Bishop of Lincolnes Case

JurisdictionEngland & Wales
Judgment Date01 January 1650
Date01 January 1650
CourtCourt of the King's Bench

English Reports Citation: 74 E.R. 920

King's Bench Division

Bishop of Lincolnes Case

and so it shall be, if he held but a mesnalty 7 Ed. 4. A man held by frankalmoigne, be shall say, infra feodum summ, and in reputation amongst men a seigniory is a manner: for if a man makes a feoffment of a mannor, with livery where he bath no mannor, yet shall it passe, 7 E. 3. where a mannor passeth by the name of knights fee. And as to the intirenes of the seigniory it is easily answered, for although the rent were entire, yet it may be severed, for a rent charge is entire, yet a proportionment may be made thereof 44 Ed, 3. To which the Court agreed that the rent without doubt might be severed. Walrnseley, for the plaintiff, The question is if the rent passeth by the name of a mannor to the devisees. If a grandmother deviseth land to her daughter J. S. whereas she is her daughters daughter, yet this is good, because in common speaking she is so called, but here the words are not apt, nor used in common speaking, viz. that rent should be taken for a mannor, and therefore it is voyd, as a gift to the right heirs of J. S. who is attaint 19 H. 8. And he concluded with this difference : that where the words have any affinity or likelihood [89] to the mannor, then it will passe by the name of a mannor. As if a man deviseth his house and land by the name of a mannor it shall passe. But here being but a service, it is otherwise. Gawdy cont. For if the rent passe not nothing shall passe, which is a hard construction on a will. For 21 Rich. 2. Devise 27. a devise ecclesite Sancti Andrem is a good devise to the parson of the church. And in Brett and Rigdens case a man devised a mannor in which he had nothing, and after purchased the mannor, the devise is good. And in 26 H. 6. Feoffment 12. land will not pass by deed by the name of a house, but land will pass by the name of a carue, and a cattle by the name of a mannor, and I hold that the rent in this case will passe by the name of the mannor, for a mannor does consist of demesnes services, and rent may be called a mannor as well as a carue, and the King gives it by the name of a mannor to the devisor, and that is the reason that the devisor calls it a manner : and if you grant to me an advowson by the name of the church and rectory, and I devise the rectory, the advowson and the church will passe by the name of rectory : and in Plouden. 194. a man did let his house and great demesnes rend ring rent, and did devise to...

To continue reading

Request your trial
3 cases
  • Richard Wrotesley, Plaintiff, and Richard Adams and Elizabeth his Wife, Defendants
    • United Kingdom
    • High Court
    • 1 January 1816
    ...parts into consideration; so that one part shall answer to another, one shall minister to another, and the one (e) S. P. cited 2 Leon. 43. Owen, 89. Fitzgib. 73. Treat, of Wills, 64. Yin. Abr. tit. Devise, Z. a. pi. 3. J. b. pi. 2. (f) S. P. Cart. 99. per Archer, J. Curson, 337. 1PLOWDEN, 1......
  • R v Toney
    • United Kingdom
    • Court of Appeal (Criminal Division)
    • 1 December 1992
    ... ... The appellant in the first case was charged with doing an act tending and intended to pervert the course of public justice in that ... 372 ; [ 1975 ] 3 W.L.R. 713 ; [ 1975 ] 3 All E.R. 468 , C.A ... Rex v. Bishop of Lincoln ( 1637 ) 3 State Tr. 770 ... The following additional cases were cited in ... ...
  • Storie, Clerk, v Charles Richard, Bishop of Winchester
    • United Kingdom
    • Court of Common Pleas
    • 25 January 1850
    ...clerk. Beverley v. The Bishop of Canterbury (1 And. 148); Baskermle's case (7 Co. Rep. 28); 27 E. 3, 85 (d); The Bishop of Lincoln's case (Owen, 89); Cumber v. The Bishop of Chichester, cited in the case of The King v. The Archbishop of Canterbury and Prust (Hetley, 124). And this latter op......
5 books & journal articles
  • Real estate law.
    • United States
    • Florida Bar Journal Vol. 77 No. 8, September 2003
    • 1 September 2003
    ...Port St. Lucie Navaretta, Stephen (93) (772)340-5121 Ste. 203 1100 S.W. St. Lucie West Blvd., 34986-1735 Punta Gorda Hackett II, Jack Owen (89) (941)639-1158 Farr Law Firm P.O. Box 511447, 33951-1447 Kahle, Gary Allen (91) (941)639-1158 99 Nesbit St., 33950-3636 Wotitzky, Edward Lee (90) (9......
  • Board certified lawyers.
    • United States
    • Florida Bar Journal Vol. 80 No. 8, September 2006
    • 1 September 2006
    ...Port Saint Lucie Navaretta, Stephen (93) (772)340-5121 Ste 203 1100 S.W. Saint Lucie West Blvd., 34986-1735 Punta Gorda Hackett II, Jack Owen (89) (941)639-1158 Farr, Farr, Emerich, Hackett and Carr, P.A. 99 Nesbit St., 33950-3636 Kahle, Gary Allen (91) (941)639-1158 99 Nesbit St., 33950-36......
  • Real estate law: field established 1987.
    • United States
    • Florida Bar Journal Vol. 79 No. 8, September 2005
    • 1 September 2005
    ...Port Saint Lucie Navaretta, Stephen (93) (772)340-5121 Ste 203 1100 S.W. Saint Lucie West Blvd., 34986-1735 Punta Gorda Hackett II, Jack Owen (89) (941)639-1158 Farr Law Firm P.O. Box 511447, 33951-1447 Kahle, Gary Allen (91) (941)639-1158 99 Nesbit St., 33950-3636 Wotitzky, Edward Lee (90)......
  • Board certified lawyers.
    • United States
    • Florida Bar Journal Vol. 76 No. 8, September 2002
    • 1 September 2002
    ...Port Saint Lucie Navaretta, Stephen (93) (561)340-5121 Ste. 203 1100 S.W. Saint Lucie West Blvd., 34986-1735 Punta Gorda Hackett II, Jack Owen (89) (941)639-1158 Farr Law Firm P.O. Box 511447, 33951-1447 Kahle, Gary Allen (91) (941)639-1158 Farr Farr Emerich Sifrit, et al. 99 Nesbit St., 33......
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT