Summary of Asset of Community Value Cases Decided so far by the Firsttier Tribunal and Upper Tribunal
| Author | Simon Adamyk |
| Pages | 337-343 |
This is a list of the ACV cases which have been decided so far by the First-tier Tribunal and the Upper Tribunal, as at the time of writing. They are listed here in the order in which they were decided. The decision notices (i.e. the equivalent of judgments) in most, but not all, of these cases are available for free on the internet on the BAILII website (the British and Irish Legal Information Institute) in its database for the First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) at www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKFTT/GRC, or its database for the Upper Tribunal (Administrative Appeals Chamber) at www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKUT/AAC.
Appeal dismissed (i.e. land still listed)
Appeal dismissed (i.e. land still listed)
Appeal allowed (i.e. land de-listed)
Appeal allowed (i.e. land de-listed)
Appeal dismissed (i.e. land still listed)
Appeal dismissed (i.e. land still listed)
Appeal dismissed (i.e. land still listed)
Appeal dismissed (i.e. land still listed)
Outcome
Key issue(s)
Identity of nominator (strike- out)
Future condition
Future condition
Ancillary use
Past condition, future condition
Future condition
Present condition, future condition, exclusion of part
Application to complex land, planning units, ancillary use, exclusion of part
Reference
CR/2013/0001 (unreported)
[2013] UKFTT CR/2013/0005 (GRC)
[2013] UKFTT CR/2013/0003 (GRC)
[2014] UKFTT CR/2013/0004 (GRC)
[2014] UKFTT CR/2013/0006 (GRC)
[2014] UKFTT CR/2013/0007 (GRC)
[2014] UKFTT CR/2013/0009 (GRC)
[2014] UKFTT CR/2013/0010 (GRC)
Wilkins v West Somerset District Council
Patel v London Borough of Hackney
Dorset County Council v Purbeck District Council
Matterhorn Capital Bristol Ltd v Bristol City Council
Name of parties
Spirit Pub Co Ltd v Rushmoor Borough Council
Reed v Shropshire County Council
Gullivers Bowls Club Ltd v Rother District Council
Firoka (Oxford United Stadium) Ltd v Oxford City Council
Name of asset
‘The Notley Arms’, Monksilver, Somerset
‘The Chesham Arms’, Hackney, London
‘Tumbledown Dick’, Farnborough, Hampshire
Wareham Middle School playing fields, Dorset
Balfour Road Scout Hut, Bristol
‘The Pheasant’, Bridgnorth, Shropshire
ers Bowls Club,
Bexhill-on-Sea, East Sussex
Kassam Stadium (Oxford United Football Club), Oxford
Gulliv
Date of decision
8 Apr 2013
7 Nov 2013
22 Nov 2013
16 Jan 2014
23 Jan 2014
20 Mar 2014
24 Apr 2014
9 May 2014
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
No order for costs
Appeal allowed (i.e. land de-listed)
Appeal dismissed (i.e. land still listed)
No order for costs
Appeal dismissed (i.e. land still listed)
Appeal dismissed (i.e. land still listed)
Appeal dismissed (i.e. land still listed)
Appeal dismissed (i.e. land still listed)
Outcome
Key issue(s)
Past condition
Past condition, future condition
Present condition, future condition, trespassory use
Future condition
Validity of nomination, exemption relating to hotels
Validity of nomination, past condition, future condition
Costs
Costs
Reference
[2014] UKFTT CR/2014/0001 (GRC)
[2014] UKFTT CR/2014/0007 (GRC)
[2014] UKFTT CR/2014/0005 (GRC)
[2014] UKFTT CR/2014/0007/2 (GRC)
[2014] UKFTT CR/2014/0006 (GRC)
[2014] UKFTT CR/2014/0008 (GRC)
[2015] UKFTT CR/2014/0012 (GRC)
[2015] UKFTT CR/2014/0011 (GRC)
Name of parties
Red Star Estates Ltd v Walsall Metropolitan Borough Council
Scott v South Norfolk District Council
Worthy Developments Ltd v Forest of Dean District Council
Scott v South Norfolk District Council (costs decision)
Higgins Homes plc v London Borough of Barnet
Sawtell v Mid-Devon District Council
Hawthorn Leisure Acquisitions Ltd v Northumberland County Council
...
To continue reading
Request your trial