{"uggmkpi"cp"qtfgt"vjcv"
c" egtvckp" fkurqukvkqp" qt" fkurqukvkqpu" qh" vjcv" rgtuqpÓu" rtqrgtv{."
kpenwfkpi" rc{ogpvu" qwv" qh" vjgkt" dcpm" ceeqwpv" *yjgvjgt" uwej"
ceeqwpv"ku"kp"etgfkv"qt"qxgtftcyp+."ujcnn"pqv"dg"xqkf"kp"vjg"gxgpv"qh"
c" dcpmtwrve{" qtfgt" dgkpi" ocfg" cv" vjg" jgctkpi" qh" vjg" rgvkvkqp" *c"
xcnkfcvkqp"qtfgt+0"
340:04" Ucxg" kp" gzegrvkqpcn" ektewouvcpegu." pqvkeg" qh" vjg" ocmkpi" qh" vjg"
crrnkecvkqp" ujqwnf" dg" ikxgp" vq" *c+" vjg" rgvkvkqpkpi"etgfkvqt*u+" qt"
qvjgt" rgvkvkqpgt." *d+" cp{" etgfkvqt" yjq" jcu" ikxgp" pqvkeg" vq" vjg"
rgvkvkqpgt"qh"vjgkt"kpvgpvkqp"vq"crrgct"qp"vjg"jgctkpi"qh"vjg"rgvkvkqp"
rwtuwcpv"vq"twng"3203;."*e+"cp{"etgfkvqt"yjq"jcu"dggp"uwduvkvwvgf"cu"
rgvkvkqpgt" rwtuwcpv" vq" twng" 32049" cpf" *f+" cp{" etgfkvqt" yjq" jcu"
ecttkcig"qh"vjg"rgvkvkqp"rwtuwcpv"vq"twng"3204;0"
340:05" Vjg"crrnkecvkqp"ujqwnf"dg"uwrrqtvgf"d{"c"ykvpguu"uvcvgogpv"yjkej."
ucxg"kp"gzegrvkqpcn" ektewouvcpegu."ujqwnf"dg" ocfg"d{"vjg" fgdvqt0"
Kh" crrtqrtkcvg." uwrrqtvkpi" gxkfgpeg" kp" vjg" hqto" qh" c" ykvpguu"
uvcvgogpv"htqo"vjg"fgdvqtÓu"ceeqwpvcpv"ujqwnf"cnuq"dg"rtqfwegf0"
340:06" Vjg"gzvgpv"cpf"eqpvgpvu"qh" vjg"gxkfgpeg"yknn"xct{"ceeqtfkpi" vq"vjg"
ektewouvcpegu" cpf" vjg" pcvwtg" qh" vjg"tgnkgh" uqwijv." dwv" kp" c" ecug"
yjgtg" vjg" fgdvqt" ku" vtcfkpi" qt" ectt{kpi" qp" dwukpguu" kv" ujqwnf"
kpenwfg."cu"c"okpkowo."vjg"hqnnqykpi"kphqtocvkqp
"
*3+" yjgp"cpf" vq"yjqo" pqvkeg" jcu"dggp" ikxgp"kp" ceeqtfcpeg"
ykvj"rctcitcrj"340:04"cdqxg="
*4+" dtkgh"fgvcknu" qh"vjg" ektewouvcpegu"ngcfkpi" vq"rtgugpvcvkqp"
qh"vjg"rgvkvkqp="
*5+" jqy"vjg" fgdvqt" dgecog"cyctg" qh" vjg"rtgugpvcvkqp" qh" vjg"
rgvkvkqp="
*6+" yjgvjgt"vjg" rgvkvkqp" fgdv"ku" cfokvvgf" qt" fkurwvgf"cpf." kh"
vjg"ncvvgt." dtkgh" fgvcknu" qh" vjg"dcuku" qp" yjkej" vjg"fgdv" ku"
fkurwvgf="
*7+" hwnn" fgvcknu" qh" vjg" fgdvqtÓu" hkpcpekcn" rqukvkqp" kpenwfkpi"
fgvcknu"qh"vjgkt"cuugvu"*kpenwfkpi"fgvcknu"qh"cp{"ugewtkv{"cpf"
vjg" coqwpv*u+" ugewtgf+" cpf" nkcdknkvkgu." yjkej" ujqwnf" dg"
uwrrqtvgf."cu" hct" cu" rquukdng." d{" fqewogpvct{" gxkfgpeg."
g0i0" ceeqwpvu." ftchv" ceeqwpvu." ocpcigogpv" ceeqwpvu" qt"
guvkocvgf"uvcvgogpv"qh"chhcktu="
92" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
*8+" c"ecuj"hnqy"hqtgecuv"cpf" rtqhkv"cpf"nquu"rtqlgevkqp" hqt"vjg"
rgtkqf"hqt"yjkej"vjg"qtfgt"ku"uqwijv="
*9+" fgvcknu"qh"vjg"fkurqukvkqpu"qt"rc{ogpvu"kp"tgurgev"qh"yjkej"
cp"qtfgt"ku"uqwijv="
*:+" vjg" tgcuqpu" tgnkgf" qp" kp" uwrrqtv" qh" vjg" pggf" hqt" uwej"
fkurqukvkqpu"qt"rc{ogpvu"vq"dg"ocfg="
*;+" cp{" qvjgt" kphqtocvkqp" tgngxcpv" vq" vjg" gzgtekug" qh" vjg"
EqwtvÓu"fkuetgvkqp="
*32+" fgvcknu" qh" cp{" eqpugpvu" qdvckpgf" htqo" vjg" rgtuqpu"
ogpvkqpgf" kp" rctcitcrj" 340:04" cdqxg" *uwrrqtvgf" d{"
fqewogpvct{"gxkfgpeg"yjgtg"crrtqrtkcvg+="
*33+" fgvcknu"qh"cp{"tgngxcpv"dcpm"ceeqwpv."kpenwfkpi"kvu"pwodgt"
cpf"vjg" cfftguu" cpf"uqtv" eqfg"qh" vjg" dcpm"cv" yjkej"uwej"
ceeqwpv" ku" jgnf" cpf" vjg" coqwpv" qh" vjg" etgfkv" qt" fgdkv"
dcncpeg" qp" uwej" ceeqwpv" cv" vjg" vkog" qh" ocmkpi" vjg"
crrnkecvkqp0"
"
340:07" Yjgtg"cp" crrnkecvkqp" ku"ocfg" wtigpvn{" vq"gpcdng" rc{ogpvu"vq" dg"
ocfg"yjkej"ctg"guugpvkcn"vq"eqpvkpwgf"vtcfkpi"*g0i0"ycigu+"cpf"kv"ku"
pqv"rquukdng" vq" cuugodng" cnn" vjg"gx kfgpeg"nkuvgf" cdqxg." vjg" Eqwtv"
oc{"eqpukfgt" itcpvkpi" nkokvgf" tgnkgh"hqt" c" ujqtv" rgtkqf."dwv" vjgtg"
owuv"dg"uwhhkekgpv"gxkfgpeg"vq"ucvkuh{"vjg"Eqwtv"vjcv"vjg"kpvgtguvu"qh"
etgfkvqtu"ctg"wpnkmgn{"vq"dg"rtglwfkegf0"
340:08" Yjgtg" vjg"fgdvqt" ku" pqv" vtcfkpi" qt" ectt{kpi" qp" dwukpguu" cpf" vjg"
crrnkecvkqp" tgncvgu" qpn{" vq" c" rtqrqugf" ucng." oqtvicig" qt" tg/
oqtvicig" qh" vjg" fgdvqtÓu" jqog." gxkfgpeg" qh" vjg" hqnnqykpi" yknn"
igpgtcnn{"uwhhkeg
"
*3+" yjgp"cpf" vq"yjqo" pqvkeg" jcu"dggp" ikxgp"kp" ceeqtfcpeg"
ykvj"340:04"cdqxg="
*4+" yjgvjgt"vjg" rgvkvkqp" fgdv"ku" cfokvvgf" qt" fkurwvgf"cpf." kh"
vjg"ncvvgt." dtkgh" fgvcknu" qh" vjg"dcuku" qp" yjkej" vjg"fgdv" ku"
fkurwvgf="
*5+" fgvcknu" qh" vjg" rtqrgtv{" vq" dg" uqnf." oqtvicigf" qt" tg/
oqtvicigf"*kpenwfkpi"kvu"vkvng"pwodgt+="
*6+" vjg"xcnwg" qh"vjg" rtqrgtv{"cpf" vjg" rtqrqugf"ucng" rtkeg."qt"
fgvcknu"qh"vjg"oqtvicig"qt"tg/oqtvicig="
*7+" fgvcknu" qh" cp{" gzkuvkpi" oqtvicigu" qt" ejctigu" qp" vjg"
rtqrgtv{"cpf"tgfgorvkqp"hkiwtgu="
*8+" vjg"equvu"qh"ucng"*g0i0"uqnkekvqtuÓ"qt"cigpvuÓ"equvu+="
*9+" jqy" cpf" d{" yjqo" cp{" pgv" rtqeggfu" qh" ucng" *qt" uwou"
eqokpi"kpvq"vjg"fgdvqtÓu"jcpfu"cu"c"tguwnv"qh"cp{"oqtvicig"
qt"tg/oqtvicig+"ctg"vq"dg"jgnf"rgpfkpi"vjg"hkpcn"jgctkpi"qh"
vjg"rgvkvkqp="
*:+" cp{" qvjgt" kphqtocvkqp" tgngxcpv" vq" vjg" gzgtekug" qh" vjg"
EqwtvÓu"fkuetgvkqp="
"Application for a Validation Order" 93"
"
*;+" fgvcknu" qh" cp{" eqpugpvu" qdvckpgf" htqo" vjg" rgtuqpu"
ogpvkqpgf" kp" 340:04" cdqxg" *uwrrqtvgf" d{" fqewogpvct{"
gxkfgpeg"yjgtg"crrtqrtkcvg+0"
"
340:09" Yjgvjgt"qt"pqv"vjg"fgdvqt"ku"vtcfkpi"qt"ectt{kpi"qp"dwukpguu."yjgtg"
vjg" crrnkecvkqp" kpxqnxgu" c" fkurqukvkqp"qh" rtqrgtv{" vjg" Eqwtv" yknn"
pggf"vq"dg" ucvkuhkgf"vjcv"cp{" rtqrqugf"fkurqucn"yknn" dg"cv"c" rtqrgt"
xcnwg0" Cp" kpfgrgpfgpv" xcnwcvkqp" ujqwnf" dg" qdvckpgf" hqt" vjku"
rwtrqug"cpf"gzjkdkvgf"vq"vjg"gxkfgpeg0"
340:0:" Vjg"Eqwtv" yknn" pggf"vq" dg" ucvkuhkgf"d{" etgfkdng" gxkfgpeg"vjcv" vjg"
fgdvqt"ku"uqnxgpv"cpf"cdng"vq"rc{"vjgkt"fgdvu"cu"vjg{"hcnn"fwg"qt"vjcv"
c"rctvkewnct"vtcpucevkqp"qt"ugtkgu"qh"vtcpucevkqpu"kp"tgurgev"qh"yjkej"
vjg"qtfgt" ku" uqwijv"yknn" dg" dgpghkekcn"vq" qt" yknn"pqv" rtglwfkeg"vjg"
kpvgtguvu"qh"cnn"vjg"wpugewtgf"etgfkvqtu"cu"c"encuu0"
340:0;" C"ftchv"qh"vjg"qtfgt"ujqwnf"ceeqorcp{"vjg"crrnkecvkqp0"
340:032" Ukoknct"eqpukfgtcvkqpu"vq"vjqug"ugv"qwv" cdqxg"ctg"nkmgn{"vq"crrn{"vq"
crrnkecvkqpu"uggmkpi" tcvkhkecvkqp"qh" c"vtcpucevkqp" qt"rc{ogpv" chvgt"
vjg"ocmkpi"qh"c"dcpmtwrve{"qtfgt0"
"
"
94" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
703" QTFKPCT["CRRNKECVKQP"HQT"C"XCNKFCVKQP"
QTFGT"RWTUWCPV"VQ"UGEVKQP"4:6"QH"VJG"
KPUQNXGPE["CEV"3;:8"
"Application for a Validation Order" 95"
"
96" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
"Application for a Validation Order" 97"
"
704" FTCHV"XCNKFCVKQP"QTFGT"
98" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
"Application for a Validation Order" 99"
"
705" FGDVQTÓU"YKVPGUU"UVCVGOGPV"KP"UWRRQTV"
QH"CP"CRRNKECVKQP"HQT"C"XCNKFCVKQP"
QTFGT"
"
9:" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
"Application for a Validation Order" 9;"
"
""
:2" Personal Insolvency Practice"
"
706" CEEQWPVCPVÓU"YKVPGUU"UVCVGOGPV"KP"
UWRRQTV"QH"CP"CRRNKECVKQP"HQT"C"
XCNKFCVKQP"QTFGT"
"
"Application for a Validation Order" :3"
"
"
"
To continue reading
Request your trial