Aktieselskabet Ocean v Harding & Sons
Jurisdiction | England & Wales |
Judgment Date | 22 March 1928 |
Date | 22 March 1928 |
Court | Court of Appeal |
-
- This document is available in original version only for vLex customers
View this document and try vLex for 7 days - TRY VLEX
- This document is available in original version only for vLex customers
7 cases
-
Mr Rustem Magdeev v Mr Dimitry Tsvetkov
...QB 74 at page 106 (Pearson J), The Glenfruin (1885) 10 PD 103 at page 109 (Butt J) and Aktieselskabet Ocean v B Harding and Sons Ltd [1928] 2 KB 371 at pages 385 (Scrutton LJ) and 391 (Sankey LJ). However, even if that is right, it does not overcome the difficulty from Mr Tsvetkov's perspe......
-
Petroplus Marketing AG v Shell Trading International Ltd
...same sum, or, if damages, exactly the same measure of damages, against [Petroplus]”: see Aktieselskabet Ocean v B Harding and Sons Ltd, [1928] 2 KB 371, 385 per Scrutton LJ.; but in view of my other conclusions I need not consider this alternative submission. 25 Petroplus are therefore ent......
-
Mercuria Energy Trading Pte Ltd and Another v Citibank NA and Another
...if the amount of the claim and the cross-claim to which it automatically gives rise are identical, referring to Aktieselskabet Ocean v B. Harding and Sons [1928] 2 KB 371. Mr Toledano argued that, contrary to the concession above, Mercuria's cross-claim would not be for restitution of the p......
-
Co-Operative Retail Services Ltd (Claimants) Taylor Young Partnership Hoare Lea & Partners (A Firm)(Defendants/Appllants) Carillion Construction Ltd (formerly Tarmac Construction (Contracts) Ltd, Wimpey Construction UK Ltd) and Another (Third Parties/Respondents) Genergy Plc (formerly Dale Power Systems Plc) (Fourth Party) Flue-Stox Engineering Ltd (Fifth Party)
...and it had probably never applied to tort cases. 70 This doctrine had its origin in a very different world. In Aktieselskabet Ocean v B Harding and Sons Ltd [1928] 2 KB 371 Scrutton LJ said at p 385: "I know of no case, and counsel could refer me to none, where avoiding circuity of action h......
Request a trial to view additional results