Gatwick Investment Ltd & Others v Liberty Mutual Insurance & others

JurisdictionEngland & Wales
CourtKing's Bench Division (Commercial Court)
JudgeMr Justice Jacobs
Judgment Date26 January 2024
Neutral Citation[2024] EWHC 124 (Comm)
Docket NumberCL-2022-000360 CL-2023-000047 CL-2023-000049 CL-2022-000638 CL-2023-000064 CL-2022-000687
Between:
Gatwick Investment Limited & Others
Claimant
and
Liberty Mutual Insurance Europe SE
Defendant
Hollywood Bowl Group PLC
Claimant
and
Liberty Mutual Insurance Europe SE
Defendant
(1) Starboard Hotel Limited & Others
Claimants
and
Liberty Mutual Insurance Europe SE
Defendant
Fuller Smith & Turner PLC
Claimant
and
(1) Liberty Mutual Insurance Se
(2) Aviva Insurance Limited
Defendants
(1) Liberty Retail Limited & Others
Claimants
and
Liberty Mutual Insurance Europe SE
Defendant
(1) Bath Racecourse Company Limited & Others
Claimants
and
(1) Liberty Mutual Insurance Europe SE
(2) Allianz Insurance PLC
(3) Aviva Insurance Limited
Defendants
(1) International Entertainment Holdings Limited & Others
Claimants
and
Allianz Insurance PLC
Defendant
Before:

Mr Justice Jacobs

CL-2022-000360

CL-2022-000640

CL-2023-000047

CL-2023-000049

CL-2022-000638

CL-2023-000064

CL-2022-000687

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE

KING'S BENCH DIVISION

BUSINESS AND PROPERTY COURTS OF ENGLAND AND WALES

COMMERCIAL COURT

Royal Courts of Justice, Rolls Building

Fetter Lane, London, EC4A 1NL

Claimants

Jeffrey Gruder KC and Josephine Higgs KC (instructed by Edwin Coe LLP) for the Gatwick Starboard and Fuller Claimants

Adam Kramer KC and William Day (instructed by Stewarts Law LLP) for the Liberty Retail and Bath Racecourse Claimants

Jeffery Gruder KC and Josephine Higgs KC (instructed by Fenchurch Law (UK) Limited) for the Hollywood Bowl Group PLC and International Entertainment Holdings Limited Claimants

Defendants

Michael Ryan (instructed by HFW LLP) for the Aviva Insurance Limited Defendant in CL-2023-000049

David Scorey KC and David Walsh (instructed by DAC Beachcroft LLP) for the Liberty Mutual Insurance SE Defendant in CL-2022-000360, CL-2022-000640, CL-2023-000047, CL-2023-000049, CL-2022-000638, and CL-2023-000064 and, Allianz Insurance PLC and Aviva Insurance Limited Defendants in CL-2023-000064

Charles Dougherty KC and Timothy Killen (instructed by DAC Beachcroft LLP) for the Allianz Insurance PLC Defendant in CL-2022-000687

Hearing dates: 24 th – 26 th, 30 th – 31 st October and 1 st – 3 rd November

Approved Judgment

This judgment was handed down remotely at 11 am on Friday 26 th January 2024 by circulation to the parties or their representatives by e-mail and by release to the National Archives (see eg https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2022/1169.html).

Mr Justice Jacobs

Contents

Section

Para. Number

A: Introduction and factual background

1

B: The policyholders and the policies

49

C: Legal principles and background

103

D: LMIE Wordings: Trigger and Causation issues

115

E: LMIE Wordings: Limits issues

170

F: LMIE wordings: Furlough payments

382

G: Allianz Wording: claim by IEH

457

H: Answers to the preliminary issues

558

Schedule

Mr Justice Jacobs

A: Introduction and factual background

A1: The parties and the preliminary issues

1

This judgment concerns a number of preliminary issues in claims under business interruption insurance policies brought by a number of different claimants against various insurers. In each case, the claimants are claiming an indemnity pursuant to clauses which provide coverage where the use of premises is prevented or hindered as a consequence of action by a relevant authority. Such clauses were referred to as “Non Damage Denial of Access” or “NDDA” clauses in the earlier litigation which culminated in the decision of the Supreme Court in the Financial Conduct Authority v Arch Insurance (UK) Ltd [2021] UKSC 1, [2021] AC 649, on appeal from the decision of the Divisional Court (Flaux LJ and Butcher J) [2020] EWHC 2448 (Comm) (“the FCA test case”). NDDA clauses are one of three broad types of clauses which have been considered in prior litigation: see London International Exhibition Centre PLC v Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance PLC and others [2023] EWHC 1481, paragraphs [115] – [120] (“ London International Exhibition Centre”).

2

The relevant coverage clause in most of the policies in the present case is headed “Prevention of Access (Non Damage)”, and the parties therefore used the acronym “POAND” rather than NDDA. In other policies, the relevant clause has a different heading, and therefore a different acronym. Whatever the acronym, the coverage provided by NDDA, POAND and the clauses considered in this judgment have considerable similarities. The similarities in the disputes between the various claimants and insurers gave rise to the hearing of a series of related preliminary issues.

3

The claimants in the various proceedings were as follows.

4

CL-2022-000360 concerned the “Gatwick” group of claimants. The Gatwick claimants are 6 insured companies each of which was the owner/operator of a hotel in England. CL-2022-000640 concerned a claim by Hollywood Bowl Group Plc (“Hollywood Bowl”), which is an operator of bowling and indoor golf centres and other leisure activities in England, Wales, and Scotland. CL-2023-000049 concerned a claim by Fuller Smith & Turner Plc (“Fullers”), which is a hotelier and owner and operator of licensed premises in England. CL-2023-000047 concerned the “Starboard” group of claimants. The Starboard claimants are 21 companies, each of which is the owner or operator of a separate hotel in England. The argument on behalf of all of these various claimants was presented by Mr Jeffrey Gruder KC and Ms Josephine Higgs KC.

5

CL-2022-000638 concerned the “Liberty Retail” group of claimants. The Liberty Retail claimants are all associated with the very well-known Liberty store in Regent Street, London. CL-2023-000064 concerned the “Bath Racecourse” group of claimants. The Bath Racecourse claimants are various companies which owned/operated racecourses and related facilities in England. The argument on behalf of all of these claimants was presented by Mr Adam Kramer KC and Mr William Day.

6

CL-2022-000687 concerned the International Entertainment Holdings Ltd (or “IEH”) group of claimants. The IEH claimants own or operate various theatres, opera houses, and similar entertainment venues in England and Scotland. These claimants were also represented by Mr Gruder and Ms Higgs.

7

The main insurer defendant to all the claims (except those brought by the IEH claimants) is Liberty Mutual Insurance Europe SE (“Liberty Mutual”). The policies issued to the Gatwick, Hollywood Bowl, Fullers, Starboard and Liberty Retail claimants were all issued on the basis of standard policy wording of Liberty Mutual, with the key clauses, central to the preliminary issues, being identical or at least materially identical in all these policies. Liberty Mutual also insured the Bath Racecourse claimants, but on different standard form wording. The difference in wording in the Bath Racecourse policy, as compared to the other policies, had resulted in Liberty Mutual accepting, in principle, that the Bath Racecourse claimants had coverage for business interruption losses pursuant to the relevant coverage clause in their case. Liberty Mutual was represented by Mr David Scorey KC and Mr David Walsh.

8

In addition to Liberty Mutual, there were other insurer defendants in some of the proceedings.

9

The Fullers policy was subscribed by Aviva Insurance Ltd (“Aviva”) as well as Liberty Mutual, each as to 50%. Unlike Liberty Mutual, however, Aviva admitted the occurrence of an insured peril under the relevant policy, and it has therefore paid Fullers the sum of £ 500,000 which it alleged to be the maximum amount of any claim under the policy. Accordingly, the issues which affected Aviva were those relating to policy limits. In relation to the claim under the Fullers policy, Aviva was represented by Mr Michael Ryan.

10

The Bath Racecourse policy was subscribed by Allianz Insurance PLC (“Allianz”) and Aviva in addition to Liberty Mutual. In relation to the Bath Racecourse claim, all insurers were represented by Mr Scorey and Mr Walsh.

11

The IEH policy was written by Allianz. In relation to the proceedings brought by the IEH claimants, Allianz was represented by Mr Charles Dougherty KC and Mr Timothy Killen.

12

The preliminary issues to be determined by the court were those identified in an Order dated 31 July 2023. They are set out in Section H of this judgment. A number of the issues were ultimately not the subject of argument. In particular, Liberty Mutual accepted that certain arguments on causation were not realistically available in the light of first instance authority in Corbin & King Ltd and others v Axa Insurance UK Plc [2022] EWHC 409 (Comm) (“ Corbin & King”) and London International Exhibition Centre. Liberty Mutual had therefore agreed with various claimants as to how the relevant preliminary issues would be answered at first instance, whilst reserving its right to advance its causation arguments on appeal. As the hearing progressed, it became clear that there was no substantial dispute on a number of other issues which had been identified. For this reason, certain questions in Section H are not discussed in this judgment, and the answers reflect the parties' agreement as to how they should be answered at the present stage.

13

The preliminary issues fall into the following broad categories. They concerned (1) trigger and causation; (2) policy limits; and (3) the question of whether receipts of “furlough” payments under the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme or “CJRS” needed to be brought into account.

14

The parties in each of the cases had reached agreement on a document which contained agreed and assumed facts for the purposes of the preliminary issues. Accordingly, no evidence from any factual or other witnesses was called. As the parties' arguments developed, they were principally focused on the wording of the relevant policies rather than particular factual points which had been agreed or assumed. There was therefore relatively little reference to the...

Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI

Get Started for Free

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex
6 cases
  • Terna Energy Trading Doo v Revolut Ltd
    • United Kingdom
    • Commercial Court
    • 12 June 2024
    ...so. …” To the same effect, most recently, is the judgment of Jacobs J in Gatwick Investment Ltd v Liberty Mutual Insurance Europe SE [2024] EWHC 124 (Comm), [110]–[112]. I respectfully agree. 97 Accordingly, I am not strictly bound by the decision of HHJ Bird in Tecnimont. But I should (and......
  • UnipolRe v Covéa Insurance; Markel International v General Reinsurance
    • United Kingdom
    • Commercial Court
    • 9 February 2024
    ...the view of Mr Justice Jacobs, in a difference insurance context, in Gatwick Investment Limited v Liberty Mutual Insurance Europe SE [2024] EWHC 124 (Comm). [443] “The CJRS or furlough scheme cannot be regarded as wholly separate and divorced from the restrictions which were introduced in c......
  • Bath Racecourse Company Ltd (and 21 other Claimants listed in Appendix 1 to the Particulars of Claim) v Liberty Mutual Insurance Europe SE
    • United Kingdom
    • Commercial Court
    • 22 July 2025
    ...The judgment following that first preliminary issue trial is better known as Gatwick Investment Ltd v Liberty Mutual Insurance Europe SE [2024] EWHC 124 (Comm) and involved overlapping issues in other COVID-19 BI insurance 22 Jacobs J held (among lots of other findings that are less relevan......
  • Gatwick Investment Limited & Ors v Liberty Mutual Insurance Europe SE
    • United Kingdom
    • King's Bench Division
    • 26 January 2024
    ...in consequence of A. accidental loss, destruction or damage at any Situation or to any Property shown below, or MR JUSTICE JACOBS[2024] EWHC 124 (Comm) IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE KING'S BENCH DIVISION BUSINESS AND PROPERTY COURTS OF ENGLAND AND WALES COMMERCIAL COURT Royal Courts of Justi......
  • Get Started for Free