Book Reviews
| Author | Dr Marian Duggan |
| Pages | 91-98 |
91
BOOK REVIEWS
Edited by Dr Marian Duggan, Sheffield Hallam University
WHERE NEXT FOR CRIMINAL JUSTICE?
David Faulkner and Ros Burnett (2011). Bristol: Policy Press. pp 245 (pbk) £19.99 ISBN
9781847428912
Faulkner and Burnett introduce their book by unequivocally stating that: ‘Our inclination
towards a non-partisan position is determined by the prin ciples of inclusiveness and
empathy, and by realism about the extent and experience of crime’ (p 12). This quote
establishes the foundation for which they examine the past, the present, and contemplate
the future direction of the criminal justice system. What makes this book stand out from
similar texts is the way in which the authors have infused their wisdom from years of
experience in p olitics, research, and public service to inform and reflexively assess the
current state of ‘justice’ within the UK. The book is a passionate and comprehensive
account of the path of travel policy has taken in the last 30 years, and considers the
political and social trends that have impacted punitiveness, responses from government,
and resultant initiatives along th e way. It provides a thoughtful and accessible overview of
issues such as ju stice, legitimacy, sentencing, communities, prisons, and the changing role
of government agencies alongside recent privatization efforts. This is a concise and
impressively researched guide, which you will find yourself taking off the shelf to
reference time and time again. Its focus on humanity and emphasis on civility is refr eshing
and long overdue. Where Next for Criminal Justice? is a valuable resource for established
academics, practitioners, and students alike.
The authors present three primary arguments: the criminal justice system needs realistic
goals and to move away from risk-led, ‘expect the worst’ cynicism; prevention strategies
should be the responsibility of other parts of government, as well as civil society; and an
agreed set of moral and practical principles should be established and frame policy
decision-making. Faulkner and Burnett make the case for a person -first criminal justice
reform, focused on the individual, their capacities, and reminds us that such an approach
‘facilitates a sense of belonging and citizenship with the rights and responsibilities that
that implies’ (p 11). The authors highlight the lim itations of government to achieve this
and call for a revised and progressive mod el of justice that promotes an d fosters
empowerment and fair action, starting at the community level.
British Journal of Community Justice
©2013 Sheffield Hallam University, Sheffield
ISSN 1475-0279
Vol. 11(1): 91-98
To continue reading
Request your trial