Macdonald v Fairfield Shipbuilding and Engineering Company, Ltd

JurisdictionScotland
Judgment Date20 October 1905
Date20 October 1905
Docket NumberNo. 2.
CourtCourt of Session
Court of Session
2d Division

Lord Kyllachy, Lord Justice-Clerk, Lord Stormonth-Darling.

No. 2.
Macdonald
and
Fairfield Shipbuilding and Engineering Co., Limited.

Master and ServantWorkmen's Compensation Act, 1897 (60 and 61 Vict. cap. 37), Second Schedule (8)A. S., June 3, 1898, sec. 7 (a)Memorandum of AgreementSpecial Warrant to RegisterGenuinenessAgreement alleged to have been made under essential error.

In answer to a petition by a workman for a special warrant to register a memorandum of a verbal agreement to pay compensation at the rate of 16s. a week under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1897, the employers, while not denying the agreement, objected that it had been made under essential error as to the rights of parties under the Act, and that the sum agreed to be paid was more than half the workman's average weekly earnings.

Held that the employer's objections were irrelevant as answers to a petition for warrant to register an agreement which was not denied.

Observed that in such a petition once the alleged agreement is proved to have been in fact concluded, the functions of the Sheriff-substitute are the same as those of the Sheriff-clerk when the genuineness of the memorandum is not disputed.

Opinion reserved as to what the proper course would be if a memorandum were presented proceeding upon a written agreement to pay a sum beyond the maximum amount which in any view of the facts could be awarded under the Act.

On 28th March 1904 Thomas Macdonald, blacksmith, sustained injuries in the course of his employment with the Fairfield Shipbuilding and Engineering Company, Limited, Govan. He was

injured on the day on which he entered the employment of the Fairfield Company. His wage was at the rate of 1, 12s. per week, but his actual earnings in the employers' service were only 6s. 4d. He claimed compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1897. It was ultimately not disputed that the employers in April 1904 agreed to pay Macdonald 16s. per week, and this sum was paid to him weekly for twelve weeks down to 4th July 1904. Macdonald signed receipts which bore that he acknowledged receipt of 16s. as the weekly payment to which he was entitled under the Workmen's Compensation Acts. After 4th July the employers refused to continue payment at the rate of 16s. per week, upon the ground that Macdonald was only entitled to 3s. 2d. per week, being half of his actual earnings.

Macdonald then sent a memorandum of an agreement to pay him compensation at the rate of 16s. per week under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1897, to the Sheriff-clerk of Lanarkshire at Glasgow, to be recorded in pursuance of paragraph (8) of the Second Schedule of the Act.*

The employers objected to this memorandum being recorded, and the Sheriff-clerk accordingly intimated that it could not be recorded without a special warrant from the Sheriff.

Macdonald thereupon presented a petition in the Sheriff Court of Lanarkshire at Glasgow, craving warrant to the Sheriff-clerk to register the memorandum.

The Fairfield Shipbuilding and Engineering Company, Limited, lodged defences. They maintained that they were entitled to object to the registration of the memorandum in respect that the agreement to pay 16s. per week was made upon the erroneous supposition that the amount of compensation to which the pursuer was entitled was to he calculated upon the amount of the wages which he would have earned in a week, viz., 1, 12s., whereas upon a proper interpretation of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1897, it ought to have been calculated upon the amount of his actual earnings, viz., 6s. 4d.

The defenders pleaded, inter alia;(1) Essential error.

Proof was allowed and led.

On 31st January 1905 the Sheriff-substitute (M. Davidson) pronounced this interlocutor:Having considered the...

To continue reading

Request your trial
20 cases
  • DPP v Doherty (1), DPP v Doherty (2), DPP v Doherty (3)
    • Ireland
    • Supreme Court
    • 24 July 2020
  • Union of Shop, Distributive and Allied Workers v Tesco Stores Ltd
    • United Kingdom
    • Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
    • 15 July 2022
    ... ... 1 In 2007 the Appellant company (“Tesco”) planned an expansion and restructuring of its ... ...
  • Kuzuchar v Kuzuchar,
    • Canada
    • Court of King's Bench of Alberta (Canada)
    • 8 March 2023
    ...at para 111-112; Nand v Nand, 2011 ABQB 324 at paras 51-52.   [119]       Having regard to sections 7(4), 8(f), 8(1) and 8(m) of the MPA, I find that it would not be just and equitable for him to share in the matrimonial property distribution without accou......
  • Duffy v. Canada (Senate), 2020 ONCA 536
    • Canada
    • Court of Appeal (Ontario)
    • 28 August 2020
    ...Automatic OPS - Unclassified Information 0 0 0 Clean 6 pt 2 2 false false false EN-CA JA AR-SA 0 {6694A02B-D871-4A4B-8F8D-C5A03FE8B6E9} ...
  • Request a trial to view additional results
30 firm's commentaries
  • UK Implementing Regulations for the Money Market Funds Regulation Published
    • United Kingdom
    • JD Supra United Kingdom
    • 22 June 2018
    ...'0' , handler: '//fbapps.jdsupra.com/statistics/pixel?partnerID=dc4a1c64-176f-4a9f-913d-afd8f74f746f&file_unique_id=2ac89950-15a3-4134-8f8a-c5ef6eab1167&profile_id=15231&type=5&' // Public , pageview: function (data) { if (data === undefined) { data = this._curpage(); } else if (typeof (dat......
  • The Seventh Circuit Joins The Second And Fifth Circuits In Holding That 28 USC § 1782(a) Does Not Apply To Private International Arbitration
    • United States
    • JD Supra United States
    • 21 October 2020
    ...'0' , handler: '//fbapps.jdsupra.com/statistics/pixel?partnerID=dc4a1c64-176f-4a9f-913d-afd8f74f746f&file_unique_id=0a35ab35-d109-4915-8f8d-02a522edc4f5&profile_id=15673&type=5&' // Public , pageview: function (data) { if (data === undefined) { data = this._curpage(); } else if (typeof (dat......
  • Amendments to the Mining Act in Tanzania
    • South Africa
    • JD Supra South Africa
    • 26 February 2018
    ...'0' , handler: '//fbapps.jdsupra.com/statistics/pixel?partnerID=dc4a1c64-176f-4a9f-913d-afd8f74f746f&file_unique_id=d176beb4-4a79-4aba-90ac-8f8ba5bb4ecd&profile_id=12833&type=5&' // Public , pageview: function (data) { if (data === undefined) { data = this._curpage(); } else if (typeof (dat......
  • Haemophilia: The Impact Of A Single Gene Disorder On World History
    • United Kingdom
    • Mondaq UK
    • 20 April 2016
    ...cascade has 14 core genes and several other extended and supporting genes. With regard to Haemophilia, there are two core genes - Factor 8 (F8) and Factor 9 (F9), both from the X chromosome. Any mutation in these two genes stops the cascading effect and stops the blood from clotting, this c......
  • Request a trial to view additional results
27 books & journal articles
  • Disparate Impact, Unified Law.
    • United States
    • Yale Law Journal Vol. 128 No. 6, April 2019
    • 1 April 2019
    ...in America, BRENNAN CTR. FOR JUST. (May 10, 2017), https://www.brennancenter.org/new-voting-restrictions-america [https://perma.cc/8QE6-8F8N] [hereinafter New Voting Restrictions] (counting twenty-four states that have adopted new voting restrictions since the 2010 (2.) See, e.g., Daniel J.......
  • ARTICLE 6
    • United States
    • Colorado Bar Association C.R.S. on Family and Juvenile Law (2022 ed.) (CBA) Title 18 Criminal Code
    • Invalid date
    ...(i) Requirement to file signed declaration. (I) The defendant shall file a copy of the signed declaration issued pursuant to subsection (8)(f), (8)(g)(I)(C), or (8)(h)(I)(A) of this section, and, if applicable, the written statement of the results of a criminal background check performed on......
  • Appeals council
    • United States
    • James Publishing Practical Law Books Social Security Disability Practice. Volume 1-2 Volume 2
    • 4 May 2022
    ...12F-13, 20F-3, 20F-18, 20F-30, 20F-36, 20F-41; helplessness, 4F-2, 12F-1; hopelessness, 4F-2,12F-1; low motivation, 4F-2, 4F-10, 4F-12, 8F-8, 8F-11, 8F-13, 8F-16, 10F-2, 11F-6, 12F-1, 12F-8, 12F-11, 19F-2, 20F-30, 20F-35; irritability, 4F-2, 4F-22; poor concentration, 4F-2; circumstantial t......
  • PROPERTY LAW FOR THE AGES.
    • United States
    • William and Mary Law Review Vol. 63 No. 2, November 2021
    • 1 November 2021
    ...(Jan. 12, 2021), https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/news-perspective/2021/01/us-covid-19-vaccine-strategy-pivots-target-those-65-and [https://perma.cc/8F8S-FE4P]. (15.) See Boni-Saenz, Vulnerability, supra note 4, at (16.) See JOINT CTR. FOR HOUS. STUD, OF HARVARD UNIV., PROJECTIONS & IMPLICATI......
  • Request a trial to view additional results
48 provisions
  • Finance Act 2016
    • United Kingdom
    • UK Non-devolved
    • 1 January 2016
    ...March 2006 and it falls within section 5(1B) . (9) In section 8J (meaning of “inherited”) , in subsection (1) , for “and 8F” substitute “ , 8F, 8FA, 8FB and 8M ”. (10) In section 8K (meaning of “closely inherited”) , in subsection (1) , for “and 8F” substitute “ , 8F, 8FA, 8FB and 8M ”. (11......
  • PL 109-171, S 1932 – An original bill to provide for reconciliation pursuant to section 202(a) of the concurrent resolution on the budget for fiscal year 2006 (H. Con. Res. 95).
    • United States
    • U.S. Public Laws
    • 1 January 2006
    ...replacement of policies). ``(VI) Section 7 (relating to unintentional lapse). ``(VII) Section 8 (relating to disclosure), other than sections 8F, 8G, 8H, and 8I ``(VIII) Section 9 (relating to required disclosure of rating practices to consumer). ``(IX) Section 11 (relating to prohibitions ......
  • MO Register Vol. 36 No. 21. (Pages 2217–2364)
    • United States
    • Missouri Register
    • 1 January 2011
    ...add subsection (3)(C); amend subsections (4)(B), (4)(C), (6)(A), (6)(C), (6)(D),(7)(A), (7)(B), (7)(D), (7)(E), (8)(A) through (8)(D), (8)(F), (8)(G),(9)(B), and (10)(A). If the commission adopts this rule action, it will be the department's intention to submit this rule amendment to the U.......
  • Massachusetts Register Issue 2016-1321, September 9, 2016
    • United States
    • Massachusetts Register
    • Invalid date
    ... ... 9.00 Cost Recovery for Major Electric Company Generation Investments 1315 6/17/16 ... 11.00 Rules ... recognized engineering organization for the construction, installation, and ... ...
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT