Precautionary Principle in UK Law
-
R Loader v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Goverment and Others
“
The decision maker must have regard to the precautionary principle and to the degree of uncertainty, as to environmental impact, at the date of the decision. Depending on the information available, the decision maker may or may not be able to make a judgment as to the likelihood of significant effects on the environment. There may be cases where the uncertainties are such that a negative decision cannot be taken.
-
AWG Group Ltd v Morrison
“
Although this is a different case, as the hearing has not yet started, the same principle applies. Where the hearing has not yet begun, there is also scope for the sensible application of the precautionary principle. If, as here, the court has to predict what might happen if the hearing goes ahead before the judge to whom objection is taken and to assess the real possibility of apparent bias arising, prudence naturally leans on the side of being safe rather than sorry.
-
R (JF and Another) v Secretary of State for the Home Department
“
No evidence has been placed before this court or the courts below that demonstrate that it is not possible to identify from among those convicted of serious offences, at any stage in their lives, some at least who pose no significant risk of re-offending. If uncertainty exists can this render proportionate the imposition of notification requirements for life without review under the precautionary principle?
-
R (on the application of Lumsdon and Others) v Legal Services Board
“
The court held that the existence of risks to health had to be established on the basis of the latest scientific data available at the date of the adoption of the decision. Although, in accordance with the precautionary principle, a member state could take protective measures without having to wait until the existence and gravity of the risks became fully apparent, the risk assessment could not be based on purely hypothetical considerations.
-
R (Oss Group Ltd) v Environment Agency; Solvent Resource Management Ltd v Environment Agency
“
In other words, although the Court continues to play lip-service to the “discarding” test, in practice it subordinates the subjective question implicit in that definition, to a series of objective indicators derived from the policy of the Directive. What is required from the national court is a value judgment on the facts of the particular case in the light of those indicators.
-
R (on the application of Champion) v North Norfolk District Council and another
“
But this informal threshold decision is not to be confused with a formal "screening opinion" in the EIA sense. The operative words are those of the Habitats Directive itself. It indicates no more than that the assessment should be appropriate to the task in hand: that task being to satisfy the responsible authority that the project "will not adversely affect the integrity of the site concerned" taking account of the matters set in the article.
Those passages to my mind fairly reflect the balancing considerations which are implicit in the EIA Directive: on the one hand, that there is nothing to rule out consideration of mitigating measures at the screening stage; but, on the other, that the EIA Directive and the Regulations expressly envisage that mitigation measures will where appropriate be included in the environmental statement.
-
European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018
... ... 5: Exceptions to savings and incorporation ... (1) The principle of the supremacy of EU law does not apply to any enactment or rule of law ... ...
-
Environment Act 2021
... ... environmental principles means the following principles(a) the principle that environmental protection should be integrated into the making of ... of preventative action to avert environmental damage,(c) the precautionary principle, so far as relating to the environment,(d) the principle that ... ...
-
The Novel Food (Amendment) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019
... ... provision of retained direct EU legislation, including the precautionary principle as referred to in Article 7 of Regulation (EC) No. 178/2002;(c) ... ...
-
The Invasive Alien Species (Enforcement and Permitting) Order 2019
... ... information is insufficient, by the application of the precautionary principle ... (9) The permitting authority must make available the ... ...
-
Risk Assessment, Policy-Making and the Limits of Knowledge: The Precautionary Principle and International Relations
This paper looks at the way in which the idea of the Precautionary Principle, increasingly influential in environmental and other policy areas, is being and might be used in foreign and security po...
-
Antibiotics, the Precautionary Principle and the Court of First Instance
This article comments upon the two judgments of the Court of First Instance (CFI) in the Pfizer and Alpharma cases of 11 September 2002. This case law is of importance as the Court for the first ti...
-
Precautionary Maybe, but What's the Principle? The Precautionary Principle, the Regulation of Risk, and the Public Domain
The ‘precautionary principle’, originating in the field of environmental protection but now widely applied, is a major point for discussion in the regulation of risk. Though promising proactive and...
-
Investor-State Dispute Settlement and the Future of the Precautionary Principle
The proliferation of bilateral investment treaties and investment chapters in trade megatreaties and the associated increase in the preference of investors for investor-state dispute settlement has...
-
EP ENVI Committee Proposes Moratorium on the Use of Nanomaterials in Food
On November 24, 2014, the European Parliament (EP) Committee on Environment, Public Health and Food Safety (ENVI) considered draft legislation concerning novel foods. The Committee amended the dr...... ... moratorium on the use of nanomaterials in food based on the precautionary principle. The Committee approved the amended draft legislation by a vote ... ...
-
BSI British Standards Issues Nanolabeling Guidance Document
Effective December 31, 2007, BSI British Standards (BSI) issued “Publicly Available Specification” (PAS 130:2007), “Guidance on the labeling of manufactured nanoparticles and products containing ma...... ... knowledge and understanding, and suggests applying a precautionary principle: Lack of scientific evidence of risk should not prevent ... ...
-
High Court rejects legal bid to prevent fracking in Lancashire, UK
The High Court has refused to grant an interim injunction preventing Cuadrilla from carrying out hydraulic fracking operations at the Preston New Road site in Lancashire. The ruling means that Cuad...... ... as medium rather than high); had failed to apply the precautionary principle; and had failed in its duty to communicate with the local ... ...
-
P & R Is For Food Contamination Risks From Pollution & Radiation
... ... proportionate and weigh up the requirements of the so-called Precautionary Principle ... The earthquake in Japan in March 2011 and the subsequent ... ...