Stuart Docherty v HM Advocate
| Jurisdiction | Scotland |
| Neutral Citation | 2003 SCCR 772 |
| Date | 2003 |
| Year | 2003 |
| Court | Unspecified Court (Scotland) |
-
- This document is available in original version only for vLex customers
View this document and try vLex for 7 days - TRY VLEX
- This document is available in original version only for vLex customers
4 cases
-
Laura Stewart V. Her Majesty's Advocate
...of responsibility, such that the jury is entitled to convict one of murder, and another of culpable homicide: cf Docherty v HM Advocate 2003 SCCR 772. Each case depends on its facts: Broadley v HM Advocate 1991 SCCR 416. [12] The only issue in this appeal is whether, on the evidence, the tr......
-
Green v HM Advocate
...30–379 Dobbins v HM Advocate 1980 SCCR (Supp) 253 Docherty v HM Advocate 1945 JC 89; 1945 SLT 247 Docherty v HM Advocate 2003 SLT 1337; 2003 SCCR 772 Elsherkisi v HM Advocate [2011] HCJAC 100; 2011 SCCR 735; 2012 SCL 181; 2011 GWD 37–758 Ferguson v HM Advocate [2015] HCJAC 89; 2015 SCL 972;......
-
Notes Of Appeal Against Conviction And Sentence By (first) Paul Green, (second) Lee Noonan And (third) Robbie Darren Brown
...of culpable homicide constituted a miscarriage of justice 18 (McKinnon v HM Advocate (supra) at para [41]; Docherty v HM Advocate 2003 SCCR 772 at 777-778; and Stewart v HM Advocate 2012 SCCR 728 at paras [11]-[12]). Mr Brown [43] Mr Brown submitted that the trial judge had failed to direct......
-
Andrew Parfinowski V. Her Majesty's Advocate
...would have reinforced the effect of the original misdirection. [17] Reference was made to Malone v HMA 1988 SCCR 498 and Docherty v HMA 2003 SCCR 772. Submissions for the Crown [18] The advocate depute submitted that the case turned very particularly on its own facts and circumstances and t......