Statutes
| Author | Christopher Jessel |
| Pages | 85-104 |
"
"
Ejcrvgt"8"
Uvcvwvgu"
RCTV"3"Î"IGPGTCN"RTKPEKRNGU"
803" ETQYP"KOOWPKV["
Cp"Cev"qh"Rctnkcogpv"fqgu"pqv"dkpf"vjg"Etqyp"wpnguu"gkvjgt"kv"eqpvckpu"cp"gzrtguu"
rtqxkukqp." mpqyp" cu" c" Etqyp" crrnkecvkqp" ugevkqp." qt" vjgtg" ku" c" pgeguuct{"
kornkecvkqp."vjcv"ku"vjcv"vjg"Cev"fqgu"pqv"ocmg"ugpug"wpnguu"kv"dkpfu0"Kp"vjg"eqpvgzv"
qh"rtqrgtv{."kh" cp"Cev"fqgu" pqv"dkpf" vjgp"rqygtu"itcpvgf" d{"Rctnkcogpv"vq" pqp/
Etqyp"dqfkgu"uwej"cu"eqorwnuqt{"rwtejcug"qt"tkijvu"qh"gpvt{"ecp"pqv"dg"gzgtekugf"
qxgt"Etqyp"ncpf0"Vjg"twng"ku"mpqyp"cu"Etqyp"koowpkv{0"
Cnvjqwij"uqogvkogu"uckf"vq"fgtkxg"htqo"vjg"rtgtqicvkxg"kv"ku"dgvvgt"uggp"cu"c"ecpqp"
qh"uvcvwvqt{"eqpuvtwevkqp0"Cp"Cev" ku"ocfg"d{"vjg" uqxgtgkip"ÒDg"kv"gpcevgf"d{"vjg"
SwggpÓu1MkpiÓu"Oquv"Gzegnngpv"Oclguv{"ÈÓ0"Ukpeg"vjg"ncvg" 35vj"egpvwt{"uvcvwvgu"
ecp" qpn{" dg" ocfg" ykvj" vjg" cfxkeg" cpf" eqpugpv" qh" vjg" nqtfu" cpf" eqooqpu"
cuugodngf"kp"Rctnkcogpv0"Gxgp"ykvj"vjcv"eqpugpv"c"dknn"fqgu"pqv"dgeqog"ncy"wpvkn"
kv"jcu"vjg"tq{cn"cuugpv="kv"tgockpu"c"eqoocpf"htqo"vjg"Etqyp"cpf"vjgtghqtg"ku"pqv"
dkpfkpi"qp"vjg"eqoocpfgt"wpnguu"vjg"Etqyp"citggu"vq"kvu"rtqxkukqpu0"
Hqt"rtgugpv"rwtrqugu"Cevu"hcnn"kpvq"vjtgg"encuugu
*c+" Igpgtcn"uvcvwvgu"kpvgpfgf"vq"crrn{"vq"rtkxcvg"rgtuqpu0"Vjku"kpenwfgu"cnn"
vjg"pqtocn" vqrkeu"uwej" cu"etkokpcn"ncy." hcokn{"ncy." eqoogtekcn"ncy."
gfwecvkqp" ncy" cpf" jqwukpi" ncy0" Vjg" uwdlgev/ocvvgt" qh" vjg" Cev" yknn"
qhvgp"dg"kttgngxcpv"vq"vjg"Etqyp0"Kh"kv"ecp"tgncvg"vjgtg"oc{"dg"c"Etqyp"
crrnkecvkqp"ugevkqp0"
*d+" Uvcvwvgu" fgcnkpi" ykvj" ncpf" dgnqpikpi" vq" vjg" Etqyp" qt" tgiwncvkpi"
iqxgtpogpv"cevkxkvkgu0"Vjgug"yknn"pqv"pggf"cp"crrnkecvkqp"ugevkqp0"Oquv"
qh"vjgo"ctg"pqv"crrnkecdng"vq"rtkxcvg"rgtuqpu"qt"ncpf0"
:8" Crown and Government Land"
"
*e+" Nqecn."rtkxcvg"cpf"rgtuqpcn"Cevu0"Kp"vjg"rcuv"vjgug"ygtg"uggp"cu" itcpvu"
d{"vjg" Etqyp"vq" kpfkxkfwcnu."eqorcp kgu"qt" eqoowpkvkgu"cpf" cu"uwej"
ygtg"cuuwogf"vq"dkpf"kp" vjg"cdugpeg"qh"urgekcn"rtqxkukqp0"Kv" vjgtghqtg"
dgecog" eqooqp" rtcevkeg" hqt" Etqyp" dqfkgu" vq" tgswktg" cp" gzrtguu"
Etqyp" gzgorvkqp" ugevkqp" vq" dg" kpugtvgf" kp" nqecn" Cevu0" Vjg"
Kpvgtrtgvcvkqp"Cev" 3;9:."u" 5"pqy" rtqxkfgu" vjcv"gxgt{" Cev"ku" c"rwdnke"
Cev=" u"43*3+" fghkpgu" cp" Cev" cu" kpenwfkpi" rtkxcvg." rgtuqpcn" cpf" nqecn"
Cevu="cpf" u"43*4+" rtqxkfgu"vjcv" vjg" 3;9:"Cev" dkpfu"vjg" Etqyp0" Uwej"
Cevu"ctg"vjgtghqtg"uwdlgev"vq" vjg"ucog"twngu"cu"rwdnke" Cevu"cpf"kp"vjcv"
ecug"cp"gzgorvkqp"ugevkqp"yqwnf"pqv"uggo"pgeguuct{"dwv"vjg"rqkpv"jcu"
pqv" dggp" vguvgf" cpf" kv" ku" uvknn" wuwcn" hqt" cp" gzgorvkqp" encwug" vq" dg"
kpugtvgf"kp"cp{"nqecn"dknn"yjkej"okijv"korcev"qp"Etqyp"ncpf0"
"
Vjg"igpgtcn"twng"ku"nqpi"uvcpfkpi0"Kp"Willion v Berkley"kv"ycu"uckf<3"
Cpf"dgecwug"kv"ku"pqv"cp"Cev"ykvjqwv"vjg"MkpiÓu"cuugpv."kv"ku"vq"dg"kpvgpfgf"vjcv"
yjgp"vjg"Mkpi"ikxgu"jku"cuugpv."jg"fqgu"pqv"ogcp"vq"rtglwfkeg"jkougnh"qt"vq"dct"
jkougnh"qh"jku"nkdgtv{"cpf"rtkxkngig."dwv"jg"cuugpvu"vjcv"kv"ujcnn"dg"c"ncy"coqpi"
jku"uwdlgevu0"
"
Kp"vjg" Magdalen College Case4 vjg"eqwtvÓu"ugeqpf" tguqnwvkqp"ycu." ÒVjcv"yjgtg"
vjg"Mkpi" jcu"cp{" rtgtqicvkxg."guvcvg." tkijv."vkvng." qt"kpvgtguv." vjcv"d{" vjg"igpgtcn"
yqtfu"qh"cp"Cev"jg"ujcnn"pqv"dg"dcttgf"qh"vjgo"ÈÓ0"
Kp"British Broadcasting Corporation v Johns5"Fkrnqem"NL"uckf
Vjg"oqfgtp" twng" qh" eqpuvtwevkqp" qh" uvcvwvgu" ku" vjcv" vjg" Etqyp." yjkej" vqfc{"
rgtuqpkhkgu"vjg"gzgewvkxg"iqxgtpogpv" qh"vjg"eqwpvt{"cpf" ku"cnuq"c"rctv{" vq"cnn"
ngikuncvkqp."ku"pqv"dqwpf"d{"c"uvcvwvg"yjkej"korqugu"qdnkicvkqpu"qt"tguvtckpvu"qp"
rgtuqpu"qt" kp" tgurgev" qh" rtqrgtv{" wpnguu" vjg" uvcvwvg" uc{u" uq" gzrtguun{" qt" d{"
pgeguuct{"kornkecvkqp0"
"
Vjg"ncy"ycu"eqpukfgtgf"d{" vjg"Uwrtgog"Eqwtv"kp"R (Black) v Secretary of State
for Justice06"Vjg"crrnkecpvÓu" ctiwogpv"ycu"vj cv"vjg"rtqxkukqpu" kp"vjg"Jgcnvj"Cev"
4228."Rv"3"rtqjkdkvkpi"uoqmkpi"kp"rwdnke"r ncegu"dqwpf"vjg"Etqyp"cpf"crrnkgf"vq"
rtkuqpu0"Vjgtg"ycu"pq"Etqyp"crrnkecvkqp"ugevkqp"cpf"vjg"eqwtv"eqwnf"pqv"hkpf"cp{"
"
3" *3783+"3"Rnqy"445"cv"462."97"GT"55;"cv"5880"
4" *3837+"33"Eq"Tgr"88"cv"96d."99"GT"3457"cv"34690"
5" ]3;87̲"Ej"54"cv"9:0"
6" ]4239̲"WMUE":3."]423:̲"CE"4370"
"Statutes" :9"
"
pgeguuct{"kornkecvkqp" *tcvjgt"vjg"tgxgtug+0" Ncf{"JcngÓu" lwfiogpv7"tgxkgygf"vj g"
ecugu"cpf"vjg"eqwtv"eqpenwfgf"vjcv"vjg"Etqyp"ycu"pqv"dqwpf0"
804" KORNKECVKQP"CPF"CRRNKECVKQP"
80403" Kornkecvkqp"
Pgeguuct{"kornkecvkqp"ogcpu"vjcv"kh"cp"Cev"fqgu"pqv"ocmg"ugpug"wpnguu"kv"crrnkgu"
vjgp"kv"owuv"dkpf0"Vjg"nctiguv"itqwr"qh"uwej"Cevu"ctg"vjqug"vjcv"iqxgtp"vjg"Etqyp"
kvugnh."u wej"cu"vjg"Etq yp"Ncpfu"Cev u."vjg"Etqyp "Guvcvg"Cev"3; 83"qt"vjg"Okpkuvgtu"
qh"vjg"Etqyp"Cev" 3;970"Qvjgtu"okijv"kpenwfg" rtqxkukqpu"gzvgpfkpi"vjg"nkokvu" qh"
vjg"tgcno"cu" qxgt"vjg" vgttkvqtkcn"ugc"qt" yjgtg"c"rtqxkukqp" kp"vjg"Cev" tghgtu"vq" cp"
curgev"qh"vjg"Etqyp0"
Kp"Province of Bombay v Municipal Corporation of the City of Bombay8"vjg"Ekv{"
qh"Dqodc{"Owpkekrcn"Cev"3:::.9"uu"444"cpf"4 87"icxg"c"eqookuukqpgt"rqygt"vq"
nc{"ycvgt" ockpu" hqt" vjg" rwtrqug" qh" ycvgt" uwrrn{" vjtqwij." cetquu" qt" wpfgt" cp{"
uvtggv"cpf"kpvq."vjtqwij"qt"wpfgt"cp{"ncpf"kp"vjg"ekv{0"Vjg"kuuwg"ycu"yjgvjgt" kv"
eqwnf"nc{" c"ycvgt" ockp"kp" c"rtkxcvg" tqcf"dgnqpikpi" vq"vjg" iqxgtpogpv0"Nqtf" fw"
Rctes."ikxkpi"vjg"lwfiogpv"qh"vjg"Dqctf."uckf<:"
Vjg"igpgtcn"rtkpekrng" vq"dg"crrnkgf" kp"eqpukfgtkpi"yjgvjgt" qt"pqv"vjg" Etqyp""
ku"dqwpf"d{" igpgtcn"yqtfu"kp"c" uvcvwvg"ku"pqv"kp" fqwdv0"Vjg"oczko"qh" vjg"ncy""
kp" gctn{" vkogu"ycu" vjcv" pq" uvcvwvg" dqwpf" vjg" Etqyp" wpnguu" vjg" Etqyp" ycu"
gzrtguun{" pcogf" vjgtgkp." ÒRoy n’est lie par ascun statute si il ne soit
expressement nosmeÓ0" Dwv" vjg" twng" uq" nckf"fqyp" ku" uwdlgev" vq" cv" ngcuv" qpg"
gzegrvkqp0"Vjg" Etqyp"oc{" dg"dqwpf." cu"jcu" qhvgp" dggp"uckf." Òd{"pgeguuct{"
kornkecvkqpÓ0"Kh."vjcv"ku"vq"uc{."kv"ku"ocpkhguv"htqo"vjg"xgt{"vgtou"qh"vjg"uvcvwvg."
vjcv"kv"ycu"vjg"kpvgpvkqp"qh"vjg"ngikuncvwtg"vjcv"vjg"Etqyp"ujqwnf"dg"dqwpf."vjgp"
vjg"tguwnv"ku"vjg"ucog"c u"kh"vjg"Etqyp"jcf"dggp"gzrtguun{"pcogf0" Kv"owuv"vjgp"
dg"kphgttgf"vjcv"vjg"Etqyp."d{" cuugpvkpi"vq"vjg"ncy."citggf"vq"dg"dqwpf" d{"kvu"
rtqxkukqpu0"
"
Uwej" ecugu." yjgtg" vjg" kpvgpvkqp"qh" vjg" ngikuncvwtg" ku" ocpkhguv."dwv"vjgtg"ku"pq"
gzrtguu" Etqyp" crrnkecvkqp" ugevkqp." owuv." ucxg" hqt" Cevu" urgekhkecnn{" tgiwncvkpi"
"
7" ]4239̲"WMUE":3."]423:̲"CE"437"cv"]45̲"vq"]53̲0"
8" ]3;69̲"CE"7:0"
9" Pqy"vjg"Owodck"Owpkekrcn"Eqtrqtcvkqp"Cev"3:::0"
:" Cv"830"
::" Crown and Government Land"
"
Etqyp"cevkxkv{."dg" tctg0"Kp"R (Black) v Secretary of State for Justice Ncf{"Jcng"
cpcn{ugf"vjg"yqtfkpi"qh"vjg"Cev"cpf"eqpenwfgf<;"
Pgeguuct{" kornkecvkqp"gpvcknu" vjcv" Rctnkcogpv" owuv" jcxg" ogcpv" vq" dkpf" vjg"
Etqyp0"Vjg"hcev"vjcv"yjgtg"Rctnkcogpv"fkf"ogcp"vq"fq"uq"kp"vjku"Cev."kv"uck f"uq."
cpf" ocfg" vcknqtgf" rtqxkukqp" ceeqtfkpin{." ku" vq" o{" okpf" eqpenwukxg"qh" v jg"
swguvkqp0"
80404" Crrnkecvkqp"
Coqpi"vjg"dqkngtrncvg"encwugu" vqyctfu"vjg"gpf"qh" cp"Cev."fgcnkpi"ykvj"vjg" ujqtv"
vkvng."vgttkvqtkcn"gzvgpv."eqoogpegogpv."kpvgtrtgvcvkqp"cpf"qvjgt"hqtocn"rtqxkukqpu"
vjgtg"oc{"cnuq"dg"cp" gzrtguu"Etqyp"crrnkecvkqp"ugevkqp0"Kv"ku"pqv"pgeguuct{"hqt"c"
yjqng"Cev" vq"dkpf" cpf"kv" ku"eqooqp" hqt"qpg" rctv"qt" ejcrvgt"vq" fq"uq"qt" gxgp"c"
ukping"ugevkqp"yjkng"vjg"tguv"qh"vjg"Cev"fqgu"pqv0"Eqttgurqpfkpin{"kh"cp"Cev"qt"rctv"
dkpfu."rctvkewnct"ugevkqpu"ykvjkp" kv."gurgekcnn{"vjqug"korqukpi"etkokpcn"rgpcnvkgu."
oc{"dg"gzrtguugf"pqv"vq"dkpf0"
Jqy"hct"cp{"rctvkewnct"rctv"qt"ugevkqp"qh"uwej" cp"Cev"crrnkgu"vq"cnn"curgevu"qh"vjg"
Etqyp"fgrgpfu"qp"vjg"yqtfu"wugf0"Vjgug"ecp"vcmg"xctkqwu"hqtou"cpf."yjkng"uqog"
yqtfkpi"ku" uvcpfctf."vjg" rctnkcogpvct{"ftchvuocp" yknn"qhvgp" etchv"c"encwug"hqt"c"
rctvkewnct"dknn0"Kv"ecp" pqv"dg"cuuwogf"vjcv" cp"crrnkecvkqp"ugevkqp"hqt"qpg" rwtrqug"
ku"vjg"ucog"cu"vjcv"hqt"cpqvjgt."uqogvkogu"gxgp"ykvjkp"vjg"ucog"Cev0"Hqt"gzcorng"
vjg" Rncppkpi" Cev" 422:" igpgtcn" Etqyp" rtqxkukqpu" ctg" kp" uu" 448" vq" 44:" cpf" kp"
rctvkewnct"u"449*7+"jcu"34"rctcitcrju"fghkpkpi"Òcrrtqrtkcvg"Etqyp"cwvjqtkv{Ó"dwv"
vjgtg"ctg" ugrctcvg" rtqxkukqpu"kp" uu"62." 76." 357."388." 44:"cpf" 453"hqt" urgekhkgf"
curgevu0"Gxgp"yjgp"cp"Cev"dkpfu"uqog"curgevu" qh"vjg"Etqyp"kv"oc{"pqv"crrn{"vq"
vjg"uqxgtgkip"rgtuqpcnn{"qt"vq"vjg" Tq{cn"Jqwugjqnf="kp"uwej"ecugu"cttcpigogpvu"
ecp" kp" rtcevkeg" dg"ocfg" hqt" uwkvcdng" rtqxkukqp" vq" dg" gzvgpfgf" vq" vjg" qeewrkgf"
rcncegu"cpf" vjg"Rtkxcvg"Guvcvgu" yjkng"uchgiwctfkpi" vjg"uqxgtgkipÓu" ugewtkv{"cpf"
rtkxce{0"
Kh"vjg"Etqyp"crrnkecvkqp"ugevkqp"uc{u"ÒVjku"Cev"dkpfu"vjg"EtqypÓ"vjgp"kv"dkpfu"kp"
cnn"curgevu0" C" oqtg" f gvckngf" hqto" ku" qhvgp" wugf" yjgtg" vjg" Cev" eqphgtu" rqygtu"
chhgevkpi"ncpf"qp"dqfkgu"uwej"cu"nqecn"cwvjqtkvkgu"qt"wvknkvkgu"eqorcpkgu0"Kp"uwej"c"
ecug"Etqyp" ncpf" oc{"dg" fghkpgf" cu"ncpf" kp" yjkej"vjgtg" ku" c"Etqyp" qt"Fwej{"
kpvgtguv0"C"Etqyp" kpvgtguv"ku"vjgp" fghkpgf"cu"cp" kpvgtguv"dgnqpikpi"vq"Jgt"qt"Jku"
Oclguv{"kp"tkijv"qh"vjg"Etqyp"qt" vq"c"iqxgtpogpv"fgrctvogpv"qt"jgnf"kp"vtwuv"hqt"
Jgt" qt" Jku" Oclguv{" hqt" vjg" rwtrqugu" qh" c" iqxgtpogpv" fgrctvogpv0"C"Fwej{"
kpvgtguv" ku" fghkpgf" cu" cp" kpvgtguv" dgnqpikpi" vq" vjg" Fwejkgu" qh" Ncpecuvgt" qt"
Eqtpycnn0"Vjg{"oc{" hwtvjgt"dg" eqpvtcuvgf"ykvj"c" rtkxcvg"kpvgtguv." fghkpgf"cu" cp"
"
;" ]4239̲"WMUE":3."]423:̲"CE"437"cv"]72̲0"
"Statutes" :;"
"
kpvgtguv"yjkej"ku" pgkvjgt"c"Etqyp"kpvgtguv" pqt"c"Fwej{" kpvgtguv0"Uqog"Cevu" dkpf"
vjg"Etqyp"Guvcvg"cpf"vjg"Fwejkgu"dwv"pqv"iqxgtpogpv"fgrctvogpvu"uwej"cu"vjqug"
hqt"vjg"rtqvgevkqp"qh"tgukfgpvkcn"vgpcpvu"*809+0"
Vjg"ugevkqp"oc{"iq"qp"vq"swcnkh{"vjg"igpgtcn"twng0"Vjwu"vjg"Ncy"qh"Rtqrgtv{"Cev"
3;47."u" 42:"dkpfu" vjg" Etqyp"dwv" pqv"uq" cu"vq" chhgev"vjg" fguegpv."fgxqnwvkqp" qt"
vgpwtg"qh" qt"kp" Etqyp"qt" Fwej{"ncpf0" Yjgtg"cp"Cev" etgcvgu"c" etkokpcn"qhhgpeg"
vjgp."gxgp"kh"vjg"Cev" crrnkgu"igpgtcnn{."kv"ku"wuwcn" vq"rtqxkfg"vjcv"vjg"Etqyp" yknn"
pqv" dg"nkcdn g"dwv" vjcv" c" eqwtv" oc{" ocmg" c" fgenctcvkqp" vjcv" uqog" cevkqp" qh" vjg"
Etqyp"ku"wpncyhwn"qt"vjcv"kv"crrnkgu"vq"rgtuqpu"kp"vjg"rwdnke"ugtxkeg"qh"vjg"Etqyp0"
Uqogvkogu"vjgtg"oc{"dg" oqtg"gncdqtcvg"rtqxkukqpu"cu" kp"vjg"Vqyp"cpf"Eqwpvt{"
Rncppkpi"Cev"3;;2"kp"yjkej"Rv"ZKKK"*cu"cogpfgf"kp"4226+"eqpegtpu"vjg"Etqyp0"Kv"
pqy"twpu" vq"gkijv" ugevkqpu"ewttgpvn{" kp"hqteg"*ykvj" qvjgtu"pqy" tgrgcngf+"cpf" ku"
hwtvjgt"uwrrngogpvgf"d{"tgiwncvkqpu0"Vjg"Gpxktqpogpv"Cev"4243."Uej"3;"crrn{kpi"
Rv"9"vq"Etqyp"ncpf"twpu"vq"43"rctcitcrju0"
80405" Cogpfogpv"
Kh"c"ncvgt"Cev"cogpfu"cp"gctnkgt"qpg"yjkej"dkpfu."vjgp"vjg"vgzvwcn"cogpfogpv"yknn"
cnuq"dkpf"uq" vjcv"vjg"Etqyp"yknn" dg"dqwpf"d{"vjg" Cev"kp"kvu"cogpfgf" hqto0"Vjku"
oc{"dg"kornkgf"dwv"uqogvkogu"vjg"cogpfkpi"Cev"yknn"uvcvg"vjku"gzrtguun{"cu"kp"vjg"
Nqecnkuo"Cev"4233."u"366"yjkej"cogpfu"vjg"rncppkpi"Cevu"qt"kp"vjg"Gpxktqpogpv"
Cev"4243." u"366*4+" yjkej"eqxgtu" ugxgtcn"cogpfogpvu0" Kh"c" pwodgt"qh" Cevu"ctg"
fktgevgf"vq"dg" eqpuvtwgf"vqigvjgt"cu"c" eqfg"yjkej"eqpvckpu" c"Etqyp"crrnkecvkqp"
ugevkqp"vjgp"c"o qfkhkecvkqp"qh"vjg"eqfg" kp"c"ncvgt"Cev" yknn"dkpf0"Hqt"kpuvcpeg" vjg"
Kpenquwtg"Cev"3:67" jcu"Etqyp"cpf" Fwej{"rtqxkukqpu"kp" uu"39"cpf" 3:0"Vjg"eqfg"
ycu"ncvgt"oqfkhkgf"kp"c"ugtkgu"qh"Kpenquwtg"Cevu"wr"vq"3:7;"dwv"kv"ycu"pqv"pgeguuct{"
vq"tguvcvg"vjg"crrnkecvkqp"ugevkqp0"
Eqpxgtugn{"kh"c"ncvgt" Cev"ku"uckf" vq"dkpf"vjg"Etqyp" cpf"kv"cogpfu"cp" gctnkgt"Cev"
yjkej"fqgu" pqv" vjgp" vjcv" d{" kvugnh" yknn" pqv" dtkpi" vjg" gctnkgt" Cev" ykvjkp" Etqyp"
crrnkecvkqp0"Kh"vjcv"ku"kpvgpfgf"vjg"ncvgt"Cev"oc{"cogpf"vjg"gctnkgt"Cev"fktgevn{"d{"
kpugtvkpi"cp"crrnkecvkqp" encwug"dwv"uqogvkogu" cpqvjgt"crrtqcej"ku"p ggfgf0"Vjwu"
vjg"Dwknfkpi"Uchgv{"Cev"4244."Rv"6"kpenwfgu"u"334*4+"yjkej"kpvtqfweg u"pgy "uu"5 2E"
vq"52K"kpvq"vjg"Ncpfnqtf"cpf"Vgpcpv"Cev"3;:70"Vjg"4244"Cev."u"386*3+*d+"rtqxkfgu"
vjcv"Rv"6"dkpfu"vjg"Etqyp"dwv"vjcv" ku"pqv"uwhhkekgpv"d{"kvugnh"cu"vjg"3;:7"Cev"fqgu"
pqv" eqpvckp" c" Etqyp" crrnkecvkqp" ugevkqp0" Jqygxgt" vjg" Eqooqpjqnf" cpf"
Ngcugjqnf"Tghqto"Cev"4224."u"394*3+"*809+"uc{u"ÒVjg"hqnnqykpi"rtqxkukqpu"crrn{"
kp"tgncvkqp"vq"Etqyp"ncpf" *cu"kp"tgncvkqp"vq"qvjgt" ncpf+gevkqpu"3:"vq"52D" qh"
*cpf"vjg"Uejgfwng"vq+"vjg"3;:7"CevÓ0"Ceeqtfkpin{"vjg"4244"Cev."u"334*9+"cogpfu"
vjg"4224"Cev."u" 394*3+*c+"kp"qtfgt"vq"gzvgp f"vjg"pgy"rtqxkukqpu"kpugtvgf" kpvq"vjg"
3;:7"Cev"vq"vjg"Etqyp0"
;2" Crown and Government Land"
"
80406" Eqpuqnkfcvkqp"
Eqpuqnkfcvkqp"qh"c"pwodgt"qh"gctnkgt"Cevu"kpvq"c"ukping"qpg"ecp"kpxqnxg"c"rtqxkukqp"
yjkej" rtgxkqwun{" fkf" pqv" crrn{" eqokpi" vq" fq" uq0" Vjg" igpgtcn" twng" ku" vjcv" c"
eqpuqnkfcvkqp"Cev"owuv" dg"tgcf"cu" c"uvcvgogpv"qp" kvu"qyp32"ykvjqwv" tghgtgpeg"vq"
vjg"rtgxkqwu" ncy."cnvjqwij" gctnkgt"ecugu"qp" vjg"eqpuqnkfcvgf" rtqxkukqp"oc{" uvknn"
dg"tgngxcpv0"Vjwu"vjg"Ncy"qh"Rtqrgtv{"Cev"3;47"dkpfu"vjg"Etqyp"cpf"kpeqtrqtcvgu"
gctnkgt"rtqxkukqpu"yjkej"fkf"pqv0"Vjg"Jkijyc{u"Cev"3;:2."u"549"eqpvckpu"c"rqygt"
hqt"vjg"Etqyp" vq"citgg" vq"dg"dqwpf" gxgp"vjqwij" gctnkgt"jkijyc{" ngikuncvkqp"fkf"
pqv"*3307+0"
80407" Cfqrvkqp"
Kv"ku"qhvgp"uckf"vjcv"vjg"Etqyp"ecp"xqnwpvctkn{"dtkpi"kvugnh"ykvjkp" c"uvcvwvg"gxgp"kh"
pqv"dqwpf."cnvjqwij" engct"cwvjqtkv{"ku"ncemkpi" cpf"vjg"rtgekug" ueqrg"ku"wpvguvgf0"
Vjg"Etqyp"Rtqeggfkpiu"Cev"3;69."u"53*3+"rtqxkfgu
Vjku"Cev" ujcnn"pqv" rtglwfkeg"vjg"tkijv" qh"vjg" Etqyp"vq" vcmg"cfxcpvcig"qh" vjg"
rtqxkukqpu"qh"cp"Cev"qh"Rctnkcogpv"cnvjqwij"pqv"pco gf"vjgtgkp="cpf"kv"ku"jgtgd{"
fgenctgf"vjcv"kp"cp{"ekxkn"rtqeggfkpiu"cickpuv"vjg"Etqyp"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"qh"cp{"
Cev"qh"Rctnkcogpv" yjkej"eqwnf."kh"vjg" rtqeggfkpiu"ygtg"dgvyggp"uwdlgevu." dg"
tgnkgf"wrqp"d{"vjg"fghgpfcpv"cu"c"fghgpeg"vq"vjg"rtqeggfkpiu."yjgvjgt"kp"yjqng"
qt"kp"rctv."qt"qvjgtykug."oc{."uwdlgev"vq"cp{"gzrtguu"rtqxkukqp"vq" vjg"eqpvtct{."
dg"uq"tgnkgf"wrqp"d{"vjg"Etqyp0"
"
Vjgtg"ctg"uqog"tghgtgpegu"vq"vjg"rqkpv"kp"qnf"ecugu33"dwv"nkvvng"oqfgtp"cwvjqtkv{034"
Kp"Cayzer, Irvine & Co v Board of Trade35" kp"vjg" Eqwtv"qh" Crrgcn"Uetwvvqp" NL"
eqpukfgtgf"kv" rquukdng" dwv" nghv" kv" qrgp0" Vjg" ecug" ygpv" vq" vjg" Jqwug" qh" Nqtfu36"
yjgtg"eqwpugn"uqwijv"vq"ctiwg"vjg"rqkpv"dwv"vjg"Jqwug"tghwugf"vq"jgct"kv037"Kp"Town
Investments Ltd v Department of the Environment38 Nqtf"Oqttku"qh"Dqtvj/{/Iguv"
kp"c"fkuugpvkpi"lwfiogpv"tghgttgf"vq"vjg" 3;69"Cev"cpf."qdugtxkpi"vjcv"pgkvjgt"vjg"
Eqwpvgt/Kphncvkqp"*Vgorqtct{"Rtqxkukqpu+"Cev"3;94"pqt"vjg"Eqwpvgt/Kphncvkqp"Cev"
3;95"dqwpf" vjg" Etqyp" *vjg" 3;95" Cev." Uej" 5." rctc" 8*3+" cdqwv" Etqyp" ugtxcpvu"
cevwcnn{"uvctvu"ÒCnvjqwij"vjku"Cev"fqgu"pqv"dkpf"vjg"Etqyp"ÈÓ+. "uckf"ÒDqvj"ukfgu"
"
32"Inland Revenue Commissioners v Joiner"]3;97̲"3"YNT"3923."JN."cv"3937."rgt"Nqtf"Fkrnqem0"
33"Willion v Berkley"*3783+"3" Rnqyf"445"cv"465." 97"GT"55;" cv"594="Case of a Fine Levied by the
King, Tenant in Tail"*3826+"9"Eq"Tgr"54c"cv"54c."99"GT"67;"cv"67;0"
34"A-G v Tomline"*3::2+"37"Ej"F"372."EC"tghgttgf"vq"vjg"Etqyp"vcmkpi"cfxcpvcig"qh"vjg"uvcvwvg"qh"
nkokvcvkqpu."hqt"yjkej."ugg"pqy"3505030"
35" ]3;49̲"3"MD"48;"cv"4;60"
36" ]3;49̲"CE"8320"
37" ]3;49̲"CE"832"cv"838."rgt"Xkueqwpv"Ecxg"NE0"
38" ]3;9:̲"CE"57;"cv"5;40"
"Statutes" ;3"
"
jcxg"ceegrvgf"vjcv"yjgp"vjg"rtgugpv"rtqeggfkpiu"ygtg"vcmgp"vjg"fgrctvogpv"eqwnf"
d{"yc{"qh"fghgpeg"vcmg"cfxcpvcig"qh"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjg"vyq"CevuÓ"dwv"vjcv"ycu"
c"eqpeguukqp"uq"pqv"ctiwgf"qt"fgekfgf0"
805" KP"TGO"CPF"KP"RGTUQPCO
Cp"Cev"qh"Rctnkcogpv"tgncvkpi"vq"ncpf"pqtocnn{"qrgtcvgu"in rem."vjcv"ku"vq"uc{"vjcv"
kv"chhgevu" vjg"ncpf"cu" uwej0"Vjku" ycu"cv" qpg"vkog"korqtvcpv" kp"vjg" eqpvgzv"qh"vjg"
Tgpv"Tguvtkevkqp"Cevu"*80904+0" Kv"hqnnqyu"htqo"Etqyp"koowpkv{" vjcv"vjg"Cev"yknn"
pqv" crrn{" vq" vjg" Etqyp" ncpf" cv" cnn" cpf" cp{" rgtuqp" jcxkpi" c" rtqrtkgvct{" qt"
rquuguuqt{"tkijv"kp"vjg"ncpf"ecp"encko"gzgorvkqp"htqo"kvu"qrgtcvkqp0"Vq"qxgteqog"
vjku"vjgtg"yknn"pggf"vq"dg"c"rtqxkukqp"hqt"vjg"Cev"vq"crrn{"vq"pqp/Etqyp"kpvgtguvu0"
Vjku"ku"tgngxcpv"yjgtg"cp"Cev"oc{"crrn{"vq"ncpf"yjkej"dgnqpiu"vq"vjg" Etqyp"
uwdlgev"vq"c" rtkxcvgn{"qypgf"vgpcpe{"qt" yjgtg"vjg"Etqyp"ku" kvugnh"vgpcpv0"Kv" yknn"
fkuvkpiwkuj" dgvyggp" rtkxcvg" kpvgtguvu." yjkej" kp" vjku" eqpvgzv" kpenwfgu" nqecn"
cwvjqtkvkgu"cpf"PFRDu."cpf"Etqyp"qt"Fwej{"kpvgtguvu0"Kv"yknn"fq"uq"d{"uc{kpi"vjcv"
vjg" crrtqrtkcvg" cwvjqtkv{" oc{" eqpugpv" vq" vjg" gzgtekug" qh" c" rqygt." uwej" cu"
eqorwnuqt{"rwtejcug"qt"gpvt{"vq" kpurgev."crrn{kpi"vq"cp{"rtkxcvg" kpvgtguvu"kp"vjg"
ncpf0"
Uqogvkogu"cp"Cev"crrnkgu"in personam."uq"vjcv"kv"ukorn{"eqpvtqnu"vjg"cevkxkvkgu"qh"
rgtuqpu"qp"vjg"ncpf"cpf"vjqug"rgtuqpu"yknn"dg"dqwpf"wpnguu"vjg{"ecp"encko"Etqyp"
koowpkv{."hqt" kpuvcpeg"cu" ekxkn"ugtxcpvu"q t"ogodgtu"qh" vjg"ugewtkv{" ugtxkegu0"Kp"
Cooper v Hawkins39"kv"ycu"jgnf"vjcv"xgjkengu"ftkxgp"d{"Etqyp"ugtxcpvu"qp"Etqyp"
dwukpguu"ygtg" pqv" uwdlgev" vq" vjg" urggf" nkokvu" nckf" fqyp" d{" vjg" nqecn" cwvjqtkv{"
wpfgt" vjg" Nqeqoqvkxgu" Cev" 3:870" D{" eqpvtcuv" koowpkv{" in personam" ku" pqv"
cxckncdng"vq"rtkxcvg"rgtuqpu0"Kp"Kellett v Daisy3:"vjg"fghgpfcpv"ycu"ftkxkpi"ykvjqwv"
fwg"ectg"cpf"cvvgpvkqp"qp"Gnngu"Tqcf."Hctpdqtqwij."Jcorujktg"yjkej"ycu"E tqyp "
rtqrgtv{0"Vjg"Vtcpurqtv"Cev"3;8:."u"36;3;"rtqxkfgf"vjcv"egtvckp"rtqxkukqpu"crrnkgf"
vq"c"Etqyp"Tqcf."fghkpgf"cu"Òc"tqcf."qvjgt"vjcp"c"jkijyc{."vq"yjkej" vjg"rwdnke"
jcu" ceeguu" d{" rgtokuukqp" itcpvgf" d{" vjg" crrtqrtkcvg" Etqyp" cwvjqtkv{." qt"
qvjgtykug"itcpvgf"d{"qt"qp"dgjcnh"qh"vjg"EtqypÓ0"Nqtf"Ykfigt{"EL"uckf
Kh"uqog"swguvkqp" jcf"ctkugp"cu"vq" yjgvjgt"vjg"Cev" jcf"chhgevgf"vjg"Etqyp" cu"
uwej."qt"gxgp"ugtxcpvu" qh"vjg"Etqyp." qpg"ecp"kocikpg"vjcv" vjg"eqpukfgtcvkqpu"
qh"vjg"mkpf"rwv" dghqtg"wu"d{"Ot"Rgtekxcn42" okijv"crrn{."uwdlgev"cnyc{u" vq"vjg"
"
39" ]3;26̲"4"MD"3860"
3:" ]3;99̲"TVT"5;8."]3;99̲"Etko"NT"7880"
3;" Pqy"vjg"Tqcf"Vtchhke"Tgiwncvkqp"Cev"3;:6."u"3530"
42" *CwvjqtÓu"pqvg+"Eqwpugn"hqt"vjg"fghgpeg0"
;4" Crown and Government Land"
"
eqpvgpvu"qh"u03::043"Dwv"vjgtg"ku"pq"swguvkqp"jgtg"qh"vjg"Etqyp"dgkpi"uqwijv"vq"
jcxg"vjg"Cev"gphqtegf"cickpuv"kv"qt"cickpuv"Etqyp"ugtxcpvu0"Vjg"rgtuqp"yjq"kv"
ku"uckf"ku"dqwpf"d{"vjg"Cev"ku"vjg"fghgpfcpv."cpf"kp"o{"lwfiogpv"jg"engctn{"ku0"
"
Vjg"ucog" rtkpekrngu"yqwnf" crrn{"kh" uqogqpg"ycu" ugnnkpi"ftwiu" qt"dgkpi" ftwpm"
cpf"fkuqtfgtn{"kp"c"rwdnke"rnceg"yjkej"jcrrgpgf"vq"dg"Etqyp"ncpf0"
806" KPVGTGUVU"KP"NCPF
Etqyp"crrnkecvkqp"ugevkqpu"v{rkecnn{"tghgt"vq" cp"kpvgtguv"kp"ncpf0"Vjg"yqtf"ku"pqv"
wuwcnn{"fghkpgf"kp"vjg"rctvkewnct"uvcvwvg"uq"vjg"ugpug"owuv"dg"cuegtvckpgf"htqo"vjg"
igpgtcn"ncy0"Engctn{" kv"kpenwfgu" tq{cn"fgogupg"ncpf" cpf"c"htggjqnf" qt"ngcugjqnf"
guvcvg"kp"ncpf0"Kv"ecp"kpenwfg"ncpf"kp"yjkej"vjg"Etqyp"jcu"c"ngicn"kpvgtguv."uwej"cu"
c" tkijv" qh" yc{" uq" vjcv." hqt" kpuvcpeg." c" nqecn" cwvjqtkv{" uggmkpi" vq" ceswktg"d{"
eqorwnuqt{" rwtejcug" rtkxcvg" ncpf" qxgt" yjkej" vjgtg" ycu" cp" ceeguu" ngcfkpi" vq"
cflcegpv"Etqyp"ncpf"eqwnf"pqv"wpkncvgtcnn{"qxgttkfg"vjg"gcugogpv0"Kv"oc{"kpenwfg"
qvjgt"kpeqtrqtgcn"tgcn"rtqrgtv{"uwej"cu"htcpejkugu"qh"octmgv"qt"hgtt{"yjkej."kh"vjg{"
ctg"chhgevkpi"htcpejkugu.44"ecp"dg"tgictfgf"cu"kpvgtguvu"kp"ncpf0"
Kpvgtguv" eqwnf"cnuq" crrn{" vq" uqog" gswkvcdng" kpvgtguvu" kp" ncpf0" Etqyp" gswkvcdng"
kpvgtguvu"ctg"eqpukfgtgf"kp" 3206."hqt"gzcorng"yjgtg" vjg"Etqyp"jcu"eqpvtcevgf"vq"
ceswktg"c" rkgeg"qh" ncpf"cpf" vjg"eqpvtcev" jcu"dggp" eqorngvgf"dwv" tgikuvtcvkqp"qh"
vkvng"jcu"dggp"fgnc{gf"qt"hqnnqykpi"c"pqvkeg"vq"vtgcv"wpfgt"c"eqorwnuqt{"rwtejcug"
qtfgt0"Yjgtg"vjg"Etqyp"jcu"cp"wpfkxkfgf"ujctg"kp"ncpf."cu"yjgtg"kv"jcu"rcuugf"cu"
dqpc" xcecpvkc" qt" yjgtg" vjgtg"ku" cp" wpfkxkfgf" ujctg" wpfgt" c" vtwuv"qh"ncpf."vjg"
dgpghkekcn"kpvgtguv" oc{"cvvtcev" Etqyp"koowpkv{" gxgp"kh"vjg" ngicn"guvcvg" jgnf"d{"
vjg"vtwuvggu"fqgu"pqv045"
80603" Qeewrcvkqp."gpvt{"cpf"tgswkukvkqp"
Gzegrvkqpcnn{"vjg"Vqyp" cpf"Eqwpvt{"Rncppkpi"Cev" 3;;2."u"4;8D*5+" kpugtvgf"d{"
vjg"Rncppkpi" cpf"Eqorwnuqt{" Rwtejcug"Cev" 4226"rtqxkfgu"ÒCp" kpvgtguv"kp" ncpf"
kpenwfgu"cp"kpvgtguv"qpn{"cu"qeewrkgt"qh"vjg"ncpfÓ0"Vjcv"yqwnf."hqt"vjg"rwtrqugu"qh"
vjcv"Cev." kpenwfg" kpuvcpegu" yjgtg" vjg" Etqyp" ukorn{" qeewrkgu" ncpf." rgtjcru" cu"
nkegpugg."ykvjqwv"c"rtqrtkgvct{"tkijv0"
"
43" *CwvjqtÓu"pqvg+"Qh"vjg"Tqcf"Vtchhke"Cev"3;940"
44" Vjg"Ncpf"Tgikuvtcvkqp"Twngu"4225"*UK"422513639+."t"4390"
45"The Pollen Estate Trustee Co Ltd v Revenue and Customs Commissioners"]4234̲" WMWV"499"
*VEE+."]4234̲"UVE"4665."]4234̲"DVE"3882="]4235̲"GYEC"Ekx"9750
"Statutes" ;5"
"
Kpvgtguv"fqgu"pqv"kpenwfg"c"ukorng"tkijv"vq"gpvgt"qp"ncpf0"Kp"R (Mid-Devon District
Council) v First Secretary of State46"nctig"pwodgtu"qh"ecvvng"jcf"vq"dg"uncwijvgtgf"
fwtkpi" vjg" hqqv" cpf" oqwvj" grkfgoke0"C"hctokpi"eqwrng"Ot"cpf"Otu" Uvgxgpu"
qhhgtgf"ncpf"vq" FGHTC"cpf"Etqyp"qhhkekcnu" ecttkgf"qwv"oclqt"yqtmu" vq"etgcvg"c"
uwkvcdng"dwtkcn"ukvg0"Dghqtg"cp{"cpkocnu"eqwnf"dg"dwtkgf"cu"Mgkvj"L"uckf<47"
Wphqtvwpcvgn{." eqpvtcevwcn" rtqdngou" ctqug" dgvyggp" Ot" Uvgxgpu" cpf" vjg"
Okpkuvt{0"Vjgug"ygtg"pqv"tguqnxgf."cpf"vjg"Okpkuvt{"ycu"tgswktgf"vq"n gcxg"vjg"
ukvg0"Ukpeg"kv"jcf"pq"ngicn"kpvgtguv"kp"vjg"ncpf."vjg"Okpkuvt{"jcf"vq"eqorn{0"
"
Vjg"Eqwpekn" tgswktgf"tguvqtcvkqp"qh" vjg"ncpf" cpf"ugtxgf"cp" gphqtegogpv"pqvkeg0"
Vjg"hctogtu"crrgcngf"qp"vjg"dcuku"vjcv"vjg"yqtm"ycu"fqpg"wpfgt"c"Etqyp"kpvgtguv"
cv"c"vkog"yjgp"vjg"Etqyp"ycu"pqv"dqwpf"d{"vjg"rncppkpi"ncyu0"Vjg"Fkxkukqpcn"
Eqwtv"wrjgnf"vjg"pqvkeg."Mgkvj"L"uc{kpi<48"
Cv"pq"uvcig"fkf"vjg"Okpkuvt{"qt"FGHTC"jcxg"cp{"ngicn"qt"gswkvcdng"kpvgtguv"kp"
vjg"ncpf0"Cv"vjg"vkog"qh"vjg"fgxgnqrogpv."eqpvtcevqtu"gpicigf"d{"vjg"Okpkuvt{"
jcf"vjg"tkijv"vq"iq"qp"vq"vjg"ncpf"vq"ectt{"qwv"vjg"qrgtcvkqpu."dwv"uwej"c"nkegpeg"
fkf"pqv"coqwpv"vq"cp"kpvgtguv"kp"ncpf0"
"
Gswcnn{"kv"fqgu"pqv"crrn{"yjgtg"vjg"Etqyp"jcu"tgswkukvkqpgf"vjg"ncpf."ykvjqwv"
jcxkpi"ceswktgf"cp{"ngicn"kpvgtguv049"
RCTV"4"Î"RCTVKEWNCT"NGIKUNCVKQP"
Vjgtg"ctg"ocp{"uvcvwvgu" yjkej"dkpf"vjg"Etqyp"vq" c"itgcvgt"qt"nguugt" gzvgpv0"Vjg"
hqnnqykpi"ku" c"ugngevkqp"tgngxcpv" vq"rtqrgtv{" vq"knnwuvtcvg"vjg" yc{"vjg" rtqxkukqpu"
yqtm0"Kv"kpenwfgu"uqog"t grgcngf"ngikuncvkqp"cpf"ujqwnf"pqv"dg"vcmgp"cu"c"uvcvgogpv"
qh"vjg"ewttgpv"ncy."yjkej"kpfggf"ku"uwdlgev"vq"eqpuvcpv"ejcpig0"
807" NCPF"NCY
Vjg"dcuku"qh"ncpf"ncy"ku"vjg"eqooqp"ncy"yjkej"dkpfu"vjg"Etqyp"cpf"ceeqtfkpin{"
oquv"uvcvwvgu" yjkej" oqfkh{" ncpf" ncy" yknn" cnuq" crrn{0" Kp" rctvkewnct" vjg" Ncy" qh"
Rtqrgtv{"Cev" 3;47."u"42:*5+" rtqxkfgu"vjcv" kv"dkpfu"vj g"Etqyp"ucxg" kp"tgurgev"qh"
vjg"fgxqnwvkqp"qh"Etqyp"ncpf0"Vjg"Tgpvejctigu" Cev"3;99."u"36"rtqxkfgu"vjcv"vjg"
"
46" ]4226̲"GYJE":36"*Cfokp+0"
47" ]4226̲"GYJE":36"*Cfokp+"cv"]4̲0"
48" ]4226̲"GYJE":36"*Cfokp+"cv"]6̲0"
49"Commissioners of Crown Lands v Page"]3;82̲"4"SD"496"cv"4:5="cpf":060"
;6" Crown and Government Land"
"
Cev"dkpfu"vjg"Etqyp"uq"vjcv" c"tgpvejctig"fwg"vq"vjg"Etqyp" ecp"dg"eqorwnuqtkn{"
tgfggogf"*:08+0"
Vjg"Ncpf"Tgikuvtcvkqp"Cev"4224."u"34;"uvcvgu"ukorn{"ÒVjku"Cev"dkpfu"vjg"EtqypÓ"
dwv" kv" eqpvckpu" urgekcn" rtqxkukqpu" vq"fgcn" ykvj" Etqyp" ncpf0" Ugevkqpu" 9;" vq" :3"
rtqxkfg"hqt" xqnwpvct{"tgikuvtcvkqp" qh"fgogupg"ncpf." fghkpgf"kp" u"354*3+" cu" ncpf"
dgnqpikpi"vq"Jgt"Oclguv{"kp"tkijv"qh"vjg"Etqyp"pqv"jgnf"kp"hgg"ukorng"dwv"oqfkhkgf"
d{"u"354*4+"pqv"vq"kpenwfg"ncpf"yjgtg"vjg"htggjqnf"guvcvg"jcu"fgvgtokpgf"*wuwcnn{"
qp"guejgcv+"dwv"yjgtg"vjg"Etqyp"jcu"pqv"ocpcigf"qt"gpvgtgf0"Ugevkqpu":4"cpf":7"
tgncvg" vq" guejgcv" cpf" dqpc" xcecpvkc0" Ugevkqp" :5" ku" vjg" pqtocn" fghkpkvkqp" qh"
crrtqrtkcvg"cwvjqtkv{0"
Vjg"Ncy"qh"Rtqrgtv{"*Okuegnncpgqwu" Rtqxkukqpu+"Cev"3;;6"dkpfu"d{"u"42" uq"vjcv"
ugetgvctkgu"qh"uvcvg"ecp"ikxg"vkvng"iwctcpvggu"*360504+"cpf"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"hqt"xguvkpi"
qh" rtqrgtv{" qp" fgcvj" yknn" crrn{" *;0:+0" Vjg" Ncy" qh" Rtqrgtv{" *Okuegnncpgqwu"
Rtqxkukqpu+"Cev"3;:;"jcu"pq"crrnkecvkqp"encwug"dwv"dgecwug"kv"tghgtu"vq"vjg"Fwejkgu"
kp"u"3*;+"kv"owuv"fq"uq"*3609+0"
808" EQORWNUQT["FKURQUCNU
Vjg"igpgtcn" twng"ku" vjcv" vjg"Etqyp" ecp"pqv" dg" eqorgnngf"vq" fkurqug"qh" ncpf"qt"
itcpv"tkijvu"uwej"cu"gcugogpvu"vq"uqog"qvjgt"dqf{"uwej"cu"c"nqecn"cwvjqtkv{"qt"c"
wvknkvkgu"eqorcp{0"Dgecwug"vjg"koowpkv{"crrnkgu"in rem"kv"ku"pgeguuct{"vq"kpenwfg"
rtqxkukqpu"vq"qxgttkfg"rtkxcvg"kpvgtguvu"kp"Etqyp"ncpf0"Cevu"cwvjqtkukpi"eqorwnuqt{"
rwtejcug"d{"c"eqwpekn"qt"uvcvwvqt{"wpfgtvcmgt"wuwcnn{"rtqxkfg"vjcv"vjg"rqygt"oc{"
dg" gzgtekugf" qxgt" rtkxcvg" kpvgtguvu" kp" Etqyp" ncpf" ykvj" vjg" eqpugpv" qh" vjg"
crrtqrtkcvg"cwvjqtkv{0"Cnvjqwij"vjgtghqtg"c"Etqyp"kpvgtguv"yknn"pqv"dg"vcmgp"wpfgt"
eqorwnuqt{"rqygtu"cv"cnn."vjg"Etqyp"ecp"eqpugpv"vq"c"rtkxcvg"kpvgtguv"kp"Etqyp"
ncpf"dgkpi"ceswktgf."vjwu" gpuwtkpi"vjcv"c"nguugg" ecp"pqv"wug"Etqyp" koowpkv{"vq"
htwuvtcvg"c"uejgog"qh"rwdnke"dgpghkv0"Kp"rtcevkeg"vjg"Etqyp"cwvjqtkv{"yknn"pqtocnn{"
dg"rtgrctgf" vq" pgiqvkcvg"qp" eqorwnuqt{"rwtejcug" vgtou" hqt"vjg" fkurqucn" qh"vjg"
Etqyp"kpvgtguv"cu"ygnn0"Kh"vjg"Etqyp"ku"qrrqugf"vq"vjg"ceswkukvkqp."hqt"kpuvcpeg"qp"
ugewtkv{"itqwpfu."kv"oc{"kpfkecvg"cv"cp"gctn{"uvcig"vjcv"eqpugpv"yqwnf"dg"ykvjjgnf."
kp"yjkej"ecug"vjg"rqvgpvkcn"ceswktkpi"cwvjqtkv{"ku"nkmgn{"vq"ftqr"vjg"uejgog0"
Vjgtg"ctg"ocp{"kpuvcpegu0"Vjwu"vjg"Ycvgt"Kpfwuvt{"Cev"3;;3."u"443"*cu"uwduvkvwvgf"
d{" vjg" Gpxktqpogpv" Cev" 3;;7+" rtqxkfgu" vjcv" kv" dkpfu" vjg" Etqyp" dwv"u"443*8+"
rtqxkfgu" vjcv" vjg" rqygtu" qh" eqorwnuqt{" ceswkukvkqp" oc{" qpn{" dg" gzgtekugf""
qxgt"Etqyp"ncpf"ykvj"vjg"eqpugpv"qh"vjg"crrtqrtkcvg"cwvjqtkv{0"Vjgtg"ku"c"ukoknct"
rtqxkukqp"kp"vjg"Gngevtkekv{"Cev"3;:;."u"85"cpf"cpqvjgt"kp"vjg"Vqyp" cpf""
Eqwpvt{"Rncppkpi"Cev"3;;2."u"488C*4+"kpugtvgf"d{"vjg"Rncppkpi"cpf"Eqorwnuqt{"
Rwtejcug"Cev"42260"
"Statutes" ;7"
"
Vjgtg"ku" cp"gzegrvkqp" kp"vjg"Gngevtqpke" Eqoowpkecvkqpu"Eqfg" eqpvckpgf"kp" vjg"
Fkikvcn"Geqpqo{"Cev" 4239."Uej" 30"Kv"fqgu" pqv"rtqxkfg"hqt" htggjqnf"ceswkukvkqpu"
dwv"hqt"vjg"eqorwnuqt{"itcpv"qh"ngcugjqnfu"qt"gcugogpvu"qxgt"ncpf"cpf"vjg"qrgtcvqt"
owuv" rc{"o ctmgv"xcnwg" hqt" vjqug" tkijvu0" Kp" igpgtcn" vjg" Eqfg" dkpfu" vjg" Etqyp""
d{" Uej"3." rctc" 326" dwv" rctc" 326*6+" tghgtu" vq" ecugu" yjgtg" eqpugpv" ku" tgswktgf0"
Wpfgt"Uej"3."rctc"86."yjkej"crrnkgu"vq"vkfcn"ycvgtu."vjg"qrgtcvqt"owuv" qdvckp"vjg"
eqpugpv"qh"vjg"crrtqrtkcvg" cwvjqtkv{."pqtocnn{"vjg"Etqyp"Guvcvg" Eqookuukqpgtu"
qt"vjg"Fwejkgu0"Vjku"hqnnqygf"vjg"rtgegfgpv"qh"vjg"Vgngeqoowpkecvk qpu"C ev"3 ;:6 ."
Uej" 4" dwv" vjcv" jcf" rtqxgf" c" rqkpv" qh" fkhhkewnv{" hqt" vjg" vgngeqoowpkecvkqpu"
eqorcpkgu"ukpeg"vtcpucvncpvke"ecdngu"*qh"yjkej"vjgtg"ctg"ocp{+"jcxg"vq"tgcej"vjg"
ockpncpf" cetquu" vkfcn" ycvgtu0" Kp" rtcevkeg" Etqyp" cwvjqtkvkgu" ygtg" rtgrctgf" vq"
pgiqvkcvg" dwv" vjg" cigpvu" cevkpi" hqt" vjg" qrgtcvqtu" hgnv" vjgougnxgu"vq"dg"cv"c"
fkucfxcpvcig"dgecwug"vjg"Etqyp"jcf"oqpqrqn{"tkijvu"qxgt"owej"qh"vjg "hqtgujqtg"
cpf"ugc"dgf"pqvykvjuvcpfkpi"vjg"Etqyp"Guvcvg"Cev"3;83."u"5*3+0"Wpfgt"vjg"Fkikvcn"
Geqpqo{"Cev"4239." Uej"3."rctc"86" vjgtghqtg"vjgtg"ku"cp" ctdkvtcvkqp"rtqxkukqp"vq"
cuegtvckp"vjg" octmgv"xcnwg" qh" vjg"tkijvu0" Kp"vjgqt{" kv" yqwnf"uvknn" dg"qrgp" vq" vjg"
Etqyp"vq"y kvjjqnf"eqpugpv"dwv" kp"rtcevkeg"kv" yqwnf"pqv"fq" uq"wpnguu"vjgtg"ygtg"
urgekcn"ektewouvcpegu"uwej"cu"ugewtkv{0"
809" NCPFNQTF"CPF"VGPCPV
C"iqqf" fgcn"qh"ncpfnqtf" cpf"vgpcpv" ngikuncvkqp"dkpfu0" Vjg"Ncpfnqtf"cpf" Vgpcpv"
Cev"3;76." u"73*5+" tgcf"ykvj" u"78" crrnkgf"vjg" Ngcugjqnf"Rtqrgtv{"*Tgrcktu+"Cev"
3;5:"vq"kpvgtguvu"dgnqpikpi"kp"tkijv"qh"vjg"Etqyp"qt"vq"c"iqxgtpogpv"fgrctvogpv0"
Vjg"Rtqvgevkqp"htqo"Gxkevkqp"Cev"3;99."u"32"crrnkgu"vq"vjg"gzvgpv"kv"kpxqnxgu"eqwtv"
rtqeggfkpiu0" Vjg" Ncpfnqtf" cpf" Vgpcpv" Cev" 3;::" yjkej" chhgevu" eqpvtqnu" qp"
cuukipogpv"rtqxkfgu"kp"u"8"vjc v"kv"dkpfu"dwv"kp"vqtv"pq"hwtvjgt"vjcp"wpfgt"vjg"Etqyp"
Rtqeggfkpiu"Cev" 3;690" Vjg" Ncpfnqtf" cpf" Vgpcpv" *Eqxgpcpvu+" Cev" 3;;7" dkpfu"
wpfgt"u"4;0"Vjg"Ngcugjqnf"Tghqto"*Itqwpf"Tgpv+"Cev"4244"crrnkgu"d{"u"450"Gcej"
qh"vjgug"jcu"kvu"qyp"yqtfkpi0"
80903" Tgukfgpvkcn"vgpcpekgu"
Kpkvkcnn{"vjg" Etqyp"ycu"koowpg" htqo"Cevu"rcuugf" vq"rtqvgev" tgukfgpvkcn"vgpcpvu"
cpf"vjg" eqwtvu" jgnf"vjcv" vjku"gzvgpfgf" vq" cp{"vgpcpe{" qh"Etqyp" ncpf0" Qxgt"vjg"
{gctu"vjku"koowpkv{"ycu"yjkvvngf"fqyp."hktuv"vq"rtqvgev"uwdvgpcpekgu"htqo"rtkxcvg"
jgcfnguuggu" vjgp" vq" rtqvgev" fktgev" vgpcpekgu" htqo" vjg" Etqyp" Guvcvg" cpf" vjg"
Fwejkgu0" Yjgp" vgpcpvu" ygtg" ikxgp" tkijvu" vq" ceswktg" vjg" htggjqnf" qh" vjgkt"
rtqrgtvkgu"qt"vq"ocpcig"vjgo"vjcv"jcf"vq"dg"kpvgitcvgf"ykvj"Etqyp"koowpkv{0"Vjg"
tguwnv"ku"cp" kpxqnxgf"ugv"qh"ngicn" twngu0"Yjcv"hqnnqyu"ku" c"dtqcf"iwkfg vjg"fgvckn"
qh"gcej"Cev"ku"urgekcn"cpf"vjg"xctkqwu"rtqxkukqpu"ctg"uwdlgev"vq"htgswgpv"ejcpig."
uqogvkogu"d{" vgzvwcn"cogpfogpv." uqogvkogu"d{" c"tghgtgpeg" kp" c"ncvgt" Cev"cpf"
;8" Crown and Government Land"
"
uqogvkogu"d{"yjqnn{"pgy"ngikuncvkqp0"Vjg"tghgtgpeg"vq"c"vgpcpe{"dgkpi"rtqvgevgf"
kpenwfgu"uvcvwvqt{"cpf"tgiwncvgf"vgpcpekgu0"
80904" Tgpv"Tguvtkevkqp"Cevu"
Fwtkpi" vjg"Hktuv" Yqtnf" Yct" vjg" Kpetgcug" qh" Tgpv" cpf" Oqtvicig" Kpvgtguv" *Yct"
Tguvtkevkqpu+" Cev" 3;37" eqpvtqnngf" vjg"tgpvu" qh" egtvckp" fygnnkpiu" cpf" eqphgttgf"
ugewtkv{"qh"vgpwtg" qp"vjg"vgpcp vu0"Kv"ycu"eqpvkp wgf"chvgt"vjg" yct"d{"c" uweeguukqp"
qh"Cevu" mpqyp"cu" vjg" Tgpv"Tguvtkevkqp" Cevu0"Vjg{" fkf"pqv" dkpf" vjg"Etqyp"cpf"
kpkvkcnn{"fkf" pqv"d kpf"Etqyp" ncpf"cv" cnn0"Vjg" u{uvgo"ycu" cfcrvgf"cpf" oqfkhkgf"
qxgt"vjg"{gctu" cpf"vjg" ewttgpv"Cev"ku" vjg"Tgpv"Cev" 3;990"Ncpfnqtfu" fkunkmgf"vjg"
eqpvtqnu" cpf" uqog" yjq" jcf" cp" kpvgtguv" kp" Etqyp" ncpf" enckogf" vjg" dgpghkv" qh"
Etqyp"koowpkv{0" Htqo"vjg" dgikppkpi"vjg" eqwtvu"jgnf4:" vjcv"vjg" tkijv"vq" jcxg"c"
tgpv"hkzgf"ycu"c"tkijv"in rem"uq"vjcv"kv"crrnkgf"vq"vjg"rtqrgtv{"cu"uwej"kttgurgevkxg"
qh" vjg" rgtuqp" yjq" ycu" vjg" vgpcpv" hqt" vjg" vkog" dgkpi" cpf" koowpkv{"crrnkgf"
nkmgykug0"
Vgpcpekgu"itcpvgf"fktgevn{"d{"c"Etqyp"dqf{"ygtg"gzgorv"uq"nqpi"cu"vjg{"ncuvgf0"
Kp"Clark v Downes4; vjg"Eqookuukqpgtu"qh" Yqtmu"dwknv"c" jqwug"cpf"ngcugf"kv" vq"
vjg"fghgpfcpv0"Vjg{"vjgp"uqnf"vjg"htggjqnf"vq"cp"guvcvg"eqorcp{"yjkej"itcpv gf"cp"
qxgttkfkpi"ngcug"vq" vjg"rnckpvkhh"yjq" uqwijv"rquuguukqp"htqo"vjg" fghgpfcpv0"Vjg"
Fkxkukqpcn"Eqwtv"jgnf"vjcv."cu"vjg"qtkikpcn"ngcug"ycu"itcpvgf"d{"vjg"Etqyp."kv"ycu"
qwvukfg"vjg"Tgpv"Tguvtkevkqp"Cevu"gxgp"yjgp"vjg"tgxgtukqp"rcuugf"vq"c"pgy"q ypgt0 "
Tqogt"NL"uckf<52"
Kv"ku"citggf"d{"dqvj"rctvkgu"vq"vjku"crrgcn"vjcv"vjg"Tgpv"Tguvtkevkqpu"Cevu"fq"pqv"
chhgev" vjg" tkijvu" qh" vjg" Etqyp0" Kv" ku" cnuq" citggf" vjcv" jcxkpi" tgictf" vq" vjg"
cwvjqtkvkgu"vjgug"Cevu"owuv"dg"vtgcvgf"cu"qrgtcvkpi"in rem"cpf"pqv"in personam0"
"
Vjwu"cu" nqpi"cu"vjg" ucog"vgpcpe{"eqpvkpwgf" vq"twp" kv"ycu"uvknn" qwvukfg"vjg" Cev53"
dwv"kh"kv"vgtokpcvgf"cpf"c"pgy"qpg"ycu"itcpvgf."gxgp"vq"vjg"ucog"vgpcpv."vjcv"ycu"
pqv"koowpg054"
"
4:"King v York"]3;3;̲"YP"7;."::"NL*MD+":5;="ugg"Carter v SU Carburettor Company"]3;64̲"4"MD"
4::0"
4;" ]3;53̲"Cnn"GT"Tgr"379."367"NV"420"
52" ]3;53̲"Cnn"GT"Tgr"379"cv"37;."*3;53+"367"NV"42"cv"430"
53"Wirral Estates, Ld"v Shaw"]3;54̲"4"MD"469."EC0"
54"Wheeler v Wirral Estates, Ld"]3;57̲"3"MD"4;6."EC0"
"Statutes" ;9"
"
Kp"Rudler v Franks55" vjg"ncpfnqtf" ycu"c" vgpcpv"qh" vjg"Etqyp"cpf" jku"uwdvgpcpv"
ycu"jgnf"pqv"vq"dg"rtqvgevgf"dgecwug"vjg"ghhgev"qh"Etqyp"koowpkv{"ycu"v q"gzg orv"
vjg"yjqng"rtqrgtv{"cpf"cnn"kpvgtguvu"kp"kv0"Vjg"Etqyp"Nguuggu"*Rtqvgevkqp"qh"Uwd/
Vgpcpvu+"C ev"3;74" vjgtghqtg" icxg"uwdvgpcpvu" qh" Etqyp"ncpf" rtqvgevkqp" cickpuv"
vjgkt"koogfkcvg" ncpfnqtfu"dwv"ykvjqwv" rtglwfkekpi"vjg" rqukvkqp"qh"vjg"Etqyp"cu"
cickpuv"kvu"fktgev"vgpcpvu0"
C"tgncvgf"kuuwg"ycu"jqy"hct"dqfkgu"enqugn{"cuuqekcvgf"ykvj"vjg"Etqyp"eqwnf"encko"
vjg" ucog" koowpkv{0" Oknkvct{" cuuqekcvkqpu" eqwnf" fq" uq56"dwv"kp"Tamlin v
Hannaford57"vjg"eqwtv"tglgevgf" vjg"ctiwogpv"qh"vjg" Dtkvkuj"Tcknyc{u"Dqctf"vjcv."
cu"dgkpi"yjqnn{"qypgf"d{"vjg"Etqyp."kv"ycu"hqt"vjku"rwtrqug"c"Etqyp"dqf{"*70604+0"
80905" Tgpv"Cev"3;99"
Vjg" Tgpv" Tguvtkevkqp" Cevu" ygtg" tgrncegf" d{" vjg" Tgpv" Cevu" cpf" kpkvkcnn{" cp{"
vgpcpe{"fktgev"htqo"c"Etqyp"dqf{"ycu"gzgorv0"Vjg"Jqwukpi"Cev"3;:2"gzvgpfgf"
rtqvgevkqp"vq"uqog"Etqyp"vgpcpvu0"Vjku"ycu"cejkgxgf"d{"c"pwodgt"qh"kpvgttgncvgf"
rtqxkukqpu"yjkej" cogpfgf" vjg"eqpuqnkfcvkpi" Tgpv"Cev" 3;990" Vjg"yjqng" qh" vjg"
3;99"Cev"ku"d{"u"376"crrnkgf"vq"rtgokugu"kp"yjkej"vjgtg"ku"c"Et qyp"kpvgtguv"vjwu"
fkurqukpi"qh" koowpkv{" in rem0"Ugevkqp" 35*3+" vjgp"uc{u" vjcv" c"v gpcpe{"yknn" pqv""
dg"rtqvgevgf"qt"uvcvwvqt{"kh"vjg"ncpfnqtfÓu"kpvgtguv"dgnqpiu"vq"Jgt"Oclguv{"kp"tkijv"
qh"vjg"Etqyp"qt" vq"c"iqxgtpogpv" fgrctvogpv0"Vjku"gzgorvkqp"vjgtghqtg"gzvgpfu"
vq" vjg" Etqyp" Guvcvg" dwv" pqv" vq" vjg" Fwejkgu" uq" vjg{" ctg" dqwpf" wpfgt"u" 3760""
Ugevkqp"35*4+"vjgp"uc{u"vjcv"c"vgpcpe{"oc{"pgxgtvjgnguu"dg"rtqvgevgf"qt"uvcvwvqt{"
kh"kv"ku"wpfgt"vjg"ocpcigogpv"qh"vjg"Etqyp"Guvcvg"Eqookuukqpgtu0" Vjg"tguwnv"ku"
vjcv"vgpcpvu"qh"vjg" Etqyp"Guvcvg"cpf"vjg"Fwejkgu" eqwnf"dg"rtqvgevgf"qt"uvcvwvqt{"
vgpcpvu0"Rtqvgevkqp"fqgu"pqv"gzvgpf"vq"vgpcpvu"qh"fgrctvogpvu0"
Vjg"Ncpfnqtf" cpf"Vgpcpv" Cev"3;76." Rv"3" rgtokvu"vjg" vgpcpvu"qh" egtvckp"gzrktgf"
ngcugjqnfu"vq"tgockp"cu"vgpcpvu0"Ugevkqp"78*9+."kpugtvgf"d{"vjg"Jqwukpi"Cev"3;:2."
rtqxkfgu"vjc v"vjg" Cev"crrnkgu" yjgtg" vjgtg"ku" c" Etqyp"Guvcvg" qt" Fwej{"kpvgtguv0"
Vjcv"fqgu"pqv" crrn{"yjgtg"vjg"kpvgtguv" dgnqpiu"vq"c" iqxgtpogpv"fgrctvogpv"pqt"
vq"qvjgt"Etqyp"ncpf0"
80906" Cuuwtgf"cpf"ugewtg"vgpcpekgu"
Pgy" Tgpv" Cev" vgpcpekgu" ecp" pq" nqpigt" dg" itcpvgf" cpf" vjg{" jcxg" pqy" dggp"
tgrncegf"d{"cuuwtgf"vgpcpekgu"yjgtg"vjg"ncy"tgcejgu"vjg"ucog"tguwnv"d{"c"ukoknct"
"
55" ]3;69̲"MD"7520"
56"County of London Territorial Forces Association v Philpot"]3;69̲"4"Cnn"GT"5980"
57" ]3;72̲"3"MD"3:0"
;:" Crown and Government Land"
"
tqwvg0" Vjg" Jqwukpi" Cev" 3;::." u" 66" crrnkgu" vjg" eqfg" vq" oquv" v{rgu" qh" Etqyp"
rtqrgtv{"dwv"Uej"3." rctc"33"gzenwfgu"vgpcpekgu" htqo"Jgt"Oclguv{"kp" tkijv"qh"vjg"
Etqyp" *qvjgt" vjcp" htqo" vjg" Etqyp" Guvcvg+" qt" dgnqpikpi" vq" c" iqxgtpogpv"
fgrctvogpv0"Vjgtg" ctg"ukoknct" tkijvu"wpfgt" vjg"Nqecn" Iqxgtpogpv"cpf" Jqwukpi"
Cev"3;:;."Uej"32."rctc"440"
The Crown Estate Commissioners v The Peabody Trust58"eqpegtpgf"vjg" vtcpuhgt"
qh"c" dwknfkpi"htqo" vjg"Eqookuukqpgtu" vq"c" jqwukpi"cuuqekcvkqp0" Vjg"3;::" Cev.""
u"5:"fgcnu"ykvj"vjg"vtcpuhgt"qh"gzkuvkpi"vgpcpekgu"htqo"vjg"rwdnke"ugevqt"vq"rtkxcvg"
ncpfnqtfu" cpf" hqt" vjku" rwtrqug" vjg" Etqyp" Guvcvg" ycu" vtgcvgf" cu" rwdnke" wpfgt""
u" 5:*7+*f+0" Vjg" dwknfkpi" ycu" vtcpuhgttgf"vq" c" jqwukpi" vtwuv" cpf"vjg"kuuwg"ycu"
yjgvjgt"vjg" vgpcpekgu" yjkej" jcf" dggp" tgiwncvgf" *gkvjgt" rtqvgevgf" qt" uvcvwvqt{+"
wpfgt"vjg"Tgpv"Cev"3;99"dgecog"ugewtg"vgpcpekgu"uwdlgev"vq"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjg"
Jqwukpi" Cev" 3;:7." Rv" KX" cpf" cnuq" jqwukpi" cuuqekcvkqp" vgpcpekgu" ykvjkp" vjg"
ogcpk pi"qh"vj g"Tgpv"C ev"3;99 ."u":8."c pf"uq"uw dlgev"v q"Rv"XK"q h"vjcv"Cev"qt"yjgvjgt"
vjg{"jcf"dgeqog"cuuwtgf" vgpcpekgu"uwdlgev"vq"vjg"rtqxkukqpu" qh"vjg"3;::"Cev." Rv"
K0"Kv"ku"pqv"pgeguuct {"jgtg"vq"eqoogpv"hwtvjgt"gz egrv"vq"tghgt"vq"vjg"qdugtxcvkqp"qh"
Ot"Ejctngu"Jqnncpfgt"SE"ukvvkpi"cu"c"fgrwv{"lwfig"vjcv<59"ÒVjgug"rtqxkukqpu."cpf"
kp"rctvkewnct"Rctv"X"qh"JC"::."ecp"rqnkvgn{"dg"fguetkdgf"cu"ncd{tkpvjkpgÓ0"
80907" Gphtcpejkugogpv"
Ngcugjqnf"gphtcpejkugogpv" ku"c" hqto" qh"eqorwnuqt{" rwtejcug"cpf" vjg"uvcpfctf"
ngicn"rqukvkqp"ku" vjcv"Etqyp"ncpf" ecp"pqv"dg" uwdlgev"vq"eqorwnukqp0"Vjg" rtgugpv"
twngu" ctg" rctvn{" gpcevgf" cpf" rctvn{" Etqyp" rtcevkeg" ugv" qwv" kp" wpfgtvcmkpiu" vq"
Rctnkcogpv0"Vgpcpvu"fq"pq v"jcxg"c"uvcvwvqt{" tkijv"vq"ceswktg" c"Etqyp"kpvgtguv0"Kh"
cp{"hqtogt" Etqyp" kpvgtguv" jcu" egcugf" vq" gzkuv" kp" ncpf" vjcv" vjg" vgpcpv" uggmu" vq"
ceswktg"vjgp"wpfgt"vjg"Ngcugjqnf"Tghqto"Cev"3;89."u"55"vjg"tkijv"ku"gzgtekucdng0"
Kh"vjgtg"ku"uvknn"c"Etqyp"kpvgtguv"*yjkej"yknn"pqtocnn{"dg"vjg"htggjqnf"dwv"okijv"dg"
c"jgcfngcug+"vjgp"kp" igpgtcn"vjg"eqpugpv"qh" vjg"crrtqrtkcvg"cwvjqtkv{"ku" tgswktgf0"
Kh"vjg"vgpcpv"ku"qpn{"uggmkpi"vq"qdvckp"cp"gzvgpfgf"ngcug"cpf"ku"c"uwdvgpcpv"htqo"c"
rtkxcvg" jgcfnguugg" cpf" vjg" kpvgtogfkcvg" ncpfnqtf" jcu" rqygt" vq" itcpv" vjg" ngcug"
ykvjqwv" pggfkpi" vjg" eqpugpv"qh" vjg" Etqyp" dqf{ " vjgp" vjg" Cev" crrnkgu0" Vjku" ku"
oqfkhkgf"d{"vjg"Ngcugjqnf" Tghqto"Jqwukpi"cpf"Wtdcp"Fgxgnqrogpv"Cev" 3;;5."
u"::"yjkej."cu"kv" pqy"uvcpfu."ikxgu"c"vtkdwpcn"lwtkufkevkqp"vq"fgvgtokpg" swguvkqpu"
dgvyggp" vjg" Etqyp" cpf" c" vgpcpv" kh" vjg" vgpcpv" yqwnf" *crctv" htqo" cp{" Etqyp"
"
58" ]4233̲"GYJE"3689"*Ej+0"
59" ]4233̲"GYJE"3689"*Ej+"cv"]6:̲0"
"Statutes" ;;"
"
kpvgtguv+"qvjgtykug"dg"gpvkvngf"vq"ceswktg" vjg"htggjqnf"qt"cp"gzvgpfgf"ngcug"wpfgt"
vjg"3;89"Cev"cpf"cnn"rctvkgu"citgg05:"
Vjg"Ngcugjqnf"Tghqto"Jqwukpi"cpf"Wtdcp"Fgxgnqrogpv"Cev"3;;5."Ej"3"cnnqyu"
hqt"eqnngevkxg" gphtcpejkugogpv"d{" c" itqwr"qh" ngcugjqnfgtu"yjq" ecp"ceswkt g"vjg"
htggjqnf"qh" vjgkt"dnqem" cpf"Ej" 4"cnnqyu" kpfkxkfwcn"n gcugjqnfgtu"vq" gzvgpf"vjgkt"
ngcugu0"Ugevkqp";6"ku"ukoknct"vq"vjg"3;89"Cev."u"550"
Vjwu" kp" igpgtcn" vjg" Etqyp" ku"pqv" ngicnn{" dqwpf" vq" fkurqug" qh" vjg" htggjqnf" vq"
vgpcpvu0"Jqygxgt" kp" c"ugtkgu" qh" wpfgtvcmkpiu"vq" Rctnkcogpv."vjg" oquv" tgegpv"qh"
yjkej"ycu" qp" 33"Fgegodgt" 42235;" vjg"Etqyp" ceegrvgf"vjcv" kv" yqwnf"citgg" vq"
gphtcpejkugogpv"qt"gzvgp ukqp"wpfgt"vjg"3;89" cpf"3;;5"Cevu" qp"ukoknct"vgtou"vq"
vjqug"chhgevkpi" rtkxcvg" ncpfnqtfu." uwdlgev" *kp" vjg" ecug" qh" htggjqnf" fkurqucnu+" vq"
egtvckp"gzegrvkqpu0"Vjqug"ctg ugewtkv{"eqpukfgtcvkqpu"
*qp"vjg"cfxkeg"qh"vjg"Tq{cn"cpf"Fkrnqocvke"Rtqvgevkqp"Itqwr"qh"vjg"Ogvtqrqnkvcp"
Rqnkeg" qt" qvjgt" ugewtkv{" cigpekgu+=" *kk+" yjgtg" rtqrgtvkgu" ctg" kp." qt" kpvkocvgn{"
eqppgevgf"ykvj."vjg"ewtvkncig"qh"jkuvqtke"Tq{cn"Rctmu"cpf"Rcncegu="cpf"*kkk+"yjgtg"
rtqrgtvkgu."qt"vjg"ctgcu"kp"yjkej"vjg{"ctg"ukvwcvgf."jcxg"c"nqpi"jkuvqtke"qt"rctvkewnct"
cuuqekcvkqp"ykvj"vjg"Etqyp0"Kp"uwej"ecugu"cp"gzvgpfgf"ngcug"yknn"dg"itcpvgf0"
Vjg"Ncpfnqtf" cpf"Vgpcpv" Cev"3;:9" eqpvckpu" Rv"3." yjkej"eqphgtu" qp"vgpcpvu" qh"
dnqemu" qh" hncvu"c" tkijv" qh" hktuv" tghwucn" kh" vjg" ncpfnqtf" kpvgpfu" vq" fkurqug" qh" jku"
kpvgtguv."cpf"Rv"5." yjkej"ikxgu"uwej"vgpcpvu"c" tkijv"vq"ceswktg"kh"vjg" ncpfnqtf"jcu"
dggp" kp" ugtkqwu" fghcwnv0" Ugevkqp" 78" rtqxkfgu" vjcv" c" ncpfnqtf" jqnfkpi" wpfgt" c"
vgpcpe{"qt"uwd/vgpcpe{"htqo"vjg"Etqyp"ku"dqwpf"d{"vjqug"rtqxkukqpu0"Vjg{"ygtg"
uwdlgev"vq" uqog"lwfkekcn" eqoogpv" kp"Scmlla Properties Ltd v Gesso Properties
(BVI) Ltd62"*30604+0"Wpfgt"u"6*3+*d+"egtvckp"fkurqucnu"ctg"gzenwfgf"kpenwfkpi"wpfgt"
u"6*4+*m+"c"fkurqucn"vq"vjg"Etqyp0"
Vjg"Jqwukpi" Cev" 3;:7" eqphgtu" qp" uqog" rwdnke" ugevqt"cpf" jqwukpi"cuuqekcvkqp"
vgpcpvu"vjg"tkijv"vq"ceswktg"vjg"htggjqnf"qt"cp"gzvgpfgf"ngcug0"Vjgtg"ctg"rtqxkukqpu"
kp"u" 342"cpf"Uej" 7."rctc"34" gzvgpfkpi"vjg" tkijv"vq"Etqyp" kpvgtguvu"kp"ncpf" ykvj"
eqpugpv0"Vjg"Jqwukpi"*Gzvgpukqp"qh"Tkijv"vq"Dw{+"Qtfgt"3;;5.63" Uej."rctc"88*h+"
crrgctu"vq"tgrgcn"vjgo."dwv"vjcv"Qtfgt"wpfgt"ctv"5"crrnkgu"qpn{"vq"kpvgtguvu"jgnf"d{"
egtvckp"rwdnke"cwvjqtkvkgu"cpf"rctc"34"tgockpu"kp"hqteg"hqt"qvjgt"ektewouvcpegu0"
"
5:" Ugg"Whitehall Court London Ltd v The Crown Estate Commissioners"]423:̲"GYEC" Ekx"3926."
]423;̲"3"YNT"453;0"
5;"Hansard."JN"Fgd."xqn"84;."eqnu"3;7Î3;9YC0"
62" ]3;;7̲"DEE"9;5"cv":3;0"
63" UK"3;;5144620"
322" Crown and Government Land"
"
80908" Eqxgpcpvu"cpf"ocpcigogpv"
Vjg"Ncpfnqtf"cpf"Vgpcpv"Cev"3;:7"fqgu"pqv"eqpvckp"c"igpgtcn"Etqyp"crrnkecvkqp"
ugevkqp."rquukdn{"dgecwug"kv"korqugu" c"pwodgt"qh"qhhgpegu0"Kp" rctvkewnct"uu"33"vq"
39"yjkej"rtqxkfg"hqt"igpgtcn"fwvkgu"qh"ncpfnqtfu"qh"fygnnkpiu"qp"uwej"ocvvgtu"cu"
tgrcktu"cpf" ugtxkeg"ejctigu" fq"pqv" dkpf064"Ewtkqwun{"u" 36*7+"rtqxkfgu" vjcv"u" 33."
yjkej"kornkgu"kpvq" ujqtv"ngcugu" qh"fygnnkpiu"c" tgrcktkpi"eqxgpcpv"qp" vjg"rctv"qh"
vjg"ncpfnqtf"fqgu"pqv" crrn{"vq"c"ngcug"itcpvgf" vquv{"kp" tkijv"qh"vjg"
Etqyp" *wpnguu" vjg" ngcug" ku" wpfgt" vjg" ocpcigogpv" qh" vjg" Etqyp" Guvcvg"
Eqookuukqpgtu+="qt"*d+"c"iqxgtpogpv"fgrctvogpv"qt"c"rgtuqp"jqnfkpi"kp"vtwuv"hqt"
c"iqxgtpogpv"fgrctvogpv0"Vjku"yqwnf"cnnqy"c"fgrctvogpv"vq"vcmg"c"ujqtv"ngcug"qh"
c" fygnnkpi" ykvjqwv" dgkpi" cdng" vq" eqorgn" vjg" ncpfnqtf" vq" tgrckt" kv0" Pq" fqwdv"
fgrctvogpvu"fq"pqv"pggf" vjg"rtqvgevkqp"qh"c" ncpfnqtfÓu"tgrcktkpi"eqxgpcpv" yjgp"
vcmkpi"c"ujqtv"ngcug"qh"c"fygnnkpi0"
Vjg"rwtrqug"qh"vjg" tghgtgpeg"vq"c"ngcug"vq" vjg"uqxgtgkip"kp"tkijv"qh" vjg"Etqyp"ku"
qduewtg."ukpeg"vjg"uqxgtgkip"ecp"pqv" vcmg"c"ngcug"*360607+"cpf"u"33"fqgu" crrn{"vq"
ngcugu" itcpvgf" vq" vjg" Eqookuukqpgtu" qt" vq" vjg" Fwejkgu" cnvjqwij"kv" yqwnf" dg"
wpwuwcn"hqt"vjqug"dqfkgu"vq"vcmg"c"ujqtv"ngcug"qh"c"fygnnkpi"kp"vjgkt"qyp"pcog0"
Vjg"Eqooqpjqnf"cpf"Ngcugjqnf"Tghqto"Cev"4224."u"394*3+*c+"rtqxkfgf"vjcv"vjg"
3;:7"Cev." uu" 3:"vq" 52D"vjcv" tgncvg" vq"ugtxkeg" ejctigu."kpuwtcpeg" cpf" ocpcikpi"
cigpvu"cpf"vjg"Uejgfwng"ujqwnf"crrn{"vq"oquv"Etqyp"dqfkgu0"Wpfgt"u" 394*5+" c"
hcknwtg"d{"vjg" Etqyp"vq"rgthqto"c" fwv{"korqugf"wpfgt" vjqug"rtqxkukqpu"yknn" pqv"
ocmg"vjg"Etqyp"etkokpcnn{"nkcdng"dwv"vjg"Jkij"Eqwtv"oc{"fgenctg"cp{"uwej"hcknwtg"
ykvjqwv"tgcuqpcdng"gzewug" vq"dg"wpncyhwn0"Vjg" Dwknfkpi"Uchgv{"Cev" 4244."u"334"
kpugtvu"pgy"uu"52E"vq"52K" korn{kpi"vgtou"tgncvkpi"vq"dwknfkpi"uchgv{" cpf"cogpfu"
u"394"uq"vjcv"vjg"Etqyp"yknn"dg"dqwpf"d{"vjqug"pgy"rtqxkukqpu0"
Vjg"4224"Cev."u"394"cnuq"gzvgpfgf"Etqyp"crrnkecvkqp"vq"vjg"Ncpfnqtf"cpf"Vgpcpv"
Cev"3;:9."Rv"4"*crrqkpvogpv"qh"c"ocpcigt+."Rv"KX"qh"vjcv"Cev"*xctkcvkqp"qh"ngcugu+"
cpf"uu"68" vq"6;"*kphqtocvkqp"vq" dg"hwtpkujgf" vq"vgpcpvu+0"Kv" gzvgpfgf"crrnkecvkqp"
vq"vjg"Ngcugjqnf"Tghqto."Jqwukpi"cpf"Wtdcp"Fgxgnqrogpv"Cev"3;;5."Rv"K."Ej"X."
uu" 98" vq" :6" yjkej" rtqxkfg" hqt" vgpcpvuÓ" tkijvu" vq" c" ocpcigogpv" cwfkv=" vq" vjg"
Jqwukpi"Cev"3;;8."u":3"yjkej"rtgxgpvu"c"ncpfnqtf"htqo"vgtokpcvkpi"c"vgpcpe{"hqt"
hcknwtg"vq"rc{"c"ugtxkeg"ejctig="cpf"vq"vjg"3;;8"Cev."u":6"cpf"Uej"6"yjkej"rgtokv"
c"tgeqipkugf"vgpcpvuÓ"cuuqekcvkqp"vq"crrqkpv"c"uwtxg{qt0"Egtvckp"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjg"
4224"Cev"kvugnh" cnuq"dkpf0"Ugevkqp" 32:"gzvgpfu"Rv" 4."Ej"3" *vjg"tkijv"vq" ocpcig+0"
Ugevkqp" 394*j+" gzvgpfu" uu" 372" vq" 37;." Ueju" ;" vq" 33" tgncvkpi" vq" ugtxkeg" cpf"
cfokpkuvtcvkqp"ejctigu."cpf" ugevkqpu"386"vq" 393"tgncvkpi"vq" kpuwtcpeg."hqthgkvwtg"
cpf"itqwpf"tgpv0"D{" vjg"Vgpcpv"Hggu"Cev" 423;."u"54"uqog" rtqxkukqpu"tguvtkevkpi"
"
64"Department of Transport v Egoroff"*3;:8+"3:"JNT"548." EC."fgekfgf"qp"vjg"Jqwukpi"Cev" 3;83"
uu"54"cpf"550"
"Statutes" 323"
"
egtvckp"rc{ogpvu"dkpf"vjg"Etqyp"kp"tgurgev"qh"c"Etqyp"vgpcpe{"cu"fghkpgf" d{"
tghgtgpeg"vq"vjg"Jqwukpi"Cev"3;::."u"66*5+0"
80909" Dwukpguu"cpf"hcto"vgpcpekgu"
Vjg"Ncpfnqtf" cpf" Vgpcpv"Cev" 3;49." u"46" ikxgu"dwukpguu" vgpcpvu" qh"vjg" Etqyp"
tkijvu"vq" eqorgpucvkqp"cv" vjg"gpf" qh"vjg" vgpcpe{"qp"vjg" ucog"vgtou"cu"vjqug"qh"
rtkxcvg"ncpfnqtfu0"Vjg"Ncpfnqtf"cpf"Vgpcpv"Cev"3;76."Rv"4."u"78"gzvgpfu"ugewtkv{"
qh"vgpwtg"vq" egtvckp"dwukpguu"vgpcpvu"qh" vjg"Etqyp"cpf" gswcnn{"Etqyp"qeewrkgtu"
ecp" encko" ugewtkv{65" ykvj" uqog" urgekcn" twngu" tgncvkpi" vq" ngcugu" jgnf" d{" c"
iqxgtpogpv"fgrctvogpv0"
Vjg"Citkewnvwtcn" Jqnfkpiu" Cev"3;98." u" ;7*3+"crrnkgu" vjcv" Cev"*qvjgt" vjcp" u"33"
tgncvkpi"vq" vjg"rtqxkukqp"qh" hkzgf"gswkrogpv+"vq" ncpf"jgnf"kp" tkijv"qh"vjg" Etqyp"
*yjgvjgt"qt"pqv"ocpcigf"d{"vjg" Eqookuukqpgtu+"cpf"vq"Fwej{"ncpf"cpf"u";7*5+"
crrnkgu" kv" vq" fgrctvogpvcn" ncpf" uwdlgev" vq" c" rqygt" vq" ocmg" oqfkhkecvkqpu" d{"
tgiwncvkqpu0"Vjg"Citkewnvwtcn"Vgpcpekgu"Cev"3;;7."u"59"cnuq"crrnkgu"vq"uwej"ncpf0"
Cnvjqwij"vjg"ocvvgt"fqgu"pqv"crrgct"vq"jcxg"dggp"nkvkicvgf"kv"yqwnf"hqnnqy"vjcv"kh"
vjg"Etqyp"jgnf"cp"citkewnvwtcn" qt"hcto"dwukpguu"vgpcpe{"kv"yqwnf"jcxg" vjg"ucog"
tkijvu"cu"c"rtkxcvg"vgpcpv0"
80:" RNCPPKPI"CPF"EQPUVTWEVKQP"
Vjg"crrnkecvkqp"qh"vjg"rncppkpi"ncy u"vq"v jg"E tqy p"jc u"c"v qtv wqw u"jkuvqt{0"Rncppkpi"
kp"kvu"oqfgtp"hqto"ycu" kpvtqfwegf"d{"vjg"Vqyp"cpf" Eqwpvt{"Rncppkpi"Cev"3;69"
yjkej" jcf" vyq" rwtrqugu0" Qpg" ycu" vq" tgswktg" fgxgnqrgtu" qh" ncpf" vq"crrn{" hqt"
rncppkpi"rgtokuukqp"htqo"c"nqecn"cwvjqtkv{0"Vjg"qvjgt"ycu"vq"pcvkqpcnkug"vjg"x cnwg"
qh"fgxgnqrogpv"ncpf0" Kp"3;69"kv"ycu" gzrgevgf"vjcv"iqxgtpogpv" *egpvtcn"qt"nqecn+"
yqwnf"dg"vjg" rtkpekrcn"oqxgt"kp" fgxgnqrogpv"uq"vjgtg" ycu"kpkvkcnn{" pq"swguvkqp"
qh"vjg"Etqyp" dgkpi"dqwpf0"Vjg" eqpegrv"qh"pcvkqpcnkugf" fgxgnqrogpv"xcnwg"ycu"
uqqp"hqwpf"vq"dg"kortcevkecn"cpf"ftqrrgf"*:05+"dwv"rncppkpi"rgtokuukqp"uvc{gf0"
Kp"Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food v Jenkins66" kv"ycu" jgnf"vjcv" vjg"
Etqyp" ycu" pqv" dqwpf" d{" vjg" 3;69" Cev" cpf" uq" fkf" pqv" pggf" vq" igv" rncppkpi"
rgtokuukqp"hqt"chhqtguvcvkqp0"Vjg" rqkpv"ycu"eqphktogf"d{"vjg" Jqwug"qh"Nqtfu"kp"
Lord Advocate v Dumbarton District Council067"Vjg"OqF"qduvtwevgf"c"tqcf"cpf"
vjg"nqecn"cwvjqtkv{"ugtxgf"c"uvqr"pqvkeg"tgswktkpi"kv"vq"fgukuv0"Nqtf"Mgkvj"qh"Mkpmgn"
fkuewuugf"vjg"rtgegfkpi" ecugu0"Vjg"ncy"kp" Ueqvncpf"ycu"vcmgp"vq" dg"vjg"ucog "cu"
"
65"Linden v Department of Health and Social Security ]3;:8̲"3"YNT"3860"
66" ]3;85̲"4"SD"5390"
67" ]3;;2̲"4"CE"7:20"
324" Crown and Government Land"
"
kp" Gpincpf0" Vjg" Jqwug" qh" Nqtfu" jgnf" vjcv" vjg" Vqyp" cpf" Eqwpvt{" Rncppkpi"
*Ueqvncpf+"Cev"3;94"fkf"pqv"dkpf"vjg"Etqyp"cpf"vjg"pqvkegu"ygtg"kpxcnkf0"
Cnvjqwij" vjg" Etqyp" ycu" pqv" ngicnn{" dqwpf" d{" vjg" pggf" vq" qdvckp" rncppkpi"
rgtokuukqp"hqt"fgxgnqrogpv"kv"ceegrvgf"vjcv"kv"ujqwnf"eqpuwnv"vjg"nqecn"cwvjqtkv{0"
Vjku"ycu" ugv" qwv" kp" Ektewnct" 322" qh" 3;72" ncvgt" tgrncegf" d{" Fgrctvogpv" qh" vjg"
Gpxktqpogpv" Ektewnct" 3:" qh" 3;:60"Igpgtcnn{"vjg"Etqyp"dqfkgu"hqnnqygf"vjg"
rtqegfwtg"dwv"vjgtg" ycu"pq"ngicn" eqpvtqn068"Uq"hct"cu" vjg"fgxgnqrogpv"qh" Etqyp"
ncpf"d{"c"Etqyp"dqf{"ycu"eqpegtpgf."vjku"ycu"ghhgevkxg"cpf"owej"dwknfkpi"yqtm"
ycu"ecttkgf" qwv" vjtqwij" vjg"Ektewnctu0" Vjku" crrnkgf" cu"owej" yjgtg" vjg"Etqyp"
cttcpigf"hqt"kvu"fgxgnqrogpv" vq"dg"ecttkgf"qwv"d{" c"eqpvtcevqt"cu"yjgtg"kv"fkf" uq"
fktgevn{069"
Kp"vjg"3;:2u"cu"c"tguwnv"qh"vjg"iqxgtpogpv"rqnke{"qh"fkurqukpi"qh"uwtrnwu"ncpf"cpf"
chvgt"vjg" Jgtuvoqpegwz" Ecuvng" eqpvtqxgtu{" *360404+" Etqyp" dqfkgu" ecog" wpfgt"
rtguuwtg." dqvj" htqo" vjg" Vtgcuwt{" cpf" htqo" vjg" rctnkcogpvct{" Qrrqukvkqp." vq"
fgoqpuvtcvg"vjcv."yjgp"ugnnkpi"ncpf."vjg{"ygtg"qdvckpkpi"hwnn"xcnwg0"Vjg"xcnwg"qh"
rqvgpvkcnn{"fgxgnqrcdng"ncpf"ykvjqwv"rncppkpi"eqpugpv"ycu" nguu"vjcp"vjcv"qh"ncpf"
yjkej"jcf"c" hqtocn"eqpugpv."gxgp" yjgtg"vjgtg"ycu" c"iqqf"rtqurgev"qh" rncppkpi"
rgtokuukqp"dgkpi"itcpvgf."dgecwug"dwknfgtu"jcf"vq"fkueqwpv"vjg"rquukdknkv{"vjcv"vjg"
eqpugpv" yqwnf" pqv" ocvgtkcnkug0" Rtkxcvg" ncpfqypgtu" yjq" ygtg" pqv" vjgougnxgu"
dwknfgtu"yqwnf"vjgtghqtg"ugewtg"c"rncppkpi"eqpugpv"cpf"ugnn"ykvj"vjg"dgpghkv"qh"kv0"
Ukpeg"vjg"Etqyp"ycu"pqv"uwdlgev"vq"vjg"rncppkpi"Cevu"kv"eqwnf"pqv"qdvckp"c"eqpugpv"
qxgt"Etqyp"ncpf0"*Vjgtg"fqgu"pqv"uggo"vq"jcxg"dggp"cp{"uwiiguvkqp"vjcv"kv"eqwnf"
vcmg"cfxcpvcig"qh" vjg"rncppkpi"ngikuncvkqp0+" Kpuvgcf"c"fgxkeg" ycu"wugf."gkvjgt"vq"
qdvckp" c" tguqnwvkqp" qh" vjg"nqecn" r ncppkpi"cwvjqtkv{" vjcv" kv" ycu" okpfgf" vq" ikxg"
eqpugpv"hqt"c"rctvkewnct" wug"qp"urgekhkgf"eqpfkvkqpu."qt" c"fgekukqp"kp"rtkpekrng"qh"
vjg"okpkuvgt"vjcv."kh"vjg"ocvvgt"ycu"tghgttgf"vq"vjg"fgrctvogpv"*gkvjgt"qp"crrgcn"qt"
qp"ecnn"kp+."eqpugpv"yqwnf"dg"crrtqxgf"qp"urgekhkgf"vgtou0"Hqnnqykpi"vjg"ucng"vjg"
fgxgnqrgt"yqwnf"crrn{"hqt"hqtocn"rncppkpi"eqpugpv"cpf" kv"yqwnf"dg"itcpvgf"cu"c"
ocvvgt"qh" eqwtug0" Vjku" crrtqcej" ycu" twngf" wpncyhwn" kp" R v Worthing Borough
Council, ex parte Burch6:"dgecwug"kv"rwtrqtvgf"vq"tguvtckp"vjg"htggfqo"vjcv"vjg"
nqecn"cwvjqtkv{"qt"vjg"okpkuvgt"qwijv"vq"jcxg"yjgp"vjg"hqtocn"crrnkecvkqp"ycu"rwv"
kp0" Ceeqtfkpin{" vjg" Vqyp" cpf" Eqwpvt{" Rncppkpi" Cev" 3;:6." u" 3" rtqxkfgf" c"
rtqegfwtg"hqt"Etqyp" dqfkgu"vq" qdvckp"cp"cevwcn" itcpv"qh" eqpugpv"kp"cpvkekrcvkqp""
qh"fkurqucn0"
"
68"R v Secretary of State for the Defence, ex parte Camden London Borough Council"]3;;7̲"LRN"
6250"
69"R (Cherwell District Council) v First Secretary of State"]4226̲"GYEC"Ekx"3642."]4227̲"3"YNT"
334:0"
6:" *3;:7+"72"R"("ET"750"
"Statutes" 325"
"
Yjgp" vjg" Gwtqrgcp" Wpkqp" kpvtqfwegf" Gpxktqpogpvcn" Korcev" Cuuguuogpvu" kp"
3;:7"kv"ycu"d{"fktgevkxg"dkpfkpi"qp"ogodgt"uvcvgu0"Kp"vjg"Wpkvgf"Mkpifqo"vjgug"
cuuguuogpvu" ygtg" ocfg" rctv" qh" vjg" rncppkpi" rtqeguu0" Vjg" eqpvkpwgf" hqtocn"
gzgorvkqp"qh"vjg"Etqyp"htqo"vjg"pggf" hqt"rncppkpi"eqpugpv"hqt"fgxgnqrogpv"qp"
kvu"qyp"ncpf"vjgtghqtg"eqpuvkvwvgf"c"dtgcej"qh"Gwtqrgcp"ncy"cpf"vjg"Eqookuukqp"
rtqrqugf" gphqtegogpv" rtqeggfkpiu0" Vjg" uqnwvkqp" ycu" kp" vjg" Rncppkpi" cpf"
Eqorwnuqt{"Rwtejcug"Cev"4226"yjkej"ocfg"c"tcfkecn"ejcpig0"Oquv"qh"vjg"hqtogt"
urgekcn"rtqxkukqpu"kp" vjg"Vqyp" cpf"Eqwpvt{"Rncppkpi" Cev"3;;2." Rv"ZKKK"*yjkej"
iqxgtpu"Etqyp"ncpf+"ygtg"tgrgcngf"cu" qduqngvg"cpf"c"pgy"eqfg"kpvtqfwegf0" Vjg"
rncppkpi" u{uvgo" pqy" crrnkgu" eqortgjgpukxgn{" vq"cnn" curgevu" qh" vjg"Etqyp"kp"
owej"vjg" ucog"yc{" cu" vq"rtkxcvg" qypgtu0"Vjcv" ku" unkijvn{"oqfkhkgf" d{"u" 4;5C"
yjkej"fgcnu" ykvj" c"fgxgnqrogpv" yjkej" ku"qh" pcvkqpcn" korqtvcpeg."cpf" owuv"d g"
ecttkgf"qwv" cu"c"ocvvgt" qh"wtigpe{0" Vjgtg"ctg" hwtvjgt"rtqxkukqpu" kp"uu"54 7C"cpf"
54;C0"
Vjg"rtkoct{" ngikuncvkqp"ku" uwrrngogpvgf" d{"ugeqpfct{" tgiwncvkqpu"kp"vjg"Vqyp"
cpf" Eqwpvt{" Rncppkpi" *Crrnkecvkqp" qh" Uwdqtfkpcvg" Ngikuncvkqp" vq" vjg" Etqyp+"
Qtfgt"42286;"yjkej"ugvu"qwv"vjg"urgekcn"twngu"hqt"kpswktkgu"yjgtg"vjgtg"ku"c"pggf"
hqt" ugetge{" qp" ugewtkv{" itqwpfu." vjg" Rncppkpi"*Nkuvgf" Dwknfk piu."Eqpugtxcvkqp"
Ctgcu"cpf" Jc¦ctfqwu" Uwduvcpegu+"*Cogpfogpv+" *Gpincpf+" Tgiwncvkqpu"422872"
cpf"vjg"Rncppkpi" *Pcvkqpcn"Ugewtkv{"Fktgevkqpu" cpf"Crrqkpvgf"Tgrtgugpvcvkxgu+"
*Gpincpf+" Twngu" 4228073" Vjg" Vqyp" cpf" Eqwpvt{" Rncppkpi" *Igpgtcn" Rgtokvvgf"
Fgxgnqrogpv+"*Gpincpf+"Qtfgt" 4237.74"Uej"4." Rv"3;" cwvjqtkugu"xctkqwu"v{rgu" qh"
Etqyp"fgxgnqrogpv."kpenwfkpi"hqt"ckt"dcugu"cpf"ugewtkv{"crrctcvwu0"
Vjg"Jgcnvj" cpf"Uchgv{" cv" Yqtm"Cev" 3;96."u" 6:*3+" rtqxkfgu"vjcv" Rv"3" dkpfu"vjg"
Etqyp"gzegrv"hqt"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"yjkej"cnnqy"hqt"vjg"ugtxkeg"qh"pqvkegu"cpf"hqt"vjg"
rtqugewvkqp"qh"qhhgpegu0"
Vjg"Dwknfkpi" Cev"3;:6."u" 66"ku" c"fgvckngf"Etqyp" crrnkecvkqp"ugevkqp" tgncvkpi"vq"
dwknfkpi"tgiwncvkqpu" twppkpi"vq" pkpg"uwdugevkqpu." dwv"kv" jcu"pgxgt" dggp"dtqwijv"
kpvq"hqteg="wpfgt"u":9"*yjkej"ku"kp"hqteg+"Etqyp"cwvjqtkvkgu"ecp"citgg"vjcv"egtvckp"
rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjg"Cev"yknn"crrn{0"Vjg"Dwknfkpi"Uchgv{"Cev"4244. u "7;"kp ugtvu "c"pgy"
u"353C"kpvq"vjg"3;:6"Cev"crrn{kpi"vq"vjg"Etqyp"igpgtcnn{"cpf"u"82"c"pgy"u"353D"
crrn{kpi"vq" vjg"Rctnkcogpvct{" Guvcvg0"Vjg" igpgtcn"Etqyp" crrnkecvkqp"ugevkqp" ku""
u"386"ykvj"ugrctcvg"crrnkecvkqp"vq"Rctnkcogpv"kp"u"3870"
"
6;" UK"4228134:40"
72" UK"4228134:50"
73" UK"4228134:60"
74" UK"423717;80"
326" Crown and Government Land"
"
80;" VJG"GPXKTQPOGPV"
Vjg" Gpxktqpogpvcn" Rtqvgevkqp" Cev" 3;;2" eqpvckpu" fgvckngf" rtqxkukqpu" cdqwv"
*coqpi"qvjgt"vjkpiu+"eqpvcokpcvgf"ncpf0"Wpfgt"u"37;"vjg"Etqyp"ku" kp" igpgtcn"
dqwpf"cnvjqwij"uwdlgev"vq"ugxgtcn"ecxgcvu"uq"vjcv"vjgtg"ku"pq" etkokpcn"nkcdknkv{"qp"
vjg"Etqyp"kvugnh"cu"fkuvkpev"htqo"rgtuqpu" kp"vjg"rwdnke"ugtxkeg"qh"vjg"Etqyp"yjq"
oc{"dg"cu"nkcdng" cu"cp{qpg"gnug0"Hwtvjgtoqtg" vjgtg"ku"rqygt"hqt" vjg"ugetgvct{"qh"
uvcvg"vq"gzgorv"rtgokugu"htqo"vjg"gpvt{"rqygtu"qh"kpurgevqtu"cpf"qvjgtu."pq"fqwdv"
rtkpekrcnn{"qp"ugewtkv{"itqwpfu0"
Wpfgt" vjg" Nqecnkuo" Cev" 4233." Rv"7." Ej" 5" egtvckp" rtqrgtvkgu" oc{" dg" cuugvu" qh"
eqoowpkv{"xcnwg"cpf"kpenwfgf"qp"c"nkuv0"Vjg"ghhgev"ku"vq"ikxg"nqecn"rgqrng" cp"
qrrqtvwpkv{"qh"rtg/gorvkqp"kp"vjg"gxgpv"qh"c"ucng0"Wpfgt" u"327"vjku"crrnkgu"vq"vjg"
Etqyp"kp"cnn"kvu"curgevu0"
Vjg"Gpxktqpogpv"Cev"4243."u"366"rtqxkfgu"ukorn{"vjcv"vjg"Cev"dkpfu"vjg"Etqyp0"
Vjg"rtqxkukqpu" cdqwv"ycuvg." ckt"swcnkv{." ycvgt"cpf" dkqfkxgtukv{"crrn{"vq" Etqyp"
ncpf"cu"vjg{"fq"vq"rtkxcvg"ncpf0"Jqygxgt"Rv"9"qh"vjg"Cev"kpvtqfwegu"c"pgy"v{rg"qh"
qdnkicvkqp"qp" ncpf" kp"vjg" hqto" qh"c" eqpugtxcvkqp"eqxgpcpv0" Vjcv"ecp"kpxqnxg"c"
rqukvkxg"eqxgpcpv"yjkej"ku"dkpfkpi"qp"uweeguuqtu"kp"vkvng"vq"vjg"qtkikpcn"eqxgpcpvqt"
yjq"jcu"wpfgtvcmgp"vq"fq"yqtmu"qt"ocmg"rc{ogpvu0"Vjg"eqpugswgpv"gzrgpfkvwtg"
jcu"vq" dg"dqtpg" d{"vjg" qypgt"qh"vjg" ncpf"hqt" vjg"vkog" dgkpi0"Yjgtg" vjg"Etqyp"
dw{u"ncpf"*qt"vcmgu"kv" qp"eqorwnuqt{"rwtejcug+"vjcv"ku"c" ocvvgt"hqt"kv"vq"vcmg"kpvq"
ceeqwpv"nkmg"cp{"qvjgt" rwtejcugt0"Cu"c"igpgtcn"twng"Etqyp" dqfkgu"ecp"gpvgt"kpvq"
eqpugtxcvkqp"eqxgpcpvu"cpf"oc{"ceswktg"ncpf"cntgcf{"uwdlgev"vq"uwej"eqxgpcpvu0"
Vjku"crrctgpv"ukornkekv{"ku"rctvn{"tgo qxgf"d{"Uej"3;"yjkej"uwrrngo gpvu"Rv "9"cpf"
ku"qpg" qh"vjg" oquv"fgvckngf" Etqyp"crrnkecvkqp" rtqxkukqpu"cp{yjgtg." twppkpi"vq""
43"rctcitcrju"qxgt"uqog"gkijv"rcigu0"Rctcitcrj"4"fgcnu"ykvj"ngicn"guvcvgu"kp"ncpf"
pcogn{"c"hgg"ukorng"qt"vgto"qh"{gctu"jgnf" kp"tkijv"qh"vjg"Etqyp0"Rctcitcrju"5"vq"
7"fgcn"ykvj"ncpf"yjkej"ku"pqv"jgnf"hqt"cp"guvcvg"kp"hgg"ukorng."vjc v"ku "tq {cn "fgo gup g. "
guejgcvgf"ncpf"cpf"dqpc"xcecpvkc"ncpf0"Rctvu"4"cpf"5"qh"vjg"Uejgfwng"cwvjqtkug"cp"
crrtqrtkcvg"cwvjqtkv{." tgrtgugpvkpi"vjg" Etqyp."vq"cev" qp"dgjcnh" qh"vjg"uqxgtgkip"
qt"qvjgt"Etqyp"dqf{0"Vjcv"kpenwfgu"gpvgtkpi"kpvq"pgy"eqpugtxcvkqp"eqxgpcpvu"cpf"
fqkpi"qvjgt"vjkpiu"kp"tgurgev"qh"gzkuvkpi"qt"pgy"eqxgpcpvu"yjkej."hqt"pqp/Etqyp"
ncpf"jcxg"vq"dg"fqpg"d{"vjg"rtkxcvg"ncpfqypgt0"
"
"
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting