Your World of Legal Intelligence
 United Kingdom | +44 (0) 20 7284 8080

Alan Paterson, FINAL JUDGMENT: THE LAST LAW LORDS AND THE SUPREME COURT Oxford and Portland, Oregon: Hart Publishing (www.hartpub.co.uk ), 2013. xxx + 335 pp. ISBN 9781849463836. £25.

Document Cited in Related
Date01 May 2015
DOI10.3366/elr.2015.0285
AuthorTamas Gyorfi
Pages289-291
Published date01 May 2015

One does not have to be a legal realist to think that the reasons that are used to justify judicial decisions do not always explain how those decisions came about. If that is the case, it is an important task of legal scholarship to look behind the published opinions of judges and analyse what influences judicial decisions. Many scholars, most notably the proponents of the attitudinal model of judicial decision-making, believe that the explanation of judicial decisions must focus on the values and attitudes of individual judges, that is, the input of the decision-making process. Others, however, suggest that the key to the understanding of judicial decisions is the process itself, in which judicial decisions are forged. Professor Paterson clearly belongs to the second camp: both in his previous book on the subject, The Law Lords (1982), and in his most recent work, Final Judgment, analysing the work of the final appeal court of the UK, he defends the claim that judicial decision-making is a collective or social process. Although this claim is rather abstract, the contrast with the attitudinal model is informative enough to locate his position in the literature.

Paterson's book covers the final years of the House of Lords and the formative years of the new Supreme Court. Although the book draws heavily on The Law Lords, and is built on the same methodological framework, it would be a mistake to consider it only an updated version of The Law Lords. While the main organising concept of the former volume is that of social roles, the more recent one...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT