Malicious Prosecution in UK Law
-
Thompson v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis
“
Such damages can be awarded where there are aggravating features about the case which would result in the plaintiff not receiving sufficient compensation for the injury suffered if the award were restricted to a basic award.
-
Willers v Joyce (No 1)
“
As applied to malicious prosecution, it requires the claimant to prove that the defendant deliberately misused the process of the court. The most obvious case is where the claimant can prove that the defendant brought the proceedings in the knowledge that they were without foundation (as in Hobart CJ's formulation.) The critical feature which has to be proved is that the proceedings instituted by the defendant were not a bona fide use of the court's process.
-
Crawford Adjusters (Cayman) Ltd v Sagicor General Insurance (Cayman) Ltd
“
Underlying Lord Steyn's reasoning – and, indeed, the reasoning of earlier cases which refused to extend the tort to civil proceedings – is the rationale that manifest injustices suffered by victims of malicious prosecution of civil proceedings could be adequately redressed by other means – the verdict of the court, the award of costs, the availability of an action for defamation or the extension of other areas of tortious liability.
-
Glinski v Mclver
“
Whereas in truth he has only to be satisfied that there is a proper case to lay before the court, or in the words of Lord Mansfield, that there is a probable cause "to bring the accused to a fair and impartial trial", see Johnstone v. Sutton (1786) 1 T.R. 493 at p. 547. After all, he cannot judge whether the witnesses are telling the truth.
-
Roy v Prior
“
It must often happen that a defendant who is sued for damages for malicious prosecution will have given evidence in the criminal prosecution of which the plaintiff complains. In such cases the actions are not brought on or in respect of any evidence given but in respect of malicious abuse of process (see Elsee against Smith, 2 Chitty's Reports, p. 304).
-
Gregory v Portsmouth City Council
“
Nevertheless, for essentially practical reasons I am not persuaded that the general extension of the tort to civil proceedings has been shown to be necessary if one takes into account the protection afforded by other related torts. I am tolerably confident that any manifest injustices arising from groundless and damaging civil proceedings are either already adequately protected under other torts or are capable of being addressed by any necessary and desirable extensions of other torts.
-
Elguzouli-Daf v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis; McBrearty v Ministry of Defence
“
While it is always tempting to yield to an argument based on the protection of civil liberties, I have come to the conclusion that the interests of the whole community are better served by not imposing a duty of care on the CPS. It would in some cases lead to a defensive approach by prosecutors to their multifarious duties. It would introduce a risk that prosecutors would act so as to protect themselves from claims of negligence.
-
Administration of Justice Act 1920
... ... respect of libel, slander, malicious prosecution, ... false imprisonment, seduction, or breach of promise ... ...
-
Administration of Justice Act 1925
... ... there is a claim in respect of libel, slander, ... malicious prosecution, false imprisonment, seduction ... or breach of promise of ... ...
-
County Courts Act 1984
... ... malicious prosecution or false imprisonment; or(c) any question or issue of a kind ... ...
-
Judicature (Northern Ireland) Act 1978
... ... shall have regard to—(a) the convenience of the defence, the prosecution and the witnesses;(b) the expediting of the trial; and(c) any directions ... (c) malicious prosecution;(d) false imprisonment;(e) ... ...
-
The Police and the Law
... ... The Police and the Law ACTION FOR MALICIOUS PROSECUTION NOT COMPETENT VVHEN PROSECUTION IS ' SUCCESSFUL' T HE ... ...
-
Relegated No Longer? The Role of Malice in the Delictual Protection of Liberty: Whitehouse v Gormley
... ... delictual: wronguous/wrongful; unjustified; unlawful; false; or malicious? This goes beyond mere “fair labelling”: the selection determines the ... financial loss (as an insolvency practitioner, the pending prosecution rendered him unable to practice) and reputational damage. His claims were ... ...
-
Compensation of the Innocent
... ... the detection of crimes and the capture and prosecution of offenders have made less significant the role of ... the conditions of liability for false imprisonment, malicious prosecution, or some other tortious wrongdoing connected with ... ...
-
Recent Judicial Decisions
... ... Email: Damian.Carney@port.ac.uk RECENT JUDICIAL DECISIONS Malicious prosecution Moulton v Chief Constable of W est Midlands (2010) EWCA Civ ... ...
- Fraud Insights: Malicious Prosecution Of Civil Claims
- Shaping The Tort Of Malicious Prosecution Of Civil Claims
-
Release clause in settlement agreement includes fraud-based claims
Tchenguiz & ors v Grant Thornton UK LLP & ors [2016] EWHC 865 (Comm) considers the circumstances in which the court may be prepared to conclude that a party intended to release fraud-based claims. ...... ... proceedings was held to cover potential claims of conspiracy, malicious procurement and execution of search warrants, and malicious prosecution ... ...
-
New Torts Principle And Pragmatism In Uncharted Territory
... ... Malicious prosecution of civil proceedings. It is long established that there is a ... ...